Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Does It Matter HOW?

Posts

Does It Matter HOW?

#1

Does It Matter HOW?

charlie belden

I'm playing with a laser engraver as a pyrograph tool. Like any other pyrograph tool, be it branding, vaporizing, scorching or selectively burning, it burns wood. The only real difference is how much more control you have over how much it burns, where it burns and how fine the details it burns ( resolution).

What is different about laser engraving (or carving) is that the actual burning process is not interactive, but controlled by the laser engraving device based on the information YOU provide it. The creation of THAT information IS interactive and is much like any other type of 2D artwork creation. The tools and techniques are different because YOU use a computer, a computer input device like a keyboard, a mouse or a pen and tablet and a computer graphics software application. What IS different is the ability to

- UNDO mistakes and quickly recover from an OOOOOPS

- manipulate the artwork, or elements of the artwork (scale, rotate, reposition, etc.)

- quickly do variations of a "drawing" - without affecting the original - by working with copies

Having just gone through 30 video tutorials on just one of the computer graphics applications (Corel DRAW 12), my mind is reeling at the possibilities.

If you've attended a Bob Rosand demo or seen one of his "written on" pieces - imagine creating a path for the text to follow then giving the program the text you want to follow that path. CLICK - and the text wraps along the path. Hide or don't "print" the path and you get JUST the words - following the unseen path line. The path can be a square, circle, oval, concentric squares, ovals or circles - or any other path you create.

Artists have been using shading to give he illusion of 3D for a long time. But shading with pyrograph pens is tricky and not very refined. With a graphic application, shading is fairly easy, as are gradients. And for the most part, you're playing with WYSIWYG (What You See Is What You Get - Wis See Wig).

Then there are the actual Low Relief 3D "carving" possibilities which is what I'm really interested in and will be exploring. The information in the Gray Scale image you feed to the laser engraver tells the laser software WHERE to burn - AND - how DEEP to burn - in VERY small, very precise increments (0.003") - a control phreak's nirvana.

Like any other tool, be it a turning gouge or a pyrographic pen system, there's a learning curve to climb to get good at using a graphic application and a laser engraver to get the results you're after. In that respect, using this newer technology is no different from using earlier technologies, be they new steels, new grinds, carbide tips, hollowing systems. sand blasters, etc..

Other than reducing The Element Of Risk associated with other methods of getting to the end result - Does It Matter HOW - you get to the end result?

What say you (and please expand on your Yes or No answer if you would)?

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#2

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

R Payne

Yes it matters how.

I'm trying to get some income from my woodworking. I keep running into people who tell me my prices are too high. They are used to seeing cookie-cutter piece where they are all the same and done by some automation. I can't afford the automation and wouldn't enjoy doing the woodwork if I used it. I've been to craft fairs where someone had set up some machine to make a piece (doesn't matter what) and repeats that piece with little or no guidance. It requires no development of skill on the part of the "craftsman". He can offet intricate work for less than I can do simple work. Often he can set up the machine then walk away to make something else. Which means more pieces in a given time. The result is people start thinking that is a valid price point for all such work.

Ultimately that forces me to go into debt buying equipment I can't afford to make cookie-cutter pieces, throwing my work in the fire because I can't sell it for a fair price given the time I spend or finding a niche that allow me to sell it (which means finding enough people who appreciate the skill and time involved in the hand making of the work).

I loathe cookie-cutter work.

ron

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#3

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

charlie belden

Ron:

I don't think a craftsman can compete in WalMart type mass markets where price point is the deciding factor. There will always be someone somewhere who will bang out bowls or whatever for much less than you can. We live in a global economy and this is a fact of life.

But you can

- educate your potential customers by pointing out the differences between your pieces and a similar, but not equal, "cheaper" piece. Even today "cheap" has a negative connotation - not well done, not good materials, not durable, etc.

- use unusual woods or wood that has unique qualities and/or characteristics

- develop "value added" things about your work that others haven't copied yet, or can't copy easily, say a unique finish like staining, dying or surface decorating

You want to emphasis Product Differntation to point out why YOURS is better and therefore worth MORE than THEIRS. You want to find a need that isn't being met - and fill it - with stuff you make and sell. Despite the maxim Build A Better Mouse Trap And The World Will Beat A Path To Your Door - you have to let the world know you've made a better mousetrap - which means marketing.

The issue you raised is an economic one. What I'm after is whether HOW something is made is significant in terms of the end result - a piece. The dollar value of the finished piece is a different issue. Certainly a significant issue if you make your livelyhood from the pieces you make, but a different issue.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#4

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Times change so change with the times... start something new.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#5

No

Carole Valentine

No,it doesn't make any difference whether it is carved by hand, laboriously, with talent and dedication or if it is whipped out in a few minutes by a machine, but I personally have no desire to own a piece created by the later method. No, it doesn't matter whether a human hand ever guided knife or burr through wood, constantly overcoming the threat of destruction from a slip of the blade and adjusting for the variables of the material through an intimate knowledge of it's properties, or if a machine precisely removed every bit of wood necessary to achieve the "desired results", but I personally have no desire to own a piece created by the later method. No, it doesn't matter that I may hold a stunning, intricately hand-carved piece in my hands and wonder in amazement at the talent and skill of the artist or whether I hold a piece made by a robot that's been fed a picture and think "machined" (though I may wonder in amazement at the talent of the person who invented the machine. ) No, it doesn't matter that I may give the hand carved piece, flaws and all, a place of honor in my collection, but that I would probably toss the machined piece in the yard sale box.

You were looking for a "no" answer, were you not?

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#6

Re: No

Mac Ray

I'll take one of yours any day Carole....................mass produced is just that......

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#7

Actually, I was just looking for answers

charlie belden

... yes or no, and why.

Your response brings up several points related to what we do.

First is the significance of the interaction between the maker, the maker's tool(s) - and the wood. With handwork there is , or should be, a conscious interplay between maker, tool and wood, with the maker and the tool adapting to the feedback given by the wood. THAT is a very significant difference between handwork and "machined" work. While the art work / design to be incorporated into a turning may be the same, the opportunity to modify and adapt the design to the wood - as the work is being done is more difficult with the laser engraver, though some of that CAN be done by laser engraving in increments and modifying/adapting the graphic image with the graphic software as you go - if need be.

Not having done much pyrography I'm guessing that it involves sketches and perhaps detailed drawings of patterns and transfering a pattern onto the piece - or sketching it on the piece with a pen or pencil. That, I think, is the creative part of the process.

And it's the artwork that can make or break a pyrographed piece. Even executed perfectly, if the art work - doesn't work - the piece doesn't work. The tool merely puts the artwork on, or in, or through the piece.

The focus of your dislike of a laser engraved piece seems to be based on the fact that "a machine does all the work". But as I said, it's the artwork that is what you see, seldom, if ever, HOW it got there. A laser engraver only burns where and how much - you tell it to. YOU have to create the artwork.

There also seems to be an impression that creating artwork on a computer and with a computer software graphics application is a no brainer. Turn on the computer, open the graphics application and - BOOM - wonderful artwork just suddenly appears - no thought, effort or skill is required. Sure, it CAN be easy to open a Clip Art file that you found somewhere and feed it to the laser engraver. To create, from scratch, out of your own imagination - a design you find pleasing and that will add something nice to your piece - is something very different . The software may give you more options and opportunities to change the design you're creating - but it still requires that YOU make choices - and have some artistic ability including an eye for what looks right and what doesn't.

What the laser engraver and graphic applications can provide is freedom to make one's "vision", for those with the inability to see fine details, or, for whatever reason, the lack of fine motor skills - a reality. THAT is what I think we're after - making our "vision" into reality. And if tools like this permit more people to do that - well I think that's a good thing. If someone else likes the results as well . . . that's icing on the cake. If someone likes it enough to BUY it - that's Money In The Bank ( OK so it probably means getting another tool ; ) )

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#8

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

Peter Hyde

Charlie I always read your posts on all the different forums and enjoy your slightly quirky questions. This one though is I think a smoke screen. The big reason why it matters is how YOU feel about what you have done. I can cut dovetails very quickly by the thousands with a dovetail machine, but I prefer to do them by hand because it means satisfaction that I can still do it after 50 years. Sure it takes a certain amount of input to set up a machine but then the only satisfaction is from being able to do the input. So yes it matters how it was done. As far as your remarks about selling against a Walmart mentality I couldn't agree more but all you are saying is "if you can't beat them then join them" That is not a valid reason to do anything as you are selling out. So personal satisfaction is what it's all about and if you are finding your new million $$$$$ toy gives you that satisfaction then great, but don't look to others to justify the process and take away any guilt you may have about joining the Wallymart club :) Sooner or later someone will look at what you are doing and take it to Asia. Then what is left for you?

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#9

Re: No

George Guadiane

Charlie,

You wrote: "The only real difference is how much more control you have over how much it burns, where it burns and how fine the details it burns ( resolution)." That's not exactly true, unless the actual ability to wield a tool and put it to wood doesn't matter. I had a techie CNC friend tell me that he could form anything I can turn with his computer (the proper program and the right set of cutting equipment), to closer tolerances and with a nicer finish, inside and out... I thought it was cool, but asked where the challenge was - "there isn't one" he replied. THAT holds no interest for me. It seems like paint by numbers.

Personally;

Yes, it matters. Mail order bride or love of your life?.. Climb Mt Everest or just take a helicopter ride and tell everyone that you made it to the top? Learn to surf or take a picture standing next to a surfboard.

Yes, you do need a certain unique skill set and enough money to buy the equipment that does the work, but scanning a picture into PhotoShop then manipulating it into a line drawing and feeding it into the program and putting the bowl/vase/whatever in "just the right spot" isn't really a woodworking/turning skill.

I WOULD say, however, that as long as you make FULL disclosure and don't let anyone think you actually carved or burned a piece then I have no issue with you. Charge what you want, it's a free market, but know that educated collectors will probably not have much interest in your work. The fact that you can reproduce it, at will, to scale, without much additional effort makes it "radioactive" to the "true collector" in search of the rare, unusual and artistic hand craftsmanship (even if the hand craft is of a somewhat lesser precision). Collectors want quality and precision, but they also want skill.

It matters, everything matters and everything counts. You are right to say that the laser takes out the risk, but beating the risk is what one is proud of, not just getting the result (well, maybe on Wall Street).

I'm not saying that what you would like to be true is wrong, it's just not "pure" and, there are those, to whom it will not matter, but if you took the time to tell them how easy it was, or what steps you used instead of hand work, they will still only think "it's really pretty" and ask "How much less can I pay?"

Interactive? Totally, you still have to do the programming, but knowing that you can reproduce a piece of artwork at the push of a button is not a compelling reason to get a collector's attention.

In the spirit of "full disclosure," I use a laser guided Monster hollowing rig to hollow my hollow forms. I resisted for a long time, thought it was too mechanical, that it took away too much of the risk I talked about... I got over it. In the end, I'm still holding the tool in my hand and using the laser as a means of guiding my hands to get the optimal thinness and contour, but I'm the one controlling the tool with no "interface." I did a fair amount of hollowing before I got that tool and I STILL hollow with just my Munro hollower and my new experimental Nano hollowing tool, and even with the laser, I have still managed to ruin several nice pieces of wood.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#10

Re: Actually, I was just looking for answers

George Guadiane

This makes things clearer for me, yo wrote: "But as I said, it's the artwork that is what you see, seldom, if ever, HOW it got there. A laser engraver only burns where and how much - you tell it to. YOU have to create the artwork."

Painters have been around for centuries. Technology exists today to reproduce virtually anything, right down to the texture and color of the finished surface on the canvas. Which has more value? Which is more prized by collectors?

Does it matter that you could take the original and scale it, flip it inside out and backwards, stretch it to fit over the couch or fit in a wallet?

Yes, it does. The original, crafted by hand, using the gifts and skills acquired by genetics and determination will always be of greater value. It's the art that has value and the art is in the creative process, not the reproduction of it.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#11

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

R Payne

You've concentrated on the economic point I made. And I admit it was the bulk of my argument, but not the whole argument. I've just started trying to earn some money selling my pieces and haven't yet found a good venue. But it still really gripes me when someone offers "Wal-mart" prices that don't cover materials.

What you missed is the cookie-cutter results of using such a machine. You can turn out dozens of identical copies. That means the pieces are not unique. By using computer controls you give up the need to develop the skill necessary to do the work yourself. You become a computer programmer not a craftsman. There is still some aspect of art in the piece, for you still need to be able to see how everything goes together so the gestalt of the piece is good but that is very different from the skill needed to accomplish it by hand.

You also missed the point, also made further down, about how I just wouldn't enjoy using automation to create with. Which I guess may or may not matter to a buyer. But it matters to me as a craftsman.

And when you do enough of the work by hand you get a feel for it that generally let you pick out the truly hand made stuff from the automated stuff.

As for making things unique, I do. I use apricot which I harvested myself from a tree I had to take down. That is not a common wood and I point that out to people who look at my stuff. I also have some grapevine large enough to do stuff with. I don't have much of that so I charge a premium for it. (Just try to find 8 inch diameter grapevine.) I've got a knife that is handled in grapevine. I forged the blade as well as doing all the finish work. I also use mulberry I harvested as well as some commercially available species that come from trees I had to take down.

As for educating consumers, I've found many that don't already know just don't care.

ron

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#12

Re: Actually, I was just looking for answers

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Charlie, create something that says WOW and more people will notice... ten years from now it will be common. How far can you take it...

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#13

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

George Guadiane

R. you wrote: "As for educating consumers, I've found many that don't already know just don't care. "

We may be able to make this thread useful in the end...

Many of those just don't know why they SHOULD care, that's part of what I want to share with them.

I buy and sell antiques to put a roof over my head. We are constantly educating customers. I have also done a few art/craft shows and actually sold a few pieces. Here too, part of what I do is to educate. I search for most of my own unique wood too. I select the best that I can. Customers find that interesting. I often answer questions about process and the most asked question "How long did it take you to make that?"

In talking about the process, I also try to help the potential client see my vision, the reason I made all of the choices that brought me to the results that they are looking at. I'm not against anyone using technology to get a result, but for me, I need the process to hold my interest... It's like an engine turning machine. It's a MACHINE, but in the right hands, it produces a beautiful product. Us old schoolers tend to resist "advances," but I don't turn on a pole lathe in the woods.

Personally, I think one would have an impossible time finding anything more than a WalMart type client for that type of work.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#14

Steve Kubien

Didn't we just...

Steve Kubien

...have this same debate a month or so ago? It may have been talking about pyrography or it may have been carving... Maybe I'm wrong.

Personally, I would rather own and/or create a piece which was handmade, not hand-programmed. I just do not feel certain things should have computers attached to them in any great way. Art/craft is one.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#15

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

john lucas

Charlie I'm on both sides of the boat on this. On one hand, I have an idea in my hand and I want to create a finished product. To me it's the product that counts, not how I got there and what tools I used. If it conveys the message that I want to say then everything before it doesn't really matter.

On the other hand there is a personal pride involved in the making of a piece. To me that's very important.

Although both pieces might sell and/or send out the message I'm trying to say, I would personally have more pride in the one I produce by hand.

I have designed a piece, that although I think I could produce it, my skills as a pyrographer are probably not there to really carry this off. I'm afraid it would look somewhat amateurish. What I'm mostly concerned with is spending many hours working by hand only to produce a finished piece that I don't think is high enough quality.

I know I can draw the design, scan it, clean it up in photoshop and then have a friend burn it on his laser. It would be perfect, but there in lies the problem for me. It would be too perfect. I'm afraid the machine quality would take away from the final piece. I'll let you know what I finally decide because I'll probably post a photo of the piece. Of course it might be awhile, that one is still a ways down on the list of things that have to be done.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#16

Steven Antonucci

Depends on what you value about the work

steven antonucci

Certainly, there are things that lasers and CNC machines can execute that would be almost impossible for humans to build. For those ideas, perhaps technology is the only means of delivering that vision.

I have one project in my head that would certainly be a lot easier to do using a laser, but it would also tax my abilities to do it by hand. Which do I choose- the easy way to create mechanically perfect piece or the hard way, where I have an opportunity to learn a new skill, experiment, and put myself into a piece?

The introduction of new methods to the field is exciting, but I don't want to lose the element of risk. For me, it is an integral part of the process. I think it needs to be there to give life to the work. Without it, there is just a machine doing my bidding, producing a soul-less object.

Introducing lasers to carve or burn a surface replaces an opportunity for me to grow as a craftsman. If I am not good enough to do it by hand, I either skip it, or practice, not automate. Warts are OK- they show the human element and allow other people to connect at a human level.

So, to answer your question- I don't know? For me, it's not OK, but that's just my work. What other people do with their own work is up to them.

steven

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#17

Denis Putland

Re: Does It Matter HOW? Nope

Denis Putland

Hi all

Hey I can not remember seeing any truly hand crafted products displayed on this site!!!

So using a powered laser on a object that we have turned on a powered lathe that may be a simple direct drive or digitally controlled.

And then perhaps power sanded and power carved and held in a powered vacuum chuck while the dust is sucked away with the powered dust collector.

Whether you use your hands to hold and control the cutting tools or to control the computer mouse and keyboard does not make any difference.

You still used your head and hands to create your finished piece.

It just depends on what you get your enjoyment from, hewing wood wid an axe or???

Personally I do not go past the powered lathe thingy so are my pieces closer to being hand crafted????? I think not in the long run.

Denis

PS; Forgot about that powered chain saw and ????????? :):):):)

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#18

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

charlie belden

John brings up several interesting points.

The first has to do with getting from concept to creation. Because he lacks the skills to make his concept a reality using existing and apparently accepted methods, must he abandon the idea - when there is a way the concept CAN become a reality? Not everyone has good eye sight and very steady hands. Should those physical limitations limit their their creativity?

The other point is the "machined look" the use of laser engraving CAN produce. Laser engravings don't HAVE to have a crisp, precise machined look. If a line was "drawn" in the digital drawing that has wiggles and a little shakiness, the result from the laser will have those hand drawn features. With a tablet and a pressure sensitive pen, subtle variations in the line can be reflected and show up in the lasered surface.

The objections to using technology to enable a concept to become a reality seems to focus on theuse of a laser and a computer. But let's step back from this specific technology. The use of a Rose Engine, with it's lobed cams, indexing mechanism and spinning cutting tool actually cutting the wood, has gained acceptance. Segmented Turnings with parts worked out on a computer - using software developed for this purpose are essentially indestinguishable from similar works done "the old fashion way". Does it really matter that a modern technology was used to create the finished piece?

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#19

Re: Depends on what you value about the work

charlie belden

Steve:

There's a common misconception that computers are smart, perhaps smarter than we are. The reality is that they only do what a human instructs them to do via "software" - either hardwired into the computer's hardware or provided by an externally supplied software program. At the user's end it's YOU who tell the computer what TO do. The computer does exactly what you tell it TO do - and not what you MEANT or INTENDED for it to do. IF you want a perfect thin line between two points, tell it that's what you want and give it the location of where you want the two points - it'll do that. If you want to hand draw a line between two points and draw that line with a pressure sensititive pen and graphic tablet - it'll do that too. If there's a little jaggyness and jiggle to your line - it will show up in the results, YOU can control the quality of the results.

There's also a misconception that using something like a graphics computer application is easy and effortless - no learning curve to climb, no skills to be developed - no sense of accomplishement - no "soul". If you want to do very simple things with it - play with clip art for example - that's about true - and there might be a lack of "soul". If you want to do original, more complicated and nuanced artwork it certainly is not true. Like any other medium, creating digital artwork requires developing an understanding of that medium and its tools. What IS different is the ability to UNDO things YOU decide you don't want done - AFTER seeing the results. Like any other medium, the more you practice with it the more you can do and the better you can do it. The more of yourself you put into the computer aided design the more you will show in the results.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#20

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

George Guadiane

In the end, after asking for opinions, it seems, that your responses to those opinions are as / more interested in convincing us that what you want to do is the "right" thing, or acceptable. I see a lot of resistance, including from me, BUT you can do whatever you want. If your bottom line question is about market acceptance, do the work, in whatever fashion and get it out there. The market will let you know in a hurry.

The rest of it sounds like either trying to "get permission" or like you're trying to sell the idea to the rest of us... Good ideas get stolen/borrowed/copied, they don't need selling, BUT, even good ideas have met with initial resistance in the past. Do it, show it and let us know how it goes.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#21

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

charlie belden

George:

Playing with a laser engraver is just something that interests me.Because I have access to, but in fact don't own one, I'm just exploring possibilities for ideas I have that might utilize some of the capabilities this tool has ( or capabilities I think it has). I've developed a rudimentary knowledge of how to use it, created some initial test images, acquired the software (under $20) the laser maker has set up their system to use and have spent two hours laser engraving onto two test pieces of redwood. The samples indicate that I can get the laser engraver to do low relief "carving" using gray scale images I created from scratch using a graphics application -PhotoShop. I already knew it could burn patterns into wood and could pierce wood since a turning club member has already done that. Initial results have confirmed that I can do low relieve 3D carving with this tool so I continue playing with the laser to see what I can do with it.

I have no desire to make any money off anything I learn or methods I might develop nor am I looking for any peer approval of the use of laser engraving - specifically low relief laser 3D carving. If by sharing an idea and things I learn from playing with the laserm another turner decides to try it and I can be of assistance to him or her - I will. No strings, no expectations for any benefit to me other than that which comes incidently when you lend a helping hand.

As long as this exploration holds my interest I'll pursue it - and share what I find. What others do with the information - if they care to look at what I post - is up to others. The nice thing about forums such as this one is I can pick and choose which messages to read and whether or not I'll join a discussion a message initiates.

Along the way, I'll try to address what I think are misconceptions with information I know from personal experience to be true.

The basic area I was interested in was the use of new tools and techniques and the view of others on their use. With more perspective it can be easier to see and understand something better.

The nice thing about forums such as this one is that I can pick and choose which messages to read and whether or not I'll join a discussion a message initiates or ask questions about a piece or technique I learn of here.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#22

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

Russ Fairfield

After reading all of these messages, I am left wondering why this topic was started, and why it is necessary to get our opinion or permission.

If the reason was to start a controvercial discussion then you have succeeded. Just be aware that a similar topic about turning wood with CNC machines has been beaten to death in years past, and without resolution.

If this is a ligitimate question about using a laser to engrave turned wood, why does our opinion matter. Just do it. That's what the rest of us do when we get a new idea, and hopefully it will be something that nobody has done before.

If the laser is just another cutting tool, where is the problem?

If you are trying to make "instant art" with a computer, then you might have a problem selling it as ligitimate art. Give it a try and see what happens. Don't expect it to be immediately accepted by the Del Mano Gallery, but there will be plenty of places to sell it.

Lasers and turned wood are not something new. You only have to look as far as the pens to see a lot of laser engraving on turned wood. There are laser cut pen kits available at a reasonable price, and many people have their pens laser engraved with artistic designs. Sometimes the penmaker does the engraving, but most of it is sent away to be commercially engraved by someone else who has the experience and the equipment to transfer your design to the wood. Some are simple designs, and some are very intricate and complex. All of them sell, and some of them sell at very high prices because the quality and the design are more important than how it was done and by whom. Whether this will be the same for larger turned wood is a question that only the market will answer.

If you just want to compete with those who are already doing laser engraving on turned wood, then do it. Advertise and hope that there are enough interested customers. Asking us what we think, will never answer that question, because woodturners rarely buy anything from other woodturners. Just be aware that there are others who are already engraving turned wood with a laser. The only difference is the size of the piece of wood. If you want to know it's value, the market will do that for you. None of us can answer that question for you.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#23

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

fgvanatta

Well put, Russ.

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#24

Steven Antonucci

Sorry, Charlie :-)

steven antonucci

Couldn't resist :-)

I disagree with a lot of what you responded with. While it is true that there is a certain amount of talent required to be able to draw with a computer, there isn't the same requirement to have the computer PRODUCE the finished product. If you go into any manufacturing environment, someone sat at a CAD station with a design and did the thinking, but in the end left the manufacturing to the machines. Whether the machine produces one or multiples is irrelevant, as it is merely a "variable" in the program.

It is the loss of manual control that I think is my issue. I have taken my ability to produce and GIVEN it to a machine. It is no longer my soul that goes into the work, and since the machine doesn't have one, the work is missing something. It may be technically representative of my ideas, but I don't see it as my work, because my work represents not only my ideas, but my abilities as well.

Conceptually, I know everything I need to know to dunk a basketball- jump high, and throw the ball through the rim, but I cannot do it (almost, once... but it never happened.) I also can do everything I need to know how to do to write the next great book (lots of words, how to form sentences, and generally put ideas together), but I do not have the ideas I need to write that book. It is the combination of knowledge, process, and ability that defines humankind's great achievements.

Subcontracting any of them out to a machine is not an option for me...

Good topic, though.

Steve

(not anti laser, or anti PC, or anti NEW...just sayin' not for me)

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#25

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

Barry L Elder

Some people have the time and talent to produce hand-made works and others diddle with their fingers on a computer keyboard. The difference between hand-made and computer-machined pieces is enormous, in my humble estimation.