Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Posts

Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#1

Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Barry Irby


A neighbor had some oak trees taken down and I grabbed some of the wood. There are two bowls i roughed out a few days ago. Very wet wood. About 11" across. About 1" thick. Put them in a paper bag and set them on the floor in a semi conditioned room. They cracked.

I did about twelve and four or more cracked. I was careful to quarter saw the blanks. I usually have better luck and loose about only about 10%. Was the sap rising?

What should I have done? These are trash/firewood now, right?

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#2

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

fgvanatta

Spring and summer are bad times to cut trees for turning - every one I ever did in those seasons resulted in badly cracked blanks.

Frank

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#3

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Greg Haugen

barry,

I'm just going to run through things to trouble shoot cracks in general.

First thing to be sure of is to never start with cracked wood. It sounds silly but I've seen people do it a lot. Don't start to turn it until enough has been removed to ensure all previous cracks are removed. Cutting 1 inch off of the end of a log doesn't take care of it all of the time. If they're cored blanks or if the blanks would have been stacked in the tree, and the cracks are close enough it could have been a crack there already.

Even wall thickness is essential. If you'll error to one side, a thinner bottom is safer than thinner sides. The sides will move more and will dry faster than the bottom due to the amount of end grain.

If I have a bowl that's over 1/2" thick, I'd anchorseal it (mainly on the end grain inside and out along with the rim) and either "store it and forget about it" or put it in my kiln. The paper bag or cardboard box methods usually works better with thinner bowls. 1" thick wet oak is a lot of wood to dry without slowing down the end grain.

Wet wood that's drying should be kept cool with little to no air movement to start. A higher relative humidity isn't a bad thing to start since it will lessen the "shock" on the wood as it dries. I'll often time leave them in the shop with the humidity from the shavings for a few days. Basement floors are a good option, if available.

If something is finished turn green-get it thin, get it an even thickness, and let it sit to dry.

What to do with these now? You could finish turn it and...

accent the cracks with inlace and epoxy.....

if you can cut a butterfly, you could patch it with a butterfly or you could add some straight stitching like some of Ellsworth's or Jerry Kermode's work.....

carve the rim to accent the cracks like the bowls on the cover of Raffan's "Art of Turned Bowls" book.......

Or you could just let it dry and see what you have left. Some say cracks in Oak will get smaller or possibly close when it's fully dried-then finish turn it and mend it or accent it in some way.

I do cut wood most of the year, except for the insanely cold months here in Wisconsin of Dec. and Jan. and even then I'll suck it up for the right wood. I haven't had much of a difference between seasons except for the bark coming off easier on the natural edge bowls from the logs cut in the spring and summer. I'm also pickier about what I cut now than when I first started. As John Jordan would say, "Life too short to turn _____ wood."

Hope that helps.

on the bright side, it does grow on trees and you had fun.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#4

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Bill Howatt

I find if the wood is really wet I need to take a bit more care in the drying It seems the loss of the first bit of real excess moisture can do nasty things. I wrap the bowls in newspaper after painting Anchorseal on the outside of the bowl in the end-grain area. I then put them in the bag or box and change the newspapers every day or two until the paper-dampening slows down.

You could put them back on the lathe and cut down the rim below the cracks and make shallower bowls. Maybe thin the walls a bit. I know the rule is 10% but I tend to go on the the thin side of 10%.

Sometimes it is just the wood itself. I had some maple, which usually doesn't give me much grief, want to crack. I noticed it and since the wood had dried a bit, I turned it off and thinned the wall. It did stop and fortunately I had enough wall left to true up when it dried. The cracks were not as bad as yours though - they were on the outside of the bowl and didn't go right through to the inside.

Bill

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#5

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Dick Coers

Lots of good advice so far. One additional comment I can make is that you got pretty close to the pith. Look at the ones that did not crack and see if the growth rings aren't quite so tight. As far as cutting wood in the spring versus latter, personally, I don't think it matters unless you have sapwood in the bowl. The heartwood doesn't carry any more water in the spring. I think that even the sapwood close to the heart doesn't carry any more water. The outer layers of the sapwood sure do.

And now for a slightly controversial comment; you can consider them firewood, or as others have stated make it "art". Now that's funny!

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#6

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Cyril Griesbach

Barry, I can't expand on the good advice you've already gotten but firewood...NO.

Watch them to see if the cracks do, indeed, close up.

Try one of the suggestions given above.

Wait and turn them into smaller bowls.

Try some pyrography, dying, carving, different finishes. In short try to learn something from them like a new skill or improving on a skill you've already tried. They are good experimental pieces and when you're done with that and if you are still cold, well then.....

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#7

O-o-o-o-o-a-a-a-a-a-a.......crack

Jack Savona

When I say "oak", sometimes it cracks before I get to the "k".

I've brought freshly cut wood home to Anchorseal and I could see the cracks starting at its pith, only one hour from being cut. At least you apparently got the pith turned out. BTW, was this from the trunk or a branch?

I agree, let them finish dry. If you don't creatively repair them, you could make shallow bowls.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: O-o-o-o-o-a-a-a-a-a-a.......crack

Steve Kubien

I'm with Jack, I think the problem may be that it is oooooaaaaa-split-kkkk. I have found red oak worse than white oak. If it had been me, I would have anchorsealed it right away, at least two coats inside and out.

Wish I had something better to tell you.

Steve

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#9

Thanks, more thoughts....

Barry Irby

I have been thinking about this. The guy brought me several pieces that were the buttresses of the stump and several short logs. I need to go look at them more closely but I think the ones that cracked came out of the the short logs. You can see that I split them and cut bowls on either side of the pith. I think the ones that came out of the the buttresses were not near the pith and may not have cracked.

One of them has a thin rim. I think it is better to cut a thick rim and thin bottom. I think it balances the drying time better and balances the stresses better.

I am out of Anchorseal. but I have a gallon of Elmer's Glue. I may coat the others with that.

I knew this stuff. Wonder why I thought I could ignore it just because I had not prepared blanks in a while? Thanks for the help.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: Thanks, more thoughts....

Steve Kubien

The Elmer's ought to work but keep a good eye on it because as the moisture comes through, it may lift the glue, opening more surface to faster evaporation and thus splitting. I could be way off on that.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#11

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions *LINK*

Fred Holder

Hello Barry,

I don't think anyone mentioned it, but several years ago Wally Dickerman gave a solution for cracked bowls. He said to soak the bowl in a 50/50 solution of white glue and water. I have a 15" salad bowl that was rough turned to be a gift to one of our friends. I went to final turn it and found it had cracked. The crack was at least 1/4", maybe more, at the rim and ran almost to the bottom. I tried Wally's solution and soaked it for 24 hours. I took it out and the crack was still there. I threw it on a pile of lumber to dry so I could burn it in the fireplace. A few days later, I walked by and noticed the crack had completely closed up. I took it into the shop for a few days to dry off before final turning. There was only the faintest hairline on the finished bowl. After four or five years, the bowl is still doing its job and the crack is still closed. You might give it a try.


More Woodturning magazine

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#12

Short log

Jack Savona

Barry, from the photos one bowl looks deeper than the other. If that means the pith was significantly off center, perhaps that was part of a limb, which would mean it had been under a lot of 'stress' - released when it was halved and especially rough-turned. Just a guess. There are many more knowledgeable 'wood/tree people' out there who know more about stress (tree type, that is) than I do. Perhaps they can tell me if I'm too green and all wet.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#13

Re: Thanks, more thoughts....

John Jordan

I knew this stuff. Wonder why I thought I could ignore it just because I had not prepared blanks in a while?

You are a wise man. :) Also, look really close and be sure there's not any bit of an existing crack. There is always some inherent cracking at the pith, and it's easy to think you have cut it all away.

It doesn't really matter when it was cut.

John

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#14

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Texian

Have had cracks close in end grain hf oak turnings as they dry, but never with a cross grain bowl. Still, you never know for sure until you try.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#15

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

robo hippy

When turning green wood, you have two choices. One is to turn it thick, and let it dry, then return it when it has stabilized. I don't do it this way as I prefer the warped bowls. If I did, I would seal it. Just putting it in bags isn't good enough, and if you put it in with wet shavings, they can color the bowl, and not always in a good way.

I turn to final thickness, the second option. Final thickness is usually about 1/4 inch, but no more than 1/2 inch. I will wrap the rim with some 6 inch stretch plastic film that you use to keep boxes on a pallet. This has done more than anything else I have ever tried. About an inch of film over the rim, into the center, and the rest down the outside. Be sure to stretch it out so that there is some compression on the rim. Usually dry in 10 to 14 days.

ALWAYS round over the rim edges. If you leave them sharp/square, they are much more prone to crack. I have never noticed that cutting in spring, summer, fall, or winter made any difference in cracking, if you protect your log blanks. Same with branch, trunk, or buttress wood.

robo hippy

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#16

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

Ron Bauer

Another thing that might have happened is the tree was split well up the trunk when it was felled. I have had this happen to cherry where it ruined 8 feet of the best part of the tree when it twisted as it fell. At least it is oak and cheap enough to experiment with.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#17

No talk of alcohol soaking?

Opelika Edro

Hi there turner-folk, chronic lurker here -- attempting to stop being such a wallflower. I've only just begun turning bowls with any reasonable regularity, and my preference is green stock (yep, a found-wood type). I have had poor results in the past with the bag-and-shavings method, so when I recently came across some red oak limbs with some spalting and crotch pieces, I looked for a drying method that would yield better results. I'm a bit green as a turner myself, but it seemed that these wet oak crotch pieces would be challenging to keep from splitting.

I went digging in the WoodCentral archives for some info, and I decided that the alcohol-soaking method (of Dave Smith, I think) was worth a shot. I consider this to have worked very well so far, and I've thrown some pretty nasty too-close-to-the-pith blanks at it. I found it interesting that nobody mentioned alcohol-soaking in this thread. I would think that this method is viable unless you are a high-volume turner, and I'm guessing it might have helped Barry out with this situation.

Any ideas/thoughts/comments? Note that the oak I have been turning has proven to be pretty unstable -- I have had to work quickly, use some CA where cracks have started, and apply beeswax to slow the drying/cracking during roughing-out. Anybody else like the alcohol bath?

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#18

Re: No talk of alcohol soaking?

John Jordan

If you are using beeswax and CA glue, I would say the alcohol isn't working so well. :) Many of us have turned 1000's of pieces over many years from fresh/green wood without alcohol, or soap, or boiling/freezing etc.

John

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#19

Re: No talk of alcohol soaking?

Don Thur

To complete a rather large commission with a short 3 month delivery time, of 30 7" x 18" Sugar Maple bowls, I had the loggers supply winter-cut 20"diam. blocks. The trees were harvested at the end of Jan. 2010; I roughed them out in Feb.; soaked the rough-outs in methyl hydrate for 2 days; after a stabilizing period of 5 days, they were introduced to 65 degrees F. of heat which was steadily increased to a max. of 85 deg.F. I was able to start a finishing process during the last week of March; the final piece will be finished this weekend for a delivery of the total to the customer on Thursday May 6.

Now for some of the other details: the first 5 were put to heat at a 85 deg.--oops;too high & small cracks appeared so I used bar clamps to hold the round rim shape--oops: wrong because I added stressors to the wood that showed in the final finishing. On the rest of the order, I coated the exterior with Anchorseal, placed them upside down on racks in my heated room, & when the ext. reached 16% m.c., they were reversed to final dry to 9 - 11% and then finish-turned.

By using winter-cut wood which had a 35% m.c. starting out, I am able to complete the commission and only lost 3 blanks. So I guess I am saying that alcohol drying does work IF the turner is diligent in its use and keeps the alcohol percentage at + 80%.

www.knotsburls.com

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#20

Steve Kubien

Re: No talk of alcohol soaking?

Steve Kubien

I've used the alcohol-soak method with really good success but I still wouldn't do it with red oak. It is my opinion that with nasty, split-prone stuff like this that you want to sssllllooooooooowwwwww the drying process and for me, anchorseal is the best for this.

YMMV.

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#21

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

P Nicholson

Here's how I fixed some red oak cracks:


img

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#22

Methanol is nasty stuff for humans

Bill Howatt

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#24

Clarification on the soak and crazy wood

Opelika Edro

Very good, John -- I read you. To clarify, I was suggesting that the alky-soak method seems to be working well for me as a low-volume turner who uses only found green wood. As I'm very much in the learning stages, I'm not choosy about the wood -- it's all practice material to me, though I'm trying to make nice enough bowls as the end result. What I'm trying to say, I guess, is that some (most?) of my stock wouldn't be very practical for a high-volume turner because of its high screwiness content -- reaction wood, squirrely species, etc.

Okay, more clarification (though you may just have been funning me; if so, I'm taking the bait): The alchohol-soaking method to which I was referring is used *after* roughing the bowl. The thing I was trying to get across was that the green wood I was turning was so prone to splitting that -- during the rough-bowl-turning process -- I had to work fast (for me, at least), even had to apply some CA to a few cracks as they developed, and also coated with a little beeswax to help retard moisture loss until I could get the rough-turned bowl into the alcohol. So, the result: really active wood seemingly tamed by the alky-soak process (turn it rough; soak in alcohol; let it dry several weeks; finish turn).

It's clear that Barry has a good deal more experience turning bowls than me; but it also seemed that this particular type of wood (wet red oak, reaction wood, opportunity knocking) was something with which I had some recent experience. And the alcohol soak seemed to have worked well for me, though there are lots of variables. Do know that I am interested to learn more about how you high-volume turners go from blank to finished bowl, as I progress.

Thanks for your comments,

Ed

Re: Cracked Bowl blank Questions

#25

What happens in the alky-soak process?

Opelika Edro

Hi Steve, and thanks for your comments as well. I am still trying to figure out the mechanics behind the alcohol-aided drying process. Based on my limited observation and understanding, I have been thinking that the "even-ness" of the alcohol-aided drying was helping to avoid cracks -- the alcohol replaces water until the whole solution reaches equilibrium; you wrap the outside of the bowl to slow drying outward; then the alcohol evaporates rapidly enough from inside that the wetness of the the thing is never very different as you travel from inner to outer side of the bowl -- and the relative uniformity of the "moisture" content helps keep stresses down and thus make cracking less likely. Or something. Heck, it made sense in my head. (And I think it might still work with your logic as well -- your slowing of the drying with AnchorSeal would be keeping the moisture content more uniform through the thickness also.)

Additional/better insight? Please jump in!