I am thinking of taking the plunge and buying coring tools. Seems like most folks here are using the McNaughton but most folks comment on the learning curve. Is the decision to go with Mcnaughton based on price because it is cheaper than the Oneway? Does the Onewayy have an advantage in quicker learning curve.
I expect my use will be on larger bowls, 12-18 inches on a PM 3520. Does that make a difference in selection.
Hi with the one way you ere set to a single shape the other has more to it in shapes and it does take longer to master but is a great tool for the prize
If I can use the McNaughton, anybody can! Seriously, it is the most flexible coring system out there. There is a bit of a learning curve, but it's not as steep as some would have you believe. Watch some videos ( Mike Mahoney's 2nd Edition is excellent) and some decent hardwood and you will be fine.
A curve is a curve. The McNaughton knives have a curve. Just because you are holding onto the knife doesn't mean that you can go in any direction that you like. You still have to follow the curve of the tool.
The McNaughton tools is easy to use when you follow the curve, and you know where the curve is going.
The Oneway tool makes following the curve easy.
Using the Oneway system makes you a coring operator. The McNaughton tools make you more of a craftsman. But both tools follow a curve.
If at all possible, find someone in a woodturning club who has one or both of them so you can watch, maybe use, and avoid a mistake.
I have both, and I use the McNaughton for the straight knife, and the Oneway for everything else. Yes, the McNaughton may be more versatile, but I will take issue with that. It is definitely less expensive than the Oneway, but it is also more difficult to learn for most folks, and most folks have to use it often to stay in practice. Personally, I use the the McNaughton for the straight tool, and the curved ones gather dust.
Yes, the Oneway has a fixed mechanical center, but it isn't as restricted as most folks told me it was because the center is moveable; and as someone alread said, a curve is a curve. The Oneway is more user friendly, it is easy to set up, and most folks can get a good core the first time and every time. That is worth the extra money to me. You will have to make your own judgement on that.
I bought the one way system a few weeks ago and was coring the day i took it out of the box, very easy to use, I had an older Mcnaughton system and struggled, i wanted to be coring and so I took the more expensive root, i have cored about 20 bowls with very little trouble, in the last couple of weeks. now what to do with all the chips from the rough turning??
I have to disagree with you about the whole shape thing being bogus. I have not used the Oneway, but from looking at it, I would say that you would be hard pressed to cut a deep vase shaped core from a tall blank. I have done that with my McNaughton. I can also determine if I want a bowl to be deep or shallow, depending on how I use the tool. I don't see how you can do that with a fixed system like the OW, but since I have not used one, I could be wrong.
I have the McNaughton's and like them. As others have said..ask a friend to show you their coring tool in action, watch a video and go from there. With whatever system let the tool do the work. I've only cored about 50 bowls but I'm happy with my success rate with about 6 bowls to scrap. I do agree the McNaughtons are not for everyone.
I bought the Oneway system after using one. I am happy with it and as Russ said it is more versatile than people think. I like the fact it was easy to setup and easy to use.
A quick look at prices for the ability of using either system on both of my lathes (16" and 20") gives me a total of about $1115 for the Oneway and four knives and a handle. The price four four knives and a handle for the McNaughton $270 and for that reason I bought the McNaughton and the learning curve is not that difficult.
With the OneWay, if you want a shallow core, you simply move the base further away from the surface of the wood. If you want a deeper core, you move it closer. If you are planning on coring, letting the cores dry, and then finish turning, the dried cores can be re-shaped to your hearts' desires.
I'll admit that the OneWay will not do a deep vase like shaped core. But for a tall or deep vase like shape, I don't see the advantage unless you have the world's most gorgeous wood. For tall shapes, I use the Kobra system. But then again, its just my opinion.
Hmmmm. Wish I'd known that before I bought the McNaughton and started coring out deep, shallow-curved vase shapes.
I'm not the only one that doesn't know this - the McNaughton was recommended to me by a woodturning friend who also happens to sell the Woodcut system, and he felt that the McNaughton was more versatile for cutting different shapes.
I have all 3 coring systems, and use the McNaughton almost exclusively. Main reason is it is faster to core with, and set up. Most of your coring will be on standard bowls, so there isn't as much difference here between the tools. However, the only thing you can't core with a McNaughton is a hollow form. You can core plates, or deep vessels, and in this aspect, the McNaughton is far superior to the Oneway. You can move the Oneway tool rest plate a bit side to side to change the trajectory, but if you are at the far end of the adjustment, the support finger can bind up in the cut. When you are coring really big bowl, (16 to 18 inches) the Oneway is a lot more stable than the McNaughton when you are that far off the tool rest. The down side here is that you have to turn off the lathe to advance the support finger. On a bowl that size, this is 3 to 5 times. I found the Oneway tips a pain to sharpen. You have to remove them from the tool (hex head screw that will be full of saw dust, but they used to include a push pin for cleaning out the head of the screw), put them on a holder, and put them to the grinder. You sharpen the top surface only, not the tip. If I was using the Oneway, I would have a belt sander, or flat disc sander for sharpening the tips as a better more efficient method than the grinder wheel.
You do not need the whole set of blades with either set. If you get the McNaughton. I would suggest the standard set of blades. If you want the big blades, learn to use the standard blades first, then get the bigger ones. With the Oneway, the 3 smaller blades will do most of what you want.
The Oneway is pretty much idiot proof. Easy to use. The McNaughton isn't, there is a learning curve. Every one who really knows how to use it swears by it. Every one who has tried to use it swears at it. You really need some one to show you how to use it, or get one of the DVDs. The instructions that come with it are not much use.
The McNaughton blades often need fine tuning, as the bends are rather inconsistent. See the above post.
The oneway coring systems are sharpened more than just the top surface. The "top surface" sharpening is the older way. The "newer" tips have a spear point that's vertical in the center of tip which helps in the "drifting" issue that all coring systems do to some degree. The new jigs for sharpening them come with directions of two different methods to use it including setup jigs. It's really easy to sharpen them. The link below has a page from Oneway's site of the top of the spear point being sharpened. The top and bottom of the point is sharpened as well as the top surface. It's an easy process. The whole time of taking the tip off of the knife, sharpening, and reinstalling is about a minute. Some say the tip can be honed. I've tried it. Sharpening on the grinder wheel is my preferred method. Honing just isn't enough for some things, at least with a fine diamond. Maybe a medium would be better. With a light touch, I just touch each of the three surfaces to the wheel. Enough to show a fresh bevel-nothing more. Just "dressing the bevel" with the grinder.
I've used both the McNaughton and Oneway Systems. Both have their advantages. I agree with Reed's explanation of them. McNaughton's are more versatile as far as shapes and straight line coning. There is no guess work with Oneway's system. There's no catches. There's no "self feeding". At a certain point with the Mcnaughton you'll also feel it "self feed" where the knife is being pulled. I've been coring a bowl, a large one, and was mid-way through it. I had a light bulb explode from moisture being thrown it. It startled me enough to let go of the coring system. Nothing happened. It just sat there. If that was the McNaughton....um....bad things would have happened. The oneway system needs contact and pressure to cut. My 7 year daughter has cored a bowl with the oneway system. McNaughtons are good systems as well. I've used one more than I've used a Oneway system. There's no "perfect" system. It comes down to your purpose, bowls forms, and budget.
If you would like to core a taller than wide forms, like trumpet shaped bowls, etc. McNaughton is the way to go. Get Mahoney's newly revised DVD or Grumbine's second DVD.
If you looking for a system for classical shaped bowls, or even if you want to do rather large bowls-I prefer Oneway.
Glenn Lucas is bowl turner from Ireland. Go to youtube.com and type in Glenn Lucas Woodturner. He has a few videos on there about his process. An interview shows footage of him using Oneway's system. He was the person that got me interested in it. glennlucas.com If you call Oneway, they'll also send a DVD on the system by David Lancaster for free.
Both are good systems. IF you're able to try one with someone, that's the best advice of all.
Once you get the hang of it, the McNaughton is very easy to use. I have had grandmothers coring bowls with very little effort once they get the setup of the tool down properly.
I agree totally with Richard. A part of a curve (which is what the knives are) is a part of a curve. You can use both to make deep bowls, shallow bowls -- or use larger or smaller knives to give a multitude of shapes. You can't make an "S" bend with either. I have both systems and since I bought the Oneway, I have never used the McNaughton. The Oneway is predictable -- no stress.
I did not mention sharpening the tips of the Oneway cutters. They require a lot less attention than the top of the cutter does. As to the spear point, I talked to Kevin at Oneway about it some time ago. The tip serves more as a chip breaker, breaking up the fiber first, then the parts on either side of the point cut off the broken fibers. As near as I can tell, the tip profile has nothing to do with how a curved coring blade tracks as it cuts. Yes, they do want to drift out a bit, but after experimenting with every conceivable profile on the McNaughton (except concave) I can't see that it makes any difference. Having the blades bent to a perfect arc does. I did have Kevin send me a tip that didn't have the point ground onto it (a rectangle). I ground off the sides some so it tapered towards the back like the McNaughton and the Woodcut, then put about an 80 degree bevel on the front. This was so I could put it straight on the grinder without having to remove it from the blades. It cut very well. It was more aggressive than the spear point, and Kevin told me that is why they don't sell them to the general public that way. I have ground all of my McNaughton blades square as well. The reason is that there is less metal on the wood. The spear point was a Mike Mahoney idea. Mostly it is to make it easier to cut a blank all the way off as opposed to cutting most of the way down, then breaking the core out. If you are cutting end grain, crotch, or burl, the fiber does not run straight across the bottom of the bowl, and breaking the core out can rip right through the bottom of the bowl. Been there, done that. I can cut them all the way down. Having the point at exact center when in the bottom of a bowl helps a lot in cutting it all the way off. There is a lot of flex in the Mcnaughton system, and especially, on bigger bowls, when you get near the center, you can be at center till you engage the wood, but when you start cutting, you are below center. Either break it out anyway, or raise the tool rest.
As far as using the diamond hones on coring blade tips, use the coarse ones. They will touch it up for a while, but you will need to go back to the grinder eventually.
It's a "Airstream" 3M helmet. One of the main suppliers of it is "Airware America".
www.airwareamerica.com
They're not cheap but you won't find better. A couple in our local club have them. There are several turners that use them; Mike Mahoney, Douglas J. Fisher, etc. I once heard someone compare Bill and his helmet to Mini Pearl and her hat with the price tag. :-)
Thanks for the feedback folks. As with most decisions, there are pros and cons either way. Since I am not in a position to try them out before hand, I am just going to have to take the plunge. Seems like they are both good tools.
The drifting issue and the newer spear point was mentioned by David Lancaster in one of the DVD's. Either the Oneway DVD or the DVD of his AAW Symp. demo a few year back. I had them send me a "old" style cutter to try to compare to the newer, I liked the newer a lot better. The older cutter was the only cutter, of three different styles I tried, that drifted a noticeable amount. You are correct about the "chip breaking". That is a big difference in the Oneway system compared to the McNaughton. The McNaughton will throw some rather fat shavings that can clog up the process if they're not cleared often. Oneway's are about 1/4 or 1/3 of the size and clears out easily.
I've often wondered about an "angled" cutter. Either the inside or outside edge being higher then the other. If a "shearing" cut would be a benefit or not. Or if it would produce the mother of all catches.
I know you like the square edge and I like the spear or diamond edges. I know you tested the Hunter Tips on the McNaughton. I really liked them. They were narrower than the standard edge and insanely sharp.