Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Strobes & Arcs Turning

Posts

Strobes & Arcs Turning

#1

Strobes & Arcs Turning

charlie belden

Strobes & Intersecting Arcs

If you�ve ever turned a three sided box you know it involves a lot of Turn A Little - Stop The Lathe To See Where You�re At. If you don�t, your 3� three sided box can quickly become a 1 1/2� box. To make matters more interesting, the �corners� are the intersection of pairs of arcs and getting them to intersect on a straight line isn�t as easy to accomplish as you�d think.

Now it�s handy to put reference lines on the sides of your blank to let you know when you�re getting close - and which arc needs some more turning. Scratching a line on the post of your tool rest At Centerline Height makes it easy to use it to redo your reference lines and then go back to its turning height. But you still have to stop the lathe to see where you�re at.

Now if you could synch a strobe light to �stop� your reference line so you could see it - as you keep turning . . .

With electronic variable speed, seems a strobe could be synched to things.

Just an idea.

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#2

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

john lucas

Charlie Many years ago when I was learning camera repair I built a variable frequency strobe. I tried it on various things including my shopsmith. It's really strange to cut a board and watch the blade sit perfectly still. Of course if you forced the cut any the blade would slow and made it look like it was running backwards. You might have the same problem when trying to stop turning although with today's more powerful lathes and light cut it would probably work quite well. You used to be able to buy strobes with fixed speeds at Radio Shack. It would just be a matter of fine tuning the speed of the lathe on these.

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#3

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

charlie belden

John:

Now that you mentioned variable strobes, around halloween they often show up in stores. If I can find them, I have two already (kids' love to dance and play in a strobe and spraying water in the light looks like a sheet of glistening diamonds).

Hmmmm. A foot switch to toggle between a normal shop light and the strobe could let you go back and forth between the light sources.

This idea has some potentially useful applications. When turning spalted wood, it's easy to cut right through interesting patterns between stops to see where you are. Conceivably, you could "stop" the piece in the spalted area and see what's going on while you turn it. Might also be useful when using a chatter tool so you don't "over chatter". For multi axis turning, it could eliminate the "shadow" and let you see what's actually being done on the piece - as you turn it.

Now if I can just remember where I stashed those variable strobes.

Thanks for noting variable strobes,

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#4

A possible method with less potential headaches

Craig Daymon

Many people develop severe headaches/migraines when using a strobe in this way. It might not be a problem for you but if it is, here is a suggestion.

We have a camera set up at our meetings that displays the demonstration on a TV (CRT), which has a refresh rate of 60HZ. If you set up a camera and TV focused on your work and adjust the lathe speed as John has said, you should be able to create a stopped image on the TV display. (I saw this happen during a demonstration with our group a few months back.) I THINK any lathe speed that is a multiple of 60 should result in a stopped image.

You could probably set it up in a way that would allow you to learn to turn the pieces by watching the TV directly, but I think the safer way would be to turn as you are doing now and just look up at the TV to see if you are getting the results you want.

-Craig

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#5

karl jr

How about a timing light?

karl jr

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#6

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

Michael Mocho

Many years ago there was a short article- I believe in Fine Woodworking Magazine(?) about using a strobelight while turning. It was written by Michael Mode, who is a great turner from New England who still sells his work at high end craft shows and galleries. Sorry I don't have the exact issue number, but it shouldn't be hard to locate. I recall it had quite a bit of information regarding types of strobes, synchronizing, and safety concerns.

-MM

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#7

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

Ace Foster

Somebody there in the SVW used to have a variable speed strobe that he lent out so people could check the speed of their lathes. Rich Johnson or some of the other oldtimers there might remember who it was; I don't. It worked pretty well, tho'.

Ace

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#8

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

charlie belden

Well, as usual, not much new under the sun - and sure enough, someone's already throught of using a strobe when turning - years ago.

I'm afraid an auto timing light wouldn't work because a) they get power from the car's battery and b) they synch to the No. 1 spark plug.

I hadn't thought to set the variable speed on my lathe to synch to my 60 cycle fluorsecent - but that'd mean having to have the shop closed up to keep out other light sources - like the sun.

I think my best bet is to find my halloween variable strobe and do some testing. Ideas that seem great - in theory - often are more hassle than they're worth when you try using the idea in the real world.

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#9

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

charlie belden

Ace:

I'll check with Rich and see if he can find it. But I think it's more of a spot meter rather than a strobe that'd illuminate a whole piece as it's turned.

SVW has all sorts of things hidden in the back. Hell, we've got a great DVD library that is hardly used. Probably should do a What We've Got And Where It Is at one of the monthly meetings - or a sawdust session.

I think we've got an Iturra bandsaw blade tension gauge back there somewhere.

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#10

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

John K Jordan

I've also tried that with a variable frequency strobe. Mine had a sort of orange light which was not too bright or pleasant and the flicker is an issue.

To get past the sync problem, you would need to trigger the strobe directly by the lathe spindle. An optical or magnetic sensor (hall-effect sensor) could do this. This would cause one flash for every rotation so it would be speed independent.

JKJ

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#11

Re: Don't forget that there is valid.....

JamieDonaldson

... evidence of strobes inducing epileptic seizures in some individuals!

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#12

Re: Beware, you are going into dangerous territory

Russ Fairfield

To me, nobody in their right mind would want to introduce the stobe effect into turning a piece of wood. It can be dangerous. It can play tricks with your vision and mind when the wood isn't round, especially if it is a triangle or square.

One of the reasons I have always avoided fluorescent lighting was that I didn't want the strobe effect that it can create at speeds that are multiples of 60.

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#13

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

John Jordan

Michael, you are right. Michael Mode demo'd this at the first AAW Symposium. I stood with Rude Osolnik and watched. Pretty weird as the piece appeared to be still while the shavings were streaming off. He did containers/boxes with burl edge lids/tops.

John

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#14

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Hey John, I watched the same demo...been a long time ago. You have a good memory for an old guy.

Wally

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#15

Re: Beware, you are going into dangerous territory

charlie belden

In theory, anything rotating EXACTLY at multiples of 60 cycles per second could, under fluorescent light flickering 60 times per second, appear to be stopped.

I've got fluorescent overhead lights and compact fluorescents at the miter saw, router table with a variable speed router, drill press, oscillating spindle sander, table saw, shaper, joiner and lathe. To date, have never had the strobing light effect happen. I imagine it COULD happen - but I've not seen it - so far. And even with ear protection, the noise of the motors let me know the tool is on, even over the sound of the dust collector.

Anyone actually expeprience a fluorescent light strobe effect on any power tool?

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#16

Re: Beware, you are going into dangerous territory

Russ Fairfield

It depends on the person. Some people are sensitive to the fluorescent flicker, and some some people aren't. I am one of those who is.

Incandescents are also helpful for finishing because their harsher light causes shadows, and that makes it easier to see those sanding scratches and ripples in the finish.

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#17

Re: Don't forget that there is valid.....

Jorge Casta�eda

Yes,

Remember nazi Germany used them to disorient enemy pilots, our own police forces doe exactly the same.

I would not use them at all while turning, I think it is not safe.

Jorge

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#18

Re: Beware, you are going into dangerous territory

Bill Howatt

No, but I don't have any problem with computer monitor slower refresh rates etc. Also, While the florescent lamps may be going on and off at 60Hz, the phosphor inside the tube does not die away that fast so the light intensity does not go on and off totally. In electrical terms, the phosphor acts as a capacitor to smooth out the light pulses.

Bill

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#19

Ballast Fluorescents vs Modern Fluorescents

charlie belden

I posted the Fluorescent Strobe Effect question over in the Message Forum and got this response

jrecord wrote:

"The old ballasts operated at 60 Hz. This gave a flicker rate of 120 per second and could cause a strobe effect. Modern electronic ballasts operate at 20,000 Hz, so

the strobe effect is no longer a problem. "

As for incandescents providing better light for seeing scratches - compact fluorescents have come a long ways from their early versions. They're getting more compact, putting out more lumens and there are more types of "white" light, some fairly "harsh".

As is the case with some many familiar things these days, things are changing pretty rapidly and what might have been true a decade ago, or a year ago, might not be true today or may not be true a year from now.

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#20

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

Bill Howatt

I started to do some offset pendants and found trying to judge where the various grooves were to go to be a problem so I was thinking of a strobe-light as a possible solution.

Strobe lights are usually made with xenon flash-tubes and they require high voltages and the cost is relatively high. Incandescent bulbs won't switch on and off fast enough because of thermal inertian in the filament.

Now that there are bright white LEDs cheaply available in the form of flashlights, it should be relatively simple for an electronics hobbyist to make a circuit with a 555 timer or two to drive a LED flashlight on and off at the desired rate.

I can do this but I have to find the time to do it plus round up some parts along with the necessary ambition!

Bill

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#21

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

John Jordan

Old is relative, Wally. That was a while ago. :)

John

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#22

Re: Beware, you are going into dangerous territory

John Jordan

Sometimes. Put a piece with light sapwood on one side, and dark wood on the other, and you'll see it.

John

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#23

Hey John...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Speaking of old...I'll be 89 in a couple of months and, well...that means that next year I'll turn 90. Of course I'm thinking that there'll have to be a party, and you're invited John.

Wally

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#24

Re: Hey John...

John Jordan

Wally, nothing would please me more than to come to your birthday party. iot would be an honor. Keep me posted.

You've got socks older than me. :D

John

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

#25

Re: Strobes & Arcs Turning

Ace Foster

It might have been Lou Gonzales or Craig Thorson who brought that strobe in.

WRT to your post about magnetically suspending things, Rich used to have a sort of top that was suspended with the axis horizontal. You might find that interesting.

Ace