Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Help with poplar balusters outdoors

Posts

Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#1

Help with poplar balusters outdoors

Don in Northern Arizona

Folks,

Sorry for the duplication. This post will also go to the messages board. My AAW chapter has volunteered to turn 65 balusters for an historic building in Flagstaff. The balusters will be painted and will surround a balcony on the front of a lovely 1895 vintage clapboard Victorian home. When I say volunteer, we are actually going to be paid $20 per baluster which will go to our club treasury. The volunteer part is that the lady who is remodeling the building has had trouble finding someone in Flag to do the job, and came to us for help.

Here is the problem. We are using a Vega duplicator to rough turn the pieces. They are rough off of the duplicator, and require quite a bit of sanding. I am using the Vega diamond V carbide cutter, so sharpness shouldn't be an issue, but the Vega cutters are basically pointed scrapers, and there is some tear-out. I am thinking the wood, poplar, may not take well to this type of scraping. We were given the wood by the home owner, so we are stuck with it.

I would like to be able to fill some of the tear-out. The balusters will be sealed with shellac, primed with oil-based primer, and painted with oil-based paint. Flagstaff is in the dry high desert, but has tough winters, so the wood will move. This year we got 140" of snow. I have been advised against using epoxy, but can I use CA glue or is there another filler that would work and survive outdoors here? Also, for future reference, am I right about poplar being a bad choice for a duplicator?

Thanks for any help.

Don

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#2

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

john lucas

Don You must be doing something different thatn I do. I am using the Vega duplicator with the V cutter and can start sanding with 180 or 220 grit with no tearout. Take smaller cuts always cutting from the high points to the lower points or with the grain. Cut close to the final size and then make a final pass trying to be very consistent with the feed rate and of course cutting downhill.

The most likely place for tearout is cutting downhill on the beads or if you have coves with a very steep side. It's just too easy to push the cutter too fast which causes tearout. When you approach those cuts take it very slow. If your using the HSS cutter instead of the carbide cutter stop every few spindles and hit it lightly with a fine or ultra fine diamond hone.

To answer your other question. You can fill the grain. I had to do that with some really bad buckeye that a customer brought for me to turn lots of spindles with. I used Durham's powdered wood putty mixed to about toothpaste consitency.

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#3

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

Dick Coers

It's not supposed to be too bad on the duplicator, but it is absolutely horrible for weather resistance. That stuff will almost melt! Well not that bad, but it won't last more than 10 years in Central IL. I also don't like the idea of shellac on anything outside. It won't resist water at all. It's alcohol thinner loves to mix with water. Think gin and tonic.

I use a Vega duplicator on my mini lathe. I mounted it on back, turned the cutter upside down. Then I use the tool rest up front and clean up all the duplicator cuts with hand tools. I set the duplicator about 1/16" to 1/32" light. That gives me material to clean up. I'm trying to remember, but I think Vega told me to set the cutter just above center, and then really turn up the speed of the lathe for better finish. I'd work pretty hard to get them to change material before too much labor is put into the project. I would suggest cypress, white oak, black locust, mesquite, etc......

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#4

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

Michael Mocho

Hello Don,

I would agree with John- if your Vega duplicator has been set up properly and you are running the lathe at a high RPM, you shouldn�t be getting significant tear out, especially on poplar. I usually rough out with a sharp cutter, then refine the details and surfaces with light cuts from a sharp skew and shear scrapers- no need to sand much if it is paint grade. The duplicator can save some time and provide a consistency of form if you don�t have a lot of experience with production turning.

The choice of poplar is unfortunate, and if they really want the balusters to last in the harsh Arizona environment, it seems it will be more cost effective to invest in better wood and top quality paint. (sometimes going cheap gets expensive). I would not bother with shellac, and look into a very durable (possibly epoxy based) exterior paint.

I would be curious to learn how old the original balusters are, what wood they were turned from, what type of paint, and what shape they are in.

I did a similar job for someone about 8 years ago- he insisted on using pine, and it wasn�t long before it became obvious that it would mean re-painting at least every other year, and the 4� ball finials in particular took a real beating from the southwestern sun.

If you have a substantial cap rail over the balusters it may not be as bad, but any place where moisture and sun can hit the end grain will be the first place the weathering shows, as well as any sharp transitions that tend to be where the paint starts to lift.

Good luck.

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#5

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

Dave Moore

Don.I have no experience with duplicators, so I can't speak to that, though I have seen poplar balusters turned on duplicators and they were rather well done, I thought.

I restored houses for a living for better than 25 years, many of them Victorian, and many of them with turned elements on porches and gingerbread and so on.

I never did find a filler material that would be truly durable outdoors, and I've tried just about all of them quite likely. The climate in Flagstaff is different than the regions I did most of my work (Gulf Coast of Texas, South Texas etc) but I've been in Flagstaff in the summer and the winter and as you say you have extremes; the wood will move.

I spent a considerable amount of time in the early days fixing call-backs with Durhams putty, plastic wood of all kinds, and even the la-di-da epoxies from Gougeon Brothers that are marketed as restoration products. And in a variety of timbers too; cypress, poplar, pine etc.

I finally gave up on them and did whatever I had to do to replace with solid wood, and if the budget wouldn't allow that then someone else could do the job.

Self defense demanded it, it was just too heartbreaking.

The problems begin in earnest when the paint coating envelope is compromised; water gets in and swells the wood disproportionally to the filler, and it begins to lose its anchor and works out of there. There was no freezing to speak of in Texas, but there sure as heck is in Flagstaff and that can only make matters worse.

My suggestion would be to do whatever you possibly can to produce the balusters without tearout so you can dispense with any need for fillers.

The painters will thank you, and so will the owners.

Remember, if the paint cracks and the filler jumps out, the folks who used the filler will get the call, even though technically it was a coatings failure. If there's no filler then all that happens is the paint pops off, and then they call the painter.

Much better.

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#6

  no   poplar outside

John D

The best you are going to get is 10 years. Probably 4to6 years. White oak would be my choice and it is very reasonable cost wise. SW MO.

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

Brad Vietje

Interesting question, Don.

I don't have any answers, but yet another question: can these be sealed in some way with a penetrating oil, like a Danish oil finish as a "primer" to add to their weather resistance ? It seems to me the problem with paints is that they form a layer on top of the wood, as opposed to penetrating deep into the fibers, and thus they can peel off. Are their treatments like a penetrating stain or oil that will help them hold up?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Snow flurries today, and a bit chilly, too...

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#8

Chuck Jones - West TN

Poplar not so bad to rot IF...

Chuck Jones - West TN

Not often I'd disagree with anything these more experienced WC wood aficionados say, but I have a 25+ year old building on my farm that is sided entirely with Poplar and not a rotted board on it... except on one side where the leaves piled up for a few years and didn't allow it to dry out. There is not one drop of sealer, oil, or paint on any of it.

I'm drawing conclusions from observation not science, but I think Poplar is fine if it is positioned where it gets air to dry after being wet. There are lots of old barns in my area that have been standing for years with Poplar siding.

Also, in the days of clapboard siding, Poplar was the most frequent choice of wood from what I've seen in KY and TN.

I am surprised that Poplar is readily available in AZ. We lived there several years and I don't recall seeing Poplar trees. But then in those days I was more interested in other things... like making a living.

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#9

Poplar or poplar?  What wood is it?

John K Jordan

Any time someone discusses poplar they might mention which species. Around here, yellow poplar (tulip poplar) is what people mean when they mention poplar. Elsewhere, they might mean true poplar. The properties of each are entirely different, both in turning and rot resistance (from what I read - I have no personal experience with any of the true poplars).

Without being clear on the actual type of wood, discussion of properties seems meaningless.

Tulip poplar does make great barn siding, barn doors, dog houses, etc.

JKJ

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#10

Re: Poplar or poplar?  What wood is it?

Don in Northern Arizona

John and Chuck,

This is 12/4 poplar that you can buy at lumberyards all over the country. Bilious green in color. Local poplar is not available in yards here. It is certainly not native. Up here you find ponderosa pine, aspen, and juniper principally.

Don

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#11

Thanks, all

Don in Northern Arizona

Thanks everyone. We are stuck with the poplar, and she has been warned about the life span. I will try to talk her out of the shellac, and I will try to take light cuts and avoid tear-out as much as possible to avoid having to use filler. This has been/will be a learning experience.

Don

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#12

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Poplar or poplar?  What wood is it?

Chuck Jones - West TN

Sorry about my lack of precision. The National Hardwood Lumber Association doesn't mention anything but "Poplar (American Tulipwood)" (page 31) and since we were talking about lumber I assumed that's what they have. I don't know anything about all the various other names that are floating around.

Re: Help with poplar balusters outdoors

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: Poplar or poplar?  What wood is it?

Brad Vietje

Gary,

Around here, in addition to Tulip Poplar, which grows further South than here, there's also Quaking Aspen and Big-Tooth Aspen that are generally regarded as "Poplar" or among locals, "Popple". Of course, then there's Balsam Poplar, White Poplar, Balm-of-Gilead, Lombardy Poplar, and the related Cottonwoods, etc... You're unlikely to find any of them in a lumber yard, but we turners/wood scroungers might use it for turning none the less.

Have fun,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT