Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

lathe choices

Posts

lathe choices

#1

lathe choices

Mike Foster

I have been considering upgrading my lathe for quite a while. I have an old Woodfast longbed with riser blocks. It has served me well and I can really turn most anything I have wanted. I did not add ballast to it, so it does tend to wobble with off-center work, but I just slow it down and turn slower.

I have a short list of lathes that I have been considering and wanted the opinions of those who have tried them all. The list is the Stubby 750, Robust American Beauty and I recently added the Powermatic to the list. I want a lathe that will last me till I croak. I want to be able to have free access to turn on both sides of the lathe. I want enough power to be able to core with no stalling. I want to be able to use my hollowing rigs and vacuum chucks. I want it to have the same spindle as the Woodfast (all on the list do) to fit my present chucks. I would like it to have more stability than I have now. My shop is on the first level of a barn with a full basement below and has hardwood floors. I do not plan on bolting the lathe down, but weighting it is an option. Distance between centers is not a strong consideration as I do little spindle turning.

So, what do you think? I am thinking right now that spending more on either the Robust or Stubby may not get me much more lathe than the Powermatic. I have not turned on either of these but have tried Powermatics, although I did not try moving the headstock to the end of the lathe like I think I would use it. I also did not try bogging it down with heavy cuts, like coring. I know this topic gets beat to death, but I am really undecided and any advice would be helpful.

Re: lathe choices

#2

Re: lathe choices

Guy Bratt

I have a PM and I'm very satisfied. However I do regret not buying american.

I had the money but couldn't put my hands on a robust to try. That was important in my decision. There seems to be more out there now. Maybe someone near you can let you check it out. I'd like to read some user reviews of late.

Re: lathe choices

#3

Steven Antonucci

other considerations?

Steven Antonucci

I've turned on the PM 3520, and it's a good lathe for sure. I can't see the added expense for the Robust. No experience with the Stubby.

I would be more focused on things like the height of the spindle (PM's aren't very adjustable), the footprint of the lathe, and how the lathe fits the habits I have developed...

Case in point- my clubs have Oneways, which are the smoothest lathes I have ever turned on by far, but EVERYTHING is in the way and nothing is one-handed. When the banjo is locked, it is locked and you need two hands to move it. Usually I have a tool in my hand, so it means that I have to find somewhere to put it. On my Nova, I would slide it in between the ways and the chip deflector... can't do that on a Oneway. It's a royal PITA that the banjo always seems to be hitting the tool because I hold the handles so low too...

You have likely developed some habits that you will need to modify with any of these lathes, and I'd spend more time seeing if the lathe fits the way you turn than "which is the best lathe". You may find that any benefits are negated by costs...

S

Re: lathe choices

#4

Re: lathe choices

Jerry Hall

Mike,

I have been on the cusp of replacing my PM3520a with a Robust. RoboHippy (Reed Gray) did that a while back and was kind enough to send me a lengthy email of his experience. He is I believe writing a review for Fred Holder in More Woodturning. You might contact either.

After I collected up the money for the Robust, I had trouble letting go of my beloved, stained, battered, 3520a. It has a bit more weight, and I like the cast iron. I would get the excellent Robust tailstock swing away in a heartbeat.for the 3520. The 24" swing of the Robust v. 20" was not a biggy for me but could be nice. The increased HP might be nice, I have on relatively rare occasion bogged down the 3520. But as I get older I turn less of the really big stuff. The cost difference is huge, and several basic things, like a ruler on the tailstock shaft, are extras which seemed odd to me. The bed extension for the 3520 when mounted below the main bed really sets it apart from the Robust too. It is a very close call, regardess of the money IMHO. Also the relative ease and sturdiness of the Vicmarc adaptation of the outboard rest is a plus for the 3520, It ties in beautifully I understand to those heavy cast iron legs. I don't think it would be as successful on the Robust, but don't know for sure.

But I am still thinking on it, am awaiting Reed's article and may well go for it in the end. I looked at the Stubby and it is really in a different class than the American Beauty and the 3520a. More compact, less throw generally, not as easy to access turning from the back than a lathe with a movable headstock.

Just some quick thoughts. I will be interested in reading this thread as it evolves. Also the Mustard Monster site has a bunch of reviews on the 3520 v other lathes. See "Reviews" page at http://mustardmonster.weebly.com/

Jerry

Re: lathe choices

#5

Re: lathe choices

robo hippy

I turned on a PM for 8 years before stepping up to a Robust American Beauty. Primary reason was that I wanted more horse power and torque. I have been turning on my Beauty for 2 years now. I did a detailed review of my lathe for Fred Holders Magazine More Woodturning, and that was followed the next month by another review from a different turner.

I never considered the Oneway. Primary reason is that I prefer the sliding headstock. My lathe sits in a corner, and turning outboard isn't an option, and I was used to the sliding headstock from my years on the PM. Biggest difference here between the PM and the Robust is that the headstock is more statically balanced than the PM. You release the clamp, and it doesn't fall back on the motor. It comes with two bolts that you use to tighten the pressure plate, but Brent has an adapter so that you can use a lever release, which I prefer as I micro adjust the headstock all the time when turning and coring bowls. The sliding headstock means never having to lean over the lathe to turn the outside or inside of a bowl. A real back saver.

Another advantage to the Robust is the Vector drive motors. I an not an electrical engineer, but it really keeps its power through all speed ranges. I can stall it, but after talking to Bill Grumbine, he said, "I can stall a VB 36." I also had Brent help my adjust torque and speed perameters on my lathe. The PM people won't do this. I need speeds down to 20 or so rpm for sanding my warped bowls. The PM 3520A would go down to this speed range, but that changed with the B model, and now they only go down to 50 rpm which is too fast for sanding warped bowls. They claim that it will burn up the motor, but I sanded out several thousand bowls at those speeds, and the motor runs cooler that when I am turning. They can adjust the speeds, but told me that the motor would have to be sent to them, and they would void the motor warranty.

If you have any problems with your Robust, if you call, you talk to the guy who made the lathe, not some tech who has to consult a manual to see what you are talking about.

Another consideration would be how big do you turn. I seldom go beyond 16 inches. The extra throw is not needed, and turning off the end of the lathe is an option. You should also look at the Robust Liberty with a 16 inch throw.

If you have the money, it is definitely worth it, and to me especially because it is made in the USA. If you are intent on saving money, the PM is a great lathe.

robo hippy

Re: lathe choices

#6

Re: lathe choices

robo hippy

Oh, I forgot, the Robust has adjustable legs to raise or lower the lathe to whatever height you need. Much better than the 2 x 4s I had my PM on.

robo hippy

Re: lathe choices

#7

Robust

Ed Moore in SW VA

Mike,

I have the American Beauty and I am glad that I made this choice. I had a small Stubby 500 (not the 750) and despite liking some of its features I got tired of making set-up changes.

The Tilt-Away tailstock feature is worth its weight in gold. Now it is even easier to use than the early form which I have.

I use a Powermatic at John C Campbell Folk School and very quickly I am reminded of how the headstock is in the way.

And Brent English is a class act who has made an excellent lathe.

Ed

Re: lathe choices

#8

Re: lathe choices

Jorge Casta�eda

Mike,

I don't know about the others, but the Powermatic is a lot of lathe for the money and you can turn on 3 sides of it. If you get it, I highly recommend to get the extension bed and the remote switch. The extension bed, lets you do stuff like newel posts if installed at the same level as the main bed, or using the alternate station, 9" lower, that lets you turn very large diameters, 39" IIRC. This is what I chose, and when not in use is a great place to park tool rests and other gear. I have the 3520b.

I did not anchor mine and so far have not added dunnage to it, and as I don't like the idea of a waltzing Matilda, I take good care of prepping and start slower. Perhaps if I was to attempt really big and unbalanced pieces a la Terry Scott, then I would anchor it and rig a big faceplate where counterweight can be attached.

One of the reasons I got it was because of a lot less money than the Oneway I had in mind, the other was because it takes all the chucks, toll rests etc I had for the Nova, same spindle and tool rest diameters.

Go for it

Jorge

Re: lathe choices

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: lathe choices

Lyle Jamieson

Ill add my kudos for the Robust. You get what you pay for in the lathe marketplace. It IS worth the extra cost. The fit, finish and engineering are all better when you spend more money. The Stubby is a good lathe but I get tired fidddling with the bed all the time. The PM is a good lathe, for the price, but no match to the Robust. Ive used them all many times. The Vicmarc is a strong lathe too. The kicker for me if I were to buy another lathe is, it is MADE IN USA, and has Brent to take care of service, but I have never heard of any service problems with Robust...like you hear from PM owners.

Re: lathe choices

#10

Re: lathe choices

Mike Johnson

I would suggest looking at the Vicmarc 300. I have the longbed version with an outoard turning attachment that would meet all of your requirements.

I have not turned on all the ones you are considering, but you could probably try them all for some travel time and little expense. For example, if you are near PA, you could take a lesson from Bill Grumbine on his Robust. If you are near Atlanta, you are welcome to try out my Vicmarc. Turning club members in your area would probably be very generous in letting you try their machies. That's the best way to decide, since there is a lot of personal choice in picking the "best" lathe.

Re: lathe choices

#11

Rikon 20x36  (Woodfast Model 70-500)

Russ Fairfield

If you liked your old Woodfast, you should look at the new 20" Rikon. It is labeled as a Woodfast Model 70-500. Everything about it looks like the Woodfast, and with electronic speed control. Sells for $2800.

I have given one of them a test-spin at the Woodcraft store, and would sure consider it if I were in the market for a lathe. It may not have the bling and bragging-rights that come with the more expensive machines you are looking at, but it will get the job done for a lot less money.

Re: lathe choices

#12

Steve Kubien

Question about the Rikon

Steve Kubien

How quiet (or loud) is it?

Re: lathe choices

#13

Re: lathe choices

Jim Canning

Powermatic!

Re: lathe choices

#14

Re: Question about the Rikon

Russ Fairfield

Nothing that I noticed as being any different from any other quality lathe.

Re: lathe choices

#15

Re: lathe choices

Jerry Hall

Lyle, I don't think it is necessary or accurate to knock PM service. I bet there might be a 30 times more PM's sold per year than Robust. So the odds of a concern are that much greater. I have experienced prompt generous service from PM, in fact shipping a part out of warrantee and no charge. Sure PM is corporate and Robust is personal (dependent pretty much on one person.) Pluses and minuses. I am aware of Robust problems, well responded too. And ditto with PM. They are both great lathes to be evaluated on their merits, features, and cost effectiveness. If someone does their homework and understands their needs I believe they will be happy. Jerry

Re: lathe choices

#16

Thanks to all

Mike Foster

You have given me a lot to think about. I really appreciate the great input that everyone has supplied. I am in no great hurry, and think that I will wait and spend some time at the AAW symposium to give the lathes a real go before I decide. I will also contact the suppliers to see if there is a Robust or Stubby around me that I could get the owner to let me go for a spin. Thanks again.

Mike

Re: lathe choices

#17

Re: lathe choices

Doug Turner

I have a short bed Woodfast with variable speed and it will be my last lathe because I like it andnd it meets all my needs. I use the jet mini lathe with the bed extension for spindles, and without the bed extension for craft shows and demos.

As far as the stability of the Woodfast 908 you can bolt it to a 3 foot long 4"x4" on each end of the lathe and it will be rock solid. You can upgrade the motor and a variable speed control to a 2 or even 3 horsepower for about 1/3 the price a a Powermatic 3520. I doubt your bearings are worn out on the Woodfast, but if needed,they are fairly easily replaced.

Consider a new lathe will be used after a few weeks.

Doug Turner

Re: lathe choices

#19

Re: Mike- I love my Stubby 750(Studly!)..

JamieDonaldson

...but if I had to replace it today I would buy the Robust American Beauty with the tailstock rotating feature. The 30"swing capacity (without additional parts) of the Stubby is larger than all the others, but I seldom use it, and doubt it would be a significant criteria for you. The adjustable legs on both Stubby and Robust allow solid stance on irregular surfaces without fastening anything down. Tough choice, and a well appointed PM 3520 with the Robust tailstock swing is an excellent workhorse as well.

Re: lathe choices

#20

Bill Blasic

Re: Mike- I love my Stubby 750(Studly!)..

Bill Blasic

I have four lathes setup in my turning area and use them all. A DVR3000, a 3520b, a 1220Jet VS and a 46-460 Delta Midi. The 3520b as I told my wife was going to be the in between step from the DVR to the American Beauty. This was before I even uncrated the 3520b as we were heading to Turning 2007. After getting the 3520b up and running I told my wife that I did not think that I would need the American Beauty as the Powermatic would suffice and it has and I believe it will for a long time. Will I rule out ever getting the American Beauty, probably not but those four lathes of which I use all still are about $2000 less than the Beauty. I do see one more midi coming in the not to far off future as a new one is coming out. Hey you only go around once so if you can, do what makes you happy :D .

Confession of a tool junky,

Bill

Re: lathe choices

#21

Re: lathe choices

Cyril Griesbach

Mike, I have a PM 3520B and like it a lot but if money were not the deciding factor I'd probably go with the Robust for most of the reasons given already. Having said that I want to point out to you that Brent also makes a Tail stock Tilt-a-Matic for the PM. I have one and it's the best addition anyone could make to their PM.

Cyril

Re: lathe choices

#22

Re: Thanks to all

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Mike, if you come to the Robust booth at the symposium, you will see my smiling face behind the lathe. Full disclosure here, I am a Robust dealer, so I might be a little biased. When you get to this level of lathe, and that includes the Powermatic, you are shopping for features. Lots of good opinions have already been posted here, so I will not repeat them, but I will write this. Many people write me saying,

"Bill, you have turned on just about every lathe out there. Why did you buy a Robust?"

My response?

"I have turned on just about every lathe out there, so that is why I bought a Robust." :D

And that is true. In the years that I have been teaching and demonstrating, I have extensive time on just about every lathe that is out there, and that includes the mysterious and elusive Rikon, which is a copy of the old Woodfast design. And I bought a Robust.

Re: lathe choices

#23

Brad Vietje

Re: lathe choices

Brad Vietje

Hey Mike,

I love the PM3520-B, and you are entirely welcome to come up here and turn a few pieces with the headstock slid down to the end of the bed, if you'd like. I have not turned on the Robust, so I have no comparative comments.

I've never had trouble with power and/or stalling -- maybe I'm just a wuss, but it seems to me that if 2 hp isn't enough, you gotta be doing something wrong. One shortcoming of the PM in coring is the height of the toolrest banjo. I wish it were taller for coring with the McNaughton rig, which seems to leave a lot of the tool post exposed, and not quite enough support down below. Maybe I could order a longer post for it, but haven't yet.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: lathe choices

#24

Re: lathe choices

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi Brad,

The longer post is a must, I got it and life is good...:o)

When you get it, make spacers so the cutting tip is at dead center or a shade above.

I drill a 1" hole trough a hardwood cylinder and then cut the different lengths according to the small set, the regular set or the jumbo knives set, no more adjusting to the proper height, saves a lot of time.

Jorge

Re: lathe choices

#25

Bill Hale The Wood Spinner

Re: lathe choices

Bill Hale The Wood Spinner

As nobody has spoken for the Oneway, I know a Canadian Import, I will put in my 2 cents worth.

I have not turned an very many lathes but I know the Oneway has done everything I could want. I have the 2436 with all rhe bells and whistles, big motor, outboard stuff with the added block etc. I added the outboard block so I can turn up to about 45 in and 5 in. deep with a tailstock in place. On thet big stuff I sure feel better with it heald on 2 sides. As to speed it will turn down to only a few rpm. Lathe is heavy and when bolted down it is amazing how stable it is. Quiet you can talk in a whisper when it is running. Any one ever wanting to test turn on mine is welcome.

Bill