Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Another first for me

Posts

Another first for me

#1

Steve Kubien

Another first for me

Steve Kubien

Earlier I posted my 1st burned piece. Well, I living proof that my mind was all over the place last week, I now give you my first box.


This is from one of the first pieces of wood I ever scrounged as a turner. -sniff- Sorry, a little emotional over here. :) Seriously, I have long admired the work of Raffan and our own Mike S. I picked up Raffan's box book here through the classifieds. I promptly lost it a few weeks after it arrived so I bought another one (so much for saving a few $$$). I do not believe Mr. Raffan or Mr. Stafford have anything to worry about from my box-making endeavours but this sure was fun.

The finish is oil/beeswax like R. Raffan recommends. It feels sooooo nice in the hand! When you pick it up by the lid, there is a tiny seperation between lid and body, but the body holds on. I think that is a good fit.

Comments? Opinions? Let's have 'em.

Re: Another first for me

#2

Re: Another first for me

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve, I think that you have done a great job.

You have asked for suggestions. Look at the profile on the side. I see a couple of knuckles. There are "bulges" at the top and the bottom - no problem. Between them should be one curve that goes smoothly through the break. Instead, there is a small knuckle below the break and a slightly larger one above the break. My suggestion would be to eliminate those knuckles.

This is much better than my first box, so I am not criticizing. :)

Ed

Re: Another first for me

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: Another first for me

Steve Kubien

Thanks Ed. Where are the bumps you are talking about? I know there is a bit of a 'base' near the bottom. That was intentional because I didn't want the bottom to meet the sides at a sharper angle. Perhaps this was a mistake? I'll eliminate it next time.

I also know there is a hump where the side transitions into the top. The idea was to give ones fingers somewhere to grip the lid securely. Too much? Not required?

Thank you for the critique. There is so much going on with boxes that I never imagined before. One could spend an awful lot of time exploring this form and I intend to give it some serious attention. I had better not let SWMBO know this or she'll never let me get a bigger lathe if I'm only working on smaller things!

Re: Another first for me

#4

Assume that you are an ant climbing...

Ed Moore in SW VA

up the outside of the box. Assume that the break occurs at 1.5", that "in" is toward the centerline of the box, and "out" is away from the centerline.

As the ant begins to climb it goes out until it reaches about .4 and then starts in. As the ant reaches 1.4 or 1.45 it goes out slightly until it reaches the break. This is the first knuckle. From 1.5 to about 1.6 the ant goes out and back in. This is the second knuckle. Then the ant goes back out and around and goes in as it climbs the top. The two knuckles should not be there. The profile from about .4 to 1.65 should be concave. If a tangent line were slid along the profile, it should be rotating clockwise from .4 to about 1.65 (ignoring the break at 1.5).

Ed

Re: Another first for me

#5

Re: Another first for me

Tery Scott

Steve what took you so long ,watch out the box journey will have you hooked in no time

Simply put an elegant box that you should keep because of its wood history and it being you first

Cheers

Re: Another first for me

#6

Re: Another first for me

Dave Moore

For a first box that's lovely. Heck, as a tenth box it would be lovely too.

I still have the first one I ever made, it's on the dresser in the bedroom, and it's nothing like as elegant as that one.

I'm fond of Raffan's forms also, and started by using his work as a point of departure.

Nothing wrong with any of that.

Good for you.

I agree with Ed, the little changes in direction you have going there are probably unneeded, either for looks or for the tactile quality.

It's a nice piece though. The thing is, pretty soon after starting this journey we start agonizing over minute details that only fellow turners (sometimes potters and other artists) even notice.

There's worse things to suffer from. ;)

Re: Another first for me

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Another first for me

Mike Stafford

I see what Ed is talking about with regard to the form but for a first box I think you did an exceptional job. I only have a couple of pictures of my first box and those were taken with a film camera and I can assure you of one thing it will never be posted on WC or anywhere else.

I like the little step you created at the join as that is something that is required on many boxes to help disguise the grain mismatch that sometimes occurs. I think you did a good job of selecting the point where to make the part for the join as your grain alignment is very good.

My biggest suggestion would be to create a little chamfer on the bottom so that a shadow line is created and the box does not appear to sit quite so heavily on the table.

Another thing that I love to do with ash is to dye and lime it. That process turns a rather blase wood into something with a lot of visual interest.

Good job, Steve, now go turn another. I love seeing boxes.

Re: Another first for me

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: Assume that you are an ant climbing...

Steve Kubien

Wow, that's like math or something but I think I follow you. Ok, back to the lathe (well, after I get an urn off of it). Thanks so much!

Re: Another first for me

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: Another first for me

Steve Kubien

Thanks Dave. Let's face it, we are our own worst critics. Still, that's what I love about groups like this...if you ask for opinions and help, you get both. Awesome.

Feelin' the WC love right now!

Re: Another first for me

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: Another first for me

Steve Kubien

Thanks for the words of encouragement and advice Mike. If I was to ebonize and lime this, how would I treat the flange and lip? Do they get finished as well? I didn't put anything on the contact areas of the body or the lid on this one.

Thanks!

Re: Another first for me

#11

Re: Another first for me

Brian George

Fantastic thread. Where else could one become an ant and realize a journey such as was de scribed. I mean that constructively and in a positive manner.

It caused me to go back and really examine the box. I still came up with the same conclusion. Fantastic - beautiful - graceful - well balanced! Great job, Steve!!

Re: Another first for me

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Another first for me

Mike Stafford

Steve, you just about don't have a choice. I have found it virtually impossible on ash to keep the dye contained/off of some surfaces. I suppose it can be done but as porous as ash is the dye seems to flow through the open grain readily.

The dye, if alcohol based, will not affect the flange on either the body or the lid. Water based dyes might cause some swelling that would have an effect. The liming wax will have minimal effect.