Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

Posts

McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#1

McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

Ed Larson

I had success today with the McNaughton Bowl Saver. The most helpful items: Reed Grays DVD and a inexpensive home made laser pointer shown below. Per Reeds suggestion I also fully tightened the set screw on the gates so they did not move on the post and sharpened the small knife (medium blades) before starting. I got three good cores from from a dry 5 X 10 pine blank (scrap). To help me I made a 5 X 10 templet and used it to estimate entry angles for each core ( the small arrows at the bottom right of the templet show the entry angles). On the large bowl notice the black lines on the back of the big core. They are located at the bottom of each core that I wanted. The laser pointer let me know that I was on course and at the proper depth.


Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#2

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

Chuck Jones - West TN

Ed I like your laser attachment. I think I might try that. I received my new Kel McNaughton yesterday and spent most of today playing with it.

I didn't approach it nearly as systematically as you did. I just set it up and stuck it into some wood. All the vibration caused my dog to move his sleeping place about five feet further away from the lathe. He's been hit with one busted bowl so he doesn't trust me as much when it comes to the lathe.

The idea of tightening the set screw is interesting. I thought about that today but figured the folks who designed it know more than me at this point.

I messed up the first couple, but then I got a couple nice ones. I think the darned thing may actually work.

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#3

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

Ed Larson

Chuck, I've had all of your experiences plus bent blades (the DVD shows how to bend them back to the correct position). Today was the first time I felt in control. There was no vibration. I'm looking forward to getting some good cores. Hope my experience may shorten your learning curve.

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#4

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

Tery Scott

Ive never had trouble with vibration

Your laser looks a great idea

How is your tip sharpened ,My set used to have a flat but I noticed the newer tools have a dart .Sharpening the new way cuts better and is less stress on my lathe

Cheers

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#5

Ed: Slick!

Jerry Hall

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#6

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

Ed Larson

Terry, My knifes have a dart point and I sharpen both side like you would a scraper and then add a burr with a diamond or ceramic stone.

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#7

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

robo hippy

Ed,

Glad my DVD helped. Also, nice improv on the laser pointer. It really helps me perfect my aim.

As to locking the gates/fingers down, for me, it gives me a fixed fulcrum for the blade rather than one that moves as I use it. Works for some, not for others. It also has the added benefit of allowing you to fine tune the blades. The bends in them are very inconsistant, and generally not true arcs of a circle. A little tweaking here and there make them core a lot easier. The tips on most of them tend to go straight rather than follow the curve of the blade.

On the tips, the old ones were flat and beveled off to one side of the blade. The newer ones are spear points which are centered on the blades. Much better. It does allow you to remove a bit off the inside of the cut, which was impossible with the old blades. I grind the spear point off square across the blade. Mostly it gives less cutter out on the tip, going from 1/2 inch of cutter to 3/8 or so. The spear point shavings seem to clog up in the kerf more than the squared off cutter ones do.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

#8

Re: McNaughton Up The Learning Curve

Ron Bauer

For what it's worth I will throw in my experiences with the McN bowl saver.

First of all, almost all my coring is done on natural edge bowl blanks.

1. It is unbelievable that after paying real good money for a tool that one has to buy instructions to learn how to use it. Absolutely the worst, as delivered, instructions I have ever seen. Come on Kel.

2. I also lock down the tool gate set screw to take out one bit of variability and slop in the post. Learned the hard way.

3. I adjust the tool post height so the cutter tip is dead center at maximum knife extension.

4. Then, I wondered what the little inserts were for that fit between the posts on the gate. They have to be for raising the knife. So, after experimenting, I get the best results by starting with the insert in place to raise the cutter tip at the begining of the cut. Then after about 60% through the core I take it out, lowering the tip. I don't know the dynamics, but seems to work best for me.

5. I have never had good luck coring off a chuck, no matter how big or tight. There is so much energy in the system that the blank jumps out or the tenon breaks. I usually core off a face plate.

6. I loosen the drive belts, relying on gravity to keep the belts tight, so any catch is less dramatic. The belts will squeal but thats better than losing the whole thing.

7. robohippy is right on when he recommends using a straight ground tip rather than a spear point. As he says, by so doing you lower the amount of wood being cut, and consequently how much power is being used.

8. When you have the correct relief angle on the cutter tip the thing feeds itself. It should be more like a scraper than a gouge.

Good luck. Ron B.