Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

Posts

Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#1

Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

Todd Nebel

Hello Everyone, a little while ago I was running my lathe and there was an electrical spark, followed by a pop and it stopped working. I called the local repair center and was told the lathe was discountinued and they don't make the part anymore. So, I'm at a lose as to what to do now. The lathe has not been used much so everything is worth saving if I can get it to work again. By now you are wondering what sparked and popped. It's the black box mounted above the headstock which controls the adjustable speed drive. It came from inside the black box (control panel / circuit board?). I unmounted the box and tried to open it from the back to see if there was a fuse to replace or reset. Can't seem to get to the board and can't see anything to reset/replace.

Does anyone here have this lathe and can offer ideas on how to fix this? Here is some additional information about the lathe.

Model 46-745 16" Wood Lathe

1.5 HP AC Motor 120V

Purchased 11/2001

The Part No in question: 438-01-016-0205 Variable Freq Drive

Thanks,

Todd

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#2

Ellis Walentine

Delta owes you a fix

Ellis Walentine

Get with their customer service people and don't let go until you have a working lathe.

Ellis

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#3

Re: Delta owes you a fix

john lucas

I would agree. Delta's been very good about customer service in the past and whenever I've had to deal with them. Be polite and ask for help. If you don't get it ask to speak to that person's boss. If your polite and friendly enough you usually can go as far up the chain as necessary to get something done.

I remember that lathe but don't remember any of the specifics. I don't remember if it had DC motor or AC. I just remember the one they brought to the Southern States Symposium had a bent spindle and they couldn't run it.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#4

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

Todd I have this lathe also. My controler also shot craps. Delta did replace it even though it was outside the warranty period. The only replacement they have not is a 220 volt instead of the original 110 box. Wasn't a problem for me since my lathe is 3' from my elec pannel. I just replaced the dedicated circuit. I did have to change the end on the power cord, but everything works fine. BTW the new box did not have the rpm gauge so I pealed the old one off and stuck it on the new box.

Good luck,

John

PS controllers can be purchased from good electrical suppliers. 220 ones are cheaper than 110 ones.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#5

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

JohnKyler

Delta.com is where you can find the part or google the part number and shop for price.

The drive is made by another manufacturer (another Delta) than Delta Woodworking machines. I have a Delta controller one my Powermatic.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#6

Delta rep called and said..

Todd Nebel

The Delta customer service representative just called me to say that he contacted engineering and they have a replacement part but it is a 220V controller and I would need to do the conversion myself. He also said it costs $240. Upon my request, he is going back to engineering to see if they have reports of this issue in the past and see if Delta would be willing to send me the replace parts at no cost. I really hope they do. I'll let everyone at Wood Central know how this turns out.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#7

A new Delta rep called...

Todd Nebel

I received a call from a new Delta representative today. He was unaware that the other representative called me yesterday. He was about to present the same solution, but will try to find the other guy and see where he is with an update for me. I'm not getting a good feeling here.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#8

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Rick in Colgate, Wi

John,

I have that exact lathe and after reading about your problem with the controller I took mine apart today.

There was a lot of accumulated sanding dust on the circuit board not to mention cotton fibers from using the buffing wheels on the lathe, any of which could of caused a short between a couple of the electrical components. If it were me I would find someone who can trouble shoot a circuit board and replace the damaged components, its not hard to do. Finding the replacement parts would be harder than actually doing the work. Maybe a local Radio Shack could help, they may even have replacement parts.

Rick

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#9

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Rick in Colgate, Wi

Oops, I meant Todd not John!

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#10

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

RJ

Todd,

I also bought a 46-745 in 2001. It has the same 438010160205 VFD, but my VFD has a Manufactured by Baldor Motors and Drives, Ft. Smith, Arkansas sticker on the side toward the tailstock.

Have you had any success with Delta?

RJ

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#11

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Todd Nebel

Hi RJ,

No I've not had any luck with Delta. I'm 0 for 3 so far. The three representatives from Delta I spoke to were not willing to investigate the failure due to the age of the lathe. Which I find dissapointing since 9 years on a woodworking machine is not old and the fact that I haven't used it but once a year for small projects doesn't seem to matter. I feel it's a defect of some kind but I can't prove it unless they are willing to investigate. Case in point, I bought a Forrest WW II blade around the same time (2001) and it burned wood from the start. I put it away and last year thought this is stupid, I need to call Forrest and have them look at this. Well they were nice on the phone, but asked every question that would lead to user's error. I finally said look I will send you the blade and pay for S/H and a re-sharpening service, just please look at it before you sharpen it. Well, they called and said the sides were not filed down to spec on this particular blade from the factory and they sent me a new blade with a hand written "we're sorry" note.

I have my local Woodcraft store and another kind member of Woodcentral contacting other Delta reps, so hopefully Delta will come thru. I'll let everyone know.

Thanks,

Todd

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#12

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Wilford Bickel

Todd,

Delta used two controllers in the history of that lathe from what I know. They used one from Baldour and one from Delta Electronics. Have you tried since it is out of warranty contacting the maker of the controller and seeing what help they can be on their unit?

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#13

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Todd Nebel

Hi Wilford,

Today I called Baldor and reached a fantastic person. He's not in customer support, he must be part of the shop floor or technical support because he's going to check the warehouse for demo models from 10 yrs ago that he thinks are back there and will send me one, for free, with no guarantee, if he finds one. I'll pay the S/h and take the chance it works. Otherwise, he provided me other options I can go with if I want to contact a Baldor distributor. All their options are cheaper than Delta's. The unfortunate thing I learned is that these Variable Freq Drives only have a life expectancy of 15 yrs. Had I known this I would never have bought this model.

Todd

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#14

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Wilford Bickel

Todd,

I am glad you got hold of someone at Baldour that is trying to actually help. I bought my 45-755X and it is still under the 5 year warranty until November 30 of this year. I don't know if trouble starts what Delta Machinery will do as mine has the Delta electronic controller. The problem is that all the brands are using these type of controllers. I have seen the same Delta Electronic controller on PM 3520's so I know for a fact that they have used the same controller I have. They do wire it a little differently and hang it on the back - don't know why. I figure when mine goes out of warranty and has a problem I know a good electrician that is qualified to work on heavy equipment and 3 phase units and I'll get him up here and let him figure out what he can do to get it running. That may mean at that time finding a motor and drive replacement system. With the 3 phase Marathon motor finding a replacement controller should be in the range of his expertise. You may need to find an industrial electrician, if you have a motor rewire shop in your area they should be able to help you get it running.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#15

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

John Lucas

Wilford The Delta controllers are not made by Delta woodworking. They are made by their own company and are excellent. I've had them on 3 different machines. when I had a problem with one I contacted my local Delta electronics distributor and he gave me the contact name of a Delta rep who helped me get it repaired. Turns out mine was just a programming problem and they stepped me through it. They were excellent people to deal with.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#16

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Wilford Bickel

John,

That was what I was trying to point out that they are two different companies. That's what I get for typing at bedtime. Thanks for making it clear.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#17

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Chuck Engstrom

While we're discussing electronic VFDs....has anyone every copied out the program as set up in their VFD for a 3520 or a 46-745? It seems to me that a dead VFD can be readily replaced, physically, but the trick then is: how should it be programmed? I kind of doubt that the ones installed on our lathes are using the generic program that would come pre-loaded, but I really don't have any actual facts about that.

The manual for the Delta on my PM3520 is available on line and I suppose I could figure out how to extract the coded parameters one by one. The machinery manufacturers kind of have us over a barrel on this and no doubt charge far more for a controller pre-programmed with their parameters than the same controller would cost from a general supplier.

Best to all--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#18

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne

Todd Nebel

Hi Chuck,

I don't know anything about the programming needed for a VFD. Maybe that would be the next hurdle to over come. You mentioned "a dead VFD can be readily replaced", this is what I'm struggling with. At $600 - $1000 to replace it I can't see this as readily available or even worth it for my limited level of use. This has been an eye opening experience for me. If I knew then what I know now I would never have bought a model with a VFD. They really sold me on the convienance of changing speeds and a reverse for sanding. I didn't know enough to ask about the total cost of ownership. My motto has always been buy a little more than you can afford, you will grow into it and it will be there for a lifetime. That backfired this time around.

Todd

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#19

I can't even see to type by bedtime 

John Lucas

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#20

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owne *LINK*

Ed Larson

I have a PM 3520b and looked at the contorller today. It is a Delta S-1. It appears that you can purchase this controller from the link below for $179. I would bet the standard programing that comes with the controller will work for the lathe. They sell many of the Delta controllers so I assume you can find the one that fits you Delta lathe. Anyway this thread has made me aware of the potentioal problem. If the $179 controller works for the PM then its cost relative to the $3000 for the lathe seem resonable. Hope you come out with resonable cost fix.


http://www.wolfautomation.com/Product.aspx?ProductID=23778

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#21

I don't get it?

Todd Nebel

Hi Ed,

Why would Delta Woodworking (DW) quote me $950 for a new VFD when I can buy one elsewhere for $179? Plus the one DW quoted me I would have to convert to 220. The one in your link I can order as 110 (which is what I have now). Thanks for the link, I will call their support line and confirm it will work for my lathe/motor if the following doesn't work out. I'm still in the process of working with other folks who offered to contact thier DW representatives and the folks from Baldor.

$179 is a reasonable price IMO.

Thanks,

Todd

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#22

Re: I don't get it?

Galen Vetterick

Reading the catolog data for your 1 1/2 HP motor you would need the 2 hp rated drive and that is $235.95 base price and does require a 220 volt input.

Then can you live with the drive speed features without adding additional external controls?

If you do not understand VFD controls best to tell a manufactures rep what you are looking for and let them select for you. You will pay more for a unit that has a 120 volt sigle phase input to 230 volt 3 phase output especially in

1 1/2 HP size.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#23

Re: I don't get it?

Chuck Engstrom

Delta Woodworking is quoting $950 because it comes to you with the appropriate programming already in it, and they're going to have to support it, and because Delta charges pretty high anyway -- compare prices on a 3-inch faceplate from Delta with others. For all we know, the program in it for a lathe is entirely generic or created for them by =their= supplier (which may be Delta Electronics, an entirely different outfit in Taiwan) from manufacturer's library of programs.

So...if we can just copy out the program that comes in a 3520 or a 46-745, we can buy the same model VFD and just get that program into it. Delta Electronics manuals are available online but are quite a bit to wade through, mine is 234 pages through it does cover many models/sizes. Needless to say, neither Delta Woodworking nor Powermatic would have much help for you if you went this route, but at $179 you can even fry one, try again, and still be ahead.

Best--

Chuck

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#24

Re: I don't get it?

bill crommett

When the VFD on my General blew up I resisted the $1100.00 that General wanted for a replacement and put in an after market $200 VFD. It works, but it has no torque at slow speeds and little torque at medium speeds. The plus is that I am becoming a more delicate turner.

Re: Calling all Delta Steel Bed 1642 (46-745) Owners

#25

Re: I don't get it?

Don Orr

Todd,

My Jet 1642 1.5 HP has a Delta Electronics VFD. It's the 110v 1 phase input that gets converted to 220v 3 phase to the motor. Have you thought of contacting WMH Tools to see what they have to offer ? Mine came with a book and CD about the programming. It is pre-programmed by JET and I had to get the unlock code from their Tech Dept. to alter my program to get a lower minimum speed. It was pretty easy to do. Just another option to think about.