The acquisition of a scroll chuck - SuperNova2 - after turning all sorts of spindles - literally opened up turning for me. Lacking tools for small hollow forms and having done a few Forstner Out A Hole & Turn The Outside "vases", a lidded box seemed to be the next thing to try. So from a dry deodor cedar logette that had been in a pile behind my chiropractor's office for three or four years, I turned this squat "capsule" box and finial. And not knowing any better, turned it mainly with a curved edge 1/2" skew - and my "80 Grit" tool (this stuff, being so dry, tore out easily).
Not the most elegant piece I've ever done, and the finial is certainly not the most refined, but it's a nice enough piece none the less. Of course I had to do a captured ring just to see if I could - with just a skew.
Still smells like cedar almost three years after turning.
Piece is about 3" diameter and about 7" tall. Finish on the outside is a couple of coats of Mahoney Walnut Oil cause that's what I had.
I totally agree that the proportions aren't that great, nor are the cuts crisp and clean and things don't "flow" much. This was probably the third or fourth piece I did after getting a chuck and had no idea who Cindy Drozda was/is and hadn't seen anything other than a Richard Raffan book.
I'll be posting examples of a few subsequent boxes with finials to hopefully show newbies that really nice and refined pieces aren't often done from the get go. With so many really nice pieces posted here, a new turner might get the impression that if their first few boxes don't look anywhere near as nice as what they've seen here - that they've failed - and can NEVER get pretty good at boxes.
This box is just an example for critiqueing (sp?)
The "collar" on the lid of the box should probably be a smaller diameter and it's transition curve should have a tighter radius. And rather than being basically flat, a slight upsweeping curve would provide "lift" for the attached with a tenon finial.
The bead at the base of the finial would look better it it too had a smaller radisu. And the curve from that point upward would look better as a single curve rather than a curve into a straight taper. The turning at the top of the finial look more like stacked wheels than nicely turned details. But hey, I was shooting for skew cuts that didn't become Spiral Cuts - and there were a few of those.
Then there are the easily corrected mistakes - not finishing the surfaces where the lid and box come together, tear out in the inside corner of the box in several places, a visible interruption in the flow of the curve on the lid (see second photo - it's subtle but obvious once you know what to look for)
On the plus side, the grain match is pretty good - and the grain flow is interesting. Oh - and the fit is close to a Pop Fit - on the tight side unfortunately. When the humidity goes up this box is hard to open.
Hell, just the fact that the piece got finished - and the lid fits was an accomplishement. Several early attempts ended with me trapping myself in a box canyon with no way out - that I was aware of at the time. The order of operations is kind of important when turning lidded boxes.
Understandably, we tend to post pictures of our best pieces. While they MAY act as ideas and inspirations for new turners, they can also be kind of intimidating. By posting some Not Quite and Near Misses pieces as well, and noting how they were subsequently improved in The Next Piece a newbie can learn a lot.
Sorry for the confusion - and thanks to Barbara for the correction and link to wiki.
When young, the branches are quite flexible and tend to produce a "weeping" tree look and the very small diameter blue green needles make for pleasing bonsai and are sometimes used for the "cascading" style. A fully mature tree can be pretty damn big and formidable looking.
Fresh cut, the wood's not bad to turn, but pretty resinous and can gunk up your turning tools - and hands. Turned dry it's proned to tear out and can be fairly hard. The smell of cedar is fairly strong of fresh cut wood tbough the smell fades some with time. It's not a flashy wood, being mainly straight grained. Dry, it appears to be pretty stabile, though, like all woods, changes with humidity.
Hey Charlie, I am one of those your article is addressed to and I appreciate it, great idea. You have advanced some of the issues that I am struggling with and wonder sometimes if I will ever get the curves, proportions and balance where they are acceptable. Thanks again.