OK, what is a finish?
Don Pencil
This quote appears in a previous thread.
Personally, I don't consider wax a finish. It may be considered a protective coating over a finish; but as a final finish it's a poor choice. producing a good finish can take up to as long as the piece took to turn and sand, maybe even more. With a good finish beneath, the surface can be waxed and polished with a soft rag, no buffing required.�
I then queried: �What are these good finishes?�
The response is too long to post here, but lacquer, tung oil mixed with polyurethane or spar varnish, shellac based finishes, and various other multi-coat, high build, film type coatings were among them.
If a finish is only the above mentioned, and the rest are not considered finishes then what shall we call surfaces that are textured, waxed, oiled, and the like?
May I here propose that we officially from this day forth refer to them as �done� and not �finished�.
One can then say �I am almost finished with the finish at which time the piece will be finished unless it needs to be refinished or the the finish is to be completely removed and it, or no other finish, will be applied in which case it will be a done �done� piece.�
Also one can say �after I am done with texturing (or waxing, or oiling), I will be done with my �done� piece, unless I then decide to finish the piece with a multi-coat finish in which case I will not be finished with my �finished� piece until I have finished finishing the finish.
If your piece is a �done� piece then at a gallery opening, demo, class, or other display of a piece, one must, when asked, �is this piece finished?�, answer �no, it is �done�. You can only answer �finished� if the piece has been finished with one of the coatings above considered finishes.
Just think how helpful this will be. One can now just hold up a piece in a meeting or other public venue and say �this piece is finished� or �this piece is done�. Captions in magazines and the like could read the same. How clear it is getting.
On the other hand, I am not sure of what we shall do with those pieces that are a combination of textured and hand painted. I will propose we will just say that this type of piece is �done finished�. That ought to get it.
Now having completed the above, I am not sure as to whether I am �done� or �finished� with my comments. I think we should pursue that in another thread.
Be Well,
Don Pencil
)

As a result, there is a need for some to defend.
Fair enough. That actually has been my point in many threads over time. So, let me be a little clearer as to what I�m driving at here.
I learn a lot from so many of you on these forums and want to respect those who post.
To do that I have to believe the experts in our field when stating facts or opinions are identifying the difference between the two. Too often they are not. Respected turners come on the forums and write statements that some issue is this way or that as an absolute. In many cases no one calls them on it when needed. Others then quote them and like the Ellsworth comment.







