Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OK, what is a finish?

Posts

OK, what is a finish?

#1

Don Pencil

OK, what is a finish?

Don Pencil

This quote appears in a previous thread.

Personally, I don't consider wax a finish. It may be considered a protective coating over a finish; but as a final finish it's a poor choice. producing a good finish can take up to as long as the piece took to turn and sand, maybe even more. With a good finish beneath, the surface can be waxed and polished with a soft rag, no buffing required.�

I then queried: �What are these good finishes?�

The response is too long to post here, but lacquer, tung oil mixed with polyurethane or spar varnish, shellac based finishes, and various other multi-coat, high build, film type coatings were among them.

If a finish is only the above mentioned, and the rest are not considered finishes then what shall we call surfaces that are textured, waxed, oiled, and the like?

May I here propose that we officially from this day forth refer to them as �done� and not �finished�.

One can then say �I am almost finished with the finish at which time the piece will be finished unless it needs to be refinished or the the finish is to be completely removed and it, or no other finish, will be applied in which case it will be a done �done� piece.�

Also one can say �after I am done with texturing (or waxing, or oiling), I will be done with my �done� piece, unless I then decide to finish the piece with a multi-coat finish in which case I will not be finished with my �finished� piece until I have finished finishing the finish.

If your piece is a �done� piece then at a gallery opening, demo, class, or other display of a piece, one must, when asked, �is this piece finished?�, answer �no, it is �done�. You can only answer �finished� if the piece has been finished with one of the coatings above considered finishes.

Just think how helpful this will be. One can now just hold up a piece in a meeting or other public venue and say �this piece is finished� or �this piece is done�. Captions in magazines and the like could read the same. How clear it is getting.

On the other hand, I am not sure of what we shall do with those pieces that are a combination of textured and hand painted. I will propose we will just say that this type of piece is �done finished�. That ought to get it.

Now having completed the above, I am not sure as to whether I am �done� or �finished� with my comments. I think we should pursue that in another thread.

Be Well,

Don Pencil

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#2

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca

Provocative post, Mr Pencil!

I am reminded, here, of the old addage:..."The work is not finished until the paperwork is done" ( a bit of toilet humor for you :D )

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#3

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Bill

OK, what is a finish?� Excuse me I am not one to complain but the real question to ask, �Why do we finish our wood projects?�

Is wax a true finishing material? Depends upon the wood, on some oily woods applying a coat of wax may well be the last thing you do to the project. To me wax does not fit the definition of a finish because does nothing to slow down exchange of moisture.

Wood Finish Selector

http://www.woodbin.com/calcs/finish_selector.htm

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#4

Don Pencil

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Don Pencil

Bill,

OK.

Then what does it do?

What does it protect against?

Oils any better?

What would you use for a natural looking finish on bare wood like wax will give you?

Don

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#5

Re: OK, what is a finish?

John K Jordan

To limit the term "finish" to some set of specific compounds or processes or attributes seems unreasonable to me. Who will define the list and who will police it? If someone wants to "finish" their work with bear fat or maple syrup, more power to them.

I personally love a beeswax finish on eastern red cedar as it leaves a soft luster. These two pieces have shown no change since I finished them, can't remember exactly but it's been at least six years for the first one. It is not in daily use as a functional container or cereal bowl but it does get some handling. I don't care if the beeswax allows moisture to pass into and out of the wood, it hasn't hurt anything.

I think the finish you choose should be appropriate for the intended use and intended look.

JKJ



Re: OK, what is a finish?

#6

Don Pencil

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Don Pencil

There ya go.

My thoughts exactly.

I too have 10 year old bowls buffed only with carnauba wax that look great.

Don

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#7

That Was Fun

Texian

A while back I turned a small vessel from the Australian wood Dead Finish. If I had textured and hand painted it, it would have been "Dead Finish done finished".

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#8

Re: OK, what is a finish?

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

When I was in junior high school I had a shop teacher who's last name was 'Done'. When the kids would come up to him and say, I'm done', he would always say, "No, you're finished; I'm Done." Weird how this silly joke has stayed with me for over 60 years.

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Keith Tompkins

Hi Don, All I'm saying is a wax finish doesn't work for me personally, and I then listed a couple of finishes that I use on a regular basis. As stated above, it's what works for you. I come from a manufacturing background, where catalyzed lacquer was sprayed on some pieces, while others were finished with modern oil finishes. A finish of wax on this type of work, say restaurant tables, would be totally inappropriate...every piece shipped out would be returned as defective, and would need to be finished with a more durable coating. Wax may be perfect for a salad bowl, easily renewable, while a lacquer finish would fail from constant exposure to moisture. On the other hand, we've all handled pens and other turned objects that are sticky and gummy after just a short time of being used...in that case, speed and ease of application were the primary concerns, not durability. Shellac based finishes may be perfect for a period reproduction, but not for a peppermill or pen. My feelings that wax isn't a finish is just my opinion, and not meant to offend anyone.

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#10

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Bill --Jacksonville nc

The link provided list wax as a finish. I do not believe paste wax is really a finishing material. Not saying paste wax does not have a place in woodturning. Oily wood a perfect example for using just paste wax. If you do not want to fool with acetone, shellac, natural resin varnish and waiting paste wax will do fine.

If have applied paste wax to your turning project and happy with results, so am I.

For some reason cannot get my link accepted in optional image url box.

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#11

Don Pencil

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Don Pencil

OK, this one was actually meant to be pure tongue-in-cheek fun. :b As a result, there is a need for some to defend. :\ Fair enough. That actually has been my point in many threads over time. So, let me be a little clearer as to what I�m driving at here.

Many of you are experts in one or areas of woodturning. Many bring expertise from other fields to the table (as reflected in earlier threads). 8) I learn a lot from so many of you on these forums and want to respect those who post. :) To do that I have to believe the experts in our field when stating facts or opinions are identifying the difference between the two. Too often they are not. Respected turners come on the forums and write statements that some issue is this way or that as an absolute. In many cases no one calls them on it when needed. Others then quote them and like the Ellsworth comment.

I personally spend a great deal of time correcting what these �experts� state as fact here and/or in some demo as fact about things that are their opinion or just what they think may be true. Sometimes it gets old. :(

You will note that I usually do not comment on things that are not in my field. I leave that for the experts or those with the experience to do so.

There are also those who have an interest (usually monetary) in the effect of the comment or they like to think their way is the absolute best but that is not included in the statements. >(

Fact, wax is a type of finish. Like others, I used it almost exclusively for many years and those pieces are looking great to this day. Fact, my gallery turnings are not meant to be used as restaurant tables. Fact, my turnings are not meant to be placed on a kitchen or bathroom sink or taken to the local farmers market or craft fair where rain or sun is an issue. :O

Opinion, I cannot imagine one would use it on a restaurant table, but if some has positive experience in having done so, then so be it. I still will not use it that way, but that is my opinion.

Fact, as noted by other turners, just about anything can be a finish. Horse manure may be the correct finish for some application, although I would not use it personally. Although it does work great on my lawn after I process the stuff I get from my neighbor. ;)

Please correct me when I am in error. Question my statements if they do not ring true to you. It will not be the first time I have had to change my thinking or point of view. If I cannot factually defend my position I will acknowledge it then and there. I will absolutely do my best to separate my statement of fact from opinion, even when I as a manufacturer have a horse in the race.

There is a great wealth of information on this forum. Keep it coming.

Don Pencil :D

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#12

Re: OK, what is a finish?

Brian George

As a younger boy, I used to watch the Finish guys peel pulp logs. I don't ever remember them getting done. There was always a hug log pile next to the loading docks at the side rail. Next time I'm back to my family grounds I will check to see if they are done, unless the Polish are doing it now...

Re: OK, what is a finish?

#13

image link

John K Jordan

>...For some reason cannot get my link accepted in optional image url box.

Bill, you should be able to paste the text of an image link anywhere into the body of a message.

http://photos-c.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc3/hs049.snc3/13650_101899453167935_100000436434935_53716_832833_n.jpg

I copied this one from a Facebook photo album and pasted the link into the message.

If you have a link and want to embed a photo into a message, use this format:

img src="url"

and enclose the entire line in open/close angle brackets (upper case "," and "." on the keyboard). Substitute your link for the url and be sure to include the double-quotation marks. Use Preview to check it before posting.

This is the same photo link embedded that way:


JKJ