Which of the following best fits your understanding and use of the term "faceplate turning?"
A. "Faceplate turning" means the same as "sidegrain turning." Therefore, you could do faceplate turning with a scroll chuck without using a faceplate at all.
B. "Faceplate turning" means that a faceplate is always used. However, you may mount a blank on the faceplate in either the sidegrain or endgrain orientation.
C. Other. (Please explain.)
Thanks in advance. Trivial? Perhaps, but important to me. ~Doc
1) "Duck Hunting" - - The sport of shooting ducks.
2) "Duck Hunting" - - The sport of shooting ducks, geese, quail, pheasants.
The name says it all, as far as I am concerned. Faceplate turning, to me, indicates the use of a face plate. You could anchor a walnut to it, and it would be face plate turned.
I think your quandry referrs to the axis your piece is being turned in.
I'll go with option C "Other". The reason being that I have never referred to using a chuck as faceplate turning, so that takes out option A for me. However, I also would never trust screwing a faceplate into end grain on a blank, so that rules out option B with its reference to any orientation. So, personally, I'll stick to turning with a faceplate screwed in to the long grain of a blank.
C. To me it means what it says - using a faceplate. I never screw a faceplate into endgrain so I have to pick C. I have been known to screw a faceplate into a wasteblock and then glue the block to a small endgrain workpiece though. Truth be told, I very, very rarely ever use a faceplate for anything. I start even capacity sized pieces between centers, then put them in the chuck.
I think of faceplate turning as being a combination of words that leads to confusion.
I use faceplate orientation to mean bowl orientation or grain running perpendicular to the ways.
I would refer to using a faceplate as mounted on a faceplate to indicate that an actual faceplate was involved...
I do my best to avoid ambiguity, especially around new turners where they may be interpreting things without understanding the reality of their situation.
To me it means sidegrain turning rather than spindle or long-grain turning. I won't say it is an ideal definition because you don't need a faceplate to do it. Maybe can pass it off as a historical quirk.
I can also do the preliminary stages between centers too, so does that make it spindle-faceplate turning? ):
The real lesson is that the term means different things to different people and if it's important then the speaker needs to clearly state what it means.
Faceplate turning was explained to me as being when the wood is revolving with the grain perpendicular to the axis of spindle rotation, i.e. face grain exposed with end grain and long grain coming into contact twice on each revolution of the wood. Faceplate turning does not require a faceplate as a wormwood screw can be used, a chuck can be used, and the wood can be started between centers.
Spindle turning differs from faceplate turning in that the grain of the wood is in alignment with the axis of rotation of the spindle. The end grain is only exposed on the headstock and tailstock ends.
I think that makes my answer "A"' but I am so confused these days about what is called woodturning I am not sure about my answer....
I have a book published in 1987 by Taunton Press and it's title is "Faceplate Turning".
The book contain 42 articles from past issues of Fine Woodworking magazine. There are articles showing the use of collet chucks, both commercial and shop made, jamb fit chucks, screw chucks and even 3-jaw machinist's chucks. The 4-jaw chucks that are so popular today weren't on the market in 1987 or they'd have been included too.
So not all faceplate turnings involve the use of faceplates.
But if the purpose of this poll is to determine conformity with regard to the terms and their usage, I think we are pushing water uphill. Analogy has been edited for sensitivities.
I think I understand where you are coming from with your question and hope to not confuse the issue any more than it already is.
I was taught in Jr. High shop that there are 3 kinds of wood grain in a sawn board. These also correlate to turning blanks I believe.
End Grain-cross cut fibers/tubes exposed on the end of a board (blank).
Edge grain-the narrow side of a board with the fibers/tubes running lengthwise along the edge.
Face Grain-the wide side of a board with the fibers/tubes also running lengthwise, but along the face-obviously the last 2 depend on how they were sawn as to what is actually exposed.
I'm sure you already know all this. When I do workshops or teach turning, I try to spend a little (or more) time on trying to get people to understand wood grain and also explain that they will hear terms like "faceplate" or "spindle" turning. I try to get them to understand that these are traditional terms used to describe the actual mounting methods and grain orientation of the wood to be turned regardless of what device is used to attach the wood to the lathe. I then try to use very specific terms like FACE GRAIN or LONG GRAIN or END GRAIN to more accurately describe how the wood is oriented on the lathe relative to the axis of rotation. As we all know FACE GRAIN turning is where the wood fibers are oriented perpendicular to the axis of rotation, and we generally cut directly into the FACE GRAIN, more or less. The resulting cuts then traverse both end and side grain as the wood rotates.
I personally think it is most important to understand wood and its grain and how it is going to react to being attacked with sharp objects and how to securely and safely mount that wood to a lathe. If one truly understands wood grain then things like "uphill, downhill, with the grain, against the grain" have more meaning.
Sorry this got so long winded, but this is an important issue to me to help beginners understand what is really happening when turning wood.
Big Thanks to everyone who responded. The comments were very informative and helpful, especially the one from Wally that gave the reference to the book. Hope you doing well, Wally ! ! !
I turned a faceplate out of MDF a little over a week ago. Threaded the hub with a spindle tap. I tested it by using it to rough out the outside of a 12-inch bowl blank, and it worked just fine!
But I must confess, . . . I cheated. I used the tailstock for support for all but the last few finishing cuts on the bottom because I read somewhere that you should always use tailstock support whenever possible.
Spindle turning means that, regardless of shape, size, or attachment method, the grain of the turning is parrallel to the bed.
There are lots of names for other grain orientations, but they are identified by not being spindles.
Now, what do you say about a really squirrly burl, turning on the bias, a turning made up of pieces of wood glued together in several attitudes, and multi-axial turning?
How many degrees off of parallel does it take before it is no longer a spindle?
Perhaps the answer is in the original reason for the definition - the methods and tools that you use to turn a spindle versus a cross-grained piece are opposites.
Who turns the outside of a cross-grained bowl for lip to bottom - large diameter to smaller?
Who turns a bead from the smaller diameter to larger?