Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

For Steve - Coring

Posts

For Steve - Coring

#1

For Steve - Coring

Carole Valentine

Steve, I am certainly not a master of coring - I still have a long ways to go - but I will try to explain what I was saying in the other thread. I may be right or I may be wrong...I am just saying what works for me. We are talking about fractions here, but in my limited experience, fractions count in coring. Couple of other things I have learned: Don't start learning with crumby, stringy, knotty, wild-grained wood. Resist the temptation to "pull" the handle towards you to force the blade around the curve...it will follow the curve set at entry on it's own. A little fish-tailing to widen the kerf is OK and I have found it to be desirable. Provide plenty of clearance for shavings - especially important on the tight radius blades. If the shavings stop coming out, stop and clear them. If you don't they will jam up everything and you get the big catch that causes our DVRs to halt. :) If you get a big catch, clean everything out, go back into the kerf and take very light cuts until you get past the gouged out area where the catch occurred - otherwise you will just dig into the same divot all over again. Let the blade do it's work, but don't let it run away with you. There are some areas where you might have to hold it back a bit and others where you may have to push it more.

Now for what you asked me to photograph - I couldn't take a pic so I sketched it as best I could. In the lower diagram (slightly exaggerated for clarity) the view is from the back of the blade towards the workpiece. It shows what I suspect happens when you start a cut with the turret very close to the wood and the narrow part of the blade between the columns instead of the wider part. Once you get into the cut a ways, you can move the turret very close to the workpiece. This is about the sum of my coring knowledge, but maybe it will help a bit. I highly recommend both Mahoney's Second Edition video and and Reed Gray's video. I probably would not be be coring if I hadn't watched them.


Re: For Steve - Coring

#2

Steven Antonucci

Thanks for the drawing

Steven Antonucci

Now, I will have to dig out a block of wood from the snow pile, make a quick bowl, and try what you suggest. When you set up the knives, I assume that you are entering the wood perpendicular to the surface and then feeding in the knife as normal?

Also, do you change the speed of the lathe with the the different knives? I try to run mine Nova 3000 at about 700RPM...would slower be better?

S

Re: For Steve - Coring

#3

Re: For Steve - Coring

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Carole shows the blade rotated to the right in one of her drawings. When I first started to core I would hold the blade upright. Generally, the instant the cutting edge touched the wood, the tool would rotate and the cutting edge would dig it. What normally resulted was a monumental catch. Now I twist the handle clockwise when starting the cut. And I hold it in that position when making setups.

If you are careful, you can enter the wood at any reasonable angle not just ninety degrees. Whether to use 700 rpm or something different depends on your comfort zone and the diameter of the cut. In any cutting operation, it is the "surface feet per minute" that is important. That is why you can turn a pen at 3000 rpm but wouldn't want to be in the same room with a 12" bowl at the same rpm.

Re: For Steve - Coring

#4

Re: Thanks for the drawing

Carole Valentine

I hardly ever start the cutting tip perpendicular to the face of the wood...I generally enter at a slight angle, based on the path desired. (That means more of the left side of the blade will be cutting at first until you get the entire cutting tip into the wood.) Don't forget to come back and relieve the left side of the kerf so it doesn't bind as you curve through the piece.

I do almost all of my coring at around 600 rpm. I may lower it a bit as I get close to the end of the cut (you can tell by the sound when that is happening.) If you think you are going too deep, move the tool rest a fraction back towards you; if you think you are too shallow, move it away from you. Again, fractions count - a very small movement results in a substantial path change!

Oh and when you do get a catch (which you will now and then) check your set up to be sure your tool post has not been forced down a tad. That happens sometimes with the Nova (cheesy locking.) If that's the case your cutter is going to be too low and you will never get through the piece. Also check the tenon and chuck seating. I can't emphasize too much how important it is for the shoulder to have absolute flush contact with the jaws when coring! Ok...I think I am though editing now...:)

Re: For Steve - Coring

#5

Re: Thanks for the drawing

Jorge Casta�eda

Steve,

The Nova is underpowered for coring, so compensate with speed, around 1200 is good, and small bite.

have fun

Jorge

Re: For Steve - Coring

#6

Re: Thanks for the drawing

Jorge Casta�eda

Carole,

The going down is easy to take care off, just tun a cylinder, make a 1" hole through it and then cut it to the proper dimension, so the tip of the cutter is just at center or a little bit higher. I have the normal set and the smaller one so I have two spacer blocks, one for each set of knives.

Greg Jennings himself told me to core at higher speed to compensate for the under rigged Powermatic, so more so with the Nova. So try at 1200 and just a small bite with sharp cutter, as you said earlier, you'll have to hold it back.

Give it a try

Jorge

Re: For Steve - Coring

#7

Re: Thanks for the drawing

Carole Valentine

May try going up that high on smaller cores, Jorge. On smaller stuff I have been going to around 800 or so. I just don't think I would go that high with a capacity chunk of wood on there though and I am not going to tell someone else to do it. LOL

Re: For Steve - Coring

#8

Re: Thanks for the drawing

Carole Valentine

When I first started, I used a piece of pipe for that. Don't have the problem much any more (famous last words - next time I core I will probably get the mother of all catches just for saying that!) I do set the stop collar when I set up.

Re: For Steve - Coring

#9

Re: Thanks for the drawing

Jorge Casta�eda

Carole,

You are right, I just came form coring a 14" x 7" and I did it at 900, the speed at the rim area is quite high and gets higher at larger diameters., I core with the live center (?) blank, senior blank, tail stock, that's it! on so it restricts the available space, and end up coring without the handle, because there is no room, it gets loose every time anyway.

I like your drawings, what did you use to make them?

Thanks

Jorge

Re: For Steve - Coring

#10

Steven Antonucci

I have the 1.5HP upgraded motor on my 3K

Steven Antonucci

I don't think my issue is power related. Usually happens pretty much on contact, speed independent (400-1000RPM). Clearly the issue is one of a user without the requisite skills holding the tool in hand...but I digress :-)

Re: For Steve - Coring

#11

Re: Thanks for the drawing

Carole Valentine

Yes, I did not do the math for 1200 rpm to see how fast the outer rim of a 14" piece was spinning, but it is more than I want to deal with in that situation! I have never brought up the TS when coring - just seems inconvenient and don't like coring without a handle - tried that once too. ;)

I use CorelDraw for drawings, but any vector drawing program would work as well.

Steve, let us know how you make out.

Re: For Steve - Coring

#12

Re: For Steve - Coring

robo hippy

I don't think this was a point that I covered on my DVD. I have done it for so long that I don't think about it. The blade will rotate a bit to the side, but it never bothered my coring. No extra catches, and as soon as you get in an inch or so, problem solved. If your gates/fingers are not locked down tight like mine are, they will rotate, effectively narrowing the gate, so the blade doesn't tip as much. If your gates are locked down, if you have them slightly angled, rather than square to the track you want to take, it does the same thing.

Speeds are like all turning, whatever you feel comfortable with. Since there is no read out on any lathe I have had, I can't quote specific speeds. I am probably up to or over 1000 on smaller bowls, and down to 500 or less on larger ones. Just like my regualar turning, on large bowls, turn it up till it starts to vibrate, then back off a bit. If you grind the spear point down like I do, you are removing a 3/8 inch wide shaving. With the spear point, it is more like 1/2 inch. So, what speeds do you feel comfortable turning at when you are taking that kind of shaving?

For the entry cut, entering square to the wood or at an angle depends on the track I want, and the blade. If the blade has more curve than the outside of the bowl, I am more square to the bowl blank. If the blade is flatter, I am at more of an angle. It does help to flatten the surface before making the entry cut, and just like when you are turning a bowl, your entry cut is gentle at first until things are evened up. You just don't plunge into an uneven surface, or an even one either.

I haven't seen Mike's new version of his coring DVD. He did tell me it was pretty much the same thing, but just better filming.

robo hippy

Re: For Steve - Coring

#13

Re: For Steve - Coring

Carole Valentine

Hi Reed,

I'm not sure what you mean when you say "if you have the gates locked down"? Is there a way to adjust them? Mine appear to be in a fixed position (no rotation). Could you explain?

Re: For Steve - Coring

#14

Re: For Steve - Coring

robo hippy

On the tool rest for the McNaughton, both the fingers/gates and the support bar (used to be T shaped, now a square) would rotate as you cored. I prefer my fingers to be locked down tight. The tool support has to rotate to account for the swing of the handle as you core. I did this by drilling a hole in the tool rest post and sinking the set screw into that, then putting another set screw in on top of that one. I just didn't like the fingers moving as I was trying to core. On some of the newer ones, the top inset ring on the tool post doesn't line up as well with the set screw, so it is more difficult to do. I do show this on my DVD. A modification that I made that helps the tool work better for me.

robo hippy

Re: For Steve - Coring

#15

Re: For Steve - Coring

Carole Valentine

Thanks. Must have dozed off during that part...no reflection on your DVD. That happens to me with all of them, no matter how interested I am. Seems that ANY DVD is a signal for my eyelids to suddenly gain 10 pounds each! LOL

Re: For Steve - Coring

#16

5/8 of a mile

Jorge Casta�eda

per minute at 900rpm...

Re: For Steve - Coring

#17

Re: 5/8 of a mile

Carole Valentine

55 feet/sec or 37.5 mph. Doesn't seem that fast until it's something hitting you or slinging across your shop! LOL