Re: How do we "categorize" (for lack of better wor
fgvanatta
When all is said and done a turner's work speaks volumes, everything else is incidental.
Frank
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: How do we "categorize" (for lack of better wor
fgvanatta
When all is said and done a turner's work speaks volumes, everything else is incidental.
Frank
Steve, categorize this....LOL
Mike Stafford
Where do you place someone using 24 grit? 
24 grit on a segmented piece.....
A caveman :-P
Steven Antonucci
rubbing rocks on a board...
Teach them what they want or what they need?
Steven Antonucci
I still struggle with the hostility in this discussion. My original point was geared around the fact that I find it very effective to correct physical problems with a physical solution. As a side note, I also thought that most turners overestimated their abilities which often put them in classes that they were in over their heads.
Personally, I don't really care how people remove wood, as there are a million ways to do it, but would I want to pay someone to show me how to hog out wood with a scraper? Seems kind of silly.
Putting someone into a "bucket" isn't bad either. It categorizes them by their needs, not their wants. If I want to make hollowforms, but I can't turn the outside without the 60 Grit gouge, is it really safe for me to be poking a tool through the hole? I am a firm believer in building on capabilites, and I don't want to endanger anyone. If there is something wrong with that, I'm oblivious.
And everyone seems focused on the fact that this is somehow "intrusive", "rude", or "offensive", but anyone I've ever do it for has not only returned, but they recommend me to their friends. Go figure.
Steve
It makes you a donut junkie :-)
Steven Antonucci
Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...
Steve Kubien
That sounds a lot like me except you actually got a bunch of stuff done. Not what you wanted to, but stuff got done nonetheless.
Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...
Keith Tompkins
HI Wally, I had a class titled "Turn a Masterpiece". The idea was to focus on just one piece, and to make that one piece the very best you've ever produced. The idea was to stress quality, not quantity. One fellow, I don't know why he signed up, really gave me a hard time. He stated "I turned a thousand bowls last year, who are you to tell me anything?" I asked him of the thousand bowls, how many did you really, really like? Finally he admitted...."None". I didn't think he was going to stay, but after two days, he had produced a pretty damn good bowl. That ended up being a very good class.
My open speech (draft, of course)
Steven Antonucci
Hey everyone, my name is Steve. I've been turning for 15 years, and good for the last three. I spent 12 years doing things the hard way. The goal of the next two days is to expose you to "the right/easy way" so that you can become proficient in fewer than 12 years.
I'm going to evaluate all of you for ability, and since you are in an Intro to Turning class, assume that all of you are beginners. That's not a bad thing, and I promise you that you'll get to intermediate in less than 12 years if you can learn 2 or 3 things this weekend (and then practice them over and over and over...)
Oh, and by the way, we are going to cut lots of wood this weekend, but we are not focused on "making things", so if you need to get a bowl out of the next couple of days, it's probably not going to happen. If things go well and we move together as a group, we may be able to rough out some bowls for you to finish at home. If you really need a bowl, there's a Walmart on your way back down 206...
Who want's to step up and turn something in front of the group...? (and I am guessing that pick the first victim from here)
(And we will be done in 10 minutes- and then go straight into tools and sharpening...)
Re: Teach them what they want or what they need?
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
Steve, don't confuse blunt with hostility. Like Ed wrote in the other thread, this is just a little of your own medicine - telling you the way it really is. You made some pretty strong statements about the abilities of other people based on your own arbitrary scale. Obviously a bunch of us don't agree with it.
I will also tell you I don't agree at all with your "grab the tool" philosophy, regardless of what is about to happen with it, or how much you disagree with the way it is being held. There is a technical word for unwanted touching - assault. Think it can't happen to you? Guess again. With all my students, but especially women and children, if I am going to do hand over hand movements - a very effective technique - I ask permission to touch the gouge. I explain where I am going to put my hands and why. Failure to do that in a close quarters situation can land me in all sorts of trouble that I do not need or want if the wrong perception is given. All it would take to lose everything you have would be to bump someone in the wrong way in the wrong place. The next thing you know, you are on Megan's List. This is not paranoia, it is a fact of our society today. If anyone wants to counter with "all turners are nice people" or "that would never happen to me" then they need to rethink their participation in the teaching process.
I have been teaching for 15 years now, and can probably claim well over 1000 students. I have never had a problem like I describe above, although I have gotten some weird vibes a couple of times. Then again, I have never cut my hand off in a saw either, but I have to think that every time could be the next time if I want to keep it that way. Anything else is head in the sand wishful thinking. It can happen and you will be in the middle of it before you know it if you are not prepared and behave accordingly.
As far as what is and isn't safe, again, that is determined on a case by case basis. I have had students come in and turn winged bowls right off the bat. In some cases they went home and turned one after a demo on how to do it with very little experience under their belts. But I have to tell you, to try and categorize people by what kind of sandpaper they use smacks of snobbery, and doesn't really address any sort of issue beyond a very narrow technical competence. It is surely important, but to make it a panacea just doesn't work.
Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...
Fred Bearman (Port Huron, Michigan)
I don't have the answer as to whether you are an expert or what, but I do know that you did a pretty good job of describing my typical day 
Steve, it would be in your best interest.........
Don Pencil
to get off this topic.
I have been a professional and/or volunteer instructor for over fifty years (I am presently sixty years old). I have been trained formally in as an instructor in three fields and informally in at least three more. I have been a trainer for instructors in two of professional instructional fields and two of the laymens' fields.
I say this with all respect due you and others and wish you well in what you are doing. But I have not read anything here that would incourage me to believe that you understand the field of instruction at all. All of your statements about "catagories", "60 grit", and how you would rate an instructor would demosrate to me that you just do not get it.
Bill has been reasonably polite in his response to these comments and everything he has stated in them are very correct.
Only this past January I witness a demonstration here in Washington state by a man who ripped through a blank with a reground planer blade stuck in the end of a piece of steel. When he got it about the way he wanted it he quickly cleaned it up a bit with a crude looking bowl gouge and then took out an angle grinder with 60 grit or less on it and worked his way up through the grits as Bill mentioned. When he was done he had a great bowl. This guy sells huge amounts of bowls ranging from $250 - $2000 and they are great. Naturally you would not consider taking a class from him as he (after 50 years of woodturning) is only a beginner.
I will say that telling a woodturner that they are not any good until they can work a bowl with tools only ready for 220 grit sanding is wrong and is very discouraging to those who love to turn and just need a little more time.
I am very please for you that you are one of the few and fortunately extremely gifted turners who can whip a bowl out with a tool ready for the 320 or 400 grit touch up. But it is not fair to impose this extremely unreasonable attitude on the others. There is no need for it and certainly does a disservice to the turning community. It does not impress me that it can be done (and yes I can do it) and it is certainly an expectation that should not be in the mix.
I wish you well,
Don
Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...
Barry
That is so cool.........and so true! Reminds me of a little story that circulated on the internet a while back about why senior citizens never get anything done.
Long Live the 60-Grit Gouge!
Barry
Re: Categorizing turning ability
Tery Scott
Steve thank you for bringing this to the thread
I have been following every comment with interest
I think I will stay in the beginner intermediate category
As I sand with what ever grit I need to do the job
Some times the timber just calls for a harsh treatment.
Nor can we gauge a turner by the years they have been turning or the amount of tools in his or her shed.
I will never look at myself as an expert because many times I have entered competitions and a pure novice (someone that has been turning for less than a year) can wip my but big time. Many times this maybe by students that I have taught to turn as well .This gives me great satisfaction thinking that I have passed on some of my Knowledge More often than not I learn as much from the lesson as they do
So maybe as you suggested the level you are at is the amount of knowledge you can pass on
Having taught a blind student to turn I will place him in the expert category
After 2 hours he had no fear ,and could get a finish better than most .He had the advantage of being able to feel and listen by ear to the chisel
I didnt charge this student as he taught me so much I felt like I was the student Listen to the cut he would say feel the form .
We all need aims and aspirations to better our selves
Me I dont care if I am a beginner or an expert I just have fun and just hope that I have gained in my 12 years of turning the ability to pass on what others have taught me
Cheers
Does that mean I'm a senior citizen
john lucas
Re: How do we "categorize" (for lack of better wor
Carole Valentine
Perfect, Bill. Perfect.
Re: Categorizing turning ability
robo hippy
Well, I was busy most of the afternoon and missed this one. Interesting.
One comment, sanding grit does not determine ability lever. Mike Mahoney starts with 80 grit. I heard one story, and it must have been about Bob Stocksdale. A noted turner was starting his sanding with 36 grit and some one commented on how rough that was for starting grit. His comment was "How much do your pieces sell for?' Most of the time I will start with 120 or 80. I used to have to start with 80 every time. I can start higher some times, but some times 120 can save more time than starting with a higher grit.
Another point, teaching ability and turning/artistry skills are two different things. Some can be masters of both.
I can teach people things to get them past hurdles in turning that I had to figure out. They can reach my level quicker than I did. Imparting knowledge feels good when it is absorbed, but not all good turners are good teachers, and not all teachers can reach all students.
I won't consider myself a master until I have nothing left to learn. Don't think that will ever happen.
Speed is an interesting competition, but no real indicator of talent. Design is every bit as important. Speed is only important for production. Efficiency is intelligent laziness, and is different from speed.
robo hippy
Re: How do we "categorize" (for lack of better wor
cliff
good morning all,
enjoying this exchange and i agree 110% with bill and don, i have been turning about 2 years i enjoy it more than anything i have ever done , have been involved with woodworking all my life 53 now. i recieved a lot of encouragment from experienced turners when starting out , my skills have imprpved tremendosly in that time to a point that i am very happy with what i can do and am always lookint to improve my skills. the first dvd i was reccomended was bills i think his teaching style is far and above most i have seen. to sum it up i would be very put off evn mad if someone put me in a category simply because of my lenght of time turning or what grit paper i use.
cliff
"Master Class" - For clarification.....
Rob Wallace
....a master class is given by a Master to promising students - not given TO masters of the art or craft.
Being invited to be included in a master class is not a definition (by whatever nebulous criteria) of being a master; rather, that someone has identified potential in the student to develop the skills toward becoming more proficient to a markedly improved skill level. BTW - Norm Abram is identified as a "Master Carpenter", but I would not want him teaching ANYONE how to use a lathe or turn wood. Like many other terms used without standards, the term 'Master' is relative to the context in which it is used.
As you and others have discussed elsewhere in this thread, names, categories, and assumptions can be confusing, or worse, misleading. Without careful and consistent application from instructor to instructor, or venue to venue, such perceived or self-declared levels of ability are really nothing more than erroneous estimators of skill or proficiency.
Trying to quantify the large and complex continuum of woodturning skill among students by using some arbitrary metric such as 'starting grit', speed of cutting, or time to project completion seems almost useless. I say 'almost' in that at least it provides some evidence that they have actually turned something. It does not, however, provide any useful information which can help an instructor assess a student's skill level directly.
As a long-time teacher of several thousand students at the University level (since 1981), I can tell you that short of some form of standard examination of specific information and skill sets (as many professional organizations have for certification), what is being proposed here is merely a guess at students' understanding and skill acquisition in a particular discipline or craft. I don't see this as a viable estimator of the kind of information about students you are seeking to learn.
Rob Wallace
Re: Does that mean I'm a senior citizen
Barry
Maybe! No question about me. Your post just described a typical day in my life..........
"multiple portfolios"?
Dave Belser
The only stupid question is the one that you don't ask.
Could someone explain the difference between "a portfolio" and "multiple portfolios"? I thought that your portfolio was simply a collection (photographic) of your work.
I must be an intermediate..... 
Re: "multiple portfolios"?
Dave Moore
Yeah, well, it's the "art" world, and the rules are different.
Your "portfolio" is what you get when you have a single collection of photos of your work. "Multiple" portfolios are what you get when you divide that single collection into smaller ones.
A lot of artists do that when they have works that are in a "series", that is to say a run of work that is connected somehow, perhaps by materials used, or style of execution, or conceptually or whatever.
If you then accompany such portfolios with just the right carefully chosen words, then you have multiple portfolios and you can charge more. 
Re: "multiple portfolios"?
John K Jordan
I don't know about fine art or turning portfolios, but before I retired I had multiple portfolios of my 3D graphics work. I used these for different audiences - for example, I had one set of images of architectural work, another with scientific and technical work, etc.
JKJ
FYI- his beginner class isn't labeled "Master"
Steven Antonucci
even though it is the same instructor.
Master in the course catalog describes the students who will participate. It is an invite/reviewed portfolio class. No doubt, I was just on a mailing list...
S
Re: "multiple portfolios"?
Dave Belser
Ah that explains it.
I'll be splitting up my portfolio first thing tomorrow, right after I raise my prices. 