Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Categorizing turning ability

Posts

Categorizing turning ability

#1

Steven Antonucci

Categorizing turning ability

Steven Antonucci

The teaching thread below got me thinking (and I do believe that I see the sun for the first time all week!). How do you all categorize ability?

Her's my definitions:

New turner- doesn't know anything about what tool does what operation, cannot stand at a lathe safely

Beginner- has the basic knowledge of the various tools and operations, but lacks proficiency with most common tools. May be turning for 1-2 years.

Intermediate- has basic proficiency with all common tools, but may improve with minor changes to stance, positioning

Advanced- has good tool skills, can perform any operation without thinking about it or fear

Expert- has the ability to communicate to any level of turner and help them understand cause and effect

My thinking is that most turners put themselves at least one category higher than they actually are. I know that I was an expert when I was an intermediate turner. I think I might actually be an expert now, but only because I have been teaching/mentoring for 2-3 years and it actually forced me to think about what I was doing instead of just doing it!

My litmus test for categories is sanding. 60G puts you in New/beginner 120-150G puts you in intermediate, 220G and above and you get advanced or better. What say you to this scale? (starting point for sanding, only!)

s

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#2

Re: Categorizing turning ability

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

That makes me a beginner then. I sand faceplate orientation work starting at 80 grit almost every time. Spindle work starts at 120. I find that it works very quickly to remove tool marks and minor tearout, and I can go up through the grits in virtually no time at all. And for the record, I know a lot of beginners who are very highly regarded at this stuff. ;)

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: Categorizing turning ability

Steve Kubien

I took a key from Bill's first dvd and I am no longer ashamed or afraid to start sanding at 80grit. 5 seconds with the 80g results in far less time with the 120 and beyond.

Before you added the sanding reference, I would have said I am an intermediate turner, certainly no more. I make my tools do what I want them to do and what they are designed to do. In a few cases, I use tools with good success doing things they are not meant to do. There are operations which I am terible at but I am often able to identify them (and I am getting better).

Cheers,

Steve

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#4

Re: Categorizing turning ability

Russ Fairfield

If the sandpaper grit is what determines the beginner, then I'm in the same category as Bill, and we have a lot of good company.

The problem with your listing is that it is only half of the story. The other half is what I will call "artistic vision" for lack of a better description. Some people have only the vision, and some have only the skills. The really great ones have both.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#5

Re: Categorizing turning ability

John Lucas

I'm glad we are just talking about skill with tools. I can't say I'm an expert with all tools. I'm pretty good with the ones I use. The next level up must be expert+. Those are people like Mike Mahoney, Stewart Batty, and David Ellswoth. These guys know why and how the tool cuts and can even explain it to you.

As for sanding. It's not my favorite pastime. It's extremely important but something I would rather not spend a lot of time with. I've been experimenting with cutting techniques and can now usually start sanding with 220 on most projects. However there are times when I can stop and start sanding and be done with the project faster than I can if I make one or two more cuts to clean everything up. This is probably what Bill G. is talking about. As a production turner you have to look at the whole system and look at time saving techniques.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#6

Re: Categorizing turning ability

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

John, that is a big part of it. One of my lesser known demos involves the skew. I'll turn two table legs with a skew and a parting tool. I will often roll beads with the skew. I will show the onlookers my less than perfect bead, make a few derogatory comments about its perfection, and then proceed to turn it into a virtually perfect bead with a quick wipe of sandpaper. I go on to explain that not only does the sandpaper smooth the surface of the bead without reducing its size significantly, it also prepares the surface to the same level of everything else that is sanded. I see lots of people who say they don't need to sand they get such a smooth finish off their skew, and then wonder why that burnished surface doesn't take stain or clear finish to the same degree as the wood around it.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#7

Re: Categorizing turning ability

John K Jordan

Like most attempts at categorization of a diverse set such as "woodturners", this doesn't make much sense to me. Like many fields a given person may be the world expert at one aspect and a rank beginner at another. Inventing metrics to compartmentalize and evaluate is something at which government agencies excel.

My favorite definition of an expert: One who makes all his mistakes in private.

JKJ

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#8

Mike Peace

Re: Categorizing turning ability

Mike Peace

What is the purpose for the definitions?

I agree with John K that labeling my not make a lot of sense. Having behaviorial definitions can be useful in describing how a turner is expected to fit in with a particular class. I think a starting sandpaper grit is a bit simplistic.

This is what Anderson Ranch uses:

Level I � Students are new to woodturning and have no formal training.

Level II � Students have a basic understanding of fundamental turning tools and techniques and are comfortable using and sharpening bowl gouges and spindle gouges.

Level III � Students have significant turning experience using both green and kiln-dried lumber. Students are capable of selecting wood, able to use and sharpen gouges, and familiar with basic principles of 3D design. Students have some formal technical training in woodturning and have a portfolio of their artwork.

Level IV � Students have advanced skill and knowledge of woodturning. Students are highly motivated, have a minimum of five years experience in the field, and have multiple portfolios of their artwork. Typical students are academics and professional artists.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#9

Steven Antonucci

How do we "categorize" (for lack of better word?)

Steven Antonucci

Ok- so how do you judge proficiency of a turner? I think anyone can sand their way to a good finish (eventually), but would you want to take a turning lesson from someone that still needed 60 grit paper?

I suspect that surface quality is a very good indicator of someone's technical ability. I think there are very few people out there right now focused upon improving mechanics- lots of style demos, making things demos- but very little focus on basic skills.

I was invited to a Master Class, which I thought was pretty funny. What made me a "Master"? Was it some technical achievement? The fact that I could afford to go? What were the prerequisites? How had I qualified?

Reread the thread below and I think it underlines my original point. Most common comment was that people had registered for courses that were beyond their perceived ability. In some cases, this slows the class down. Is that fair to the other people if the "slow" person requires more of the instructors time?

My first act in my class is always to have someone "turn something". I watch how they stand, where they stand, what their cuts look like- and then I throw them in the "right bucket" (according to me).

How would you evaluate a turner as an instructor (if not by grit)?

Steve

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#10

Re: Categorizing turning ability

John Lucas

Bill I found out first hand that sometimes you have to sand. I can turn a spindle so it looks like you used 400 grit or higher. The problem is it's a burnished finish and won't take stain evenly if at all. I sand spindles that are going to be stained no higher than 220.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#11

Steven Antonucci

Independent (objective) assessment

Steven Antonucci

The problem with the Anderson Ranch definitions is that the student gets to put himself/herself anywhere they want. I know turners with years of experience on me that I have to wear earplugs around (to drown out the screeching of their tool ability). Quite often (always), we see ourselves differently than the world view us.

In addition, I may be comfortable with my own level of skills because I have never been exposed to someone with more skills. Before I "left the garage" for the "turning world", I was the best turner I knew and an "expert" (intermediate, in reality)...

If someone else (with more skills) evaluates ability, I think it has some basis in reality. I don't understand the AR model...

Steve

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#12

Re: Categorizing turning ability

John Lucas

Russ I could not agree more about the artistic side. When I look at fine piece of work at the instant gallery I don't know or care how good a turner the person is. What I care about is the final product. In fact if they did a great job and used a metal lathe for all of it, that's fine with me. If they had fun and turned a nice piece of work that's all that really matters.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#13

Steven Antonucci

I sand to unify the surface, not remove defects

Steven Antonucci

for the exact reasons you and Bill have stated. 320 is as high as I will go if there is a finish going over it, mainly because I hate sanding...

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#14

Categorizing turning ability is like ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

nailing Jello to a tree. There are world class experts like Stuart Batty who can make cuts that many can only dream about. His apprenticeship with his father has served him well in that regard. And there are turners with world class reputations who can't make half the cuts that Stuart can make because they are so focused on a narrow aspect of turning. They may be masters of design (or a design), but lack some of the technical skills. Jimmy Clewes also comes to mind as having superior technical skills. And both Stuart and Jimmy are optimal choices for teachers. I like Jimmy's reference to "muscle memory".

I like John K Jordan's statement that an expert is someone who makes their mistakes in private.

Students and teachers have something in common: They both have strengths and weaknesses. Some students will catch on quickly and some will need to cogitate a bit so that a week after the class the latter may have overtaken the quick learner. And some instructors impart knowledge in such a way that a student doesn't realize how much they have learned until a week or two later.

One way to evaluate turners is to give each a blank and a half an hour to make the best simple unfinished bowl that they can make. The beginner will still be trying to mount the piece or may have shaped either the inside or the outside. The intermediate will have the bowl shaped and may be starting to sand. The advanced intermediate will have it sanded. The expert will have it sanded and be helping the beginner.

Ed

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#15

Steven Antonucci

Now we're getting somewhere

Steven Antonucci

I like the idea of a block of wood and 30 minutes to assess skills...

I ran a workshop for my club with 6 guys on making hollowing tools. I was under the impresion that I could spend X amount of time on this, and Y amount on that- oh, and we'd turn some handles real quick...

3 hours later, we had 6 so-so handles... because I never assessed the ability of the students up front. The one I made took 5 minutes.

Might just use something like this at Peters Valley, Ed. (I had planned on starting like this, but probably not a bowl.)

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#16

Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...

John Lucas

In a half an hour I would still be eating a doughnut trying to decide what shape to turn. Then I'd go to the lathe and open up the drawer to get a chuck and notice that my tools needed sharpening. I'd go to the grinder to sharpen and find out my stones needed truing. While trying to remember which drawer I put the diamond dresser I remember I was supposed to call someone about the heater.

I head to the house to get the phone and notice the package of doughnuts on the counter. Grab another one and head to the shop to turn a bowl. Oops don't have the right blank so I grab the chainsaw. Out of gas. Head to the store to get more gas. Grab another doughnut before heading out. Fuel up the chainsaw and decide to sharpen it while I'm there, it's still cold outside and I want to warm up a little more. Sharpen the chainsaw but it's still cold. Oh yeah I forgot to call about the heater. Head to the house to call and notice it's lunch time. Heat up some hotdogs for me and the dog.

Then I head to the shop trying to figure out what it was I was going to do this morning. Oh yea a bowl, so I cut the blank and haul it into the bandsaw. That's when I remember I was going to change the blade because this one is so far beyond dull that it actually cuts with friction. I pull out blade and change it. I cut the bowl blank but notice that the dust collector isn't working worth a darn. The bag is full so I remove it and haul it to the backyard.

While heading out back I notice one of the tires in the truck is low so I turn on the compressor. Move the truck around to the garage and inflate the tire. Then I move the truck back to the driveway and notice it's running on fumes so I grab the dog and we head off to the store. Yea had to get another doughnut before we left. when I get back I realize how many doughnuts I've had so I grab the dog and head off to the track to walk a few miles.

Now it's 3 oclock, I've really got to get to that bowl. On the way to the shop I notice all the cutoffs from the bowl blank so I pick all of those up and haul them to the backyard. the wind has blown a bunch of limbs down so I pick those up and haul them out back. Man all this work is making me hungry so I head to the house to get another doughnut. Who's eating these things, I had a dozen this morning?

Getting close to 5 so I need to start dinner so my son and I will have something to eat. Put everything on the stove to get it going and remember I need to iron some clothes for next week so I pull out the ironing board and start on that. Oops, what's that noise. Oh crap, well maybe he won't notice the burned noddles on the bottom. Eat dinner and finish the ironing while watching the news. Darn still haven't turned that bowl.

I head to the shop and mount the bowl. Turn the outside, reverse, turn the inside. Bam, it splits in half at a bark inclusion joint. I say several nasty things and head back to the house to console myself with another doughnut. Darn only 2 left. Maybe the dog is eating them.

I still don't have the bowl done. Does that make me a beginner or an expert?

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Categorizing turning ability

Keith Tompkins

This is a hard one to categorize...many turners have "self-imposed" limitations that really hold them back. "I've only been turning five years" is a common one...they truly believe they don't have the experience to produce top-notch work. Yet, with a bit of patience and encouragement, they produce something in class they thought they were incapable of....and, their whole outlook begins to change. "I don't use grinding jigs... that is for beginners". After all, big-time turner "Y" said so. How many turners have that attitude, yet it's the very thing holding back their progress! Guess what?! After humoring me a bit, and trying the jigs, the turners are amazed how much better, and consistently, they can turn. How many terrible forms have I seen because of one simple misconception? That the final cut MUST be done from foot to rim in one pass. Oops...Oops again. Finally, the piece looks nothing like what the turner envisioned. When they realize it's OK to work on just the area that needs tweaking, their work improves a great deal. "I'm a woodturner, not an artist!" That's a tough outlook to change, but often that attitude is all that's holding someone back. Perhaps, rather than focus on student ability, as teachers we should ask "How can I have a positive impact on this person?" When that happens, the whole thing is worthwhile.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#18

Don Pencil

A rating system is...........

Don Pencil

Fairly useless.

1. There are a lot of fairly effective ways to determine who should or should participate in a particular class.

2. A proper written discription of the skills necessary to enter the class must be available in advance.

3. It will always be up to the student address whether they do or do not have the skills necessary for the class before they pay up.

4. Once the student is there is will become very obvious as to whether they are capable of doing the work.

5. If it is a very small class the instructor may choose to allow them to continue with the understanding that if they cannot keep up with the others that they will be left behind. If that is not exceptable to the student, or the class is to large for this, then while escorting them to the door explain that it was certainly a pleasure to have met them, here is the date of a class suited for them, and their refund check will be in the mail tomorrow.

As noted by Bill and others, a system like this is probably of very little value.

I have other thoughts on the subject but Ellis would no doubt take exception to them. :b

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#19

Danger, thin ice!

Ed Moore in SW VA

Having taught at JCCFS I have come to appreciate a non-competitive learning atmosphere. And the beginner suffers the most when it becomes competitive. And since they have paid their money, each hopes to improve their skills and to make something. They don't want the MIT experience - taking a drink of water from a firehose. It is very easy to get discouraged when starting to learn to turn bowls.

If you are going to teach bowls then I would expect a couple of absolute beginners. Start by showing the class how to start the process. When they have their bowls mounted stop them all and show them how to start the turning process. Then you might start the exercise. You will know very quickly who needs help. You must balance between determining skill levels and getting them started comfortably.

And there well may be one student who NEVER gets it. I use Bill's 45 - 45 - 45 approach when introducing bowls because it works. I had one student who never got it. We were roughing a bowl and I would ask if I might adjust the tool and with his approval I put it right. As soon as I turned my back he rotated the tool until it was straight up and get a catch every time. He refused to listen. He finally gave up on me and went to a different mentor with whom he did the exact same thing. He also told my friend that I was a terrible teacher. My friend got frustrated with him and he came back to me for help. Pigs will fly before he listens to anyone.

Ed

Ed

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...

Keith Tompkins

I don't know John, but that was funny!

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#21

No.  It means that you are getting ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

Old Age Syndrome. And some days it is like that. DAMHIKT.

Ed

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#22

Re: How do we "categorize" (for lack of better wor

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

"but would you want to take a turning lesson from someone that still needed 60 grit paper?"

Evidently quite a few people do want to take lessons from someone who still needs 60 grit paper on occasion, since I continue to be quite busy with people coming from all over the US and Canada. I can tell you I for one would not want to take a lesson from someone who is going to "throw me in a bucket" based on some arbitrary assessment that may not be an accurate measure of my ability.

Steve, I have been around enough to see the work off the lathe of some very very well known people, and I can tell you right now, that your sandpaper litmus test is just so much hogwash. I turned two spindles yesterday that needed no sandpaper at all below 320 grit, and that was a demo. But you know, tomorrow I am going back into the shop and it will be a different day and a different piece of wood on the lathe. Who is to say what is appropriate as to how it gets done?

I knew a guy who got upwards of $1500 for his bowls. Ninety percent of them were turned entirely with a scraper. And we all know that people who use scrapers aren't real turners, don't we? Are you pulling down that kind of cash for your turnings yet? Maybe we should use that as a measure of a turner, how much money they can get for a given piece?

I teach all the time, in all sorts of venues all over the US and even into Canada. I do not pigeonhole my students, nor do I toss them into "buckets" according to some sort of perceived ability or lack thereof. Right in my promotional literature I state that there is no "synchronized turning". People can do what they want at whatever pace they are comfortable or capable. I teach classes where every person is working on something different. I am there as a mentor and a guide, not some sort of drill sergeant with a gouge. This stuff is supposed to be fun. It is a hobby for most people, not a race to see who can do the bestest the fastest. I can tell you true, if I had a teacher that started out with a negative attitude, I would be walking out without a class or a gouge, as it would probably be firmly installed in someone else's nether regions.

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#23

Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I fail to see what speed in producing a bowl has to do with ability. Especially for a newbie. When I was doing production work many years ago, speed was important but not at the expense of quality. I've taught a lot of turners over the years and those that finished a project first, seldom had the best finished piece. I've never stressed speed to a student. Instead, I've encouraged them to spend time working on form.

Many of you don't know who Bob Stocksdale was, but back in the 70's and 80's he was consided one of the best, along with Rude Osolnik and a few others. I sat in on a demo by Bob...I was amazed when he started sanding with 36 grit. Said that it was the final tool. So much for the master turners starting their sanding with 220 or 320 or even 400. I think that most experienced turners could do that if they wanted to spend a lot of time on tool control.

Wally

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#24

Re: Categorizing turning ability is like ...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

John, that sounds like a lot of my days here!

Re: Categorizing turning ability

#25

Re: How do we "categorize" (for lack of better wor

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

"How would you evaluate a turner as an instructor (if not by grit)? "

I'm going to continue on with my own personal theory as an instructor. First, I ask people about their experience. Most people are pretty honest and objective with me. I get answers like,

"The last time I turned something was a lamp in shop class 30 years ago."

"I have never turned anything on a lathe."

"I was just passing by and thought this would be interesting." (Yes I have gotten this one!)

"I have been turning for a while but I am frustrated with the catches I get."

"I'm pretty good with my tools, but I want to get better."

The list goes on, but you get the idea.

Brand new people are a blank slate. Rather than hurl a lot of technicalese at them, I give them the tool appropriate to the task, and say, "Hold this like this, and move it this way." It is that simple. They don't need to know that they are holding the dreaded skew, or a side ground bowl gouge. All they know is that they are applying a sharp piece of metal to wood and the shavings are rolling off the tool. Once we get going with that, then I can start with nomenclature and such. But it grabs their attention, whereas a whole bunch of this is this and that is that can turn real boring real fast.

Then there are the folks who have some experience, and habits to go along with it. They benefit from gentle, consistent correction once they have been shown the proper way to do things. And even that proper way is subjective to a certain point. How do you compensate for someone who is too short or too tall for the lathe? How do you handle the man standing with crutches, or the one in the wheelchair? What do you tell the person who is stiff with arthritis? How about the little girl who is just learning about a new and exciting world? How do you keep it that way for her?

All these people are here to have fun, and learn how, as Clint Eastwood said, to improvise, adapt, and overcome. It is not about me, it is all about them. Each person has different needs, different strengths and weaknesses. Some people are deathly afraid of high rpm. Guess what? Lots of stuff was made centuries ago with pole lathes, great wheel lathes, and other mechanisms where 100 rpm was the state of the art. Some people know no fear, and need to tone it down a little with the hogging cuts. Some folks have a heavy hand and some a touch so light it barely removes wood. How do you explain to them that it is not wrong for them to cut in their style? How do you adapt your teaching methodology to address their unique set of circumstances?

I get a lot of people who have never touched a lathe before they came to see me. Just this past week I had three like that in two different classes. Two of them went home with natural edged bowls, and the third spent about 12 of his 16 hours learning all the things a skew could do. But wait! These are things that are out of bounds for noobs, aren't they? Ideally there are other things to do that would help them get to the place where they started, at least for the NE bowl guys. But the man with the skew, that was right on. His last job of the class was to take a square block of wood and make a tool handle using nothing but the skew, and a parting tool for sizing the tenon for the ferrule. It came out beautifully. It is all about the people in the class, not the teacher. There is no room for the ego of the instructor. It is all about communicating information so that people can go home and make a good start on their chosen hobby.

I've taught professionals too. Often they come for a little tweaking of techniques, and that is all there is to it. It is an issue of getting a little more out of a tool, or changing a grind just a little. Most often there is no dramatic epiphany, but rather a culmination of little things that brings them just a little bit higher in their level of efficiency, competence, or enjoyment of their craft. I do not look at them and say, "You are doing it all wrong". No, I observe, suggest, and we move on together so that they can go further and higher and understand why it works the way it does.

And in all of this, it really helps to have a relaxed attitude about it all. Rome was not built in a day, and a teacher needs to be able to see the progress in all of his or her students, even when the overall result is still far from perfect. The best results come from encouragement, not compulsion.