Re: How do we "categorize" (for lack of better wor
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
"How would you evaluate a turner as an instructor (if not by grit)? "
I'm going to continue on with my own personal theory as an instructor. First, I ask people about their experience. Most people are pretty honest and objective with me. I get answers like,
"The last time I turned something was a lamp in shop class 30 years ago."
"I have never turned anything on a lathe."
"I was just passing by and thought this would be interesting." (Yes I have gotten this one!)
"I have been turning for a while but I am frustrated with the catches I get."
"I'm pretty good with my tools, but I want to get better."
The list goes on, but you get the idea.
Brand new people are a blank slate. Rather than hurl a lot of technicalese at them, I give them the tool appropriate to the task, and say, "Hold this like this, and move it this way." It is that simple. They don't need to know that they are holding the dreaded skew, or a side ground bowl gouge. All they know is that they are applying a sharp piece of metal to wood and the shavings are rolling off the tool. Once we get going with that, then I can start with nomenclature and such. But it grabs their attention, whereas a whole bunch of this is this and that is that can turn real boring real fast.
Then there are the folks who have some experience, and habits to go along with it. They benefit from gentle, consistent correction once they have been shown the proper way to do things. And even that proper way is subjective to a certain point. How do you compensate for someone who is too short or too tall for the lathe? How do you handle the man standing with crutches, or the one in the wheelchair? What do you tell the person who is stiff with arthritis? How about the little girl who is just learning about a new and exciting world? How do you keep it that way for her?
All these people are here to have fun, and learn how, as Clint Eastwood said, to improvise, adapt, and overcome. It is not about me, it is all about them. Each person has different needs, different strengths and weaknesses. Some people are deathly afraid of high rpm. Guess what? Lots of stuff was made centuries ago with pole lathes, great wheel lathes, and other mechanisms where 100 rpm was the state of the art. Some people know no fear, and need to tone it down a little with the hogging cuts. Some folks have a heavy hand and some a touch so light it barely removes wood. How do you explain to them that it is not wrong for them to cut in their style? How do you adapt your teaching methodology to address their unique set of circumstances?
I get a lot of people who have never touched a lathe before they came to see me. Just this past week I had three like that in two different classes. Two of them went home with natural edged bowls, and the third spent about 12 of his 16 hours learning all the things a skew could do. But wait! These are things that are out of bounds for noobs, aren't they? Ideally there are other things to do that would help them get to the place where they started, at least for the NE bowl guys. But the man with the skew, that was right on. His last job of the class was to take a square block of wood and make a tool handle using nothing but the skew, and a parting tool for sizing the tenon for the ferrule. It came out beautifully. It is all about the people in the class, not the teacher. There is no room for the ego of the instructor. It is all about communicating information so that people can go home and make a good start on their chosen hobby.
I've taught professionals too. Often they come for a little tweaking of techniques, and that is all there is to it. It is an issue of getting a little more out of a tool, or changing a grind just a little. Most often there is no dramatic epiphany, but rather a culmination of little things that brings them just a little bit higher in their level of efficiency, competence, or enjoyment of their craft. I do not look at them and say, "You are doing it all wrong". No, I observe, suggest, and we move on together so that they can go further and higher and understand why it works the way it does.
And in all of this, it really helps to have a relaxed attitude about it all. Rome was not built in a day, and a teacher needs to be able to see the progress in all of his or her students, even when the overall result is still far from perfect. The best results come from encouragement, not compulsion.