Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Lacquer & Fire

Posts

Lacquer & Fire

#1

Chuck Jones - West TN

Lacquer & Fire

Chuck Jones - West TN

>The discussion yesterday about Paul Zerjay's question on lacquer finishing got my attention. I've long contended that "Needless and excessive warning labels are dangerous" because they cause us to ignore all warning labels. I've recently been experimenting with Deft spray lacquer in my shop which happens to be cozily heated with a wood burning stove. I reluctantly admit that until last night I had not read the warning information.

How real is the danger? I have been spraying small bursts about 20' from the stove. No explosions yet! Should I get farther away from the stove and turn on my dust collector? Or should I just wait for warm weather? My shop is 1500 square feet and my dust collector exhausts into a large wooded area out back.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#2

Re: Lacquer & Fire

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca

>The danger is real. Lacquer has a low flashpoint but it is too cold coming out of your spray gun to "flash off" right there. If you fill your shop with fog, however, and there is an ignition source (like a wood stove) at some point, I believe, it'll blow the hinges off the doors and the eyebrows off your face. The key is to ventilate...to evacuate the stinky stuff and replace it with fresh air.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#3

Re: Lacquer & Fire

John Lucas

>Chuck there is a lot of space between your stove and your workbenches. I don't know where you spray but I think you will be safe unless you really create a fog.

I've been spraying in my doorway for years and during the winter I have a kerosene stove about 6 or 7 feet away. So far no problems but then I try not to get a cloud of spray. I spray a coat on several pieces and then step back in and close the door. I let any over spray settle before doing anything else. It is highly flammable as are most of the things I use for finishes or cleaning so I try to do it smartly. I really don't think I have a cloud near the stove but then there might be stuff in the air that I can't see. It may be one of those things that will catch up with me some day. I'm trying to find finishes that are less hazardous to my health and safety but Lacquer works so well for some of my products.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#4

brush deft or wait until spring

bob davis

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#5

Re: Lacquer & Fire

steve worcester

>What will happen is you create a cloud of suspended flammable material in the air, just a few of these particles have to drift back to the stove and the entire cloud goes up faster than you can react and the shop is a flashbomb. Not worth it to me, I wait until it is warmer.

On another note, exhausting the dust collector out of the shop also exhaust all the warm air and it gets replaced with cold air from outside.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#6

Re: Lacquer & Fire

Fred Bearman (Port Huron, Michigan)

>I spray Deft, and my worry is not from the heating, as I use one of those oil-filled electric radiators (and lots of insulation). I do use an exhaust fan when I spray lacquer, or any other smelly stuff. As I don't use an explosion-proof fan, I asked a friend who is a firefighter what he thought of the risk. His first response was not to comment, but when I said "off the record," he said that he felt that the risk was low due to the volume of air being moved by the fan and the continual addition of fresh air due to even minimal leakage around the doors, and considering this and the volume of spray, the spray being exhausted at any given time would be diluted to a concentration below its explosive point. So far, so good.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#7

Re: Lacquer & Fire

Barry Irby

>This won't answer your question, but I have a friend with a shop that includes an honest to God Spray room. The shop has a 80,000BTU heater and the spray room has a 400,000 heater designed to pull fresh air form outdoors, heat it and blow it through the spray room and out through an explosion proof fan.

One day he sensed the big furnace and a problem. He walked out into the shop at the exact moment the the explosion occurred. It turned out the flame had gone out in the furnace and somehow it vented the gas into the shop. Propane is heavier than air. The shop filled up and he walked in just as the gas reached the pilot in the smaller furnace. Fortunately he had never finished his windows and they were just tacked into the frames with a couple of little blocks behind each one. The explosion blew most o them out into the yard. It was all over so fast he did not have time to poop his pants. Only broke one or two of the panes. He just tacked them back into the openings.

I think it is amazing that many of us have been spraying lacquer around wood stoves and gas heaters and through window fans with no ill effects and he has the real deal and nearly blew himself up.

My bet would be that you can't spray enough lacquer from twenty feet away to ignite. But, OTOH, I won't be there when you do. Come to think of it, by the time there is that much air borne lacquer you would be so stoned on the fumes you probably won't care.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#8

Fire isn't the problem. Lung damage is.

Russ Fairfield

>Kids sniff model airplane glue to get high. It is a thick form of a nitrocellulose lacquer and the solvents are the same. Get the picture.

The damage to your lungs IS THE PROBLEM with spraying lacquer in a closed room. Fire and explosion requires a lot of solvents in the air, and a higher concentration than what would make you light headed and giddy. You will pass out long before the concentration was high enough to explode and kill you.

Permanent damage to your lungs doesn't require anywhere near an explosive concentration, and it is a slow a creeping damage. You will know you are there when you have emphasema or worse, and have problems with breathing. Brushing lacquers is bad enough, but spraying is far worse.

Lung damage is something that creeps up on you over time. It is definite and it is accumulative. There is no healing the damage, and it can kill you.

Come back in 20 years and tell me I am wrong.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Lacquer & Fire

Keith Tompkins

>I've never seen a lacquer explosion, but I've personally witnessed: a sawdust explosion! The electrician where I worked flipped the on/off handle on a 3 phase elecrical box near a line of belt-sanders (big, 8x120" belts) which produced fine dust. The explosion blew him across the room, he required a metal plate in his head. Also, watched a bucket of rags soaked with linseed oil mix begin to smoulder, then ignite...back when they said it was impossible. I wouldn't want to see a lacquer explosion.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#10

Questions for Russ

Barry Irby

>Russ, will a respirator with a charcoal filter reduce/eliminate the problem? I generally have ventilation going and wear a charcoal respirator. (one with the canisters) When I can smell the lacquer, I put in fresh canisters.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#11

Re: Questions for Russ

Russ Fairfield

>If you cannot smell the solvents, your lungs are safe; if you can, they aren't. Lacquer is pretty good that way.

HOWEVER, that is only half the story. The airborne solvents can get into your eyes and cause visual damage, and the respirator won't do anything for that.

I didn't have a problem with lacquer and the fumes for many years. Then the accumulative effect caught up with me. Now I cannot spray lacquer until spring so I wait until spring so I can do it outside or open the door and run a fan to blow it all outside.

I have started to use a brush and buff application. I apply 2 or 3 heavy brush on coats just before I close up for the night, let it dry until morning, and then sand it smooth with 400, and buff it to the gloss I want. It looks just a good as 20 spray coats.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#12

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Lacquer & Fire

Chuck Jones - West TN

>Thanks guys for all the input on this. As I've indicated before, I'm very skeptical of warning labels these days, but I have a pretty good feeling most of you know what you are talking about. The lung issue gets my attention more than anything. Just to be safe I think I'll make the trek to town tomorrow and get a can of brush lacquer. (Come to think of it even the trek to town isn't safe; the roads are snowy/icy!) I'm going to use either the dust collector or exhaust fan too. My shop is well insulated and once it's warm it takes a lot to cool it down.

Thanks again.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#13

Re: Lacquer & Fire

john lucas

>Chuck I base my response on the fact that I was a fire bug as a kid. We quickly learned that you could light the spray from a can of hair spray and make your own flame thrower. Then of course we tried other cans. If it said flammable on the side that was like a dare. Then we started seeing how far we could get away from the fire and still ignite our flame throwers. You really can't get that far away unless you create a cloud and then you got a big flash.

Yea I know it's a miracle I survived my youth. I really should have yelled Hey Bubba watch this before I did anything but I think that was before that was invented.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#14

full-face respirator

John K Jordan

>This type of respirator will protect both the eyes and lungs if equipped with the proper filter canisters. I don't use it much in the shop (I use the canister type without the face mask), but I use it on those rare occasions when I need to spray pesticides.

I also used it once when cutting a fire break with my tractor after a guy down the hill set the woods on fire. It was great for keeping the smoke out of my eyes.


JKJ

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#15

Re: Lacquer & Fire

John K Jordan

>>...Yea I know it's a miracle I survived my youth.

You and me both and half of my friends. While most our age were into drinking and drugs and wrecking their cars, we tended towards hobbies with extreme audio and visual impact. We never did the hairspray flamethrower, but for fun we mixed up large quantities of explosive materials (some pretty powerful), made and detonated a variety of things that made really big flashes and bangs, mixed liquid chemicals with extreme reactions, explored explosive combustion of fine particulates, enjoyed spectacular combustion of large quantities of mixed gasses and liquids (think "mega-fireball"), launched rockets with active payloads, propelled many projectiles with significant mass large distances, detonated insanely dangerous home-made hand grenades, discovered the joy of obtaining ever-increasing heights of explosive-driven water jets, injured self and each other with various explosive-driven mechanisms, and set the family houses on fire a time or two. In other words, nearly everything we did would probably attract the attention of the Dept of Homeland Security these days. It's amazing this bunch all lived past high school. (Can't say the same for the drunks and druggies.)

JKJ

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#16

Re: Questions for Russ

Don Evans

>Barry there are different types of cannisters for your respirator. You need to read each one to know which one to put on the unit depending on what type protection you are aiming for. There are "vapor" "pesticide" "dust" and many others available.

I have an AOSafety unit and the cans for it can be stacked. In other words I may have a dust cannister and charcoal cannister on it, one on top of other.

It gets harder to draw through them if using two or more however.

One problem with what you said is "charcoal" tends to eliminate odor I don't know if that stops all the danger with dealing with vapors. It could be stripping just part of the lacquer out but not all the harmful particles. I would use a vapor cannister for it or one of the one's specific for paint.

If you are mucking the horse barn then the charcoal may be best one to have :(

Don

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#17

Re: full-face respirator

Carol Reed

>Who makes that, John? Where did you get it? Model number? Thanks.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#18

Rob Wallace

HELLO BROTHER!

Rob Wallace

>JKJ:

We really need to do some DNA tests.....I think you may be my long-lost twin brother... you just wrote the 'executive summary' of my childhood.... ;)

(This made me look at the small scar on my left hand caused by a "premature" ammonium tri-iodide explosion!)

Rob Wallace

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#19

Re: HELLO BROTHER!

Galen Vetterick

>Add to the list a cherry bomb at the bottom of a can of fine magnesium dust I would bring home from the foundry. Like a mini nuclear explosion cloud!

Not sure I've grown out of that phase yet with some of the things I do.

Not a threat to anyone else but myself though. That is as long as you stay away from me.

Galen

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#21

Re: why I'm trying to learn Blacksmithing

John Jordan

>JKJ:

Some, in their youth, combined the two............. :O

John

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#22

Chuck Jones - West TN

You're all a little bit nuts

Chuck Jones - West TN

>Sounds like I should just send the lacquer and these pieces I'm trying to finish to one of you and let you relive your youth. At my age I figure I've enjoyed so much good luck maybe I better not stretch it much further. :)

John Lucas may have a lot of that Yankee in him, but he's learned the "Bubba" role pretty well.

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#23

Re: full-face respirator

John K Jordan

>Carol,

My respirator is a 3M which is very much like the one in the photo but not exactly the same model. They make a number of models - search google for full face respirator.

A friend bought a bunch of these at an industrial auction, with and without full face masks, and gave me a couple. I bought a variety of cartridges for both dust and fumes from a local industrial safety supplier.

I use the non-face mask version a lot for sanding - it works far better than and actually is more comfortable than the paper masks. I bought a similar model at Home Depot and it is not nearly as comfortable as the 3M model - the 3M is lighter and the material more flexible.

JKJ

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#24

Re: why I'm trying to learn Blacksmithing

John K Jordan

>They do that every year at the Appalachian Museum up the road. Very popular event.

Someday I want to see someone do that with an automobile and some gasoline instead of an anvil and black powder. Did you ever stop to think that you should theoretically be able to propel an automobile 20 miles or so through the air by releasing the energy of one gallon of gasoline? (There is the issue of calculating the friction due to air v.s. mechanical friction and energy losses of the conventional propulsion method as well as a few minor engineering details, but hey.)

JKJ

Re: Lacquer & Fire

#25

Re: why I'm trying to learn Blacksmithing

Bob Macgregor

>Assuming that you are still somewhat suicidal, it seems to me that your childhood passions could be combined with "blacksmithing" by using thermite: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermite

If you are generally just interested in having things explode (or flash), you might try some of the forums at: http://www.pyrosociety.org.uk/

Oh, and if any of this catches your fancy...you didn't hear about it from me.

BOB