>The gouge I use most is a 1 1/4" forged (european style) roughing gouge. Yeah, I know - not for use on bowls. BS! With the "ears" ground back it makes a really fine shear cut on the inside of bowls - and the outside as well. It's really easy to control. Yeah I know - if you get a catch the tang isn't as strong as a bowl gouge and it could snap. So I don't get catches. I was never a fan of hogging out a lot of material anyway.
>I'm coming in late to this discussion, but I use lots of gouges. I even use a skew chisel once in a while! ;-) My bowl gouge is probably my very favorite and most used tool, but like a couple of others have posted, I have been known to use a continental style spindle gouge for those hard to smooth areas on both the inside and outside of bowls. And what do you know, but it also works well on spindles!
Round spindle gouges and detail gouges also see frequent use in my shop, but I am not a fan of having to try a whole bunch of tools to get a single cut done. I believe in knowing all that a tool can do in as many situations as possible. That, I believe, is the best way to choose the best tool for any particular cutting operation.
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Guest
Re: Let's talk about gouges
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
>Right on, Jorge! I have been using one of Doug's 1 1/4 inch gouges like this since he first introduced them I think I have one of the first ones. Before that, I used to make my own by cutting the tang (tine better describes it) off a normal spindle roughing gouge and welding in a 5/8 inch rod for a tang.
The AAW says to never use spindle roughing gouge to turn a bowl. This is correct, as far as it goes, but it does not go far enough. It protects the manufacturers of equipment rather than encouraging them to improve their product. I have seen several spindle roughing gouges bent 90 degrees while turning spindles. The problem is the tang -- which Doug has fixed. P&N also produces a gouge with a sturdy tang. So, it is possible to make the tool safe. It just costs a bit more.
I make large bowls, mainly in a production environment. Without Doug's 1 1/4 inch gouge, I could not do it quickly enough to even come close to covering my costs. Like Jorge, I use it with bevel rubbing, cutting wood just off bottom center -- and even up on the side of the flute, peeling off bushels of shavings. How effective is it? On a good day I can fill the back of my Dodge Ram truck (8 foot box) with shaving, right to the top of the box.
>We put way too much emphasis on the tool, its shape, the profile, how we grind it, and what it is called. The only thing that is important it a sharp cutting edge, and how we [resent it to the wood. Everything else is personal preference.
Great minds think alike uh? I make big bowls too. We must have gotten them at the same time, I have one of the very first batch and with the Nova 3000 I used little, it just stalled the lathe. Last summer I got the mustard monster and then that gauge came into it's own, same with the 3/4" V bowl gauge.
Like you in a good day I make so many shavings that it takes a while to clean up, 5 30 gal garbage bags yesterday, 9 rough bowls 12" - 15".
You are right it works great for the outside but it is too big for the inside; for the inside the bowl gauge is queen, although as I said before I have a 9/16" Henry Taylor spindle gouge and also an ancient 1 1/4" cast steel, that was before the electric furnace! (1850), with a very substantial tang and takes a keen edge, I use them both on the inside or outside, you just have to be aware at all times were the corners are.
I'm talking about "mini" tools - and you're going close to nano-scale, not micro-scale. I trust you have watchmaker's lathe. When the scale gets small enough, I image only certain types of woods can be turned successfully since the grain of open grained woods would look like cracks and fissure in a tiny turning.
So much emphasis seems to be on turning BIG. But it's turning small, really small, that is probably the most challenging, both in terms of technique as well as being able to see the desired form while turning - BEFORE it disappears in a single cut.
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Guest
Re: Let's talk about gouges
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
>Very interesting because your work technique is similar to mine -- and we discovered and perfected these techniques independently. I , to, do the outside of the bowl with the 1 1/4 inch spindle roughing gouge (Doug's, with the 3/4 inch tang), then use one of his 5/8 inch bowl gouges for the inside.
I also have an antique 1 1/4 inch gouge -- close to the "Continental" shape. It is hand forged. And, it has a real tang on it because the blacksmith was able to fatten the tang so it is twice the thickness of the metal in the gouge. It would not bend if a horse stepped on it. That was how they made tools in the days before the big presses arrived and they just started stamping them out. Now, they don't bother to try to "fatten" the tang and I think that is a major shop hazard even for those only using the SRG to turn spindles.
Glad you found some of the stuff on my site of interest - and that the Having Fun part came acrossed.
As for Why Use A Skew? - I was a flat work woodworker who got sucked into turning - by kids. The sound of a power tool durng the summer seems to attract kids like flies - "What're you doing? What does THIS do? Can I make something? Can you make magic wands?"
It was the magic wands project that got me to buy a JET mini lathe, and am inexpensive set of "mini-turning tools", the UniMat I had used when I did jewelry just didn't have the length capacity needed.
Having no idea of which turning tools did which types of cuts best, nor any idea of how to use any of them, I tried different tools in the set and found the skew to be the easist to use - oddly enough. And once Peter Pipe showed me how to put a curved cutting edge on it the skew became even easier to use - for me. The quarter inch spindle gouge, on the other hand, was a nightmare for me - mainly because I didn't know how to use it.
So - I figured out ways to get a skew to make the cuts - or in many cases - scrapes - I wanted. Not knowing I shouldn't, or that there were better gouges for many of those cuts, I stuck with the skew. With a lot of practice using it for all sorts of things, I've gotten pretty good with it - so it's the tool I reach for first and use for just about everything. Seems this is common for self taught turners - before acquiring books and DVDs and the resulting exposure to other tools and techniques - find a tool you can use - then figure out ways to make it do other things you need to do.