>I keep hearing all this talk about bowl gouges. I'd be willing to bet that a lot of guys use a bowl gouge exclusively for the entire turning process. From rough blank, to finished shape. I hear no one ever saying that their new roughing gouge is the best thing since sliced bread, nor do I hear any comments on spindle gouges. I agree that a bowl gouge can be a workhorse, but blow the dust off 'em and try using your spindle gouges again. I think you'd be quite impressed with the finish coming off a well sharpened spindle gouge. What say you? Got a favorite gouge that's not of the bowl variety?
I go through stages when I use one gouge as you said and then when keep switching, right now I am roughing bowls of green red maple and begin with a roughing spindle gouge, one of Doug Thompson, 1 1/4", yes it works great to bring a way out of balance blank to a point where I can switch to another whooper, the 3/4" V bowl gouge also from Doug, that removes a lot in a hurry, when closer to where I want switch to one of the spindle detail gauges, and finish shaping the outside with that.
Then with same detail gouge, star hollowing the inside for a while and then switch to a bowl gouge to finish.
For the last cleaning cuts I mustly revert to my HSS gouges, I don't really know why, must probably because I started with those and have been using them a lot longer than the powder metal ones.
my lates flame is the 1/4" detail gauge also from Doug, a perennial favorite is a 9/16" spindle gouge I use both in spindles and bowls.
>For roughing bowl blanks, I prefer a big heavy scraper. When you stop to think about it, your roughing cuts are scraping cuts, and what better tool to do the job than a scraper. The size you use and amount of wood you remove at one time depends on how much torque your lathe has, and how much you feel like removing at one time. For finish cuts, just about any gouge can work. The main problem with spindle gouges is that they tend to be more pointy than bowl gouges. A gouge with a more rounded nose profile just works better for me. I do tend to favor a traditional finger nail profile on the outside, and a swept back design on the inside. Again for removing bulk on the inside, a scraper is my preferred tool. I would never consider using a spindle roughing gouge for removing bulk. The tang on them isn't made to take that type of abuse, at least not the type that I would heap upon it. A continental roughing gouge, more ( shaped works fine for finish cuts. A scraper at a 45 degree angle with a fresh burr cleans up very well also.
>I am really starting to love my 1/2 spindle gouge from Thompson Lathe Tools. Mostly I have used it for pens to date but using the wings (for lack of a better term) gives me great control in a pull cut and leaves a finish like a skew. I also have a 3/8" which I like very much.
The one I have a love/hate relationship with is my 3/8" detail gouge. I catch this thing more than I do my skew! I think what I haven't gotten used to, or forget constantly, is that the cutting edge is so much higher and away from the central axis of the gouge. I sure cannot roll it like I can a regular spindle gouge. More practise is needed with this thing.
Having said all of that, I decided to try using my 1/2" V-bowl gouge (another of Doug's) on a peppermill yesterday and it worked very well. Not sure why but I liked it.
>I think I'm more talking about a finish cut on the outside of a form more than anything while using a spindle gouge. I was just saying guys seem to use one bowl gouge all the way through the whole process. And I think they get in a rut and forget what another gouge can actually do.
The 1 1/4" Doug Thompson Spindle Roughing Gouge is milled of a solid cylinder, not tang to brake in there, the section that goes into the handle is 3/4", plenty metal there... and presented on its side is really more like using a skew in a peeling cut, if you look at the shavings it makes you may never use a scraper again for that cut, it takes a lot less effort.
>I thought that David Ellsworth said that using one gouge for the whole process was an advantage: we need to buy only one gouge, sharpen only one tool, keep track of one tool in the shavings etc. No confusion over which tool to use where and when to change from one to another.
Also, the tool retailers have been going to extra trouble to tell woodturners NOT to use a "Spindle roughing Gouge" on bowls. Or are you talking about some other kind of "Roughing Gouge"?
>I keep hearing people say they can remove more wood with a scraper but I use a bowl gouge with swept back wings and can remove enough wood to stall my lathe in one pass. I usually back off and just remove about 1/2" thick at a time which is an awful lot of wood.
I've been playing with the C1 and so far don't see the advantage for me. I can see how it would be easier for a beginner because it doesn't have a learning curve.
>I use my Thompson detail gouge a lot, on both bowls and on everything else. I have them ground to 35 degrees so they take a very fine shaving. It can be a little tough turning beads on the lips of bowls with it. Because of the steep sharpening angle I have to be pretty precise with my movements.
>Quarter inch bench chisel as a small, very short handled, bedan. Bayonet saw blade - teeth ground off - paper towel handle - for parting AND turning things to REALLY small diameters - short things of course - for the most part. Short handled skew - with curved cutting edge (ie. toe and heel ground back). Dental ground back a little "scaler" for inside hollowing of small to almost tiny "hollow forms".
On a related note - why long handles - even when the tool is going
to be used on a mini/midi lathe - that can't turn anything larger
than 10 inches in diameter and can't do end grain on anything much longer than about 6 inches?
I've got the drive end of my little JET close to the wall - where I
never go - nor is there a need to go - unless perhaps you're using a lamp auger drilling through from the drive end. BUT - when using "regular" length handles, there are cuts I CAN'T make because the handle hits the wall before the cut is completed - or only half done.
>Hi Paul, it sounds like you tried the spindle gouge on the bowl with tough grain. Works, doesn't it? The old-style continental gouges are now out of fashion, but I love mine. I grind a very steep bevel, and then finely hone. Using one of these on the exterior of a bowl, starting at the rim and cutting towards the foot leaves a finish that needs no sanding in many cases. (I usually don't recommend this technique online because one never can tell how the tool will be misused) I have had many people who don't believe honing tools makes any difference stare in disbelief at the finish this cut produces. I like my Packard round spindle gouges as well, ground with a radical swept back grind. I have a Doug Thompson detail gouge as well, but haven't had time to turn a handle for it yet, or modify the grind to my liking. I started out as a furniture maker, so I'm very comfortable with spindle turning tools.
>That's exactly what I'm talking about Keith. I use a small credit card hone, and my handles are all bunged up from sticking them in between the ways of the bed to give me support while honing.
>Charlie I like long handles because I turn with my body for finer control. If you think about it moving a 10" handle 1/4" is not as fine a movement as moving a 16" handle 1/4".
Even when I use my short handle mini tools I lock them against my arm and move my body. It just a much finer way to control the tool for very accurate cuts.
>I use a spindle gouge for roughing bowls quite a bit. My "Big" lathe is a HUG and they are notoriously undermotored. The 1/2" spindle will peel back a big chunk without slowing down the motor as badly as a long bevel on a bowl gouge.
>For spindles, and details on bowls and vessels, I adore my 3/8" Packard/Hamlet spindle gouge with a swept back grind as well as my 3/8" Thompson Detail gouge. I grind both tools with the vari-grind, and I round off the "heel" of the bevel. The way I grind spindle gouges, they practically become a "thinner" detail gouge. I also use my 5/8" 2030 Lacer Skew and a 1/2" Henry Taylor rolled edge skew (not radiused) a lot. These are my "go-to" tools for spindles and details.
For bowls and vessels shaping, I use a couple of swept back bowl gouges but if it's end grain oriented I use a 1/2" Sorby spindle gouge just as much (vari-grind ground swept back). For the finish/final cut on bowls I use a 3/8" (1/2" american) stubby ground bowl gouge-that has a different sweep to each side (one for the inside and one for the outside)-a grind and technique I learned from Trent Bosch. I only use "conventional" scrapers on boxes.
I use spindle gouges just as much, if not more, than bowl gouges.
To be honest, one tool I don't use much is a parting tool. I'll most often use a skew or if I have the room I'll use one of the spindle/detail gouges. I have one thin parting tool for seperating box lids from bases in blanks and a standard 1/4" that I most use to cut a fast tenon for my oneway chucks or for fitting ferrules.
If it works well for you, then great, but I'm not convinced that roughing cuts are scraping anyway... I guess it all depends on what tools are used, and how they are presented to the wood, but I rough out bowls with a 5/8" bowl gouge with a fairly long bevel (abut 45 degrees) and present it to the wood at roughly 45 degrees off horizontal, so the shavings, while often intermittent, cut very cleanly. I don't think it takes as much force as a scraper.
For roughing the insides I use the same gouge until I get to the final cuts, which I usually make with a 3/8 Pro-PM deep fluted bowl gouge sharpened with the Ellsworth grind.
Once dry, and after rounding up with the 5/8 or 3/8 bowl gouges, I often refining the outside with a 3/8 Pro-PM detail gouge with a pretty long bevel (~35 degrees), with the handle and tool rest very low, and making a very fine, vertical shearing cut. I sometimes refine the outer curve with the flat side of a teardrop scraper in shear scrape mode. (Tracing a curve with a long-bevel spindle gouge with a vertical shear cut will cut wood very cleanly, but its hard to make a beautifully smooth fair curve that way.) I refine the inside with the 3/8" BG, and often make finish cuts with a 1/4" bowl gouge with a traditional English grind, over on its side for a shearing cut, or a back cut with the 1/4" BG or a 3/8" Sorby BG with a shorter bevel of about 60 deg. I only seldom use a scraper on the inside of bowls -- usually if I can't get just the right fair curve off the gouge.
Since I don't like sanding, I try to do what gives me the cleanest cut. If a scraper will do that, I'll try mastering that method!
>Maybe 'cause I didn't know I needed long handles for fine tool control - I apparently developed a way to do some pretty small stuff that requires fairly fine tool control. The smallest diameter one on the next page was done with no handle at all. O.K. - so I wrapped a paper towel around the end of the modified bayonet saw tool.
>The now out of fashion continental gouge was the original spindle roughing gouge. Flatter, and with a ( shaped nose and flute, rather than square across the top and a C shaped flute. I believe the advantage to the continental gouge for a finish cut is that it is usually at a steeper shear angle, like 70 or 80 degrees rather than the standard 45 or so degrees that we all use. This will give a cleaner cut. I think the problem with a SRG on a bowl isn't on the outside, as it can give a nice shear cut there, but on the inside where the corners can dig in. Never really used one on a bowl though.
As to handle length, I have longer ones for hanging out a bit farther off the tool rest, and I prefer bigger heavy tools. They just fit my hands better, and feel more comfortable to me. Other than that, they feel more steady under my arm rather than just in my hand. I can make just as delicate of a cut with my big gouges as I can with my smaller ones. Again, just my preference.
The amount of pressure on the tools, and force required to cut depends on speed, sharpness, and how much steel is on the wood at one time. The scraper isn't any rougher to use than a gouge is, once you learn to use it, and I have extensive time with both. I still go back to a gouge once in a while for roughing cuts, but the scraper requires less manual labor to achieve the same results.
>Charlie my micro tools don't have a long handle, which is why I call them micro. Of course when I use these they are gently twisted in my fingers. The only way I move my body when I use these is to hold my breath and try to remain as still as possible.
Really neat site -- thanks for the link. Great compilation of interesting work, fun projects, and excellent graphics. I followed a few links, and have to wonder, why use a skew for example, on the teardrop shapes with the compound curves ? I use a small spindle or detail gouge with a long bevel and about 25 - 30 degree included angle -- really pointy -- for that, and reversing the curve is pretty simple with a small gouge.
I also do miniatures and fine spindle details with rather short tools; I like big long tools and handles for larger work like 10" - 20" bowls, though.
>I rough turn almost all of my box stock into cylinders with a tenon on each end and let them stabilize to the surrounding humidity. When I'm close to turning them, I'll true up the cylinder and tenon, part off the lid piece, and rough hollow out the interiors. After the wood "rests" for at least a week or more later, I'll finish turn it.
I usually don't like to cross cut "cylinders" on the bandsaw and I much rather prefer to "turn" than to "cut".