Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Posts

Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#1

Mike Stafford

Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Mike Stafford

>I received a flyer from Enco yesterday with lights resembling the Sanders design that contained compact fluorescent lamps (CFL's).

My limited exposure to these bulbs is that they are slightly better than darkness and do not provide nearly enough light for my purposes.

That said I was wondering if anyone is using them in their shops for directed task lighting such as a Sanders lamp. How do CFL's fare in the cold (my shop is not heated)? How resistant to dust accumulation are they? What about flicker that is sometimes seen with other fluorescents in the cold? What about vibration; any ill effects?

I suppose that CFL's are okay for general illumination but in general I don't think they put out nearly enough light for my purposes. Of course in another year or so incandescents will be illegal as we strive to "save" the planet....

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#2

ebd

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

ebd

>I use them in my shop. One's equivalent to 100 w. They are dim when first turned on but within a minute or so are as bright as incandescents. Haven't noticed anything else and I've been using them for about a year. My shop is unheated though I do use a barrel stove in the winter.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#3

I use them everywhere I can

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Mike,

I like them because they don't put out much heat. If intense light is your goal try LED spot or flood lights. There are direct replacement bulbs for 120v Edison sockets. Much more expensive but use very little power.

I have two compact fluorescent bulbs in task lamps on my lathe. The only problem has been a duel between a big gouge and a CFL. The result was numerous fragments. Some large. Some small. An incandescent bulb would have met the same fate.

CFL's works very well in the drill press. They seem to be immune to vibration. I gave up on a drill press light until I tried a CFL. Even rough duty incandescent bulbs didn't last very long.

If I ever sell more than my monthly Visa bill I plan to invest in LED lamps.

Dave Smith

Parked until April in Mesa, AZ.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#4

They are not green: Mercury

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>True they useless juice, but they ate an environment hazard, they brake and your kitchen, bedroom bathroom and shop are contaminated with mercury, who needs that?

I am converting to LED's, they use even less juice seem to last forever and they are getting cheaper and cheaper.

Light safely

Jorge

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#5

JL

Re: CFL task lighting works well.

JL

>I installed a track light above my lathe. I have three CFL PAR 30s installed in the lighting fixtures. I normally heat my shop to about 60-62 degrees in the winter. I have an abundant amount of light (which is important to bifocal wearers).

I use the PAR 30s because I want more directional light. My set up works well for me. If a light burns out, I take it to Home Depot and let them recycle it. I haven't had one burn out yet.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Keith Tompkins

>I had been using a halogen automotive headlight bulb with a flexible shaft and magnetic base...it makes thin turnings almost transparent. I recently knocked it off my lathe and broke the base. At a hundred bucks I haven't replaced it yet. Yes, it gets very hot.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#7

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I use CFLs everywhere in my house, but have been using Xenon for the past several years for task lighting in my shop. Xenon costs more than CFLs, but they are brighter and the light is whiter. The bad thing is that they don't last as I recently discovered when they burned out. I just bought a new LED strip to replace the Xenon which will be directly above my lathe to add more light.

With all the new advances in LED technology, I'm planning to eventually switch everything to LED as I replace bulbs, specifically for the reasons Jorge noted.

keithz

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#8

Halogen

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>A heat source for an unheated shop. LOL

keithz

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#9

Re: CFL's - - I'm Not Impressed ! ! !

Barry Turner

>I use overhead 8' fluorescents in my shop for general lighting. I use a 150w halogen in a Moffat light on my lathe. It's wonderful! I am not a big fan of CFL's. I have tried a few in my house and have already replaced at least half of them because they failed. They were used in track light and recessed fixtures. So much for their claims of long, long life. I'm not impressed. As for the mercury within, it's a relatively small amount, but it's there.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#10

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I hate them! I live in a mobile home and with my bad feet, I must be able to see the floor. When I enter a room, I have have moved to the next room before the CFL gives off enough light for me to see properly. In my former industrial workplace we would have had to execute a toxic waste clenup for a broken CFL. I have about a hundred regular bulbs stockpiled for when they are banned. I will be dead and gone before I run out of them.

Don't do any color sensitive finishing with them either. What are the people that have refrigerator kilns with light bulb heat gonna do?

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#11

Same for me..except...

david------WebKitFormBoundary4+uSADSoemuCbQzw

>I have a track above the bed with 3 CFL spots aimed as I want. Works well for general lighting, but still need a concentrated light source at times. I had a Luxo lamp available, so I mounted that on a rolling stand that I fabricated, and use a 100W incandescent or halogen in the Luxo. The swivel shade and articulating arms of the Luxo fixture allow me to position the light anywhere needed.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#12

I use them

DavidWalser

>Mike,

I have three task lights on magnetic bases in my shop. All three are loaded with CFLs. I didn't use the CFLs to save energy -- I only get out to the shop once or twice a month. I switched to the CFLs so I could get more light. These lights

have a 60 watt maximum. With CFLs I can get the equivalent of 100 watts of light. It makes a difference.

I haven't noticed any problems with flickering nor have I a problem with the different color lights the CFLs. The main lighting in the shop is provided by overhead fluorescents (pairs of 4' tubes), so I may already have gotten used to the flickering and color issues.

I can't help you with questions about how the lights work in an unheated shop. You might not think my experience relevant to your situation. My shop's unheated, but it's also in Mesa, Arizona. I can say the lights have proven reliable. I've knocked them off the lathe and onto the cement floor several times. They've been covered with dust and chips. (In this respect, I think the CFLs may be a safer alternative to incandescents. One of my lights is frequently mounted below center on my lathe. In this orientation, the metal shade can accumulate a lot of chips! With the low heat output of the CFLs, there's no risk of fire. With incandescents, there would be.) After more than two years of abuse (at a rate of only a few times a month!), the original CFL bulbs are still working. Before switching to the CFLs, replacing an incandescent bulb was a regular occurrence.

Hope this helps!

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#13

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Carol Reed - Strawberry, AZ

>Wow! A love hate relationship! I have some and I like them. Yes, they take a minute or three to get to full brightness. That's ok. I need a minute or three to get there as well. I have quartz lights in the overhead, but they are way too warm in the summer. Now I have parallel CFL's because they are cooler and less expensive to operate. These days I have both on at the same time. Older I get, the more light I need.

Lighting around the lathe is yet to come. But I have given it some thought. CFL's on articulated arms thus far have the nod. We shall see what we shall see - especially if we have some light to see it!

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#14

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Hi Mike,

We have gone to all CFL bulbs in our house. We have been using them since they first became available at a decent price several years ago. I find that they last much, much longer than conventional bulbs. As far as cold weather performance, I have two in a motion-controlled outside light and one out in the carport which I plug in at dusk so that I can see to load the wood furnace. They take a minute or two to get to full brightness, but there is no flickering or hesitation about firing up even with the teenage temps that we are enjoying right now.

I would suggest trying one of the 100W equivalents at your lathe and see what you think. I may even have seen a 150W equivalent, but I wouldn't swear to it. I use the 100W's for work lights when I'm working on bikes. They work fine for me and I think my eyes are older than yours are.

Gary

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#15

Ken Vaughan

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Ken Vaughan

>I have one CFL style bulb and one LED style bulb (both from Costco) in the lamps ove the lathe. The LED style is outdoor rated and handles cool/cold just fine (same bulb as outside) but big reduction in watts. CFL has to "warm up" for about 1-2 minutes for full illumination.

I have Saunders jig with two lamps.

short of halogens and the like works fine for the turning so far. Two lamps allows different light angles and I see the spots that need work better (at least for me).

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#16

Doesn't matter...

Mike Nelson

>...now they're sayin the planet can't be saved! Apparently something to do with this new 'Ice Age' over-ruling global warming ;)

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#17

Re:A CFL also solved the vibration ....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. problem with my garage door opener which ate rough service filaments like candy.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#18

Re: I use them

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Hey David....Takes a pretty big catch to knock the lights off the lathe.

Wally

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#19

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights Par 20 vs Par 30

Stuart Johnson

>What is the difference between the different Par types?

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#20

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Walter Ahlgrim

>To see sanding scratches I need a strong single point light source. CFL do not cut it for me. I like a 12 volt halogen spot light.

CFL may or may not be rated for low temp operation, you must check the label. It has been my experience that CFL that are not labeled �outdoor� will fail in a few weeks if used in the cold.

Dust will not be a problem.

Flicker should not be a problem as most operate with electronic ballast flickering thousands of times a second. Magnetic ballast will flicker 60 times a second.

Most CFLs should handle vibration better than incandesce lamps.

A lot of us use 4 foot T12 florescent lamps with 22 mg of mercury and a CFL only has 2mg.

Don�t believe the savings claims for indoor applications. All the �wasted energy� is converted to heat. If I have the lights on then the furnace is probably also on. When the AC is running I have little need for lighting as the sun is likely shining. I like CFLs in my porch lights, but CFLs will never populate in every socket in my home.

Walta

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#21

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Mark Wollschlager

>I use CFL where appropriate.

One problem with ceiling mounts ( with the base up ) is that the heat of the bulb will cook the electronics.

The newer 3 way bulbs are nice as the are 150w equiv.

I have used the flood style CFL in the Moffatt, they really don't have enough wattage equiv. in that style yet.

I think they top out at 70w.

I have also gotten an LED flood style light on a flex neck from IKEA that is very bright and usable to illuminate the inside of a turning.

The LED bulbs have to come way down in price before I can use them in the shop.

Mark.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#22

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

russ faifield

>Be prepared for surprizes with your sanding and finishing. The surprize is that the perfect finish you saw in the shop won't looks so good in the light of day. Like conventional fluorescents, there are no shadows and that makes scratckes and flaws difficult to see. You can't beat the harsh light from an incandescent filament for accenting the sanding and finishing flaws.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#23

Dick Hines

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

Dick Hines

>I jsut put two sets of track lighting in the shop. One set is over the lathe. It has 3 cans with 125W spots in each. I almost need to wear sun glasses now.

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#24

JL

Diameter

JL

>

Re: Compact Fluorescent Lights in the Shop

#25

There are CFs and there are CFs

John K Jordan

>Mike,

I bought some very bright compact fluorescent lights at an electrical supply house - much brighter than I can get elsewhere, the incandescent equiv of around 300 watts or so. I use them as overheads in my garage and also in directed fixtures at the lathe. For the lathe, I like to mix CFs and incandescent lights for the color. Note that CFs operate at a much higher frequency than standard fluorescent bulbs so flicker or strobing is usually not an issue.

Note that CFs are pretty dim when turned on compared to when they have heated up to operating temperature. Don't judge the light brightness for about 10 minutes or so, especially in a cold shop. I have one in my feed/tack room in the barn that is incredibly dim this time of year until it warms up.

JKJ