Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Guest
Re: Design Rules
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
>Excellent update, Russ. I am glad you have illustrated it. That makes it much easier to understand. Can I get permission from you to use this as a "handout" for my turning classes?
>Russ, you did an excellent job. I love the way you showed the different forms rather than just Einstein-type drawings which my brain doesn't have the patience to process! : )
>For those interested in this subject, get the book Woodturning Design by Mike Darlow, about $35. This is an amazing and comprehensive book and will enlighten any serious student of design. He presents what I think is a healthy perspective on "the rules". This book is not light reading.
I found Darlow's comments on the proportion (golden rectangle, etc) especially interesting. (pgs 47-53)
Also interesting are Darlow's views on those he refers to as "tastemakers".
>Thanks Russ! Very helpful... I hope I can post this link to my Woodturning Links web page for more woodturning design resources...
ALSO.....
...don't forget Charlie Belden's interesting illustrations of different shape aspect ratios that were posted here not too long ago! These also are very instructive in showing the effects of changing form based on various max-min height and diameter proportions.
>I have that book. It's incredibly difficult to read. You have to literally read each paragraph and ask yourself, what is he trying to say. It has a ton of information but not for the faint hearted.
>I strongly recommend every woodturner visit Russ' Corner and read (and later on re-read) his concise and comprehensive woodturning information. It is your best one-click resource to sanding, finishing, dust control, chucks, and a whole lot more.
Russ demonstrate the selfless sharing that is synonymous with turners. And beyond that he has gone out of his ay to amass, organize, and update all of his knowledge and offer it to every turner in the world via WC.
Russ, your sharing of your woodturning knowledge has helped me immensely. From this one turner...a huge THANK YOU!
>It took me weeks to read this book. It is certainly not a flowery, artsy, "feel good" book or a "follow this woodturning procedure" book, although it does contain a lot of practical how-to.
Darlow admits in the intro to writing like an engineer. Most chapters start with a clear intro/outline, end with a summary, and include exhaustive references - chapter three for example has 50 references to other publications, most with specific page numbers. Illustrations include much historical material. Many of the concepts are discussed relative to architecture and furniture. The names of the first few chapters give a hint to the depth: 1) The Design Process, 2) Perception (how the mind perceives), 3) A History of Aesthetics (ancient to modern).
Unlike many, Darlow is not the least preachy in this book, not claiming that "this is right" but more presenting widely varied historical and current thinking. (The history alone makes it worth reading.) It contains a spectrum of ideas including strongly polarized philosophies. While it is a rich source of specific ideas on form and detail, I think it is equally valuable in providing a sense of both the epic and fluid natures of the aesthetics of design. It might be especially interesting for those who like to think about what defines art.
The level of research that must have gone into this book astounds me (and I'm not all that easily astounded). It's an equivalent of an advanced college course or two. This book is admittedly not for everyone.
>I've been looking to learn more about spindle turning design and especially the history and symbolism of the commonly used features. As an example, it is common to encounter the pineapple form atop a bedpost, and various urn shapes -- are they there because they just look "good" or "right" there, or is there also symbolism at work or implied like life, death, fertility, honor, trust, etc... Does Mike Darlow's book explain this stuff, too? Can someone here at WC explain some of that stuff? Hey -- inquiring minds want to know!
I don't specifically remember the pineapples and bedposts (may well be mentioned), but even if not the book is full of things I think you would find interesting. For example, leafing through just now I found this which explains possible meaning for one design feature: "The origin of the Corinthian capital. Vitruvius records that the Corinthian capital was invented by Athenian sculptor Callimachus after seeing the grave of a Corinthian maiden. A basket containing offerings, with a tile of the top to protect them, had been placed in the winter over a dormant acanthus plant..." Darlow of course only used pieces of the original references to suit his purpose - if he doesn't address the pineapple question and others directly his reference lists should be a good starting point for further research (for inquiring minds, of course!)
If you want to read the book and can't find a copy I'd be glad to loan my copy for a month or two (if you pay the postage!). Or you might check your local library - a quick online check indicates one of the libraries in Knoxville has the book.
>Three years ago, when I became president of our woodturner's club, I started featuring a website and listed it on our meeting's agenda, under the heading: "Website of the month". Russ' website was the first one I thought to list. His website is also linked on our subsequently created club wesbsite. The next two presidents have asked me to continue this practice. With new and interesting stuff, it is time to feature Russ' Corner again! At the Portland symposium several years ago (the only one attended so far), I recognized Russ and went up to him and introduced myself, proud to make his acquaintance.
>That is certainly an excellent article. And since I'm one of those guys who tends to sketch something out before tackling it, it is very valuable.
I'm curious, though, how (or if) either the Golden Mean or Rule of Thirds would factor in with respect to sizing a finial or a foot for a vessel? It seems they probably would have some relationship with the vessel's diameter, height, or size of base in the case of a foot. There's plenty of food for thought in the article to play around with in my doodling.
>Thank you, Russ. Your photos make the text all the more valuable. I've read your web pages a couple of times, but it's always good to have a refresher! Thanks.