Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Box elder bowl

Posts

Box elder bowl

#1

George Taylor

Box elder bowl

George Taylor

>I posted a few weeks ago about tear out on a box elder bowl. Below is a much less than perfect result. I fought cracks but after all my work, one still got me. I got a lot of practice with 2 part epoxy and Mixol colors. I thought the piece of wood was worth the extra effort; I don't know if I still feel that way. Give me a nice piece of maple, cherry or walnut any day. Comments and critiques are welcome.

George


img

Re: Box elder bowl

#2

Re: Box elder bowl

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

>George, the next time you turn some box elder, consider bleaching it with two part bleach. The results are spectacular. The light portion of the wood turns an ivory white and a red staining seems to get even redder. I have a box elder hollow form I finished a couple months ago that has more red staining than I have ever seen. If I get a chance I'll post a picture of it in the next couple days. But, the bleach really works.

Re: Box elder bowl

#3

Re: Box elder bowl

john lucas

>George Looks great. We turners worry about things like cracks filled with epoxy but people will buy it. Good save.

Re: Box elder bowl

#4

Re: Box Elder Platter

Barry Turner

>I spent the better part of the day turning a wide-rimmed platter from Box Elder. It had some spalting and was somewhat punky. Tear-out was pretty bad. I finally was able to get a clean cut with a 1/4" square-end bowl gouge. It really worked well. Those things are way under-rated. Now, if I could just learn to sharpen that gouge and keep the end square!

Re: Box elder bowl

#5

Re: Box Elder Platter

George Van

>Barry, I learned the benefits of the �� gouge from Jimmy Clewes, now I use them all the time. I have three of Doug�s �U� flute 3/8� gouges ground straight across at 60, 50, & 40 degrees. One of these always seems appropriate. A 50 degree, Henry Taylor, �� forged gouge is also in my �spalted arsenal�. Cutting on a skewed angle it produces nice curls in softer fiber.

Re: Box elder bowl

#6

Re: Box Elder Platter

john lucas

>Just to be clear, are you guys talking about a bowl gouge ground flat on the front so it looks like a U. Then sharpen at the appropriate angle. What part of the cutting edge are you using. I keep the flute up and cut with the straight part of the U or maybe so the cut is near the bottom of the straight part. Is that how Stuart uses it? I don't have one ground like that right now or I would take a photo.

I use my rough out gouge that way sometimes because it has the same grind. I know don't use a rough out gouge on a bowl and I don't recommend it because it's too easy to screw up and get a really bad catch. I do have 25 years of working with those tools so like they say in Mythbusters, don't try this at home, where what they call professionals.

Re: Box elder bowl

#7

Re: Box Elder Platter

Texian

>John, Sounds like shear scraping with what I call a straight conical grind or "traditional" grind. Have an old 5/8 Sorby with very modest V shape (used to think it was a U) that does this very well, and I use this cut a lot. Flutes angled 45 degrees (give or take) in the direction of travel, cutting just below the nose of the gouge. Probably not even good technique, but works well across inside bottoms and for making tiny adjustments to the outside shape of a piece.

Re: Box elder bowl

#8

Re: Box Elder Platter

john lucas

>I'm not shear scraping with it. I'll try to take a photo after while. The cut I'm using is almost like cutting with the skew, toe down. The wood shears down the cutting edge.

Re: Box elder bowl

#9

Re: Box Elder Platter

Barry Turner

>Yep, that's what I am talking about. I was using it on the inside of a platter, taking a sort of skew cut. It worked wonders on some punky Box Elder.

My gouge is a Crown 1/4" bowl gouge, U-shape, ground straight across the end. At least, it was until I ground it a few times. I think I am just going to have to grind the end square and do the bevels all over again.

Re: Box elder bowl

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Box Elder Platter

Keith Tompkins

>Barry, Are you using a wolverine jig on the gouge? That makes it an easy task. I intentionally grind the wings back slightly, which creates the perfect angle when I take a finish cut... The "U" is flute down, cutting with the side of the gouge. There is a risk with that cut; the more the tool is rotated into the cut, the greater the possibility of a catch, yet the better it cuts.

Re: Box elder bowl

#11

Re: Box Elder Platter

George Van

>John, I use it the same as you, cutting on the lower left side of the gouge, flute up, handle horizontal. (The forged gouge is handle down) This is a thin finishing cut with minimum extension of the gouge over the toolrest. If I have to remove a tool mark it is a skim the surface-shave the bump cut. I have to look at the opposite side of the bowl to see the cut start, if I can see the start of the cut at the tool, I am taking too deep of a cut. I use a curved toolrest on the inside to make this cut to minimize vibration.

I sharpen mine on the Wolverine tool rest, rotating in place. I do not use the Vari-grind on these tools. I have made a series of �C� shaped gauges that rest on the toolrest and make contact with the wheel in two places that make changing grind angles on the Wolverine easy, quick, and repeatable.

Re: Box elder bowl

#12

George Taylor

Re: Box elder bowl *LINK*

George Taylor

>Is this the kind of bleach you are talking about? I didn't see any 2 part bleach on the Woodcraft or Craft Supplies web sites. Do you know of a source that sells it in smaller quantities? I want to try it but I don't get excited about shelling out $80 on an experiment. How do you apply it and how long should I let it sit? I am getting a bunch of stock ready for when I attend a Stephen Hatcher workshop in early February and it might be neat to have some more of the box elder to "embellish."

Thanks

George


http://woodworker.com/wood-bleach-gallon-kit-mssu-155-126.asp?search=bleach&searchmode=2

Re: Box elder bowl

#13

rough out gouge skew cut

john lucas

>Here are two shots. the first is the rough out gouge used with the left wing cutting. I would prefer to do this with a bowl gouge ground to this same U shape profile. Why, well if you get a catch you only have a 1/4" thick tang to take the blow on the rough out gouge. It will bend if not break. A bowl gouge has a thick shank so it's less likely to be damaged in a catch.

You notice how close the top edge of the rough out gouge is the the wood. Any closer and you get a catch. Further away and you are cutting with more of the bottom of the U and give up some of the skew type cut. You have to concentrate to do this cut as any lapse will mean a catch.

The second shot is basically the same cut using the nose of the spindle gouge. A much safer cut.


img

Re: Box elder bowl

#14

Re: Box elder bowl

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

>George, That is the stuff I was talking about. What I have is a "Pint Kit" which is two 16 oz bottles. (One of Part A and one of Part B.) I went to their website but could only find the one gallon size kit. Perhaps they have discontinued the smaller sizes. They stated that most Lowes, Home Depot or Walmarts carry their products.

I've included a picture so you can get an idea of the results. Not a wonderful hollow form, but a dramatic piece of wood.


img

Re: Box elder bowl

#15

Re: Box Elder Platter

Barry Turner

>Yes, I'm using the Wolverine, but not the vari-grind jog. I'm just putting the gouge handle in the socket of the Wolverine extension. I rotate the handle to grind the bevel. It's very easy to grind too much or unevenly. I have tried running the grinder up to about half speed and switching it off. This helps some. Any other advice?

Re: Box elder bowl

#16

Re: Box elder bowl

Barry Turner

>I asked the local Woodcraft about 2-part bleach not long ago. They said they were having problems with shipping the reactive chemicals and no longer carried it.

Re: Box elder bowl

#17

Re: Box elder bowl

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

>I also heard that Woodcraft had dropped it. There caps of the two bottles are different. I believe they said that one was a 'venting' lid and they cautioned to keep the bottle upright. I imagine that coulsd cause some problems when shipping.

Re: Box elder bowl

#18

bleach

Jack Savona

>I picked up 2-part bleach (16 oz. bottles) in at my local hardware store about a year ago. The price tag says $16.99. I've also since bought some oxalic acid that will be my next try at bleaching.

The caps on my 2-part bleach bottles are the same. That's why I wrote 'A' and 'B' on the caps to make sure I didn't mix them up.

Re: Box elder bowl

#19

Oxalic Acid,, Clorox

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Jack,

I've tried it and it is very mild, but it does remove rust stains not only in wood but in the kitchen sink as well.

Clorox is not in the same league as the two part bleach, but it does work quite well, specially if done on the sunlight, and can be repeated until you cannot see any further change.

Give it a try and it is a lot cheaper than te two part one.

Jorge

Re: Box elder bowl

#20

Re: Box Elder Platter

George Van

>Barry, I used to grind with the handle in the pocket of the arm also. Then I wrecked a wheel when grinding a 70 degree bevel and the gouge pulled down below center and jammed the wheel while taking a chunk of the wheel out. I now grind on the toolrest for safety and accuracy. I am able to get right on top and view the evenness of the grind. I can also apply much less pressure as the wheel is not pulling down on the bevel. In fact if I do not apply pressure forward the bevel will not grind, can�t get much lighter than that. Also with the toolrest set at a given angle I can grind any tool to that angle even if the handles and overall lengths of the tool are different without changing anything.

Re: Box elder bowl

#21

Re: Box Elder Platter

Barry Turner

>OK. I'll try your method. It sounded like it would be harder, though. Thanks.