Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Making A Mental Leap To Maker

Posts

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: I think that's the point exactly-

Keith Tompkins

>Steve, I once ran my own cabinetmaking shop. I would show customers my wood racks with row after row of various wood species. The typical reply..."What's that for?" They couldn't make the connection between rough lumber and the finished items they were interested in. Kinda' like a city kid thinks milk comes from a plastic carton.

Same with turning...the average customer doesn't know how, or with what equipment, the pieces they buy are made. Wood Art seems to cover it all, whether turned or not. Only other turners or "makers" really care.

Yes, AAW seems to embrace "Wood Art". Do you think the field would be growing as rapidly if they DIDN'T?

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#27

Re:So what's the big deal??

russ fairfield

>The only difference between carving and turning is which moves, the wood or the knife.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#28

Keith Tompkins

Re: we're all woodcarvers

Keith Tompkins

>Dammit John, I thought I had this all figured out...now I'm confused.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#29

"I'm not creative"

David Belser

>This one allays bothers me when I hear someone say it. My response is:

"Well tell me about your fantasies"

Which can bring the conversation to a halt but clearly demonstrates one or two points.

Everyone is creative.

If you have ever fantasized about wining the lottery or running away or..., if you have ever told a story to get out of a ticket or keep a surprise, then you are capable of being creative.

Sharing your creativity is scary.

If you don't want to tell me about your fantasy, then you are afraid of sharing your creativity. Creative acts are very personal, they come from within your mind and are influenced by your beliefs and experiences. Sharing them can be quite scary (for both the creator and the observer :) What if people laugh? or misunderstand or just don't get it? That's part of me out there.

Dance as if no one is watching.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#30

Steven Antonucci

I LOVE WOOD ART!

steve antonucci

>Wood art is why I do this. I saw work from Jordan, Ellsworth, Raffan and I had to know how they did it. Next, I had to be able to do it too.

I am all for the progression of the medium, but there's a lot of wood art that isn't turning. I just don't understand why folks call things that weren't turned turnings? That's my only gripe, Keith.

It's about semantics largely, but our culture has a way of manipulating words and meaning over time to a point where the words have no meaning. In my "segmented woodturning #1" piece, I facetiously asked the very simple question: Does a woodturning actually have to be turned? if not, then the word woodturning has no meaning...

Steve

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#31

Steven Antonucci

That's just great!

steve antonucci

>I love the idea of making something that looks like it was made on the lathe without it actually being made on a lathe at all...

An artist's view if I ever saw one...

s

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#32

Creativity - Artist Linkage Barrier?

charlie belden

>Andi's example of internally defining "artist" as one who creates 2D art ( oil painting, water colors, pen and ink, pencil, acrylics, tempera, etc.) and therefore keeping her from believing for a long time that she just wasn't artistic (creative?) is a great example of the type of mental barrier that keeps many from using and enjoying the creative ability we all come with - though often don't use much.

Our brains are set up to make connections - to associate things with each other. Sometimes those connections are erroneous. Creative and Artist have a strong connection. But if you think about it Creative and Parent go together, Creative and Auto Mechanic go together, Creative and Mathematician go together, Creative and Cooking go together. The connections to Creative go on and on.

But when we consider if we are creative or not, we think in terms of artists and inventors. If that's the yardstick against which we measure whether we're creative or not it's understandable that so many don't think they are, or can be, creative.

What I'm trying to get acrossed is ways of using other "yardsticks" to measure our creative ability.

Andi introduced the term "maker" rather than "artist" or "creator". If we use "maker" as the yardstick and synthesis/combiner instead of creation/creative as what's being measured most will say they can make things by putting things together - in interesting ways even.

Once you can think of yourself as a "maker/synthesizer" a whole lot of possibilities open up on ways to be creative. And when that happens the only thing left between an imagined thing and the thing becoming real is figuring out how to do it - and doing it. The doing part is something you can learn to do, just as you can learn to imagine / be creative.

Back to the Creativity - Artist Linkage. Creating isn't a problem. It's what happens with the creation after it's created where the angst comes in. If the creation is made for the experience of the making, things are simple. I got something out of the making - and that's it. If what I made has an affect on me after I've made it - maybe a motivation to make more things - that's it.

It's when you need feedback from others - other makers, artists, critics, customers, patrons - that things get complicated. Now the intent is to achieve external evalution of the thing made - and perhaps by extension - of ME - the old - Love Me, Love My Art and visa versa thing. Now it's your ego that's on the line.

I'm just not very competative. I never aspired to be The Winner. I do things because it interests me and the doing is the main motivation, the results and what others think about it isn't that important, except if it gets someone else to try it and also enjoy doing it.

With a prod from someone on this forum I entered something I really enjoyed making, enjoyed playing with when it was done and then sold at an auction to raise money for a bird sanctuary in Panama. The piece was An Elegant Tight Rope Walker. It had movement, made noises. was kind of nice to look at and it was fun to play with.

I really liked the idea and how the finished piece came out and that it worked as I had imagined it would.

Then I put my ego on the line and got feedback from three prominent woodturner judges of the Elegant Forms Contest.

Close - but no cigar.

Well executed - BUT - .

Individually well done. Together? Not so good.

My initial reaction to their critiques was

WHAT!? It's elegant AND whimsical AND fun as hell to play with because it has actual movement AND sounds AND it's nice to look at. All the other entries just sit there and look nice. But they don't move too. And they don't make sounds either. And none of the other entries DO anything or have a surprise (the finial of one of the elements swiveled and remained upright regardless of the angle of the thing below it to which it appeared to be attached tilted).

Of course that was my ego kicking in. But then I thought about it. I COULD have done some of the things suggested to make the piece look nicer and more coherent and still keep the movement and sound and play option. If I do another piece like this I'll try to incorporate some of what the judges suggested. And I'll probably enter a piece for some other contest that includes a critique and I may learn something more I can use later.

Now about that idea for feathers and hog bristles and pearlescent paint and PrismaColor markers and a Mother of Pearl inlay for the next magic wand . . .

Hey, you wanna make something creative?

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#33

I turn, therefore I am...

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Jorge Castaneda

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#34

Keith Tompkins

Re: It is difficult to explain....

Keith Tompkins

>Mike, allow me to muddy the waters just a little bit more...Let's say I turn a wooden vase, then fill it with a carefully arranged flower bouquet. Then, I make a still-life painting of the scene. Has my three dimentional craft item become 2- D art? Bet I could get more money for the painting than the vase.:)

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#35

Keith Tompkins

Re: "I'm not creative"

Keith Tompkins

>Hi David. I have a small ceramic piece above my lathe that is inscribed with the simple word "dance". At the Buyer's Market for Craft, a lady's acceptance speech for winning a Niche Award quoted the country song "I hope you dance." I was touched by her statement, and by the words in the song. I cannot dance, probably for the same reasons some people say they are not creative. That one word now serves as a reminder that working at my lathe is my equivalent of dancing...in every sense of the word.

Too many time we succumb to "self-imposed limitations". I don't carve. I don't use color. I'm not an artist. I'm not creative. It's all been done. There's nothing new under the sun.

People: Life is short. We're going to dead a very, very, long time. Like the song says...Dance.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#36

Mike Stafford

Re: It is difficult to explain....

Mike Stafford

>You know Keith, you are probably right. There does not seem to be as large a market for 3 dimensional art as for paintings etc. This is easily substantiated by attending any art show and you will see the 3-D category overwhelmed by the oils, watercolors, etc.

I might enjoy looking at the painting but more than likely I would be wondering what kind of wood is pictured....LOL

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#37

milk from the spout OT but maybe interesting

John K Jordan

>> Kinda' like a city kid thinks milk comes from a plastic carton.

I let the kids who come here (little kids and big kids) learn first "hand" where milk comes from.

I was a little surprised at how almost everyone wants to try. BTW, with the goat Princess here, it took about 500 squeezes to milk, twice a day. Made a lot of cheese and yogurt.

JKJ


img

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#38

The Trend Towards Art Driving The Field?

charlie belden

>Keith T noted

"Yes, AAW seems to embrace "Wood Art".

And then asked

"Do you think the field would be growing as rapidly if they DIDN'T?"

Not to side track How To Get Around Thinking I'm Just Not Creative, but I have to ask

What field are you refering to?

- the amateur turner who turns (and carves and scortches and sandblasts and pierces and dyes and . . .) for the pure pleasure and has no intention or desire to make a living from their turning (and carving and piercing and . . .) or to have their stuff in someone's collection?

- the amateur who turns AND wants their pieces in collections and museums just as recognition of excellence, or imagination, or . . . - but doesn't require that as the source of their earned living?

- the people formally trained for the career of making unique and hopefully purchased hand crafted objects?

- the person with no formal training but a natural ability to make things others want to buy - and earns her/his living doing that?

I'm guessing that purchasers of most woodturning magazines and books and DVDs/videos, and paying students of turning classes are NOT people who make their living turning, teaching turning or sponsored by tool makers of turning tools and accessories. I'm putting my money on the bet that it's the amateur and hobbyist, not the professional, nor galleries or collectors or museums that are driving the interest in turning and the demand for lathes, turning tools, finishes, accessories and so on.

The trend to Art seems to be for the benefit of a few - artists, agents, dealers, collectors and perhaps a museum or two - and only as a trickel down effect to the people who I think ARE driving the growth in woodturning - the amateur and hobbyist.

I've not seen the books of the AAW so I don't know what chunk of the revenue stream comes from membership fees, but if it's significantly over 50 percent, the focus should remain on the amateur and hobbyist and the proliferation of wood turners, not the marketing of wood turningS.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#39

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Trend Towards Art Driving The Field?

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Charlie, I would include everyone who considers themselves a turner. After all, how many people can honestly say they make the majority of their income through sales of their turnings.

Time out: Let's see....gotta make 50 big ones a year, minimum. (Wait a minute...I live in New York; my property tax is almost $11,000 a year) Net profit of 20 percent(that's double real-world numbers) means I gotta bring in $250,000 gross. That shouldn't be too hard, only about 4800 bucks a week. Five turnings a week @ $1,000 a pop. Maybe ten turnings a week @ $500.00 a pop. If I sell 137 pens a week @ $35.00 that should do it. Piece of cake.

OK, I'm back. Now I remember why I kept my day job. Lets jump ahead to Hartford. There will be maybe 1,500 turnings there on display in the instant gallery. How many of those turners represented there are making a living soley by turning. Not many. How many pure turnings will we see in comparison to the artsy stuff? No many. I must conclude that there sure are a whole lotta' amateur turners who are making some pretty awesome stuff. Maybe even art.

Charlie, I teach quite a few classes a year. Many students don't want to learn the basics of turning. They want the good stuff...carving, burning, texturing, whatever. Too many can't even sharpen their turning tools yet.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#40

Re: The Trend Towards Art Driving The Field?

john lucas

>I agree with Keith. When I do demos people like to see the neat stuff. Burn it, carve on it, decorate it some way. They've already seen someone turn a bowl. In fact they've probably seen 20 someones turn a bowl.

After you've turned a bunch of bowls you just naturally want to add a little something to it. Even if your after the perfect shape, in that quest you will have a piece that just doesn't seem right so you texture the rim. Maybe you've done a natural edge bowl and the bark won't stay on. Peel it off and burn the edge.

I'm not saying this is art, it's just a natural progression when you turn a lot of stuff.

The AAW is usually just showing people who have taken this progression to the top level.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#41

I'm a tool nut

john lucas

>Mike I was at a museum the other day and was looking at the paintings. In one painting they were building a boat. I was much more interested in the tools laying around in the scene than the painting itself. :)

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#42

Steven Antonucci

I turn, therefore I am... covered in shavings :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#43

Re: The Trend Towards Art Driving The Field?

charlie belden

>Keith, John, et.al.

If I gave the impression that the AAW isn't conributing to the growth in the "field" of wood turning that was definitely NOT my point. The networking resource and the club insurance it provides supports LOCAL amateur/hobbyist turners as well as semi-pros.

By semi-pros I mean turners who make some money from turning - selling their pieces, demonstrating/teaching/writing articles/writing books/making videos and DVDs - who could barely stay alive on what they earn from just selling their pieces.

The grants to turners, outreach programs to encourage getting into wood turning (including putting on symposiums, special purchase deals and discounts for members from suppliers of wood turning tools, lathes and accessories - all foster the expansion of interest and then participation in woodturning - as wood turnerS - NOT as gallery owners, or collectors, or museums curators, or art dealers/brokers or as speculators. Support for the turners/ MAKERS and Wanna Be Makers is where I, as a member, believe the focus and emphasis should be. To support THIS creative outlet - woodturning.

Which gets us back to the Creative Thing - and the I'm Just Not Very Creative (and can never be creative) Thing - and how to help people discover that they CAN be creative.

I've been playing this little game with kids who "just can't draw". We call this games DOODLES.

The instructions are simple.

1. put the tip of the pencil in the center of a blank piece of paper

2. close your eyes

3. when I say "GO!" you start scribbling all over that paper, circles and zig zags and anything else that'll make marks on the paper. NO STABBING ALLOWED!

4. when I saw STOP! you lift the pencil point off the paper and open your eye

When the first Doodle is drawn I look at it and see something - or part of something - a leaf, a bird, a nose or ear, a car hood, a cowboy hat - a camel. I darken some of the lines already there - and maybe add some to "bring out" what I see.

Takes no time at all for kids to get the idea so the next step is getting them to find something in the next doodle and I repeat the darken some of the existing lines and adding some to bring the rest of IT out. Sometimes understanding and seeing what the kid sees takes some doing - but communicating an idea is part of the Doodle Game.

The next step is getting out of the way and encouraging the kid to do the next one completely. If they see that what they've got isn't all that they "see" we figure out what's missing and how to add it. That may be a quick lesson on drawing an eye, or an ear or maybe the parts of a leaf and which part is missing.

Then it's time to turn the kid loose - on a friend or sibling nearby, probably observing but not willing to participate - yet. It helps if you brag on the kid a bit to the friend or sibling "Did you know that you're sister / brother / buddy was an artist? I'd bet you are, or could be, an artist too."

So now you've got an artist AND if he or she gets a friend in the game - a teacher as well!

And look on the kid's face as she or he says

"Look at what I did! I CAN draw. I'm an artist!"

- THAT's my paycheck.

Now there's no guarantee that the kid will keep artisting - but she or he now knows that he or she - CAN artist - and be creative.

One of my early DOODLERS didn't pursue drawing or what's called "art" - but she told me years later, actually decades later, that she still remembers her first game of DOODLES and that she got the "I CAN draw!" (and maybe do other things I didn't think I could do) idea in her head. Five year olds are very impressionable, and if they're really bored by being around a bunch of adults, easy to engage - especially if you sit on the floor, doodling on a piece of paper ;)

At my highschool class reunions, her mom always tells me her daughter insisted she say Hi to Doodles for her.

enough rambling

Anybody got any crayons or colored pencils?

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#44

Jesper, Denmark

Re: To do or.........

Jesper, Denmark

>To do, or not to do?....Shakespeare

To do is to be......Nietzche

Doo bee doo bee dooh�..... Sinatra

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#45

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Trend Towards Art Driving The Field?

Keith Tompkins

>I think the problem that seems to be frustrating you is that some people are just not creative. Their strong points lie elsewhere. Maybe accounting or finance. I don't know. There are certainly different levels of aptitude in any category. I know when I try to explain a concept to some turners, the blank expression on their faces tells me I'm not getting through. When I give them a blank sheet and ask them to draw their turning in advance...they can't envision it. Maybe it's the way we're taught from the very beginning; color within the lines, everyone always has to come up with the same conclusion with no room for individualism.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#46

Mike Stafford

I've got crayons!!!!

Mike Stafford

>I don't have any art talent but thanks to Molly and Carole I have lots of beautiful crayons. I mean to tell you I have all the colors!!!

Thanks ladies, my life is complete now that I never have to feel inadequate about crayons.

8-))

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#47

Creativity Ain't Limited To Art

charlie belden

>You've never heard of creative accounting? ENRON sure appreciated creative accounting. Creative attorney? I give you Johny Cochran. Creative engineers? The engineers who figured out how to get the Apollo crew oxygen - and back to earth - alive. Creative doctor? Jonas Salk. Creative car designer - Shelby and Jim Hall. Creative social activist - Ghandi.

Pick and endevor and you'll find creative people, many never heralded as such. Creativity is not the sole domain of ART. But if you can cop to being really good at something, anything, you CAN be creative in aesthetic areas - "the arts". And "the arts" includes all sorts of things besides paintings and sculpture. Dance, music (sung or played or written or hummed or whistled), found art, assemblages, collages, writing, poetry, comedy, acting, juggling, and yes - woodworking - of some sort. The list goes on and on. And I believe EVERYONE can be creative in at least one of "the arts", specifically with wood - IF a) they want to and b) if they stop thinking "I'm just not very creative".

We're born with the ability to be creative. Think about it. You never hear a four or five year old say "I'm bored!. There's NOTHING to do." But by the time they get to be a teen ager, most have lost stopped using their inherent creativity - and I think how we "teach kids" has much to do with "I'm bored. There's NOTHING to do."

I think being creative - maybe not world renowned creative - but creative enough to do something or make something that gives you, and maybe someone else a buzz, you in the making and them in the experiencing the results.

So if I can get someone to shift to Maker and I Can. I Can. I THINK I Can - maybe they will. And that gives me a buzz thinking about what might come out of that attitude shift.

charlie b

aka Doodles

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#48

BarbS

Excellent post, Charlie.

BarbS

>

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#49

Keith Tompkins

Re: Creativity Ain't Limited To Art

Keith Tompkins

>Perhaps exposure to various craft venues would be helpful to those who feel they have no creativity. I teach at a craft school that offers classes in glass blowing, ceramics, cabinetmaking, turning, fused glass, bookbinding, metal fabrication and welding, painting and drawing. Instead of thinking 'I Can't"...just do. When asked where he got his ideas from, Thomas Edison stated that ideas are everywhere..one just needs to reach up and pluck them out of the air. Creativity, imagination, whatever comes naturally to some, others have to work at it. We are all different, and that's the real beauty of it....if we all had a block of wood, and a week to work on it, every result would be a different shape and color, etc.