Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Making A Mental Leap To Maker

Posts

Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#1

Making A Mental Leap To Maker

charlie belden

>In an earlier thread "When Is It No Longer A TURNING?", Andi Wolfe contributed the following:

"My take? Too much anxiety out there about the "purity" of wood turning. For me, the lathe is a wonderful tool. I enjoy turning wood, but brown and round just doesn't completely fulfill my needs as a "maker." I enjoy working with wood and it's all about the journey of discovery that is fun for me. I'll use whatever tools and techniques are needed to make my art."

I'm betting that just about everyone here is using a lathe in order to be a Maker - of something tangible - and on a Journey of Discovery, whether we want to think in terms like this or not. Most of us, whether we will admit it, to ourselves or others, want to create something ourselves - that's unique - and that we MADE come into existence - and that's "really nice".

And that desire to Make Something Unique and Nice is what drives creative people - some of whom we call artists rather than makers.

Many think "I'm just not very creative." - and aren't - yet. If You Are What You Eat is true, maybe You Are What You THINK You Are is also true. So if you think only Artists can be creative, and can't think of yourself as an Artist, how about thinking I'm A Maker. NOW maybe creative ideas that MIGHT otherwise be ruled out or dismissed perhaps will be pursued - and maybe - created - as a turning, or a carving, or a sculpute or all of the above.

Making A Mental Leap To Maker just might be what's needed to get acrossed that I'm Just Not Very Creative barrier - or not.

Just something to think about - or not.

Thanks Andi.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#2

Ellis Walentine

Some rambling thoughts on this

Ellis Walentine

>I generally try to avoid these topics because they so often lead to disagreement. It seems to me that we'd all be better off without labels and semantics for everything. Art, craft, design, artist, turner, maker -- these are all just words that overlap in many different ways, like morphing Venn diagrams. I'm *making* things whenever I cause something to exist. I am a *turner* when I use a lathe. Woodworking -- at least the aspects of it that I engage in -- is my *craft*. I guess you could call me a *crafter*, although that word has come to imply someone who makes lower end craft items, gee gaws, knick knacks, for the flea market sale or church bazaar. I am a *designer* when I conceive of something that solves one or more concurrent design problems, e.g., function, cost, style, etc., usually utilitarian in nature, although you can call sculpture and non-functional art designed as well. I don't need to be the *maker* of my designs, but I usually am. If I try to render the thing I make -- whether functional or not and whether I designed it or not -- in an artful or artistic way, e.g., balanced proportions, good composition, tasteful detailing, good use of line, form, color, embellishments, etc. -- in other words, concentrate on aesthetics as opposed to purely functional concerns -- I am being an *artist*, or attempting to be one, misinformed as that may be. Whether or not anyone else thinks my work is art will determine if I'm regarded as an artist outside my own self concept.

So where does all this word soup leave us? I like Andi's characterization of "brown and round" as a term for unembellished turnings. I happen to fall into this camp more often than not because I really love forms and the beauty of the wood, and I'm not practiced at, patient enough, or generally inspired to do post-lathe embellishments -- painting, burning, carving, surface decoration, etc. -- that are aimed at making a turned piece into a more involved work of art. But, I don't deprecate those who enjoy that aspect of "making;" in fact I really admire them and wish I had the time and talent and motivation to try some of those techniques myself. I can understand why some people might not consider these non-lathe-based extensions of the actual turning process to be "turning" because technically they aren't. "Art" or "sculpture" is probably a more accurate way to characterize them, but since the lathe is involved in the creative process, this whole field of art has been included under the general umbrella of turning. The popularity of these methods among turners is testimony to their legitimacy as part of the turning lexicon. A lot of turners view the actual turning as just the first step in the making process.

For myself, I'm content to be a turner/maker who makes round, brown things, sometimes to stand alone as artful objects, other times to be incorporated into a design of some sort, usually also as artfully as I can. (I happen to be making a towel rack today, for example, which includes a turned ipe rod suspended between two end caps bandsawn from flat stock.) I enjoy the design process, of deciding how big and what color and how far off the wall and how strong it should be, and I like the making -- using my turning and flat work skills, and I expect the result to be at least not unattractive -- I don't know about artistic. But my concept of *maker* easily extends into all these overlapping areas. I don't want to get hung up on the words that attempt to describe what I'm doing -- "The Way that can be described is not the true Way," and all of that -- I just want to come up with the idea and see it through in whatever way results in the intended outcome. That, to me is what making is all about.

Maybe intention is the key here. What we decide we want to do may include all these skills. Or not.

Ellis

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#3

The Focus Wasn't On The How - But The Where

charlie belden

>What I'm trying to get at has nothing to do with Art vs Craft or Round and Brown vs Piereced, Carved, Scortched, Colored. It's not even about HOW.

HOW you get "there" can require learning new skills and developing new techniques. And lord knows, that can involve quite a learning curve to climb. Some ideas aren't pursued because of the learning curve required, or thought to be required. But that's just part of the "journey".

The discussion I'm after isn't about the HOW or the Journey, but about WHERE - the possible WHEREs.

I've known people who have never left the county they were born in. For whatever reason, that's as far as they want or are willing to explore. Maybe they get lost easily and had a bad experience on the way to "outside". Or maybe they're quite content with the space they choose to stay in. Maybe they're not even aware of what's in other places to see and experience. They're born and will die in the place they started in. And that may be a good thing - for them.

Then there's Andi Wolfe - treking all over hell and back - and the outskirts of heaven as well. I can only imagine, and I must confess - envy - her "I want to go" WHERE List.

It's the WHERE List thing I'm interested in. To imagine journeying to potentially interesting places, to consider the possibilities - thinking of a "new to me" WHERE one might go - and maybe CAN go. Sure, many of those WHEREs will never be reached - but maybe close imight be close enough - to encourage more thinking about other WHEREs.

Just considering other WHEREs is what can get one past "I'm just not very creative - and I CAN'T be creative." That mental shift from I'm HERE and I Will Stay HERE to I'd Like To Go THERE - someday - just might open up a whole host of possible WHEREs - and open up the tap on CREATIVE - maybe just a trickle - at first. Once the tap is turned on it gets harder to keep thinking "I'm just not very creative.".

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#4

Peter Lamb, in SC

Re: Some rambling thoughts on this

Peter Lamb, in SC

>E;;is,

I could not agree with you more. I mean every word you so artfully typed. I could not have said all the things you covered if I had locked myself in a closet for a month.

Thank you so much,

Peter

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#5

Why is there heartburn?

Ed Moore in SW VA

>I don't really care who makes what. But I feel that there is considerable pent-up heartburn among the more traditional woodturners because elitists, some on the AAW Board, use "brown and round" and similar expressions in a pejorative sense. I cannot understand why those who specialize in wood art feel the need to put down some incredibly talented craftsmen (and women) and act as if that talent is somehow second-rate and is inferior to what they do. I know of at least one recognized wood artist who is not a good turner - and the name has not been mentioned nor has that person participated in this discussion on WC. So, I would say that unless one has exceptional woodturning skills, they should be careful to not put down the "brown and rounders" and regard them as lesser members of the community.

In a private discussion with a distinguished mathematics professor at the University of Pennsylvania, he remarked that very few people make truly significant contributions to mathematics, but that many make very worthwhile contributions. It is the same in woodturning. No one should assume that they are the be all, end all of woodturning, and put down the brown and round. Talent exists in all areas of woodturning endeavor, not just in wood art.

My good friend, Stephen Hatcher, does incredible artistic mineral inlay platters and more. I love his work. And I have never heard him put down woodturners who do work less artistic than his. I include this because I do not want to come across as brown and round and nothing else. I do like to use dyes on platters, too.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#6

Re: Why is there heartburn?

AndiWolfe

>I must be missing out on some of those conversations, Ed. I don't hear much denigration of traditional wood turning when I talk to featured demonstrators at major symposia, but I do hear conversations wondering why there is this artificial division between traditional styles of turning and the move toward expression of ideas using surface enhancements.

I think that most of us who have become known for developing a signature style of work also appreciate a beautifully turned bowl, platter, box, spindle and the like. I think we also enjoy the process of turning. I have a hard time coming up with a list of more accomplished turners than J. Paul Fennell, John Jordon, Mark Sfirri, Pascal Oudet, Bill Luce, Binh Pho, and many others that push surface enhancements to the limits of imagination. As I said in another post, though, many of us *need* something beyond the lathe for expression of an emotion or to tell a story via a piece of art.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#7

Re: Why is there heartburn?

AndiWolfe

>Jordan - geez, can't even type this evening. ;-)

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#8

Ellis Walentine

Beginning or ending at the lathe

Ellis Walentine

>Agreed, Andi. Turning shouldn't be viewed as an end in itself, but rather as a means to other ends. If our intention is to make lovely forms, we can stop there. Or, if we want to make wonderful carved or embellished objects, we can go as far as we like down that road. Like you, I try not to pay too much attention to people who pass judgment on one path or the other.

Ellis

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#9

Steven Antonucci

Some days, I am a turner. Someday, an artist...

steve antonucci

>There are days when I just want to cut. The sheer joy of watching the ribbons of wood flying. The smell of fresh cut cherry, my hands blackened from the tanin stains. Doesn't really even matter what I am making- I love standing at a lathe. It allows me to focus.

Some days, I go there with a purpose. I have a specific idea, need, project, goal. Whatever. I am a maker. I want to be good at my craft. I want to be able to make things that are finished when I turn off the lathe. I have practiced my craft long enough to be a very good maker.

Finally, there are field trips. Days when I go to the shop with a purpose, but I am off on some tangent within 5 minutes of the lights going on. I cannot predict when these days will come, but I relish them. Something just hits me and I have to follow it. Often, I do not "make" anything that day, because I do not know how to "make" the ideas that usually accompany these days. I sit. I figure. I test, and retry methods. I learn I grow.

I aspire to do things that I cannot already do.

And sometimes art is the result.

(But I do all three, and will admit to it!)

Steve

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#10

Ellis Walentine

Creativity

Ellis Walentine

>More good questions, Charlie. How do we conjure up creativity? How do we challenge ourselves to do things that satisfy our need to be creative? I don't know, but I have the feeling it has a lot to do with squinting your eyes and imagining what you might make. Be inspired by others, but be the captain of your own destiny.

Ellis

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Cogito ergo sum.....

Jesper, Denmark

>Descartes: I think, therefore I am.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Cogito ergo sum.....

Keith Tompkins

>Tompkins: "I turn, therefore, I am". Sorry, couldn't resist. :)

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#13

I THINK I Can, I THINK I Can, I THINK I Can

charlie belden

>: The Little Engine That Could

There's a singificant difference between

"I can't", "I don't THINK I can" and "I consciously choose not to."

"I can't" means I am actually unable to.

"I don't THINK I can" is a mental attitude behind most "I'm just not very creative". To a large extent, what you think you are is what you are. If thinking of yourself as creative is for some reason difficult to do, perhaps thinking of yourself as a maker - of ideas into realities - gets you passed the "I'm just not very creative" thing - who knows where you'll go.

And Wild Hare Ideas can be fun to pursue - even if you don't catch the little . . .

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#14

Re: Creativity

Carole Valentine

>Ellis, you have a wonderful way with words. I always enjoy reading your posts...you should do it more often. :)

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#15

Who is an artist?

AndiWolfe

>Charlie - you raise some interesting questions and points in this discussion thread.

I'll share a personal story with the group. My Mom is a very talented artist who has worked in oils, pastels, charcoal and other media for 2D imaging. I've always set my benchmark on artistic ability on her and her cohorts. My impressions were from an early age since I was a frequent model in the art classes my mom attended or co-taught.

I can't draw worth a d**n. Even my doodles are ugly. Thus, I never considered myself to have any artistic ability. Imagine my surprise when I discovered that I can think in 3D and make my ideas come to life. If I had limited myself to 2D I would never have been able to explore the world of creative expression as I've done over the past 10 years. From that jumping off point I've discovered I have a good sense of color and I've been willing to take some leaps of faith, or desperation, along the way.

On creativity - my advice is to "open your eyes" and learn to "see" the world. A camera comes in handy - going beyond snapshots to capture images from angles one wouldn't usually consider to be aesthetically pleasing. My Flickr album is full of abstract captures that set my mind free to wonder how I could express some of that imagery in my wood art. I spend a whole day on this activity during my week long class at Arrowmont.

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#16

Re: Beginning or ending at the lathe

john lucas

>I could not agree with Andi more. Noboby I know puts traditional turning down. It seems to be the other way around. For some reason a few people simply can't accept that some of us went beyond traditional turning and are looking for another means of expression. I still love to see a good bowl and still turn quite a few.

to me the lathe is just a tool, not any different than a rasp, a chisel, the dremel, chainsaw, bandsaw etc. I have a vision of what I want to make and I use whatever tool it takes to make it.

I think it a lot of cases it might be jelousy. I know I'm jelous of people like Andi, Binh Pho, William Hunter, Mike Hosaluk and others who seem to have more time and possibly more imagination and more skill.

I entered an art competition one time with a piece that had a little bit of everything, carving, router work, lathe work and flat work. It took second place behind an incredible painting. It was supposed to be a competition among amatuer artists. I was taken to task by one person because I was a professional photographer. It was obvious that my professional photography skills had nothing to do with the hand skills required to do that piece and the judges agreed that the complaint was silly. Was it Jelousy, or some other motive. I don't know but it comes to mind every time I hear the controversy over something done off the lathe.

It's the kind of piece I personally would not enter into a turning competition because there was so little turning involved and even though it had carving there wasn't a huge amount of that either. It was simply an expression I created from wood that came from the heart. I was dating a women much younger than I and had to come to terms with the possibility that she would want children. It made me start thinking about all of out biological clocks and the reponsibilities. I call it the biological clock. It took months to plan and I have a male version that is still evolving and will be built some day soon.

A funny story about this piece. I have a degree in physical education and have been lifting weights and studying muscles all my life. I knew how legs should look but did not know how baby fat looked on legs. I went to Walmart to look at dolls to find one that had the right amount of baby fat. I was picking up the dolls and lifting their skirt to look at the leg when it dawned on me that I was probably being video taped and would appear in a Walmart training video on how to catch a pervert.

The Wood is Walnut, the Female symbol is spalted dogwood, the pacifier parts are maple as well as the letters on the block. The Block has my initials and the lady's initials. The rattle is also walnut.


img

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#17

you nailed it Charlie- I think I can

john lucas

>

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#18

Ditto on the drawing- cavemen do better than me

john lucas

>

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#19

Steven Antonucci

"Do or Do Not, There Is No Try"- Yoda

steve antonucci

>I personally believe in this philosophy. It might sound contrite, but there are very few things that I cannot do, only things I haven't done yet.

I have been within inches of dunking a basketball, a crash from a top three finish in a mountain bike race, and now a defining style away from being an artist. The one thing I've seen in art (that I have yet to DO) is following a concept all of the way through. I tend to chasing that shiny new thing...

Padawan Antonucci

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#20

Mike Stafford

It is difficult to explain....

Mike Stafford

>Just this week a friend was visiting and she picked up the AAW Journal, you know the one with the articles on spirals and "Garage to Gallery". As she looked at these images she asked if I did work like that. I chuckled and answered no. She then asked how these items were produced on a lathe. I had no answer for her except to say the final form was not produced on a lathe. We discussed some of the items pictured in the magazine and I tried to explain how I thought they were produced and invariably I kept using the words "wood carving". So she asked, "Wood carving is the same as woodturning?" I could not answer her question because I don't know the answer.

When a finished piece no longer has any remaining surface left that was created on a lathe is it a woodturning? If people who are not familiar with wood art cannot discern that the object was produced on a lathe is it woodturning? Is any object we deign to call a woodturning actually a woodturning? Or does it just contain elements that were turned on a lathe? And if it is not possible to discern whether or not any elements were turned on a lathe is the object a woodturning?

Is a section of a wooden 4X4 which is carved on all sides, dyed black and has a round dimple in one face a woodturning?

It is very hard to explain...

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#21

Steven Antonucci

I think that's the point exactly-

steve antonucci

>If everything becomes a woodturning, does the word have any meaning? Can a hewn bowl now be called a woodturning even though it was produced without a lathe simply because it COULD have been produced on a lathe?

I am no purist, but I think the word woodturning is going to become meaningless if things that weren't turned can be called turnings by the most influential organization in the woodturning community.

Use whatever processes and tools you need to create your art, but I believe in truth in advertising. If it isn't wood, and it wasn't turned, it's not a woodturning... (Sculptural wooden vessel is too long and wood art is too generic...ideas?)

Steven

Lathe Assisted Artist and Woodturner

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#22

we're all woodcarvers

John K Jordan

>>So she asked, "Wood carving is the same as woodturning?"

I once gave a "magic" wand and finger top to the head guy at ORNL (he sat down on the floor in a lab and spun tops with me!) and a year later he showed it to me and said "some wood carver gave me this." Tells the impression I made on him! :)

Seems technically wood carving is shaping wood with some tool, preferably but not necessarily a sharp tool. Says nothing about how the wood and tool get together or what guides the tool or supplies the power.

JKJ

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#23

Re: we're all woodcarvers

John Jordan

>Entirely turned.Stoney Lamar


img

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#24

Re: we're all woodcarvers

John Jordan

>Entirely not turned: Buzz Coren


img

Re: Making A Mental Leap To Maker

#25

Katherine Kowalski

Re: we're all woodcarvers

Katherine Kowalski

>Among laypeople that I meet, quite a large number have no idea what the word "woodturning" means. I often explain to them that it is like "power carving" using a lathe, because "carving" is a word to which they can relate. Often that's the way I think of turning -- instead of using rotating burrs in a flex-shaft tool, we are using rotating wood against a fixed tool.