Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Undercutting the rim

Posts

Undercutting the rim

#1

Undercutting the rim

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Hi all,

It's been awhile since I've devoted much time to actually turning something out of wood. I'm doing a practice piece now which is an 8" diameter x 1 1/2" deep silver maple dish with an undercut rim. I am planning on doing some platters for Christmas with this feature, but I haven't actually done it before. That's why the practice.

For this piece the only tool I have that seemed to work at all was a miniature goose neck hollowing tool with an 1/8" tip. Even with the the tool rest right up against the piece, it was terribly "catchy."

I'd be interested to know how you go about undercutting the rim on a bowl or platter. I'm using the tailstock to provide extra support till I get things pretty well cut to thickness, so it interferes with the use of even small bowl or spindle gouges.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: Undercutting the rim

#2

Stewart Hollowing Tool...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The small cutter and swiveling head lets me get in there right where I want to be.

Wally

Re: Undercutting the rim

#3

Re: Undercutting the rim

Bernie

>You can also use a round nose scraper.

After shaping use a lite touch and it actually

leaves a nice finish. This has been working for me.

Bernie

Re: Undercutting the rim

#4

Re:Perfect use for a Hunter tool.

JamieD

>

Re: Undercutting the rim

#5

Re: Undercutting the rim

Ed Heuslein

>Your problem might be the rest is too close to the turning. Back it up so the straight portion (not the curved part) of your goose-neck tool is resting on it. That's the way they are supposed to work - eliminates 99% of the "grabby" problems.

Re: Undercutting the rim

#6

Hunter #5

john lucas

>At least I think that's what it's called. It has a 5/8" bar with a 1/2" Hunter cutter. I've turned a fair number of bowls with under cut rims, both inside and outside. I like this shape. The hunter tool is the best method I've tried so far.

Re: Undercutting the rim

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter #5

Mike Stafford

>The Hunter is exactly what I have been using to undercut the rims on the platters I have been turning.

Re: Undercutting the rim

#8

Re: Hunter #5 is a 5/8" shaft tapered.....

JamieD

>...to a 3/8" cutter John, and you are thinking of the #6 Hunter. I like the #5 for most of my Hunter tool needs.

Re: Undercutting the rim

#9

Your right Jamie- 3/8"

john lucas

>

Re: Undercutting the rim

#10

Re: Undercutting the rim

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Thanks for the responses, guys.

Since I don't have money to spend for new tools, I'll be experimenting some more with what I have.

Gary

Re: Undercutting the rim

#11

Re: Undercutting the rim *LINK*

George Van

>Gary, look at the Josh Hill scraper. I'm sure you have an older unused forged spindle gouge or a firmers gouge laying around to make one of appropriate size to scrape the under cut area. It will take very fine shavings on the inside of a bowl.


http://woodturning.maine-web.com/shapeshifter/scaper.html

Re: Undercutting the rim

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Undercutting the rim

Dick Hines

>I use a hook scraper i got at Woodcraft years ago. I don't know if they stiil sell them but Packard does. I am sure there are a lot of tools out there that will work just as well or better but I will stay with this one until I grind it away.

Re: Undercutting the rim

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Undercutting the rim

Mike Stafford

>Gary, I fully understand the shortage of money. Before I had the Hunter tools I used a hook nosed scraper to do my undercutting. I will attach a picture but I am sure you know what I am talking about.

I saw a picture of one in a catalog and used a 3/4" square scraper as the tool blank and with my 4" mini-grinder and my 8" grinder shaped it. It worked really well except for the tear out problems under the rims of my boxes. It did not seem to matter how sharp it was I still had tear out so I determined it was the angle of presentation.

Maybe you can make one like this...


img

Re: Undercutting the rim

#14

Re: Undercutting the rim

Joe Herrmann

>I have a tool like this that I didn't use much because it was so grabby. I took a hand-on with Cindy Drozda and she used a similar tool but it was ground as a negative rake scraper. I reground mine that way and I was amazed how much better it performed. It cut clean and was no longer grabby.

Joe

Re: Undercutting the rim

#15

Re: Undercutting the rim

John Lucas

>I agree with Joe although I have not tried it as a negative rake scraper. I used my tilted in sort of a shear scraping angle which I suppose is sort of a negative rake. I eventually gave that scraper away after I discovered the Hunter tools.

The dangerous part of cutting and undercut is what I call the deep part. If you look at it like a cove and you start the cut and go toward the bottom (it might be upside down on a bowl rim) and then stop. Then approach the cut from the other high side and go to the bottom you will get far fewer catches. These tools want to catch when the nose of the tool goes across what I call the bottom of the cove. By going from both directions, no matter which tool you use you will reduce the tendency for it to grab.

Re: Undercutting the rim

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: Undercutting the rim

Mike Stafford

>I did not experience any grabbiness but subsequently have ground a negative rake on it after seeing Cindy's video. It does seem to work better. I haven't used it in a while.

I have my Hunter swan necks as replacements.

Re: Undercutting the rim

#17

Re: Undercutting the rim

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Thanks George,

I don't have a suitable chisel, but I'll keep my eye out for one.

Gary

Re: Undercutting the rim

#18

Re: Undercutting the rim

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Thanks Mike,

I can see how that would work and I think it would be much more controllable than the little hollowing tool I'm using now. I am pretty sure I have an extra scraper I could use to make one of those.

Gary

Re: Undercutting the rim

#19

Re: Undercutting the rim

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Joe,

Can you explain how to get that negative rake grind?

Thanks,

Gary

Re: Undercutting the rim

#20

Re: Undercutting the rim

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Thanks, John,

That sounds like good advice. I'll try to be aware of going both directions.

Gary

Re: Undercutting the rim

#21

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Undercutting the rim *LINK*

Katherine Kowalski

>I've taken classes with Cindy Drozda as well, and negative rake scrapers are the only scrapers I'll use. (Not grabby in the least and give a very nice finish).

To give your scraper a negative rake, grind a 5' bevel on the TOP of the tool at the cutting edge. You can do this freehand on the grinding wheel.

Makes a world of difference.

(The link below is to Cindy Drozda's web page -- she's got links on the left for sharpening tools.)


Cindy Drozda's Sharpening Instructions

Re: Undercutting the rim

#22

Re: Undercutting the rim

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Thank you, Katherine,

That is a very useful link.

Gary

Re: Undercutting the rim

#23

I use a bowl gouge

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Hi Gary,

I use that feature frequently, all you need is your bowl gouge, nice and sharp. If you can stand in the other side of your lathe it makes it easier, but is not really necessary.

The example is a big bowl, but I use in all size bowls

Take care

Jorge


img

Re: Undercutting the rim

#24

And another

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>This two were the first I found, but sometimes I go a lot deeper under the rim.

Do you recognize that wood? I got the blank from you...

Take care

Jorge


img

Re: Undercutting the rim

#25

Re: And another

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Thanks Jorge,

I'd know that piece of wood anywhere. 8^]

I was trying to use my bowl gouge for my little practice piece, but I still have the tailstock in place and it just wasn't working out.

Gary