Would it, and similar ceramic art, occupy a lot of space in an "American Potter" magazine? Or should there be a new magazine called "Ceramic Art"?
BTW I couldn't help imagining all of Jennifer's artistic creations as possibly being made out of bleached wood. I'm sure many pieces like hers have been posted here on this Turner's site as well as on others.
>Hi Jack, The reason I posted this is to perhaps give some people a glimpse of what's going on in other fields, and the "problems" we're having are not unique to us. There are various diciplines in ceramics; molded, hand-built, wheel thrown,etc. Yet they all fit into the same category: ceramics. Are there some who feel "pure form" is the only relevant venue? I'm sure. But, overall, creativity is rewarded.
A major difference between wood and ceramics is that many potters study their craft for years, an MBA is common. It is their art, craft, source of income, it is their life. You cannot compare their approach to their work, their outlook, or attitude to a hobbist turner.
I've been around craft for a long time, having lived and worked in two craft communities,(when I was single) worked in several woodworking shops, and have many craftspeople friends. Frankly, I've seldom encountered the "Pure" attitude that some turners seem to insist upon. Most people I hang out with are pushing the very limits of what they can create.
>I carve and embellish as much as many people, but I still view my work as rooted in woodturning. Woodturning is a craft which can be transformed into art through study and practice like ceramics. It is a specialized field in which the lathe is prominently featured.
I hold no grudges against other wooden art forms, but I simply can't understand how some folks are representing pieces as "turned" when they spent 5 minutes on the lathe? I wouldn't refer to a Windsor chair as a turned object, even though it contains a lot more turning than some of the carved items that are represented these days. Some of my favorite turners probably spend half of their time at the lathe, and the other half in some other process.
If something is a carving, why not call it a carving? I think the answer lies in the marketing. Turning, simply put, sells better. Folks are jumping on the bandwagon becuase we've got a better marketing organization than carvers do. I don't blame them for it- but my momma didn't raise no dummy!
I'm just sayng that a lot of wood art today has very little to do with woodturning. Just calling a spade, a spade.
>steve I think you kind of nailed it. When you start as a turner and the lathe is still an important part of each piece. All of your contacts both sales and friends come from the turning background and marketing venues. It only makes sense to stick to that.
Kieth brings up an interesting problems when discussing the other arts. Ceramics for example may start on the wheel, or it might start flat or simply rolling "snakes" if your familiar with the farside cartoon. Glass can be blown (which is very loosely a lathe) but it can also be fused, slumped, just plain melted or simply glued together.
These groups don't limit themselves to strickly blown, or strictly wheel thrown. They look at the medium as art.
We as turners have chosen to seperate ourselves from other woodworking and that's where the confusion steps in. The furniture society on the other hand allows things made from stone, chain, metal, plastic etc. So I guess it really is up to the particular competition or venue as to what is allowed or not and there will always be those who want don't want to accept people who go outside the box.
>It's about the purity of the passion the artist has put into the piece. Why do we have to categorize everything? If I like a piece, I'm going to purchase it, whether its turned, panted, carved or whatever. I do a lot of art shows. I have many times had people, and fellow artists as well, walk into my booth and exclaim they can feel the passion in my work. That statement alone is almost as good as a sale.
So who cares if it's purely turned? Why should it matter? If it touches your heart, it's special. Lets just categorize our stuff as wood...Hmmm?