>If you ask a purist, the answer is probably "ALL done on the lathe" and perhaps "If the cross sections ain't ROUND - it ain't a turning.". The slightly less conservative might allow for multi-axis and eccentric work.
Then there's the Fluting, Piercing, Texturing and Coloring pieces - maybe even some of the Carving pieces. If you can see that the basic form of the piece was turned - then it's still a turning. Even the Slice and Dice and Rearrange pieces that start with a turning are still predominately turned pieces - though some mental gymnastics may be required to recognize that.
But let's take Andi Wolfe's recent pieces that are carved paper thin. They could just as well been carved completely - no turning involved at all. If sculpting is removing everything that IS NOT what you want, or keep adding until you have what you want - in the former case, turning is sculpting, though usually very symetric sculpting - normally on a single axis.
Since most of what we turn isn't actually functional (OK so pens and maybe lidded boxes and ring stands are) are we actually sculptors who happen to use a lathe? Or - does it matter what we call ourselves?
>I like to hang around turners and I turn a lot. Most things start or end on the lathe. However I really think I'm a wood sculpture because I will make what is in my mind and if requires work off the lathe or possibly no lathe at all, then I will create that piece. I think we limit ourselves by saying everything must be turned.
I think it is good practice to limit yourself for learning purposes. Lets say you decide to do nothing but boxes. By limiting yourself to just boxes you have to really think and look inside yourself to produce boxes that are outstanding in both form and design. After you produce 100 or so you will start to see the really fine details that take that simple box to another level.
I suppose a lot of it depends on what you are trying to achieve. Do you want to impress other turners or do you want to create something from within. That is something you have to decide for yourself.
>Charlie This is a question that has been asked almost as long as the history of turning began. Me when people come to my gallery and they comment on the aray of works the the first thing I say is Woodturning is a crude word for what I am doing . So if I can I will call it Wood art as when you mention Woodturning people through generations have and still do conceive it as Utility items.
Plus I have to justify the prices I charge some how l.o.l
>I think John Lucas nailed it on the head in several aspects. If you're making "art", you're making "wood art" and the tools or techniques are not important as the final product. There are several that call themselves a "woodturner" who I'd call them "wood artists". When I think of this category, I think of some of Andi Wolfe's highly carved pieces, among others where a lathe is a " tool for prep". Trying to list them under the limits of a "woodturner" doesn't apply. They are some that are true "woodturning artisans/artists" that merely use a lathe and its ability to make art. First one who comes to mind is Mike Stafford, a true box making artisan woodturner. Then there's a large group that have a compromise between the two areas, like John Jordan, etc. who's work is carved and enhance but still quite obviously turned. Which could, in my view, be in either category. It's easier to go by "wood art" which can be anything, completely turned or barely turned. Woodturning is a huge area in the category of "Wood Art". I see it as wood art, and woodturning is a subdivision, just like carving or unlimited sculptures.
As you can see there's a lot of "gray" area here. That's the point I'm making. Art is about the maker and their audience. Art shouldn't be defined, it's limitless. Art shouldn't be put into a box, it's never ending. Art is art. Art is what the maker want's to call it.
My background is cabinetry and furniture. The best thing about turning and carving, in my opinion, is that it's not so easily defined or boxed up as cabinetry or furniture building. They have several guidelines and definitions that define or at least help to define different areas of the trades. Woodturning and carving doesn't have those. Keep it that way.
On the subject of "impressing turners." I've posted several piece of work on here and on WOW. The pieces that have the most constructive critiques have been the pieces sold in galleries first, hands down. Woodturners/artists don't usually buy turnings/wood art. I've made hundreds of door stops. The one profile that is my least favorite has out sold all of my favorites by a land slide. Just keep that in mind when pieces are being critiqued.
>Potters make things out of clay- they don't need to use a wheel to make their work. The term potter is analogous to woodworker. Woodturning is a subcategory where the lathe is the principle tool used in the process.
I suspect that my "rule" from turning to wood art is if every element of form and surface obtained on the lathe has been removed and replaced by a mark from some other tool, you are looking at wood art. When the lathe is "just a roughout tool"...odds are that the artists doesn't view it as a turning anymore either.
>There was a Walnut box and a smaller pop top ambrosia maple box. They were the least favorite of the boxes from critiques and the fastest to sell at the gallery. The favorites of turners are still there, a round bottomed Elm bowl is still at the gallery and the box elder box with a chattered redheart inlay on the lid has become "the box style" that I make for turner friends as gifts. I've never sold a single one of either of those two styles.
The door stops; there's a profile with a rather large bead by the pommel, then a "V" bead, then a matching larger bead. It's my least favorite and best seller by a long shot. The lower portion of my home page has a picture of a variety of door stops that includes two of this style among the ones I like.
>I will not be drawn into this discussion as I have very definite opinions about what is woodturning and what is not.
However I am intriged by what Greg said about what "turners" thought was a great box and what actually sold. I have long ago given up on making determinations what my customers like based upon what I like. By placing a variety of styles on display and seeing what is sold this time, next time and the next time I have learned what customers want. That is predominantly what I give them.
I have sold a number of boxes with chatterwork inserts in the lid but that style is not my best selling. I have never been able to sell a box turned from bocote regardless of the form in which it was turned so I give them as gifts and I no longer buy bocote box stock. I happen to like bocote but evidently no one else does.
If I place the four best selling styles of boxes I turn in front of a new customer they almost invariably handle one particular style the most. Even though they might buy a different style, had I offered all the boxes in the same timber I feel certain they would have chosen the style they handled first and the most.
And interestingly enough that box style is the one most frequently commented upon by women on this and other forums. I have learned to learn from my customers and women buy more of my boxes than anyone else.
So whether it is art or craft matters not as long as the customer is happy and the maker is happy.
>Personally, I consider myself a complete woodworker. Why on earth would I limit myself to working on just one machine, or using only part of my abilities. If someone is content to work as a "pure" turner, that's perfectly fine. However, I resent anyone's attempt to impose their own "self-imposed limitations" on me.
In the most traditional sense the lathe was always considered just another tool, usually employed to make component parts, not completed pieces from beginning to end.
>Here is a shot of my latest project. Obviously, some turning is involved, and this piece is something a novice turner probably shouldn't attempt. The raised area about 8" in diameter is where a glue-block disc will be added in order to perform operations on the reverse side. Yet, when I'm finished, it will have been burnt, painted, goldleafed, and highly carved, and the amount of turning involved will not be obvious to the casual observer. I don't consider this piece a turning, nor do I consider it a carving. I simply consider the things I make as "my work". Work I've poured something of myself into, and something that forces me at once to rely on all of my skills, and to believe I can accomplish something I've only seen in my imagination. This piece is part of a natural progression that has been inspired by previous pieces, and I expect this piece will be the basis for subsequent work. In turning, as in life, innovation is often rewarded. A magazine editor who has seen previous pieces of my work asked me to photograph a piece as it progresses for an article about my work. When completed, this piece will be be part of a major exhibition as well. Would I be better served by sticking to "Pure" turning?
>I'm reminded of the latter years of the last century (sounds far away, doesn't it?) when digital photography began to "encroach" on film and darkroom photography. Little by little the film camera magazines and the darkroom magazines started inserting a digital article or two or maybe a software or digital camera review. Totally innocuous at the time, but noticeable to a purist like me.
Pretty soon my beloved darkroom magazine began surrendering more space to digital. (They knew where the advertising dollars were.) And the letters to the editor started protesting it. And the magazine and its digital progressives got defensive.
Long story short, the magazine eventually changed its name, a few times I think, to a more 'umbrella-like' name that encompassed ALL 'photographic art'. The word "darkroom" was removed, never to return.
When I first saw computer manipulated images, I cringed. 'That's not REAL photography.' A computer can overlook the highest skills of photography. Instead of moving your camera to avoid a distracting foreground or background object, you merely erase it on the computer...after the fact. And...the unholiest of all...you could now manipulate a photograph to look like a watercolor, or even a total abstract. Why, you could even make a collage of photos that eliminated the reality of the moment. (We've seen it in doctored journalism photos, haven't we?)
I remember last year when my cousin entered a photo contest and digitally added a full moon into his photo. It was spectacular!! But when a losing contestant found out it was manipulated, he squawked...
...and somehow I understood.
I see the same phenomenon that I saw in photography happening in woodturning...and I find myself reacting in the same way. We're evolving from woodTURNING into woodART. My prediction is that "American WoodTURNER" will have it's name evolve into a more umbrella title within the next three or four years.
Many woodturning purists are expressing the thoughts I had when my darkroom world started changing into digital. It first started as an embellishment to woodturning...a little bit of color...some woodburning, kind of like adding a full moon to a photo or cloning out the distracting telephone wires. Then it evolved into producing a 'turning' that an average viewer would never realize was turned. It was more like an abstract collage of photographic images.
And the purists object...and continue to do so...
...and I somehow understand.
Whether it's a two-dimensional image or a three-dimentional object, woodTURNERS are in transition. Is it more camera or computer? Is it more lathe or other tool?
Maybe Woodcentral should consider adding another category to its groups: woodART. That way flat-workers, round-workers, wood-sculptors, wood-carvers, wood-burners, etc. would have a forum to focus on their specific interests and skills. If flat-workers and round-workers want to diversify and embellish their work to the point that it does NOT say 'basic + embellishment' but instead says 'sculpted', then why not give them their own niche and give others their more purist pursuit.
Personally, I see people (like Art Leistman, Terry Scott, Michael Hosaluk, John Jordan, et al.), as extremely creative TURNERS. Others I see as VERY ACCOMPLISHED and very creative CARVERS, PIERCERS and PAINTERS. I REALLY REALLY do accept and appreciate their art. Most of it is absolutely extraordinary!
BUT...
...somehow I see a distinct line between turning, recognized as turning, and carving, recognized as carving. I am currently a turner who is interested in ADDING some carving, burning and coloring to embellish my turnings. If I get to the point that I am REALLY into carving, I would rather be called a 'carver'. Otherwise I would prefer to call myself a 'turner' who is striving for 'turned' art.
This is where I am. I LOVE wood art...and I LOVE artistic turnings. But right now I strive to be an artistic woodTURNER. Who knows? That may change. I may love carving so much that it eventually becomes my identified area.
BTW, I now only shoot digital, and haven't developed a negative in 5 years...but if I had the opportunity to do it again, would love the opportunity.
>Old habits die hard. The costal watchers are still being paid for looking across the Channel for the German invasion fleet because nobody told them to go home, the war is over. And the US Government still has an office that writes specs for spruce lumber for aircraft construction because nobody told them that airplanes were no longer made from wood.
>I thought the exact same thing when Digital started up. My Hasselblad gave an image quality that could not be matched by a 1MP camera at any size, but the transformation occured anyway. I didn't realize that the driver would be the millions of folks who take snapshot, and not the few elite folks running their own darkroom.
I think the analogy you used is interesting, because in the driver in the woodturning world is still TBD. Will it be the masses buying the equipment and working in their garages? Or the Studio Artist pushing Wood Art? Time will tell.
I also miss the darkroom, and I occasionally "just turn" because I enjoy the simple process of creation...
>Everything I turn in cocobolo sells almost instantly. But bocote boxes are not sellers here. I don't think that this wood is appealing to women.
Who buys most of your bocote items? Men or women....?
I do recall, now that my wife reminds me, that I have sold small decorative flatwork bocote boxes. She says bocote is too masculine for women to find it attractive....Don't ask me....I just live here.
>print photo manipulation? In the dark room we would crop, highlight, shade and in many ways touch up and change prints. Photo Shop just takes it a few steps further.
>HI Jack, Good analogy. I have a bit different take on things however. Back in the late 70's, woodturning was dead, or nearly so. Woodturning was no longer taught at the high school level, it had become irrelevant many years previously. Schools auctioned off their wood and metal shop equipment. Try to think of a lathe-related innovation to spring from that era.
I believe turners like John Jordan and David Ellsworth can be thought of as starting the "digital revolution" of woodturning. After all, their hollowforms were not created as functional items, but rather as collectible items comparable to items created in other, more established fields. The formation of the AAW, I feel, allowed these pioneers to communicate with each other, who had previously been unaware that others had the very same interests as they did.
Until rather recently there was virtually no such thing as "pure" turning. In the past, lathes were used to produce furniture components, architectural items, and utility items. The lathe has always been looked upon as just another tool, designed to fulfill a specific purpose. Professional woodturners stood anonymously at their lathes, paid by the piece, or by the hour to perform a dead-end job. Who can name just one famous woodturner from the 17th or 18th, or early 19th century? BTW, those big, collectible antique burl bowls were usually carved, not turned.
Don't believe it? How many windsor chairs will we see in Hartford at the AAW symposium? Ballusters? Utility items? Tables with turned legs? Not many...but you will see an unbelievable explosion of wood turning/art items like the world has never previously seen. And, yes, a well turned bowl rises to the level of art.
I think the turning renaissance that we are experiencing is about raising the craft of turning to the level of an art form, and was so from the very beginning. THAT, I believe, is what's driving the explosion of wood turning...the ability of people to create and express oneself through the work of their own hands, without limitations. That, in turn, is what's driving the revolution of new woodturning tools and equipment. In sharp contrast to yesterday's turners, today's top turners are superstars; writing books, filming DVDs, and travelling the world.
>Jumping in a bit late, but just found this today.
My take? Too much anxiety out there about the "purity" of wood turning. For me, the lathe is a wonderful tool. I enjoy turning wood, but brown and round just doesn't completely fulfill my needs as a "maker." I enjoy working with wood and it's all about the journey of discovery that is fun for me. I'll use whatever tools and techniques are needed to make my art.
If I am an artist and my medium is wood, I am free to use any tools or methods or materials I want to make my art.
Does it make sense to call an alabaster vessel a woodturning?
Does it make sense to call something that was "roughed out" on the lathe a woodturning?
If I make something with turned components, is it a woodturning? A chair? A chess set? A heavily carve form that only spent a few minutes on a lathe?
If I paint it, does it become a painting?
There is some intangible line in space when something transforms from being a woodturning to something else. I don't know who decides where the line is drawn, but at some point, I think all of our woodturning aspires to be something else.
Re: But they define it as something other than a *LINK*
Keith Tompkins
>We, if we are serious as woodturners, may want to pay attention to what's happening in other fields. I have enclosed a link to Jennifer McCurdy's work, just as one example. I became aware of her work both through my brother; she frequently stays at his bed-and-breakfast in PA.; and through someone who collects my work.
I can't help but wonder...does her work qualify as "pottery" or "ceramic art"? She has risen to the top in a field far more crowded, and far more mature than ours.
Do what's in your heart. That's all that matters. If you become successful at it, that's just a bonus.