Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

A question about shop safety

Posts

A question about shop safety

#1

Steven Antonucci

A question about shop safety

steve antonucci

>Not trying to single anyone out, but Ed's tag line "respect the bandsaw" got me thinking. If I was going to adjust it in any way, I'd say "Respect anything with a sharp edge and a motor".

This got me to thinking. We all know the value of taking lessons about how to turn. Whenever I teach a beginner, I stress all the usual stuff. However, I can't recall a single thread or conversation about bandsaw lessons, tablesaw lessons, router lessons?

I see a lot of gruesome injuries on the various sites from folks not having the proper education on how to work in a shop safely. Why is there a perception that one tool is more dangerous than another? Why aren't there tons of instructional courses in how to not cut your fingers off with a saw? Why do "flat" courses usually start with the assumption that the students know how to use the tablesaw/bandsaw correctly?

After seeing some folks stand at a lathe, I don't think I'd ever let them touch anything else in my shop...

Thoughts?

Steve

Re: A question about shop safety

#2

Re: A question about shop safety

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I thin it all depends on what tool got who, as for what is considered the most dangerous. When people ask me what the most dangerous tool in my shop is, I reply, "the utility knife", since that is what slipped one day and earned me a trip to the doctor and six stitches. But they are all dangerous. And as soon as someone stops thinking that, he or she is on the path to serious injury.

Just as a side note on your other post, it does not matter if a person is famous, highly skilled, or both. Poor safety practice is just living on the ragged edge of disaster.

Re: A question about shop safety

#3

Re: A question about shop safety

robo hippy

>The most dangerous thing in the shop is the person using the tools. I do make sure to point out as many dangers as I can, but using an old quote, "If you do succeed in making some thing that is idiot proof, some one will invent a better idiot." No matter how hard you try, people will make mistakes. This is why there are release waivers, and warnings on all DVDs. I do include in my bowl turning demos a section on things that make your bowls explode. From all my years of turning, there are some things I 'just know', and some times forget that others don't know or understand from the view point of experience. Teaching some one from the 'this is a wood lathe' level is more difficult that mentoring some one who has turning experience, and you are just pointing out some technique things to.

robo hippy

Re: A question about shop safety

#4

Steven Antonucci

Agreed.

steve antonucci

>never touched a spinning blade, minor nicks from carelessness with hand tools.

Just because Sam can do it, doesn't mean I could (or even more importantly- that I should even try it!)

CA glue in the eye is the worst I've ever gotten, and would have been completely avoided if I had a face shield on or had waited for the glue to properly cure. I don't use it anymore, but for other reasons.

S

Re: A question about shop safety

#5

JL

Re: A question about shop safety

JL

>Some instructors take the time to teach shop safety. Many assume that the students already know about shop safety.

Some instructors won't let anyone use the band saw except for themselves (I've seen this at JCCFS). Other instructors will let you use anything after showing you the proper way.

Sharp tools are dangerous. Sleds (band saw, table saw, router or whatever) are a nice thing to use/have - so are other safety devices such as push sticks and the like.

I don't know if there is a correct answer. Many people get "offended" if you mention safety. Hey - I'd rather listen to a five minute lecture or whatever and walk away intact. Beats the heck out of a trip to the ER.

Re: A question about shop safety

#6

Re: A question about shop safety

Scott in Falcon, CO

>I teach the woodworking merit badge for Boy Scouts (ages 12 - 18). Any time I have a young man in my shop for the first time, we make a circuit of all the tools and discuss their use and their safety precautions. I always ask what tool they think is the most dangerous in my shop and, almost always, the answer is the table saw. I agree with them that the table saw can be dangerous and then explain that a surgeon might have a chance of reattaching something cut off on the table saw but (pointing at the jointer) there are some tools that won't leave enough to try. This usually puts them in the frame of mind that they are willing to listen to my instructions for the rest of the time they are with me.

I tend to think of the lathe as one of the safer tools in my shop and every time I think this, I remember that a good portion of accidents that happen are to experienced woodworkers that get too lax around their machines.

You can never be too safe.

Scott

Re: A question about shop safety

#7

Re: A question about shop safety

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>At the Louisville AAW symposium, one of the demos was done by a medical doctor on shop safety and pictures of actual accidents. He was very graphic. I believe that similar demos should be at ALL major symposiums and be MANDATORY attendance. The session that I attended had about 1/4 the attendance of other demos.

As a partial foot amputee, I know how a few missing parts can affect your total outlook on life: job, bank account, ability to walk or stand, length of life, ability to travel, ability to turn, ability to swim, ability to drive, cost of insurance, what motor vehicle that you own, etc.

Have you ever said, "We can't go there anymore, I can't get into the building?" Do you unplug tools while you make adjustments? Can you accidently hit the on-switch while you tighten the blade?

Bill in WET WNC mountains

3" yeaterday

Re: A question about shop safety

#8

If you had been watching me as ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>I was using the bandsaw you would have thought that I would not have gotten cut. Even if I become the poster boy for dumb mistakes, if my tag line makes my WC friends, or even semi-friends, give pause, think, and avoid a bad injury, then it is worth it to me.

Carole Valentine posted a while back that every time she turns the bandsaw on now she thinks of me. I made a few of the obvious jokes, but privately I went "YES!" and I was pleased that Carole had been sensitized to safety considerations, even if it was at my "expense".

I'm sure that more than a few have muttered under their breath when they see "Respect the bandsaw", but I hope that even the mutterers don't get hurt. And I secretly hope that the tag line ran through their minds and made them think. ;^D

Respect the bandsaw, anyway,

Ed

Re: A question about shop safety

#9

Steven Antonucci

Not the major point of my original post

steve antonucci

>My original post wasn't meant to single you out, but more ask the question "why is turning safety something we teach to beginners, but other equipment just assumes that everyone gets it?"

We hear about how most turning instructors cover some elements of safety in their courses, but I don't think I've ever seen an article on tablesaw/bandsaw/other flatwood tool safety? Often, turning classes don't let students use other equipment because turners are somewhat more likely to have a "safety first mindset".

My first thing in one on one instruction is to hand a piece of wood to the student and say "turn something". I watch to see where they stand, if they check the lathe setup (which I always make wrong beforehand), and general lathe procedures. I usually stop them before they turn on the lathe because I have a good sense for where they are just from that.

I suspect that there is a similar checklist for every piece of equipment in the shop, and a similar set of rules to live by, but I never hear anything about it.

Respect EVERYTHING in the shop, not just the bandsaw.

Steve

Re: A question about shop safety

#10

Turning wearing gloves

John Cotten

>On the topic of safety, when did it become acceptable to turn wearing gloves. I have seen three men two after the fact and one when it happened loose the skin OFF of the bone on a finger when the glove material got caught in a lathe. Nothing even remotely pretty about that one.

I have people say "The shaving hurt my hands" I say toughen up. Yes I have had my hand slapped several times with bark, stringing wood, and just shavings coming off at high speed. A glove will eventually get you when you are wearing it around a spinning piece of machinery.

Re: A question about shop safety

#11

I understand.

Ed Moore in SW VA

>Steve, I understood the gist of your message and I support it.

You began with a reference to me/my mishap as if in apology. My point was "Bring it on. Think about how many safety posts there have been because of my mistake. No apology is necessary." We might as well make lemonade out of the lemon.

The rest of my message was to say a kind word to those who think less of me for what they consider to be a trite phrase.

Of course we should respect all our machinery. But the bandsaw seems safer than all the others and we let our guards down a little. We forget that every butcher shop has a bandsaw.

With all due respect,

Ed

Re: A question about shop safety

#12

Steven Antonucci

We actually discussed this last night

steve antonucci

>At my club meeting. I think you can wear a glove with no risk, but only if you truly are competent at a lathe. I wear one on my left hand, which NEVER goes past the tool rest because of the way that I cut. In my situation, it is impossible for the glove to get caught.

I am far more cognizant of long sleeve shirts and sweatshirts with draw string hoods. Neither one belongs at a lathe.

Steve

Re: A question about shop safety

#13

Steven Antonucci

Add an underhand grip at the lathe to my "no-no"

steve antonucci

>New turners are also often shown to hold their tools with an underhand grip for finger tip control. I never teach this grip to a new turner.

I know a few new turners that have learned about Newtonian Physics the hard way. A catch with the underhand grip will drive the tool into the tool rest. Every action has an equal and opposite reaction- the tool rest then pushes the tool upward. Since you are gripping under the tool, it comes out of your control hand and hits you in the face. Sometimes, the shield 9we all wear them, right?) stops it. Sometimes, you get stitches...

I've seen it happen three times, and that's enough data for me to put it on the "Unsafe at any speed" list...

Steve

Re: A question about shop safety

#14

JL

Re: Turning wearing gloves

JL

>I don't turn wearing gloves. I do finish wearing gloves though. I carefully back the tool rest out of the way first.

I usually burnish with shavings bare handed though.

Re: A question about shop safety

#15

Re: A question about shop safety

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I've had a few people get offended by safety discussions, but if they don't like it, that's tough. They can leave. Most people are good about it, and I get a lot of very positive feedback wherever I go because of my attitude towards working safely.

I am a certified NRA instructor as well as a woodturning teacher. You want to talk about safety procedures!?! Even - especially - the most experienced people are all about safety procedures. It is one thing to get nicked by a power tool. It is quite another to get shot.

Re: A question about shop safety

#16

Re: Not the major point of my original post

wilbur

>Popular Woodworking did a several issue series on safety in the shop. Safety articles show up on a regular basis in Fine Woodworking. Of course, these two magazines aren't ones that turners read very often, I would guess. :@)

As far as safety in flatwork woodworking classes goes, my experience is that it depends on the class. Beginner level classes seem to always cover safety issues. More advanced classes probably assume that you know about shop safety, just like they assume that you have some idea how to do a glue up.

I think that one other issue is that with turning, a beginner can really get into trouble fast if they don't know basic safety principles, much more so than working with a bandsaw or other piece of machinery. Not that a table saw is inherently safer, but more so that the learning curve for woodturning from a safety standpoint is steeper. For a table saw, it's probably clear that you shouldn't get your fingers too close to the spinning thing with the teeth. It's probably not as intuitive that you should only put the sandpaper on the lower part of the workpiece facing you, or that it's not a good idea to have the gouge contact the workpiece below the center line.

Re: A question about shop safety

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: A question about shop safety

Keith Tompkins

>Steve, I think the fact that nobody stresses shop safety is because many turner's only exposure to woodworking is through the lathe. They consider themselves TURNERS, not WOODWORKERS. Their experience on major woodworking tools is limited. I have spent many years in an industrial woodworking setting, and have worked in positions from shop foreman to shop owner. I have been responsible for training new employees, and for establishing shop safety procedures. In that setting, safety is crucial. An employee who doesn't pay attention to safety rules gets fired, hopefully before he hurts himself. A typical hobbyist would be completely lost in such a setting. Currently, I am employed as an Industrial Training Supervisor for the State of New York. I train inmates in a Max Security setting to operate woodworking equipment in an industrial setting, then put them to work in actual woodworking factories. This is a rigorous program which must adhere to all NYS and OSHA laws, and I must take constant training to keep up with the newest laws and proper operation of the latest equipment. I am often appalled when I visit a friend's shop, or watch a new student. I won't let anybody use the bandsaw at the school where I teach unless I know them and their ability. Statistically speaking, the table saw is involved on over 90 percent of all woodworking accidents.

Re: A question about shop safety

#18

I have posted this before......

Barry Irby

>But it bears repeating.

I know of lots of people that have been hurt by many of the tools in the shop, but I only know of two that were killed and they were killed by the lathe. Or, At least they were using the lathe when they were killed. It's been a long time, but as I recall one of them was spindle turning a really crappy piece of wood and cut away the part that was holding it together at one end and a slab of it clubbed him to death.

The other one was using the under hand grip and the chisel snapped his head back so hard it broke his neck.

Statistics indicate the table saw is the most dangerous power tool in the shop. But that could be that there are more table saws out there than most other tools.

In the line of injuries not in the shop I knew an old man who was building a house and cut himself badly in the thigh with a skill saw. He was on the second floor, alone and apparently could not climb down. Lead to death.

And of course there have been plenty of chainsaw accidents.

The Shop Teacher at my high school was showing them what not to do with the jointer and jointed the tip off his pinky. I bet all those students passed "Safety".

I know I could use some training and reminding. One night, I saw my hand reach out to stop the table saw blade. Apparently I was about to pinch it on the sides. Fortunately, I caught myself, but I was so stunned at the near accident, I left the shop.

Re: A question about shop safety

#19

Seven Stitches, Two Weeks Ago

Charlie Anderson

>But not me!

I was in a workshop two weeks ago when one of the guys (who sometimes posts here) got a catch, the gouge came back up and got his finger.

Re: A question about shop safety

#20

Re: Turning wearing gloves

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud,Fla

>I strogly believe that no rings, watches, gloves, or long sleeves should ever be warn near operating equipment. I have seen first hand some pretty gruesome results of people doing so. There is a picture on a website showing what remains of a man who wore long sleeves while working on a lathe. I will send link to anyone who would like to see some real gory stuff.

Re: A question about shop safety

#21

Re: A question about shop safety

wilbur

>Of course, if something comes off of a workpiece turning at high speed and hits you, that's pretty close to being shot.

Re: A question about shop safety

#22

Please email the pic to me Ken.

John Cotten

>I am about to start teaching some wood turning again, and would like to have a photo like that to show.

Thanks

John

Re: A question about shop safety

#23

Steve Kubien

I took a small class with...

Steve Kubien

>...Lyle Jamieson, what almost 2 years ago. There were 4 or 5 of us. Lyle's rule was simple: You will wear a face shield. No debate. No discussion. Just reality. If someone didn't want to wear one, they were asked to leave because they were not going to be doing any turning, no matter how much they paid.

It was a no-brainer for some of us but it still reinforced the safety aspect.

I know Bill G. is a safety minded fellow. I had the pleasure of attending the Robust christening a while back and he too made everyone who was turning wear a shield. Those of us that he had never met before, well he was right by my shoulder watching every move I made, hoping I didn't do anything stupid (he didn't stop me so I must've been ok).

I have long considerd some finger-less padded gloves due to my carpal tunnel syndrome, really form fitting ones. Every time I see them at the store I think about it and a little voice pops into my head and leave them at the store. Maybe there is someone watching over me.

Good topic Steve!

Re: A question about shop safety

#24

Re: Turning wearing gloves

Carole Valentine

>Ken, why not just post the link (with a warning about very graphic content) rather than hassle with emailing it? I have not decided if I really want to see it or not, but maybe I need to so I will remember to remove my rings and watch when I go in the shop. :(

Re: A question about shop safety

#25

Re: Turning wearing gloves *LINK*

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud,Fla

>http://ehowa.com/features/longsleevedlathing.shtml-This is extremely gruesome so be forewarned.


http://ehowa.com/features/longsleevedlathing.shtml