Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

bandsaw safety

Posts

bandsaw safety

#1

Keith Tompkins

bandsaw safety

Keith Tompkins

>Ed Moore's comments concerning "respect the bandsaw" got me thinking. Accidents can happen to ANYONE; statistics show two major categories of operators are usually involved in accidents: beginners, and the very experienced. Some of the worst accidents happen to the most experienced; it's easy to become so comfortable with a machine that we don't always think safety. Sometimes we are in a hurry, or are tired, or just plain distracted. The images shows the bandsaw method I employ both at work and when I teach. The first image shows my starting position, and wood grain orientation. The cut is easier to start when crosscutting. Once the cut has progressed, I move my right hand BEHIND the saw blade, as shown in the second image. If I slip, or the blade exits the blank, my hand will not be in the saw blade's path. This is the technique I use on every bowl blank I saw. Caution must be used when the saw begins to a rip cut...more effort is required, and the blade exiting the wood while ripping is the most dangerous part of cutting bowl blanks....having the right hand behind the blade prevents injuries. I suggest NOT to use circle cutting jigs when cutting blanks...the blade may bow from stress or tracking problems, and exit the wood unexpectedly with unanticipated results. ( the blade may appear to be following a line on top of the blank, yet be cutting outside of the blank further down towards the table).

The bandsaw is useful for many other operations besides cutting blanks. For holding small pieces, a wood hand screw clamp is ideal; fingers are never near the blade. Also, double stick tape will hold a small piece to a larger piece for safety.

Round stock must be held securely from rolling with a shop-built fixture or v-blocks. Freehand cutting is a no-no.

Re: bandsaw safety

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: bandsaw safety 

Keith Tompkins

>


img

Re: bandsaw safety

#3

Re: bandsaw safety

Alan T

>I hear you Keith. But I like using push sticks extensively. I don't want my hands anywhere near the blade. Thanks for the reminder on this very important topic.

Re: bandsaw safety

#4

Re: bandsaw safety

Dan Oliphant

>Well, I must agree with everything you said, and your hand diagram is right on the mark.

Two years ago while cutting out a lot of bowl blanks I got lazy and had my left hand on the front side of the blade, near the end of a cut the blade hit a soft patch and ran. $40K later my ring finger is more or less back in place, although it is not of much value any more.

Your diagram and advise should be followed by anyone using a bandsaw!!!

Re: bandsaw safety

#5

Re: bandsaw safety

Matt Overton

>With a new 18" jet on order, this subject can't be revisited enough. I find that the bandsaw is probably the tool that is easiest to let your guard down while using.

Re: bandsaw safety

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: bandsaw safety

Keith Tompkins

>HI Alan, Push sticks are always a good idea, but I don't know how one would use push sticks on a bowl blank, especially a big one. On smaller items I use push sticks as well.

Re: bandsaw safety

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: bandsaw safety

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Dan, and sorry to hear of your accident. The reason I posted was to hopefully prevent the same thing happening to others..Keith

Re: bandsaw safety

#8

Re: bandsaw safety

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>After many years of woodworking and woodturning, the only visible woodworking scar that I have is on my left thumb, and that came from my bandsaw after it had been turned off. The blade was still running and I got careless. A slow moving BS blade doesn't slice flesh, it tears it. Ow.

Wal;ly

Re: bandsaw safety

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: bandsaw safety

Keith Tompkins

>HI Wally, I've had a few myself...yep, table saw. The automatic ripsaw was out of commission at the shop where I worked when I was a rookie, so I had to rip palet loads of chair leg blanks to feed into the lathe, which formed the tenon, bored holes and turned in one operation. We produced 300 chairs a day. I had spent literally DAYS on the tablesaw when I ran my left hand over the blade. Just plain boredom. Luckily the blade didn't protrude too far past the stock. Couldn't play guitar for two years, I couldn't touch the end of my middle finger. While finishing up a mortise, I put a 3/4" chisel through my left hand starting at the thumb and exiting the padded part of the hand. Big, dumb ow. Not too bad for 38 years of woodworking, mostly in an industrial setting. I've seen too many horrific accidents over that time period. While I believe the bandsaw is one of the safer tools in the workshop, I've observed people operating the saw in a way that scared the hell out of me just watching them. I won't let a student operate the bandsaw at my shop or at the school where I teach, or at work without direct supervision.

Re: bandsaw safety

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: bandsaw safety

Keith Tompkins

>The scariest thing that ever happened to me at work: I was operating a shaper with a three-wing panel-raising cutter head. These things are BIG...about 8 pounds! As I was running a panel through the shaper, the cutter head literally exploded. The cutter hit the cement block wall facing me, putting a huge hole in the wall and cracking it from floor to ceiling. Then, it went through the ajacent machine department, exiting through the exterior wall, doing the same damage to that wall. It didn't hit anyone, luckily, but I never used that shaper again....it scared the living #%^&% out of me. I'm lucky to still be here.

Re: bandsaw safety

#11

Re: bandsaw safety

Carole Valentine

>Shapers, even home workshop types, scare the hell out of me. I won't even be in the same room when one is running. I don't know why. I have never witnessed an accident from one. Maybe it is just the sheer size and mass (and sound!) of those cutters.

Re: bandsaw safety

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: bandsaw safety

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Carole, shapers are certainly intimidating, but indispensible in cabinet shops. We got a new one at work...two spindles, each powered by a 7.5 HP 3 phase motor. It's used mainly to produce parts for raised panel doors.

Re: bandsaw safety

#13

Re: bandsaw safety

john lucas

>What scares me are large bowls. You never know when on will come apart, even when the wood seems solid. Grinders running at 3450 rpm also scare me. I've seen a wheel explode. It happens at incredible speed.

Re: bandsaw safety

#14

Respect the bandsaw

Ed Moore

>I am sure that my sign-off bugs some people, but if I can prevent at least one person from having an accident by using it, then it is worth it.

My hands weren't in line with the blade. I was standing to the left, my left hand was leading and my right hand was following - both hands to the left - and the right hand was applying the force to rip the dry half-log. It was too much force and when the piece broke through it moved to the left, something blocked it, and my right hand was probably still applying force, so the piece pivoted when it was blocked and my hand went into the blade. My accident would not have happened if I had applied less and more reasonable force. That said, I certainly will not position myself that way again. When feasible I use push sticks now. There are times when four-foot push sticks seem reasonable.

Keith, thanks for discussing this and encouraging others to be safe.

Respect all woodworking machinery, and ESPECIALLY THE BANDSAW,

Ed

Re: bandsaw safety

#15

Re: bandsaw safety

James Watriss

>First post over here on the turning board. I spend my days doing hand tool/furniture type stuff.

I'm a relative newcomer... about 5 years into the hobby, counting 2 years at North Bennet, and 3 years spent between 2 woodworking retail stores.

Maybe Keith's point about push sticks works for me, but your response caught me pretty quickly. Most of the accidents I know of came about because the day to day normal operating procedures didn't quite apply, and improvisation seemed 'safe enough.'

The band saw is a remarkably safe tool, but it's still very powerful... which we almost never see, unless things go horribly wrong.

Ditto the drill press... I know one guy who got his hand pulled in, his thumb torn into, and broken, by a big forstner bit, while he was hollowing out a bowl blank. His improvised work holding jig wasn't nearly strong enough to do the job. It takes a really big bit for a drill press to be able to show how powerful it really is, but it's so easy the rest of the time to think it's one of the safest tools in the world, and easy to get used to. BUT, it can turn on you if you're not paying attention.

So... it's worth the second look. 99 times out of 100, you're probably right, and there's a safe way to do it without push sticks. But finding a safer way to do things may be faster and easier than you think.

Re: bandsaw safety

#16

Re: Respect the bandsaw

Barry Irby

>Ed, I agree with you. Respect the Bandsaw. Actually, respect them all. I can't think of a tool, especially a power tool that doesn't have the potential to hurt somebody and I personally know of injuries caused by most of them. Most of the injuries were contributed to by the operator doing something they shouldn't have. Some of them were doing things that seemed rather harmless. Yesterday I was ripping a pine stud and the TS spewed a blast of splinters out of a concealed knot. OK, I should have an over the blade guard. I was wearing safety glasses and got a mild stinging on the face. Could have hurt if it had been in the eye or worse had distracted me into sticking an hand into the blade.

Years ago I was using one of those dado cutters that wobbles on a RAS. Cutting slots for shelves in pine shelving boards. When I finished, I realized one of the teeth was missing. A piece about an inch long and a 1/4" square. Never did know where it went. Never used that thing again. Sometimes you are just lucky.

I have suffered a number of shop injuries over the last 45 years. Never hurt myself on the bandsaw, but my son has. A cut that required four stitches.

So keep reminding us. We should be using proper sharp blades and good technique. Thank you.

Re: bandsaw safety

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Respect the bandsaw

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ed, I reread your post a couple of times to make sure I understand what happened. My first question, Was the blade sharp? Were you using an appropriate ripping blade? Were you using a fence? As I understand, left hand was leading (beyond the blade) right hand feeding. One possible solution would be: with one to two inches left before the cut is completed, switch so both hands are past the blade and PULL the remainder of the cut through. A slip would then be harmless. Last question: How would you do the same operation next time? It's embarassing to admit having an accident, but your post may have saved someone else from the same fate or worse.

Re: bandsaw safety

#18

You have it right

Ed Moore in SW VA

>Keith,

I think you identified it correctly. And I think I was using a fence. The wood was dry magnolia and it did not cut easily. I can't remember whether I switched blades since then or not. It was not cutting as if it was sharp. I am considering upgrading my blades in the future.

You have made a good suggestion. Had I stopped and put my hands on both sides and behind the blade we wouldn't be having this conversation.

I don't mind being the poster boy for having done something stupid. If I can prevent others from making a trip to the ER, then bring it on. ;^) I am sure that some of the AAW Board have enjoyed my discomfort.

Thanks for the suggestion.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: bandsaw safety

#19

Scary grinder moment

Carole Valentine

>Speaking of grinders, the other day I was sharpening a detail gouge (with a Wolverine) and the gas man drove up in the driveway. My dog hates the propane truck and she went into a frenzy. A split second of distraction on my part while grinding and WHAM!!!! Scared the you-know-what out of me! I was very lucky that all I had to replace was the wheel. Gouge was OK...chewed up the side of the Vari-Grind though. That's the second near accident I have had on the grinder. The first was a spindle roughing gouge. Some SRGs come from the factory ground at what I now consider a dangerous angle, but I didn't know any better then. My roughing gouges are ground at an angle now that they don't get anywhere near the center of the wheel.

Respect the grinder!

Ya like that one, Ed? LOL

Re: bandsaw safety

#20

Re: Scary grinder moment

Carol Reed - home in Strawberry

>Glad you survived!

I am thinking about changing from my high speed grinder (gotta use what I have) to a belt sander. Much wider. Multiple grits available. Slower and much cooler cutting. I've noticed that several very talented turners use this method as well. Not that that will make me a better tuner, but perhaps a more confident sharpener.

I also have wanted a small disk sander in the turning shop and Grizzly has a combo 6" disk and 2" belt sander available. Might be my Christmas gift to myself.

Re: bandsaw safety

#21

Respect the grinder

Ed Moore in SW VA

>Carole,

I am simply glad that you were not hurt. Underwear can be washed.

Respect the grinder and the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: bandsaw safety

#22

Respect everything that moves

russ fairfield

>If it moves under its own power or glows in the dark, it can hurt you if you get in the way

Re: bandsaw safety

#23

Mike Stafford

Re: Scary grinder moment

Mike Stafford

>Carole, I think your experience and that of many others including myself is the reason that the Sharp Fast and Vari-grind 2 sharpening systems have been developed.

With the original Vari-grind one must manually control the tool and the jig and make sure it does not slide off the slide and get dragged by the wheel into grinder. The Sharp Fast and Vari-grind 2 prevent the jig and the tool from sliding off the side of the wheel.

I have not used either of these improved methods and cannot comment on their effectiveness. I am assuming they are safer but I imagine there are inherent risks with any kind of power tool.

I always wear safety glasses while turning and sometimes I wear a face shield but I always wear a faceshield while sharpening.

Let's be careful out there....

Re: bandsaw safety

#24

Re: Scary grinder moment

Carole Valentine

>Mike, I have not used the Vari-Grind II, but the thing that struck me about it is that the tip of the tool is always wearing the the same area on the wheel. The description of the product on their site was Greek to me without being able to see the thing in hand. Have not checked out the other system you mentioned.

Re: bandsaw safety

#25

Re: bandsaw safety

Don Evans

>I believe that is one of the reasons "foot pedals" began to show up on bandsaws, not only does it turn the motor off but it brakes the blade to an almost immediate stop.

My bandsaw, a MiniMax MM16 states that you should never use the off switch to turn it off, but instead turn it off with the pedal.

It is very difficult to see that a band is still moving if it is off but still free wheeling.

Don