Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

New to me lathe, and chuck question

Posts

New to me lathe, and chuck question

#1

New to me lathe, and chuck question

Grant in Iowa

>Hello all,

I recently acquired an old Rockwell 46-111 lathe in pretty good shape.

Being new to turning (I have completed 1 total project, but I find myself intrigued and motivated to do more. In addition to turning projects, I see the value and capabilities of a lathe in general woodworking and shop use. So far, I have played around by using faceplates and a sacrificial piece of wood.

The lathe has a 1"x 8 threads per inch headstock. Indeed it has a second lefthand set of threads on the left side of the headstock.

I'd like to put a lathe chuck on my Christmas wish-list, but I really have no idea what to look for or what might be the best option.

I can see myself turning bowls, some spindle work, bowls, Christmas ornaments, small boxes, and of course bowls.

So what say you? If a guy wanted a decent chuck for a reasonable price, what would a guy put in his Christmas list? Suppose we try to keep it under $200, and even less of that is possible. 3 jaw? 4 jaw? brand? size? style? other features I hadn't thought about yet... I have looked at a couple OneWay units at the local tool store, but I didn't leap because I knew I was uneducated on the subject.

Thanks in advance,

Grant in Iowa<---running the risk of slipping down a slippery slope.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#2

JL

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

JL

>I have a couple of Oneway chucks. I like them. For your particular lathe (if you were going with a Oneway), I would suggest a Oneway Talon chuck ($250).

If you wanted to go with Penn State's version, it would be the Barracuda 2 ($180). If you wanted to go with Vicmarc's version, it would be the Vicmarc 3 1/2" ($240). For Teknatool, it would be the Supernova 2 ($190).

I don't really think you could go wrong with any of them. I've used the Vicmarc and I like it. I haven't really used the Barracuda 2 or the Supernova 2 to any extent.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#3

Roger in MO

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Roger in MO

>Welcome to the addictive world of turning.

I have the Barracuda 2 from PSI and am happy with it. I mostly use the pin jaws since I have a larger chuck with #2 jaws. The PSI chuck includes multiple sets of jaws. I prefer a chuck that tightens with a key instead of levers. Roger

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#4

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Texian

>You might consider the Grizzly chuck H6265 at 99.95. It is said to be a copy of the Vicmarc VM100 chuck, will accept the Vicmarc jaws, and operates with a T-handle hex key. I have two of them and have been well satisfied with them. No doubt the fit and finish of the more costly chucks are better, but the Griz. chucks do grip the wood firmly and cause it to rotate when the lathe is turned on. Nearly everyone has their favorite brand of chuck, and you probably can't go wrong with any of the major brands. Possibly more important not to buy a huge chuck for a small lathe, or vice-versa.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#5

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Carole Valentine

>You'll get as many different answers as there are chucks, but I have 3 Supernova 2s and am real happy with them. Would like to have one more. You can never have too many chucks. ;) Oh, and you will soon find that the lathe itself seems to be the least expensive part of woodturning!

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#6

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Jim Sebring

>All modern chucks used for woodworking lathes are four jaw scrolling types. That means that when the adjusting key or tommy bars are turned all four jaws compress or expand in unison.

As mentioned above, if you ask ten turners which chuck to get, you'll get 15 answers! I have several Nova chucks because I don't want to change jaws every time I need to change how a different workpiece is to be held. All of the jaw sets available from the Nova folks are interchangeable on the different Nova chucks.

Probably the best deal right now is the Nova G3 chuck available from a Ebay dealer in Vancouver, B.C. Just type in 'Nova G3' on the Ebay site to find him. I received a new G3 last week three days after I ordered it and paid via PayPal. Current price, including shipping and insert for your lathe 1 x 8 headstock threads is $125. I've bought several products from this site and have been pleased with the transaction each time.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#7

Bill Blasic

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Bill Blasic

>Grant,

I believe in December at Woodcraft the Nova Precision Midi is going to be on sale with a couple of jaw sets. This is a Tommy Bar chuck and not all people like them. I myself find them easy and fast to use and might just get another.

Bill

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#8

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Barry Irby

>Grant, Carrol is right. Some manufacturer should give you a lathe if you would agree to buy all the stuff to go with it from them.

I have the Super Nova Chuck and like it. Do remember that there will probably be and insert to go with any chuck you buy. Many of them are milled to a large size of threads and we all buy inserts (think Reducer) to make it fit whatever shaft we have. ($25 or 30)

I have one of the Tommy bar chuck also and found it to be hard to use. Sort of required three hands, one to hold the blank and two to operate the bars. Obviously you can do it with two hands, but there is a learning curve.

Think carefully. Maybe find some local turners and look at theirs. There will be more jaws and probably more chucks in your future and you probably want to stick with the same brand or at least ones that have interchangeable jaws.

If you like the Nova chucks, Check with Tim Geist. He is Nova's representative in the US and may have some that have been rebuilt at a significantly reduce price. I would tell you his contact info, but I lost it in a computer crash. If you are interested, ask and someone more computer savvy or luckier than I am will tell you how to reach him. (Great Guy also).

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#9

Dick Hines

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Dick Hines

>Grant, buying a lathe is like buying an old car to fixup. The price of the car is a drop in the bucket to what you will have in it before you are finished.

Like Carole I like the Super Nova2 chucks.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#10

Thanks, Everyone.. good input...on my list!

Grant in Iowa

>

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#11

Re:Hey Bill, you need to tell Barry ..........

Jamie Donaldson

>.... about the ol' golf ball third hand trick! (;-D)

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#12

Where do you live in Iowa?

Steve Harder

>There are a number of good turning clubs in the state.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#13

Katherine Kowalski

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

Katherine Kowalski

>Lesson from experience -- when you buy an insert, buy the name-brand one that goes with your chuck. I initially bought my SuperNova2 chuck and the cheaper "WoodRiver" brand insert at WoodCraft. The chuck wobbled significantly, but, being a beginner at the time, I didn't think about the cause, and just used it as it was.

As my projects grew in refinement, I needed a more accurate chuck, so to solve the problem I bought a VicMarc... and I absolutely LOVE it -- very precise, and it *feels* like a well-engineered tool.

Actually, just recently talked to WoodCraft folks about my Nova chuck wobble, and they said it could be the insert problem... so I've got a new _SuperNova_ insert on order. Hoping to make my chuck work...

I also have two smaller SuperNova chucks to do my everyday turning, they work just fine -- and I like the tommy bars -- fast and easy.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#14

Bill Blasic

Re:Hey Bill, you need to tell Barry ..........

Bill Blasic

>Jamie,

Barry, if he belongs to a club, should look into having you come and do a demo and possibly a hands on. Then the golf ball (excellant tip!) would have a special meaning. I'm doing up a dozen balls to pass out at the next meeting.

Thanks again Jamie for a great Demo!

Bill

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#15

OK, I'll bite, whats the Trick?

Barry Irby

>

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#16

Re: Barry- I don't know how to post ......

Jamie Donaldson

>... a link, but YouTube has a 5 part demo of me turning a square edge bowl, search for "square edge bowl turning#2." This video was shot by a spectator and camera is hand held, but the golf ball on the tailstock live center will be explained.

Re: New to me lathe, and chuck question

#17

Shueyville

Grant in Iowa

>I am aware of the turning clubs. I belong to three clubs right now boating, waterskiing, and woodworking. Someday I'll find the time to go to the turning club and learn a thing or two.

Regards,

Grant in iowa