Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

Posts

The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

#1

The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

charlie belden

>Uniform Wall Thickness? Why?

Common Knowledge is that wall thickness of plates, platters, bowls and the various versions of hollow forms should, ideally, have uniform wall thickness - to minimize warping - and cracking/splitting. This is especially true if you turn �green� wood since �green� wood changes dimensions far more as it dries than does �dry� wood.

But, thinking about it, it seems as though what you�re after is uniform shrinkage, not uniform wall thickness. I�m putting together some info, spreadsheets and illustrations examining shrinkage turners often have to deal with and will have that stuff available on my personal site in the next few days. But before I do that, I�d like to have a discussion about an overview of the subject to see if I�ve overlooked something important or if any of may assumptions are wrong.

For purposes of discussion, I�ve done some illustrations to use in what I hope will be a discussion of the affects of wood shrinkage on a hemispherical bowl, just to keep things simple, turned from a typical �half a logette� blank. (See attached PIC). Hope to do something similar for end grain hollow form such as lidded boxes.

Figure 1 shows the bowl�s orientation within the Half Logette starting point.

Figure 2 shows how the turned bowl is expected to change in terms of three views - top, end grain end and side.

Figure 3 shows how how the bowl will shrink �acrossed the grain� due to Tangential Shrinkage and shows that the AMOUNT of shrinkage as you go down from the rim to the bottom of the bowl progressively decreases, thought the Percent of Change remains at the Tangential Shrinkage PERCENT.

Figure 4 show an End Grain View and a Side Grain view of the bowl, with the resulting Radial Shrinkage that would result from going from �green� to �dry�. The farther you get from the End Grain end the more the rim will dip when viewed from the side grain side.

Comments, suggestions, discussion?


img

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

#2

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickne

Greg in Oshkosh

>typically we have the bowl rim at the pith, not at the bark except for natural edge bowls. Looks like your shrinkage in fig 4 is for a bowl with the rim at the pity not how you have it drawn in fig 1

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

#3

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickne

Jim Pugh

>I agree with Greg, your 'bowl' in the first illustration needs to be turned 180�, top to bottom. I have also noticed that a shallow bowl made closer to the bark seems to warm quite a bit more than one taken from near the pith.

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

#4

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickne

charlie belden

>Greg:

If you have the rim at the pith side of the logette, you'd turn away most if not all, of the heartwood. Granted, you could get a larger piece if you went that way - but bigger isn't always better if you end up with almost all sapwood in the finished piece. Sometimes, smaller can mean nicer - looking - with both sapwood and heartwood.

Jim:

When you say

"I have also noticed that a shallow bowl made closer to the bark seems to warm quite a bit more than one taken from near the pith. "

what do you mean by "warm" and why would wood "warm" quite a bit more closer to the bark than to the pith?


img

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

#5

some of us can't spell..

Jim Pugh

>Charlie, it's amazing what one little letter can do to the meaning of a word. The intended word was 'warp'. Probably a better choice would have been 'distort'.

Now, further discussion about illus. B: some of us have decided that deep bowls like you are showing are not fun to turn and quite often aren't practical to use either. Let's back up a bit and presume a log larger than 12 inches for my part of the discussion. I have started cutting a slab next to the center (after eliminating the pith) of around 4 to 5 inches thick - depending on the diameter. This yields a large but moderately shallow bowl. The remaining piece toward the outside of the log is where I was referring to 'more likely to warp beyond expectations'. It will also make a fairly shallow bowl - more like a platter. Keep up your line of thought as I for one, find it interesting.

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickness

#6

Re: The Shrinkage Thing - And Uniform Wall Thickne

Greg in Oshkosh

>I don't leave sapwood in my roughout unless I want it for color contrast etc. You are correct in assuming that it shrinks more and is more difficult to handle. I just use a bigger piece of wood. I find that I can get bigger pieces of wood than I want to make bowls out of. There is just not much call for bowls 16" or bigger. Most tables aren't that big and the bigger bowls look out of place.