>I have been turning for about 6 years. About 85% of my turning is face work with my spindle work usually smaller items. I consider myself quite proficient with most tools and my work is well received. However, I have yet to master the skew. Most likely because I use it so seldom.
Last month, I made a couple of rolling pins out of laminated stock. A perfect application for the skew I though. After several catches that ruined one of the blanks, I returned to my trusty gouges and turned the next two without incident. I am now making Christmas ornaments and while I know the skew should be tool of choice for much of the work, I find that by using Doug Thompson�s shallow detail gouges, (� and a 3/8) I can get the desired fine details with a smooth finish right off the tool.
So my question is, what am I missing. Am I limiting myself by not using the skew. If it is a question of production efficiency, I am OK with that because I have no need to hurry. So what is the down side of not using it.
At the Greensboro Symposium, Stuart Batty showed how he uses the skew as a negative rake scraper. I reground one of my skews to do this and it works great. I am thinking this may be a better use of this expensive steel.
Steve
(Killing time in an airport, pondering the great philosophical questions of life.)
>I do primarily spindlework, and find that the skew does indeed make an excellent negative rake scraper! Actually, if I need a "skewing" cut, I will use the side of either of my (primary) spindle gouges. I grind a straight area below the curve, which can act like a skew. (On one of my gouges I have a wider "fingernail" grind at the top, the other is Cindy Drozda's grind, with a 1/8" diameter tip).
Because of this straight part, I can present the tool to the wood at a 45' angle, and the chips come off as wonderfully curly skew-like shavings... with a finish to match. Another benefit -- no need to spend the extra seconds changing tools.
I find my skew extremely useful only for v-grooves... and now even I'm moving to the gouge for those as well. The skew is BEST at being a negative rake scraper. I have a straight-edged one that I use for scraping convex surfaces, and a round-edged one for concave surfaces.
Personally I don't think you're missing anything. But it all depends on your own work and style -- you find the tools that perform the best for you and do the job you want them to.
>Short answer: If you're getting great results without using a skew, keep doing what you're doing.
Longer answer: Once you master the skew, it may become one of your favorite tools. I've not mastered mine, yet, but it's already one of my favorite tools and one I find myself reaching for more and more. The surface left by the skew when it's cutting properly is the standard against which the surfaces left by all other tools are compared. More important for me, there's nothing sweeter than the feeling that comes from using a skew properly. (It's even better than the feeling that comes with roughing out a bowl in wet wood.) YMMV.
>Steve, I would never claim to be a skew expert but you may want to focus on laying the skew on its bevel. If you contact the wood with the bevel and are confident that the bevel is riding on the wood then a slight change of angle will lead to the wood being removed by the cutting edge. At no time should the point at which the wood contacts the chisel edge should that point of contact be above the mid-point of the skew's cutting edge. Most of the time when I make a mistake with the skew it is because the angle of my handle is far too obtuse with the axis of the wood. That leads to a catch within a few seconds. Again, keep the skew bevel in contact before you try to remove any wood. Good luck! Phil
>My best friend is a master turner and can't use the skew. He turned for a living and just never used the skew. I kid him all the time because he actually uses a V tool like I would use a skew. He rubs one of the bevels and undercuts candlesticks the same way I use a skew to do goblet bottoms.
I love my skew. I find it especially useful for getting long flowing curves or straight lines. I can get just as clean a cut with my big spindle gouge but it's more difficult to get those long straight lines.
Properly used I can get cuts so clean you actually have to sand them if you want to apply stain to a project.
When turning beads right next to each other you can use the skew to turn them very close with straight sides. It's hard to do this with a spindle gouge because nose can get thick pretty quick and will hit the side of the bead.
If you getting catches you probably either came off the bevel, got above the center point on the cutting edge, took too big of a bit or had a dull tool. Those are the main reasons.
The skew is a great tool for cleaning up the bottom of goblets or for cleaning up the endgrain on spindles. Used toe down it's really great for box lids with endgrain.
As was already mentioned it's to tool to go for if you want V grooves or need to "tuck in a bead" which is basically just a good sharp V groove between two beads.
I use the toe of the skew when I need to undercut something close to the headstock. It will reach into tighter places than the spindle gouge.
>Hi Steve, Yes the dreaded skew is certainly worth mastering. I tell my students to get comfortable with just one function of the skew, then use only the skew for that function. An example would be turning a tenon for chucking work. Then, expand the uses for the skew...the skew is invaluable for detailing finer points of a turning, such as the base of beads, where I use the skew in a long-point-down operation. Riding the bevel with the cut occuring on the centerline of the work , this is a simple, catch-free cut. Also cutting filets, which I consider necessary in spindle work, is a job the skew does best...clean, crisp cuts. Think of a skew as a spindle gouge that has been hammered flat, and ride the bevel. On work such as a rolling pin, the cutting edge should not be 90 degrees to the work, but rather closer to 45 to shear away wood. Hope this helps, Keith
>Keith's advice makes a lot of sense... Pick one skew-function, get comfortable with it then expand to newer functions/uses.
I use my skew all of the time for making chuck tenons. It makes getting the dovetail angle a breeze. Cutting V's, easy with a skew. What I really love it for are long straight cuts and long gently curved cut like on my peppermills. It is so much easier to control than a spindle gouge for these tasks, IMHO.
Heck, I used to use my 1-1/4" skew to rough out spindle blanks before I had any other spindle tools. THAT was exciting!
>Even if you never use it again, there are many benefits to learning to use and becoming proficient with thr skew chisel.
It will teach you the benefits of a sharp cutting edge. Nowhere is it more obvious that sharper tools cut better than dull ones, and the sharper they are the better they cut, than when using a skew chisel.
It will teach you how wood is cut by shearing and slicing it apart rather than tearing it apart.
It will teach you the importance of the bevel, and how to use it to your advantage.
It will teach you tool control like no other turning tool.
Lastly, you will become a better woodturner for learning to use the skew. I don't know of a single woodturner whose work hasn't gotten better because they learned to use the skew. They may not admit it or recognize the difference it made, but it is obvious to everyone else.
If nothing else, you can impress other woodturnewrs with your turning skills.
>Hi Russ, It's funny, when I demo, I've asked the people in the front row to please leave their seats as I'm about to use the skew chisel...many people instantly get up out of their seats....then I tell them "Just kidding!" You are correct, the skew must be sharp. I have also found many skews are ground to a far too obtuse edge. A more acute angle can be honed to a far keener edge, slices through wood easier, and gives a wider bevel.
>In the posts above, I don't think anyone mentioned what I think is critically important to having a skew be manageable, and that is to have the bevels ground FLAT.
Suppose they aren't flat. If the bevel is convex in the vicinity of the cutting edge (like rounded over)and you rub the larger area of the bevel, which may be flat, it won't cut. The cutting edge will be above the surface of the wood. To get it to cut, you have to lift it off the larger bevel so the cutting edge engages the wood. At that point, any bevel that is rubbing is very small. This makes for a very sensitive situation. The slightest increase in cutting angle will cause the edge to dig in and . . . away she goes!
If the bevel is concave near the cutting edge, like hollow ground all the way to the cutting edge, simply putting the bevel in contact with the wood will initiate the cut. Then, as the skew advances, the cut tends to get deeper as the edge arcs deeper into the wood. At the same time, the surface left behind tends to be rough. Pretty soon, the cut is so deep you can't control it. Then ...away she goes!
With a truly flat bevel, you should be able to place the bevel flat on the surface of a spindle without getting any cutting action at all. It is only when you roll the edge into the wood ever so slightly that it will begin to cut. I have an oval skew and the rolling is about the long axis of the tool with maybe an unconscious tilting of the edge into the wood. I am not sure about the tilting.
At any rate, it is controllable in this mode. If the cut starts getting too deep and the reaction force increases, just roll (or tilt, or whatever) it back the other way.
If your method of sharpening naturally produces a hollow grind, you should then use a flat diamond hone to obtain a flat bevel at least 1/8" wide near the cutting edge. You will also get a flat region at the rear of the bevel. You can see the flat areas easily in reflected light.
Now check this out: with the lathe off, place the bevel of your skew against the squared end of a piece mounted in the spindle orientation. Press on the bevel until it is flat against the end of the piece, then look at the angle the handle makes to the axis of the lathe. This is precisely where the handle should be as you make a slicing cut across the end of a spindle. Think about it. It MUST be that way or the bevel would not be rubbing.
>Good question Steve. Been wondering the same thing. Also wonder if the much touted smooth finish isn't partially the result of burnishing by the back edge of the bevel. Recently noticed I seemed to be making a "skew" cut with one wing of a bowl gouge, so dusted off the skew and checked. Now have some renewed interest in learning to skew.
>After watching Eli Avisera demonstrate with a convex grind skew I decided to try one. I'm not convinced it's as good as a flat grind but it is functional and works well for some people. I've been switching back and forth trying to find out why he likes it. So far I don't see an advantage and have trouble on some cuts but nonetheless it does work.
I think using the skew is more about finess and practice. You have to make little movements to keep the tool on the bevel. You can't make gross movements or you come off the bevel and get a catch. Slow down and let the tool do the cutting,don't force it. It doesn't remove wood as fast as some tools.
I've also been playing with flat bevel vs hollow grind with small flats created when sharpening. This is the method I prefer. I've read that the hollow grind makes a weak edge that can chatter, etc. I can't prove it in use and it's much easier to sharpen an edge with a hollow grind than a flat edge.
Curved edge vs straight edge. I use a straight edge and have tried the curved edge. I simply don't see any advantage to the curved edge and it's harder to sharpen at the grinder unless you use a jig. Turning with the toe there might be some advantage because it changes your angle of approach of the tool but for most cuts it doesn't matter. I find the straight edge easier to see when doing many cuts with just the very tip.
Just my opinions of course but I use the skew an awful lot and have about 8 or 9 with different shapes and grinds so I've played with the different grinds quite a bit.
>I use the skew cut with my rough out gouge wings and also use the wings of a bowl gouge in a sort of pull cut. With the rough out gouge when I rough out a piece I will often use the wings as a sort of skew by using the bottom 1/3 of the straight area to clean up the small grooves left by the rough out gouge U. I turn most of mirror handles with the rough out gouge leaving only a little clean up with the skew. This makes it faster and also saves the edge of the skew which I find slower to sharpen than the rough out gouge.
>OK, how many of you pick up the skew and apply it to a project your turning to learn to use it. I did, many year ago of course. I remember blowing up a project and cutting my thumb. Still don't know how I cut my thumb doing that.
When you want to learn to use a new tool, don't do it on a project. Pull out a scrap of wood and just waste away wood with the new tool. The Hunter tool was like that for me. When I first got one I didn't really understand how it worked and it took a while to really learn it. I put a scrap piece in the lathe and just played with all kinds of different angles. Now it's my go to tool for finishing cuts because I know exactly how it cuts.
The skew is no different. It takes practice. Nick Cook starts teaching with the skew because it's so easy to understand how the bevel works. Most beginners don't understand that the bevel controls the depth of cut and the angle of the cut. With the skew it's straight and flat and it's obvious where it is. With a bowl gouge it's kind of constantly changing and most beginners don't understand how to use it to their advantage.
Put a piece of wood on the lathe and just turn a cylinder with the skew. Then turn tapers both left hand and right hand. Then try large barrel shapes. You can gradually make your barrels more and more rounded until they become beads. use it toe down and heel down to learn the difference. Use the toe to cut v's. Try to change the shape of the V's (this teaches you to read the bevel direction) Then see how deep you can make the V's
This practice only needs to take 15 minutes or so. Toss that piece and go on with your bowl turning or whatever you plan for the evening. After a few weeks of this practice you'll be pretty good.
I did the same thing when learning to cut dovetails by hand. I went in the shop each night before dinner and cut a dovetail is scrap using just the saw. By the end of a 2 weeks I was cutting them so close with the saw that it took almost no clean up with the chisel.
Practice is key to every tool. This should be fun and not work, Practice makes your tool usage easier and more controllable and then makes your projects quicker and easier.
>`Hey John, I've ground a couple of my skews to a curved edge as well...HATED IT! Had to grind them back flat. I think the proponents of curved edges use the tool primarily as a planing tool. John, try this....adjust your tool rest so the center of the skew is on the centerline of the turning. With the long end down, turn a bead riding the bevel, cutting at the center of the tool with the handle horizontal. No rolling of the tool, body english swings the tool. Tell me what you think! (I'm doing this demo tonight) You can make this cut anywhere along the bevel, but notice the clean cut and little tendency to catch. Using the skew tis way gives great access to the bottom of beads and tight areas. I've been experimenting with a new skew grind; a bevel on only ONE side. This will require a right and left skew chisel. I don't think it' so much the shape of the bevel that causes problems...lay your skew so the bevel lies flat on the workpiece. Notice the top bevel angles downward into the wood; I think this angle is what draws the skew cut deeper and deeper into the cut unless light cuts are taken. A flat top may work better, esp. on curly grain.
Now for something really controversial: I can make a cleaner cut straight across end-grain with a continental spindle gouge than with any skew. Not even a contest.
>I use a curved skew and don't use a jig at the grinder. Just set the rest for the angle I want, plant the tool and pivot it on the rest to follow the curve. Actually very easy.
I really like the curved skew and have several sizes for different purposes. Like you, I use the skew quite a bit. I have some straight ones, but very rarely use them. It just seems to me to be more forgiving. Wife has given me the project of turning icicles for the Christmas tree, so that should be some good practice, probably 100 or so of them........
This thread could become one of those about cutting dovetails and cutting the pins first, which of course, is just wrong.......:)
Agree with the practice. Stop by any construction site and pick up some scrap 2x4's, rip them to 1 1/2", turn a cylinder, practice at whatever you want, turn a smaller cylinder, and keep going until the piece breaks. Great fun, and if you can do it with #2 SPF and get a good finish right off of the tool, a piece of cherry is a breeze.
>Most beginners want to make stuff, not practice. The lathe is not like a table saw. Other shop tools require very little "learning" curve, so new turners often buy a lathe and don't realize that you can't "just make things"...not well, at least.
This is why I am starting to teach. I see lots of folks going out and buying the lathes and tools, then wasting big money on fancy wood when they have no basic skills. Expensive wood shouldn't be your first experience on the lathe. A good understanding of wood and how the tools work is an investment. If you understand these things, the skew isn't so mystical...
>Keith I'll have to digest all that later. I have a client coming in shortly and will be working all day. I do get to shoot some furniture this afternoon which is always fun.
Regarding the continental gouge. I've been playing with endgrain cuts lately because I had the box elder that sucked. What I'm finding is it's more about the cutting angle than what tool. I have a skew ground to 25 degrees and my Hunter tool is around that. Those two give the cleanest cuts. My normal skew is about 35 degrees and my detail gouge and Thompson spindle gouge are also 35. It's pretty close but they don't seem to cut quite as good. I have a Henry Taylor bowl gouge ground to 40 degrees like Stewart Batty. Most of the time it's the tool I go to for end grain tearout. The other tools do work better but it's really almost as much about feedrate of the tool. If you push any tool fast enough it will tear out.
I'll give your skew technique a try tonight. I have to turn a couple of things to get ready for my demo in Jackson tomorrow.
>Doc I probably misread. I'm playing with a convex grind bowl gouge (ala Johannes Michelson grind) and also the convex skew. I'm trying to learn the pros and cons of these. The verdict is still out because I've had so much work to get out that can't be tested on. I do pick them up and cut while the wood is still thick and I can't screw it up. I'll let everyone know what I think after I've had some hours with the tool.
The convex grind skew I've worked with more. I don't get catches with it but it seems to come out of the cut too easily. I guess it's because the bevel is harder to find. For planing cuts it seems to be about the same as the flat grind. Beads is where I have the problems with it.
>Hi Steve. You are correct..using a router and want a different profile? just change the bit. Using the lathe is an acquired skill that will take time and effort to master. And, no matter how good you become, there are always new, even better techniques to learn. There is no substitute for time at the lathe, using correct technique! Time spent the WRONG WAY is pretty much a waste of time. Having trouble? Try finding a turning partner....you will be amazed how much progress you both will make. It's important to keep an open mind! When I visited New Jersey recently, Steve showed me Raffan's back hollowing technique, something I really hadn't tried. This is one of those techniques that takes some practice...so every chance I get, I practice the cut. Soon, it will become part of my regular routine. Thanks, Steve.
>HI John, my conti. gouge is about 35 degrees with a rounded nose..I think the rounded nose presents a very favorable angle to shear cut end grain...pushed straight in, letting the tool feed itself. I cannot get the same results with the skew, however, I'm fooling with using the skew below center, starting a groove, then riding the bevel pushind down on the handle to cut towards the center. so far, so good.