Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

I have often wondered...

Posts

I have often wondered...

#1

I have often wondered...

Paul Zerjay

>I'm not accusing anyone of anything here alright? Let's get that straight right from the start. But I've often wondered just how hollow are all those hollow forms you see posted online. Last week a guy came to my shop for a lesson and asked this same question. Most of mine are just over 1/8th inch in thickness. I use to be a carpenter, so when I say 1/8th, it's 1/8th. I know people exaggerate, so whats keeping them from saying it's 1/8, when it's 1/2? Whats keeping them from shooting it so it shows just enough to look hollow, when in actuality, it's not? I realize the turning community as a whole, is an honest bunch, but I've picked up enough "clunkers" at art shows to have my suspicions. I've also seen forms with such high, tight shoulders, that there is no way they can get a tool even close to the wall (at the shoulder), with the entry hole so small. I realize that I don't know s--- from shinola, and I haven't seen every tool out there. Maybe I should take a class with Ellsworth, or some other master, and learn how it's done.

Re: I have often wondered...

#2

Re: I have often wondered...

John Lucas

>I'm sure some exagerate. I turn small vessels to about 1/8" but larger vessels I leave thicker. My clients don't care and it takes twice as long to go from around 1/2" thick to less than 1/4. If it was a piece I would be showing at a turning event I would take the time and turn it thin.

As far as turning shoulders. You can turn them as square as you have the tools and skill. There used to be a tool that would let you turn a shoulder 90 degrees. Binh Pho uses one. I forget who made them. They have an articulated front piece that you can adjust after you put it in the hole. I intend to build one some day.

Re: I have often wondered...

#3

Rolly Munro?

Paul Zerjay

>

Re: I have often wondered...

#4

is there some standard for wall thickness?

bob davis

>

Re: I have often wondered...

#5

Re:Generally the only person who....

Jamie Donaldson

>...considers wall thickness important is another turner! Of course uniform wall thickness is an important criteria in the curing process, because thin is less likely to crack than thick in most green woods. This subject can be related to the interior surface discussion, as do you sand your vessel interiors to 400 grit? If the hole is small enough to exclude a finger, only the maker knows or cares!

Re: I have often wondered...

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

When I tell you one of mine is...

Chuck Jones - West TN

>...between 1/16" and 1 1/2" you can count on it. I haven't figured out the d@mn*d secret yet.

Re: I have often wondered...

#7

Steven Antonucci

A Turner's 1/8" is probably much closer to 1/4"

steve antonucci

>I've seen some turners talk about their wall thickness and I'm guessing that they are almost 2X the actual thickness by weight. More important than wall thickness is UNIFORM wall thickness. A heavy shoulder in a light pot feels very tippy. A heavier base tends to feel "dumpy".

I aim for between 1/16" on smaller pieces to 1/4" on larger ones. Doing the "impossible" is what makes it fun for me. Cutting through a large hole to 1/4" isn't very challenging, so I try to keep making smaller holes and thinner walls.

when I say 1/16", it might be 3/32", but usually, it's 0/16" and a few bad words...

S

Re: I have often wondered...

#8

Re: I have often wondered...

Raymond Overman in SC

>I have a hollow sphere on my desk that I know is more than 1/8th thick. You can't stick your finger in the hole to tell. The difference is in the weight more than the thickness for the buyer. If the weight feels proportional to the size of the piece they're generally happy.

I sold a nice little hollow form last week that the lady picked up and said, "Wow, that's a lot lighter than I thought it would be." I knew that I had the right thickness for the piece.

Re: I have often wondered...

#9

How much does it matter?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I'll admit straight out that most of my hollow forms are not uniformly thin. Depending on the design I will work to get thin edges to give the piece sufficient grace. But yes, you will find my work to be thicker towards the bottoms of the forms. (Not always, sometimes by design I want thin everywhere but thos are few cases)

I'm know that turning officianados will inspect a piece for thinness. But oddly enough, I have spoken to several customers who have purchased my turned work to see what attracted them to the pieces. Attractiveness of wood and overall shape seemed to matter most. I would ask about uniform thinness and that didn't really seem to matter to them. In fact, I have had customers tell me that they like having the piece "feel substantial".

Maybe I just have weird customers....I dunno?

Tom

Re: I have often wondered...

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: I have often wondered...

Steve Kubien

>My HF's range between 1/8" and 1/4" and, more often than not, closer to the 1/4" mark because I am chicken-sh*t. I spend more time on the outside and trying to make a pleasing shape, sand it well and finish it better than the last one. The inside becomes ALMOST irrelevant. I try to make uniform walls but I am glad nobody takes micrometers to then. Small vessels (2-4" tall) tend to be thinner but that is because I want it to weigh less. 1/16" is just too scary to me after all of the work done on the outside.

Re: I have often wondered...

#11

Dick Hines

Re: I have often wondered...

Dick Hines

>I shoot for 3/16". At least that is what I set my laser for. I am sure it does not measure 3/16" top to bottom. I know that I have had some that were -1/32" thin. Those ones are the ones that make the sound of eggs shells breaking.

Re: I have often wondered...

#12

Re:Only another woodturner cares

russ fairfield

>Thickness of our hollow forms depends on what we are doing with our turned things, and who we are trying to please - ourselves, other woodturners, or the people who buy stuff from us.

If we are doing it for ourselves, "thin" is a challenge.

Other woodturners always encourage "thin", but other woodturners never buy anything.

95% of the buying public souldn't care less whether it is 1/16" or 1/2" wall thickness. In fact, many of them will be put off by "thin" because they think it is too fragile. Only that 5% are willing to pay us for all of the time it took us to make it so thin.

Re: I have often wondered...

#13

Re: I have often wondered...

Texian

>Saw a big 16" tall "hf" vase at a craft show a while back. Was ready to be impressed until noticing that the "hollowing" was just a straight hole bored about 5" deep. I try for 3/16 to 1/4 with a slightly thicker bottom to keep it from being tippy. The laser is a huge help.

Re: I have often wondered...

#14

No-Hugh McKay I think.

john lucas

>

Re: I have often wondered...

#15

Re: I have often wondered...

Carole Valentine

>Sometimes I will make something really thin just to see how thin I can go, but for the most part, I am over that. Most of my stuff I just try to make appropriate for the vessel size so that it has a good feel and balance. On small footed pieces I leave a little more in the base for ballast. I started doing this after having a couple of very light pieces get knocked off a display and broken when it was bumped. I have had one very thin hollow form get broken in a gallery. I was told that it was "turned too thin and was too fragile".

Re: I have often wondered...

#16

Lyle Jamieson

Re: I have often wondered...

Lyle Jamieson

>I did a goblet for my club recently that was 1/100 inch thick, just to show how easy it is, no big deal with the right tools. But it is not about the wall thickness it is all about uniform wall thickness. You dont have to go thin but there is some good reasons to be uniform. The feel when picked up must communicate a consistent message. If the hole wall visible is thin then the rest of the HF should be equally thin. There is a conflict in the viewers mind, even if subconscious, if it does not feel right. This inconsistency could cost you a sale. How about pride of workmanship?? Dont do it for anybody else but yourself. Why do you turn?? Cause its fun. Enjoy the finished product too, or is it OK to "settle"?? Its your call.

On top of all that, and more important to me, is the risk of cracking. If you do a uniform wall thickness it will not crack. Again it does not have to be thin but just uniform.

Re: I have often wondered...

#17

Just like flat lumber get thinner.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Any way you look at it somebody's getttin' it... 8^(

Mostly he who made it.

Re: I have often wondered...

#18

SO TRUE RUSS

bob davis

>