>Well I fought the coring tools yesterday. Was trying to core out an 18" bowl. I was using my new tool which was working great until I got about 1/2 way home. I got a nasty catch. I have no idea what I was doing. I was feeding it at a slow consistent rate with the tool firml against the captured bar. It bent my tool.
I took the McNaughton tool and proceded to core some more. I got about another inch and got another catch. This one broke the tool in 2 places. I'm sure I'll spend a little time away from the pearly gates for what I said at that point.
I cut away some of the core until I could get at the remains of the blade and pull it out. My other McNaughton tool and my hunter tool were both too short finish the cut so I heated the bend area on my original tool and bent and hammered it back to shape. That let me finish coring.
I learned several things but I'm still confused as to why I got a catch at all. The first thing was the McNaughton tools are too short to core a bowl this large and deep. Second was I have a very hard time trying to visualize the entry angle. To get the shape right you have to enter the work at just the right angle of the curve of the blade won't let you cut properly. I guess that's something I'll just have to learn.
I feel like the shavings bind up over the blade. I'll be cutting perfectly and all of the sudden it won't cut anymore. I pull the blade out and them go back in. Sometimes it will cut perfectly and other times it won't. I'll clear the blade again and usually it cuts. I think I need a mini move camera to tape to the blade so I can see what's happening inside.
I did save the big bowl and got one more small bowl out of that blank so it wasn't a total loss. Should have had 3 or 4 bowls out of that blank.
>John, I would send them back to the guy that made them. I found that if you don't make waide enough cut the shavings will block up the slot. I use a wide cut and pull the knife out often to clear the shavings.They seem to work better that way.
First, I gather that you are just learning how to core with the McNaughton. Start with the standard set, and learn how to use them before you step up to the large set (which will core 18 inch bowls). You do this for pretty much the same reasons your first bowls will be smaller ones, not 18 inch ones. You have a lot to learn.
Next, the cutter needs to be at, or slightly above center. Since there is some flexing in the blades and tool rest, being above center (1/4 inch or so) is good, especially on the larger blades that hang way out over the tool rest, because if it is at center, on an 18 inch bowl, by the time you get to the center, you can be 1/2 inch or more below center.
When coring, as long as the shavings are flowing, I keep coring, but if they stop, if you don't clear them, they can jam up inside the kerf/cut and stop your lathe. Once you have cleared the shavings, if you put the blade back in and it is bottomed out in the cut but not cutting, you have shavings over the tip of the blade. Clear some more. Do not try to force the blade through the shaving as this will cause a major catch.
The blades tend to drift as you core, always towards the outside. This means you have to open up the cut a bit wider, usually to the outside, or I some times go to the inside of the cut. The blade can actually bind inside the cut because it is cutting a bigger curve than the curve of the blade. You can also bump the tool rest towards the inside a bit.
Most catches are due to being below center. Some times, it is the wood being stringy, or just not cutting easily and tearing more than cutting. Now that I have a few thousand cores under my belt, I can push the cutting, but the tool will self feed. This is some thing you just need to learn to feel.
I am surprised that you broke a blade. This should not happen. The flex in the system is in the blades and tool rest so that it will bend but not break. I have bent countless blades. Some from catches, and some from heavy use. This bend is usually a twisting, not just straight down bending. Lay it on a flat surface to see how much bending there is. You can clamp one end in a vice, and use a monkey wrench or big adjustable wrench to twist it back into place.
The bends in the curve/arc of the blade can be a bit inconsistant. They are stamped, not cut from tube stock. Draw a template on some paper or a work bench and see how it matches up. I did take one blade and bent just the tip inwards a tiny bit (not possible for me to measure how much). This helped to correct for the drifting.
I do also have a end grain turned collar to go around the tool post to keep the blade at proper cutting height.
Aiming is the tricky part of using this tool. You know where you want to enter the wood, and where you want to come out, but getting on the right path is difficult. Some people set up graphs on paper to help determine. I hold the blade I am using up against the outside of the bowl blank to compare the two curves, and then again up directly over the bowl blank where I intend to core. These two things give a visual idea of where to core. Of course, it is kind of guess work that you will get better at the more you core. I do have the laser pointer system that McNaughton makes, and Randy at Monster Tools (articulated hollowing systems) makes an adapter for his laser pointer to go on the McNaughton handles. His laser system is really slick. This doesn't really make your aim any better, but it lets you know if you are off course and need to correct.
There are 2 DVDs out on how to use the McNaughton. One by me, and one by Mike Mahoney. Mike just redid his, and I haven't seen it yet. If you are interested in mine, then e-mail me.
>Glad you weren't hurt. And I suppose like everything else there is a learning curve. I hope you learn the process before your tool breaks again or you get broken....8(
And I will keep you company waiting for the Pearly Gates to open if saying bad words is gonna keep you out. I try not to use expletives but certain circumstances go cause the mouth to run amok....LOL. And never has saying, "Oh, darn" been as satisfying as a string of blue tinged bad words.
>John, in my limited experience coring, the cut goes very easily while you are cutting into the bowl. Bill Grumbine guides the cutter with just his thumb and forefinger. During this time you are cutting across the grain. Once you 'turn the corner' and start working your way across the bottom, the cut is a little more difficult so expect to use a little more force. As others have said, keep the kerf cleaned out and if necessary move the tool rest a bit. In Mike Mahoney's video, he moved the tool rest on each bowl he demonstrated. Finally, keep the cutter sharp. I touch mine up on a diamond hone before each cut.
>I'll keep reading the responses. My home computer is at the Doc right now so I won't be able to read anymore until tomorrow. I'll be roughing tonight but may not core any of those. They will be smaller bowls.