Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

A finishing question for the masses

Posts

A finishing question for the masses

#1

A finishing question for the masses

BQ in VT

>Greetings all! I use pure tung oil that I cut about 50% with a citrus solvent for a food safe finish I top with beeswax. It take the oil a while to dry during the summer, but now that it is cold and my house/turning "studio"(studio sounds fancy, don't you think?)is at about 60 degrees and the stuff just doesn't dry. I was wondering if I could do some thing to speed it along like blasting it once in a while with a hair dryer to get the temperature up or should I switch to something like Watco, which is non-toxic after 30 days. Would the Watco dry better or am I just screwed? I sell my items, so food safe is very important, but also I need the stuff to dry so I can get it out the door and sell it. At wits end, any thoughts or ideas would be greatly appreciated. As always, thanks in advance.

BQ

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#2

Re: A finishing question for the masses

Sean Troy

>I've set my oven to 150 and set things on a pie tin for awhile and had them dry nicely. I wouldn't go any hotter than that though.

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#3

Re: A finishing question for the masses

Bernie Weishapl

>The finishes of today are considered food safe after 72 hrs. I wait until I can't smell the solvent anymore. I quit using Tung oil because it was such a pain and wouldn't dry. I use Mike Mahoney's walnut oil. It needs sunlight to cure.

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#4

Re: A finishing question for the masses

BQ in VT

>can the walnut oil cause an allergic reaction in someone with nut allergies?

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#5

Re: A finishing question for the masses

BQ in VT

>good idea, how long is awhile and how close is the rack you place the pie plate on to the heating element?

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#6

Rob Wallace

Sean: Question - Does the kitchen...

Rob Wallace

>.... stink really badly after you do this? I had thought about trying to raise the temperature of the bowls and 'bake' the oil finish in our electric oven until the finish cured..... I was worried about persistent odor in the oven from the oil and *really* catching hell from SWMBO if it does smell of woodworking finishes. I can only imagine the "tung oil cupcakes" being brought to school by my kids. Have you had any problems along the 'malodorous lines' after you've baked the bowl finish?

I also thought about putting the oiled but uncured bowl in a metal chamber (normally used for placing experimental items under vacuum) and increasing the atmospheric oxygen concentration a bit in the chamber's air surrounding the bowl to promote curing of the "drying" oil finishes. I haven't done this yet, but it might be an interesting experiment...(??)...as long as it remains at low temperature without a source of ignition, and doesn't go 'Boom'! Perhaps this could be part of a Mythbusters show?

Curious about your experience with use of the oven....

Rob Wallace

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#7

Re: A finishing question for the masses

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Why did you use D-Lamiline (sp) or Citrus solvent? I would have serious doubts that it would ever dry. I would worry about a funny reaction with the Tung oil. D-lamiline by it self does not completely evaporate. It leaves a residue. If you want a truly food safe finish, use a blend of Bee's wax and mineral oil. It will need to be reapplied periodically but thats the trade off.

Just 2 cents worth

Dave

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A finishing question for the masses

Jesper, Denmark

>First, just about all finishes are food safe when dry.

You can cut the tung oil with your most favored turps or mineral equivalent. Try adding some Japan dryer to the mix to make it cure faster.

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#9

Re: A finishing question for the masses

jim miles - Charlote NC

>A number of turners use an old refrigerator with a big light bulb inside to dry their wood and finishes

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#10

150 F is too hot!

Doc Green

>I have a shop-made drying "oven" made from wood paneling and styrofoam insulation with a low-wattage heater and a small fan to circulate the air inside. I use it to speed up the drying of a finish when my shop is cool and humid. At first, no temperature control was available other than opening more or fewer vents to allow more air to pass through.

Once I was in a hurry to get it going and closed all the vents, and then forgot about it. When I remembered it, after about an hour, the temperature was 130 F. The finish had dried, but the bowl warped and cracked in the process. My conclusion was that 130 is way too hot.

Now I have a thermostat to control the temperature, and it is set to 98 degrees. This temperature works just fine and doesn't subject the pieces to high temperatures.

I use a mercury lab thermometer to measure the temperature. The bowl that I cooked was not green. It had been roughed out and allowed to dry for several months before I did the final turning and applied the finish. ~Doc

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#11

Re: A finishing question for the masses

BQ in VT

>I started out using beeswax and mineral oil, but it was not giving me the finish that I wanted. The manufacturer(The real Milk Paint Co out of PA) of the tung oil suggested the citrus oil solvent. With higher temperatures, it seemed to dry ok.

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#12

Re: A finishing question for the masses

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>I wrote this recently for our woodturning club newsletter.

Food Safety.

Woodturners often face this question -- Is this wood, or wood finish, food safe?

The answer is almost certainly yes. But since we have some column space remaining, let�s present the evidence for the dogmatic answer. And remember that food safe is different from food friendly � a few drops of linseed oil or turpentine won�t harm you, but the flavor of your food may suffer.

In fact, the solvents and wood dust inhaled in the average shop constitute a vastly greater health hazard than any wood or wood finish that might be ingested by placing food in contact with a finished wood item.

In a previous life, I was a pharmacologist/toxicologist who spent a lot of time evaluating the toxic potential of drugs and other substances foreign to the body. It is important to know that most foreign chemicals are quickly removed from the body, typically by some biotransformation in the liver, followed by elimination in the urine.

Dose is a critical factor. As Paracelsus (circa 1530) stated: All things are poisonous, for there is nothing without poisonous qualities; it is only the dose which makes a substance a poison. Cherry wood and apricot pits contain cyanide, one of the most toxic chemicals found in nature, but the amount of cyanide is too small to produce problems under most circumstances. On the other hand, drink enough water, and it will kill you.

Let�s take an extreme case. Rather than ingest a tiny amount of shellac with each bowl of cereal, we could swallow the amount of shellac covering a wooden bowl in one gulp. What would happen? Not much. Shellac is a resin secreted by an insect, the lac bug. And you won�t be consuming all the shellac at once, probably not even over many years. A similar situation exists for most other common finishing chemicals.

Most ingested oils and waxes are not absorbed by the body to an appreciable extent; in fact, long chain hydrocarbons (mineral oil, etc.) are used as lubricant laxatives because they pass right through the gastrointestinal tract.

How did all this concern about containers being food safe get started? Remember I said most foreign chemicals are quickly eliminated from the body. Well, there are a few exceptions and heavy metals constitute a major exception. Lead, for example, accumulates in the body when ingested over a period of time. And, it does not take a lot of lead to produce serious toxicity to the brain, heart, kidney, and just about every other critical organ in the body.

About 50 years ago there were a rash of toxicities reported in people using unglazed lead-containing pottery from Mexico. Daily consumption of acidic beverages (orange juice, etc.), which leeched lead from the pottery, and over a period of years, resulted in irreversible and serious neurotoxicities, including developmental disorders, seizures, coma, even death.

If you want to worry about food safety � think about the last person who used your fork at your favorite restaurant. Did they have hepatitis? Was the tableware really sterilized in the dishwasher? Did the kitchen guy making the cold salads have E. coli smeared all over his hands? There is a lot to worry about relative to food safety, but a few micrograms of polyurethane in your cereal is not one of them.

A postscript for the professional woodturner. If you are trying to sell �food safe� products, you have to respect what customers believe, even knowing that they are wrong.

Some people are so caught up in the green, organic, and natural world that they are totally opposed to any commercial �chemicals.� Therefore, you may be forced to use mineral oil, beeswax, walnut oil, and other perceived �natural� finishes to make a sale.

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#13

Re: A finishing question for the masses

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>No, once the oil is cured it is no longer reactive.

Re: A finishing question for the masses

#14

Re: A finishing question for the masses

Jim Pugh

>Emment, I would like to see this posted in every woodturning club newsletter. Would you consider making it available?

Ellis: I believe this information qualifies as an 'article' for ready reference as the question continually comes up.