Kicking and screaming
Paul Zerjay
>I try to be as open minded as I can. But when it comes to turning, I find that I can't think of a worse thing than scrapers. I am a firm believer in bevel rubbing, and have been since the gitgo. To me a scraper does nothing more than rib the fibers from the surface leaving an undesirable pitted surface. I know there are people who will say to raise a burr, and shear scrape. That's fine. The burr is actually slicing the wood, creating ribbons, and leaving a good clean finish. This, (I hope) is how scrapers were intended to be used, although I don't believe most people use them this way. JMHO.
Now for the kicking and screaming part. I have come across the hardest chunk of wood I have ever had the displeasure of turning. I able to get about 1/2" of roughing done and have to go back and resharpen. I have several hours in this burl, and still the outside is not even halfway roughed. I have used every tool I can think of and no better result. Then I started thinking about carbide cutters and resorted to using a hunter tool. It cuts, but it just not the tool to be using in a roughing situation. Hmmm. Carbide cutters... easy rougher! What? the Blasphemy!! This goes against ever grain of my fiber.
I have not gone to the store yet. I just find it hard to do such a thing that I'm so against. I would like to ask if anyone has one of these things, and if they are worth the price, and do they actually do what they claim. If you have one, did you get the extra "windshield" thing for deflecting the chips? Is it necessary?



