Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Kicking and screaming

Posts

Kicking and screaming

#1

Kicking and screaming

Paul Zerjay

>I try to be as open minded as I can. But when it comes to turning, I find that I can't think of a worse thing than scrapers. I am a firm believer in bevel rubbing, and have been since the gitgo. To me a scraper does nothing more than rib the fibers from the surface leaving an undesirable pitted surface. I know there are people who will say to raise a burr, and shear scrape. That's fine. The burr is actually slicing the wood, creating ribbons, and leaving a good clean finish. This, (I hope) is how scrapers were intended to be used, although I don't believe most people use them this way. JMHO.

Now for the kicking and screaming part. I have come across the hardest chunk of wood I have ever had the displeasure of turning. I able to get about 1/2" of roughing done and have to go back and resharpen. I have several hours in this burl, and still the outside is not even halfway roughed. I have used every tool I can think of and no better result. Then I started thinking about carbide cutters and resorted to using a hunter tool. It cuts, but it just not the tool to be using in a roughing situation. Hmmm. Carbide cutters... easy rougher! What? the Blasphemy!! This goes against ever grain of my fiber.

I have not gone to the store yet. I just find it hard to do such a thing that I'm so against. I would like to ask if anyone has one of these things, and if they are worth the price, and do they actually do what they claim. If you have one, did you get the extra "windshield" thing for deflecting the chips? Is it necessary?

Re: Kicking and screaming

#2

Ric Taylor

Re: Kicking and screaming

Ric Taylor

>Paul,

I have the easy rougher, and I love it. It works very quickly and easily, and it should make work on your burl less stressful. I have the "windshield" also. I can't say that it is necessary, but it is nice to have.

There are demo videos of the tool in action out there, but at the moment I can't remember if they are at the tool website or on utube. You might check both places.

Ric

Re: Kicking and screaming

#3

Re: Kicking and screaming

robo hippy

>Some pieces of wood are just like that. Hard, silica in it, tough as nails. I don't think there is any easy way around it. You will have to take smaller cuts, and take your time. I do prefer scrapers as a roughing tool. Heavier than gouges, and less vibration. You won't get a finished surface with the scraper flat on the tool rest, but when doing a shear cut with one, once you know how, you can get just as good of a surface, after all, it is the same steel, and sharpened on the same grinders, it is all in how you present the tool to the wood. The only way I could give you any real help is to be in your shop and see what you are doing. I agree that the Hunter and Eliminator carbide disc tools are great for finish cuts, but lousy for roughing. The Easy Rougher might work better. You could get just the cutters and make your own tool.

robo hippy

Re: Kicking and screaming

#4

Re: Kicking and screaming

Steve Harder

>Carbide inserts take a little practice but, at least for me, work much differently and better than the traditional scraper when used for tough rough outs.

If you can make your own handles and tool holder then search on ebay for "Carbide Insert Knives 14mm x 14mm x 2mm #IC-2014144" -- that will get you 10 carbide inserts including shipping for under $20. Those are roughly equivalent to EasyRougher knives.

And my personal opinion is the EasyFinisher Ci0 round insert is worth the $17 purchase price from Easy tools - it's great at doing final finishing that you would normally use a scraper with a light touch.

Re: Kicking and screaming

#5

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Kicking and screaming

Katherine Kowalski

>Have you ever thought about using a negative rake scraper (for finishing?) I too believe in making fine cuts with a bevel-floating cut. However, using a negative rake scraper allows you to get rid of the tiny little bevel marks in the surface, smoothing it to a fine curve. It's like using med-grit sandpaper... but with much finer control.

(I would not, however, recommend a negative rake scraper for roughing -- the edge is very fine and should be used only for finishing cuts).

Re: Kicking and screaming

#6

Re: Kicking and screaming

Barry Elder

>What kind of burl is this monster that has you so upset? Is it a rock, sand, dirt, and silica type of burl like many of them? Those we have to live with! As a last resort, send it to me and I will make sure it is sorry it every offended you (grin)!!

Re: Kicking and screaming

#7

Steven Antonucci

Overpriced tools

steve antonucci

>Whether the tool works or doesn't, the pricing on all of the carbide tools is ridiculous. Get a catalog like Enco's and look at what they charge for steel stock and carbide cutters, and make your own.

You do not need to be a machinist to do it. Having the surface perfectly flat and square is great, but not 100% necessary. I usually work with a cutoff wheel and a file, and you can get 99% of the results without a machine shop.

I drill my screw by hand and tap them by hand as well. Never had one fail.

I'm guessing you can make one for about $10.

steve

Re: Kicking and screaming

#8

Re: Kicking and screaming

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

>Paul I turned a piece of Teak one time. Not large but I wanted something to toss my change into. The first pass with my Ellsworth gouge cut pretty well. The second not so good and the third was a disaster. Sharpened the tool and the same thing happened...three passes and time to sharpen. Finally the light dawned. I put a carbide router bit in my Jacobs chuck and used that for most of the cuts. That Teak must have been full of silica (sand.) Not a great solution, but it worked!

Re: Kicking and screaming

#9

Re: Kicking and screaming

john lucas

>Paul I'm not a believer in scrapers either. At least not for final shaping. The can be used successfully for roughing but I feel I don't get a clean enough cut (scrape) and can't control the shape accurately enough with a scraper held flat.

Now shear scraping is another matter. With a fresh burr and held properly a shear scraper will leave an excellent finish.

I have turned some incredibly hard wood over the years. A bowl gouge has always worked. I've had some woods dull the tool so fast that you could only cut half way down a bowl before it needed sharpening. That may be your problem.

Re: Kicking and screaming

#10

Re: Kicking and screaming

Paul Zerjay

>John

I don't know the exact rpm's I was spinning this burl. No more than 400 I'm sure. I am willing to bet I could not keep a gouge sharp for longer than 30 seconds, which is roughly 200 revolutions.

A good friend of mine (I may have to re-think that) gave me this burl. He is the brother of the owner of a well known hardwoods dealer here in St.Louis. It was labeled as Ramoan when I got it. I could see that someone had tried to turn this burl before, as it had spur center marks on it, and gave up. Who knows how old this thing is, but I'm determined.

Re: Kicking and screaming

#11

Are you sure it's not petrified wood :)

john lucas

>

Re: Kicking and screaming

#12

+1 What Steve Said!

Texian

>

Re: Kicking and screaming

#13

Re: Kicking and screaming *LINK*

Fred

>I have all three of the Easy Wood Tools: Easy Finisher Ci0, Easy Rougher Ci1, and Easy Rougher Ci2. I've been turning with conventional tools for over 20 years and I consider these tools excellent for roughing out. The addition of the Easy Finisher took care of the inability to cut inside curves like the bottom of a bowl or goblet bowl. The work best at high speeds. I turned a goblet completely with the Easy Rougher Ci1 at 3000 rpm, except the very bottom of the goblet bowl. That required another tools. the Easy Finisher Ci0 would have eliminated that problem. My wife and I both use these tools and find them very useful. They do not behave like a scraper and you definately do not have to sharpen very often.


More Woodturning magazine home page

Re: Kicking and screaming

#14

Re: Kicking and screaming

Jim Sebring

>I bought a CI1 and the deflector over a year ago. I used the deflector once, then put it aside. I suppose if you had a huge, soaking wet blank it might be useful, but I think it's overkill for the most part. I do use my CI1 as the first tool when roughing large, out of balance blanks to round. That big, strong shaft just makes me feel real secure during the initial bouncing around phase.