Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?
Andrew DiPietro
>David Ellsworth was the judge who made the comment. Thanks for your comments.
Andy DiPietro
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?
Andrew DiPietro
>David Ellsworth was the judge who made the comment. Thanks for your comments.
Andy DiPietro
David Ellsworth said it
steve antonucci
>but he didn't mention Mike Mahoney's well publicized kitchen set or Molly Winton's basket weave pattern on the same piece for the second place finisher (no offense to #2).
This is a sticky subject and their are folks at either extreme. I know Andy's work at a glance as I know your work at a glance, and while similar, I think it would be silly to refer to Andy's as a knock-off so dismissively.
You also validate that there might be room in the world for two guys to make elongated box elder vessels. Thanks for stepping in...
Ditto
steve antonucci
>
Re: You GO, Daddy-O
Keith Tompkins
>Hey Brad! It's good to see you back! Sorry I couldn't spend more time with you in Derry!
Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?
Jim Shaver
>Beautiful work, I think it's great.....
I always get a kick out of the silly comments of who is who and who owns what when it comes to turning, come on get serious, some people get so "Special" about being "so famous" for something that doesn't matter at all. The design is in the hands of who creates it, that judged comment was lame.
Just glad I didn't display my considered pepper mill entry , it would have caused a fire storm all on it's own, LOL..
Jim
A few nice articles abbout Andy *LINK*
Ron in Drums PA
>
http://www.woodartforms.com/4.html
Re: yes, I own the patent on all shapes!
Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan
>You all owe me MONEY!!!!
Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?
RonZ
>Woodturning goes back at least 3000 years to Egypt and pottery goes back to the dawn of time. No one can own a shape unless proven that they originated it.
Re: yes, I own the patent on all shapes!
Keith Tompkins
>Bruce, you can't patent a shape, but you CAN copyright it. For real!
Pomposity reigns supreme....sigh....
Mike Stafford
>There is not a shape under the sun that is not reproduced in nature in one fashion or another. For someone to think that a particular shape is "owned" is the ultimate in pomposity.
Absurd.....
Re: Pomposity reigns supreme....sigh....
Keith Tompkins
>Mike, the shapes I was referring to (half-jokingly) are copyrighted materials. Any shape may be copyrighted, even words or individual letters. Look at ANY product you buy...notice the little "r" in a circle or the letter "c" anywhere on the product cover? It is a registered copyright, and can used by only the owner of the copyright. Absurd? 3M (another copyright in itself) corporation has copyrighted the color purple...only they have the right to manufacture purple colored abrasives...I could go on and on. What we may think of as silly or absurd means serious business to some
If you ever get a chance, read a bit about copyrightable material. You will be in for a shock.
Re:You are mostly right Keith, but ....
Jamie Donaldson
>...you're mixing in trademark and trade dress protection as well as copyright. And of course without registration it means nothing!
Re:You are mostly right Keith, but ....
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Without deep pockets none of it means much, even patents. You have to be wealthy enough to defend your rights in court.
plato is spinning in his grave
karl
>anyone heard of platonic forms?
Re:So Karl, have you been reading ......
Jamie Donaldson
>...Plato's Republic or Timaeus?
Voltaire's Candide might be more appropriate
George Taylor
>Let's just worry about "tending our own little garden..."
that is more ellsworth
bob davis
>
Re: Pomposity reigns supreme....sigh....
Mike Stafford
>Keith, my "sigh" was not in response to anything that you said. In fact I agree with most of your comments.
My sigh was about the fact that a specific shape had been assigned ownership to someone who may or may not have made a similar shape.
My comment was more to the fact that anyone who decides that they own a specific shape that is similar to anything in nature is being arrogant and pompous to an extreme. It seems that many artists have let the title go to their heads.
For a judge to make such a comment as was referenced in the beginning of this thread illustrates that point for me. Even if the shape was identical to something that Mr. Jordan once turned I am willing to bet that some time in the past someone else created a similar shape in wood, pottery etc. To suggest that someone owns a shape is the height of arrogance. I get very tired and bored of the elite in this craft/hobby/art form deciding what is art; what is not etc.
Pompous elitists all....
Re: Pomposity reigns supreme....sigh....
Keith Tompkins
>Agreed, Mike! There is a place for things such as copyright protection but turned shapes are not the place...I just thought of something: Why we are free to use ancient forms as we please; nobody owns them, they are public domain free for the taking.
Re: yes, I own the patent on all shapes!
Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan
>Keith, Darn, that's what I get for hiring my brother-in-law as my attorney.
Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?
Betty Scarpino
>For anyone interested in reading more about copying and making art (or in our case, woodturning), I'd like to suggest a book, "No More Secondhand Art: Awakening the Artist Within" by Peter London. He addresses most of the concerns raised in this thread in a way that inspires and uplifts.
Re:Can you own..Imitation is the Finest Form
JohnKyler
>If I recall a few years back in Provo on a panel with, Mike Mahoney David Nittmann, Cindy Drozda, and Ken Sager..... Cindy or David said something like this....Imitation is the Finest Form of Flattery..
Re: Pomposity reigns supreme....sigh....
John Jordan
>You might note that Mr. Jordan has indicated he had no issue with this. :)
John
Re:Can you own..Imitation is the Finest Form
Don at Central Illinois
>I always thought plagerism was when you took someone elses work (be it word, art, etc.) and passed it off as your own. In essence, taking someone else work and claiming it as yours.
Re: Pomposity reigns supreme....sigh....
John Jordan
>And to add:
This all has very little to do with right or wrong, ownership, copyright or anything like that. It has to do with perception.
Certain things are visually connected with certain people. If one makes a nice shapely bowl from Norfolk Island Pine, the neighbor lady may say "oooohhhh". Someone may gladly buy it at a local craft show. But if you submit it to a contest, or approach a major gallery or collector, you now have Ron Kent in the deal with you. The image of the material is so strongly related to Ron, it can't be avoided. It doesn't have anything to do with "ownership" or right or wrong, it's just how it is. See a thin boxelder piece with piercing an oriental-themed airbrushing, or a little exotic wood container standing on a spindle base with a long, detailed finial, we think of certain people-same deal. We like making them and seeing them posted here, and people enjoy making them, but if theses pieces are entered into competitions/exhibitions/shows and such, the people that are most strongly associated those pieces will come into the picture.
I wish David had not made the statement the way he did, but the fact is I made many pieces not unlike the piece Andy entered, and I made many of them in boxelder. Since it's been a long time since I made those, the similarity would probably occur to people that have been around a long time. That's understandable even if it's not apparent, particularly those that may not be familiar with the history of our small field of woodturning.
Everyone that reads here and on WOW recognizes Andy's work because he is productive, very focused the wonderful pieces he makes and he posts pictures frequently. That's how it works. He is interested in the same things that have interested me for many years-that's why I like his work and even comment on it occasionally. It's inevitable that sometimes things will look similar as he pursues a similar aesthetic. Is that the same as copying? Nope. Does that bother me? Nope. Does Andy want work he makes confused with someone else's work? I doubt it. Should it affect his work? Not really, but it's something to keep in mind as he goes forward, as we all must.
A major complaint in juried shows/exhibitions etc., is that there is rarely any feedback from the judges. Ellis has promoted his contests here on WC for a long time now. A positive part of this is feedback from the judges. As I said, I wish David had been less emphatic about "copying" because I know that's not the case, but it would not have been honest on his part to not speak to what he sees. And the point that can be taken is that people who have been involved with the turning field(or any media for that matter) MAY see similarities as well. And that is worth considering if one is interested in pursuing one's craft on another level. It doesn't help anyone if someone's work is *perceived* to be like someone else's, intentional or not.
This is not a "silly" conversation. Andy didn't think it was silly, or he wouldn't have brought it up. And in spite of what some may think, most of us who have been around a while doing exhibition/gallery work really like seeing new people and new work come along. It helps us all. The reason people are willing to jury exhibitions, critique work, write articles etc. is to pass along knowledge and be helpful. It's surely not for the big bucks that Ellis will pay. :)
I hang around here and WOW a bit because I like to see what woodturners are doing, hobbyist and "professional" alike.
John