Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Posts

Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#1

Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Andrew DiPietro

>I would like to thank Ellis and all the judges for their time and effort in putting the Elegant Form contest together.

I am responding to a comment for general discussion purposes.

�I immediately gave it a low rating due to its being a direct copy of a John Jordan pot�

Any similarity between my form and an earlier John Jordon form is purely coincidental.

I based my design on a Catenary Curved sides and bottom blended into a rounded top with a small collar opening. This is a shape I developed on my own and in my shop after turning hundreds of hollow forms. It is probably more likely that an Egyptian or Roman potter created this shape first or someone else in antiquity.

So as modern woodturners can we lay claim to a simple shape that we turn in wood?


img

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#2

Re:Such a statement from a judge....

Jamie Donaldson

>... in this example is nonsense! There are very few turners who will ever design a unique new shape, and any such shape is a derivitive from prior examples. John Jordan didn't invent his forms, but benefitted from many examples he had seen in his past studies of other resources, then added his own design elements such as surface enhancements that identify his style, which has changed many times over his turning career.

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#3

Of Course Not!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I agree with Jamie; no need to repeat it.

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#4

I Agree With Jamie!!...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#5

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

john lucas

>I've seen a lot of John's work and although it might resemble one of John's pieces, there are lots of other shapes he uses. I think that was a misguided point. I'll bet you can find pottery from 1000 years ago that resembles that shape. Although I'm a firm believer in not copying someones work (other than to learn the technique or for personal satisfaction) I think this thing is going a little too far.

Beautiful piece by the way and a very elegant form.

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#6

Steven Antonucci

An to think, I was going to e-mail you about this!

steve antonucci

>I read that comment in your piece and a few others. I think that the subject of plagiarism is a funny one. If I read David's comments at face value, you can be influenced by other turners, but you can't copy them. It is perfectly OK to copy Southwestern Indian forms in wood because you somehow make them your own by changing the material from clay to wood.

I thought David's opinion was overstated and oversimplified. Why is plagiarism such a topic these days? I believe it is because the technology and training has enabled a great many folks to quickly match the technical skills of the "old masters". We do not need to innovate or reinvent a process to accomplish- it's all relatively simple to get to the basic shapes.

Simply put- each piece of wood requires it's own treatment at the hands of the maker. If you are striving for pure form, there are few options out there, and they've all been "taken". You are likely to be compared to someone at some point, so I just go with it.

If someone can own a shape, I'm calling "round"...so stop copying me!

Steve

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#7

Re: An to think, I was going to e-mail you about t

Don at Central Illinois

>No worrys from my end. I can't make anything round, only egg shaped and that not very well.

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#8

Balderdash!

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I also agree with Jamie. Insinuating that someone "owns" a particular form is like saying that one particular painter "owns" a color. All ANY artist or artisan owns is their technique and their interpretation.

BTW, I love the color on this piece. From the angle of this photo, it is quite spectacular.

keithz

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#9

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Curly Smith

>I think it's a "throw away" line that doesn't mean anything. It's the result of having to evaluate "X" number of forms and having to write evaluations on each.

If you read DE's comments on the other pieces you'll find "not elegant" heavily represented. For this piece I think he's simply trying to find a way to say "There is nothing technically wrong with it but it doesn't do anything for me and it doesn't deserve to win".

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#10

Brad Vietje

NO, but a good topic for discussion...

Brad Vietje

>Andy,

I've turned a lot of hollow forms, and I can tell you, that's a really beautiful vessel! I love the form, the finish, and the wood selection, and the fact that John Jordan has made some a lot like it is of no concern to me.

David Ellsworth will probably take some well-deserved crap for some of his comments, but I respect him not only as one of the world's greatest turners, but someone who has brought a lot of art to the craft of wood turning. I suspect he's defending a strongly held position regarding plagiarism, which is his right, but I don't agree.

Some entries were "marked down" for being too much like those of relatively famous turners, with the pejorative and way-too-obvious implication of forgery or plagiarism. Is every long & elegant finial an assault on Cindy Drozda ? Are all hollow forms derived from the work of David Ellsworth or John Jordan? HELL no. Might there be other, less well-known turners in other lands who are as innovative and talented as Ellsworth, Hunter, Lindquist, et al, or do we have to have a piece in the Mason or Horne collections to be "real" wood turners?

I can make a pretty decent hollow form, and occasionally I can even create a finial that rivals those of -- (dare I write it?) -- Cindy Drozda. That doesn't make me a plagiarist or a phony or a cheat, just someone trying to do the finest work I can. When we really look at the shapes considered beautiful or elegant, most are those forms that have endured through not centuries, but millennia -- perhaps even eons. David and Cindy and John and William and were not around to invent them, and it's ridiculous that they would take credit for doing so. When we hit upon a real eye-popper, we have more than likely re-discovered a classic, elegant form, and not coined something unique. When I occasionally get it just right, and create a top-notch piece, does that threaten someone like David Ellsworth? Hardly.

And here's why: David Ellsworth is famous, and I am not.

And let's not get all wide-eyed here, either: David Ellsworth, William Hunter, and Richard Raffan, along with a dozen or two others, are "famous" among a self-selecting group of wood-turning enthusiasts and wood art collectors from around the world -- a very, VERY small pond, indeed! They are not famous like Desmond Tutu or Nelson Mandela or Mother Theresa, or the Dali Lama.

Now, I suppose Cezanne and Chopin were, at one time, well-known to only a few hundred or even a few hundred thousand people, and they surely are very well-known now. But, they're also both dead, so let's keep all this ego stuff in perspective -- you can leave behind a reputation and a body of work -- even a portfolio of great works, but you can't take all that fame and fortune with you when you exit.

People collect the works of well-known turners, and not even my mother collects mine. Thus, an elegant piece with their signature on it is worth a LOT more than one of mine -- even if mine is occasionally just as nice. The people who want a beautiful, well made piece might spend $400 with me instead of $4,000 with David Ellsworth. I would submit that those customers don't recognize the higher value of the more collectible piece, or the value of collecting works of that famous artist, so they wouldn't be shelling out the extra $2,600 anyway! For those that want a beautiful turned object, any number of us here at WC or at WOW could satisfy their need. If they're a serious collector, and want a Jordan or Hunter or Ellsworth original, they will recognize, and thus value, the added expense involved in buying one.

There are many turners who make perfectly beautiful hollow forms, finials, and other turned elements, but that doesn't make their work forgeries or copies, nor the turner guilty of a sin or a crime. After all, some people want a nice painting, not a Monet.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#11

Well said Brad

Mike Nelson

>

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Andy, This was an impressive turnout with some spectacular pieces. Your piece is quite elegant, and worthy of much praise. Here's the problem, as I see it.

First, there are many demonstrators and teachers who teach how to achieve good forms. As you probably know, I'm one of those who stress design issues, and I use the catenary in all of my presentations to show the power of a flowing curve. I did not conceive the catenary concept, by the way...the ancient Romans used it freely, I simply borrowed it. Frankly, if one follows my instruction of where to place the emphasis point on a form, and connects the elements of the form together with flowing curves, the resulting piece would look strikingly similar to the shape you entered....it's a very pleasing, organic shape. By applying the same guidelines,the only real difference between various turned forms would be the overall dimensions of the original blank....some tall and narrow, some short and squat, but all with the same flowing lines. You can see this same shape throughout history in all media. So it shouldn't be a big surprise when many turners begin to create similar, beautiful pieces....the shape is inevitable.

It's a completely different topic when someone is trying to establish themselves as an artist..if their work "looks" to similar to an established maker, they're dismissed as copycats, or worse. Seems the world is always looking for the new and exciting. The galleries and collectors are always looking for new, readily identifiable works. My take on your piece is not that it is a Jordan copy; (which I don't believe it is) rather, by viewing the image, it's impossible to say who really made it.

I particularly liked the blue-painted fish sculpture, which I would have included in the finalist selection. It was dismissed because it retained a foot. I have often wondered why turned pieces with a foot are frowned upon, but seems to be the norm in other fields, especially glass. I spoke with a few prominent glass blowers, who told me that in their opinion, the piece in not complete without a foot, which adds a sense of lift. It may exhibit a Ron Layport influence, but nobody has a sole license on fish, or for that matter leaves, flowers, or any other natural shape. If I create a piece with carved feathers,(which I am in the process of) am I infringing on the rights of Mr. Vesery or the millions of decoy carvers throughout the world? No, I'm creating a piece based on my own opinion of "elegant".

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#13

Brad Vietje

You GO, Daddy-O

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#14

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Barry Elder

>I subscribe to the philosophy that there is nothing new under the sun! And that definitely applies to shapes and forms. Plagiarism refers to the written word and you have to get nit-picky to use it to eliminate a turned wood piece or a piece of pottery or a piece of art, etc., ad infinitum!

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#15

Steven Antonucci

You should use a calculator :-)

steve antonucci

>or you'd be giving away a $1000 with every Ellsworth!

Just bustin' chops! Welcome back!

Steve

P.S. I freely plagiarize the acorn tops you make, and everyone I know thinks they are mine!

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#16

Brad Vietje

OOPS -- that would be $3,600 ;^)

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#17

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Barry Turner

>I'm no student of design and shape, but have always believed there are only so many classic shapes in the world. If we tried to never duplicate a shape that had already been done, a lot of lathes would be sitting idle.

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#18

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Eduardo Sarmiento-Hall

>Any one try t copy,malliard,escoulen,or others in that league?love to see someone try,lol

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#19

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Cyril Griesbach

>Andy, I have nearly always been able to identify your forms as yours whenever I've seen them posted here or on WOW. I'm also pretty good at identifying those of John Jordan and I don't believe he'd make such a foolish statement.

Now why wasn't that same statement made on some of the other forms? Surely they could be attributed to some other, most likely ancient, maker.

This whole issue comes up now and again and it's always the same pile of cow cookies.

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#20

Re: Thanks!

Andrew DiPietro

>Thanks everyone for taking your time to post your comments and insights. I am no stranger to receiving constructive criticism from woodturners who have more experience and talent then me. I post my work regularly on the WOW website and invite constructive criticism as well as give it too.

I make no claims on the shapes I use as being unique, but I think they are a little different then most turners use. I do believe it was wrong to be told that I made a direct copy of J.J. pot.

I was excited to enter this competition and I am not so sure I will be next time.

Enough said from me.

Thanks

Andy DiPietro

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#21

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Bill Crommett

>I claim ownership of several shapes, all ugly from my beginning days. But, ugly or not they are mine - all -- mine.

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#22

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

John Jordan

>Who was the judge? I don't see it, really and I haven't done anything remotely like in years. Don't let it bother you. there's lots more to the work than just the form. :)

John

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#23

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

Joe Landon

>Andy, I immediately recognized this as a classic "Andy" form prior to them posting your name on it.

Joe

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#24

Re: NO, but a good topic for discussion...

rick pixley

>This conversation reminds me of a couple of quick stories..

Once,at my home in Fl I had a senior turner and somewhat professional look at some of my early work and compare it to some later pieces. He said my first turnings looked like the proverbial "doggy dishes" and my later ones were copies of his..I said so the egyptians and romans copied you too? End of that discussion..

What's in a name?

Once had the pleasure of a visit from JJ himself and after reprimandeing me about how dirty my stubbby was I decided to be a smart ass..I handed him a piece of my work and asked him to sign it,He said sure,that'll be 600 dollars...

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

#25

Re: Topic: Can you own a simple shape?

George Van

>Andy, what I appreciate about your work is the way you recognize the grain and figure in the wood and then chose an appropriate form to display your hunches. If you did it the other way your forms would not have your high success rate!