Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Thompson Bowl Gouges

Posts

Thompson Bowl Gouges

#1

Roger in MO

Thompson Bowl Gouges

Roger in MO

>Is there any advantage of the V vs. U shape bowl gouge?

Thanks Roger

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#2

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Sean Troy

>V's will make it easier for a shear/push cut and u's can remove more material in a pass. They both have thier use but it depends on what your comfortable with.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#3

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Texian

>Roger,

I think that Doug discusses that on the website. Most people find the V to be more versatile, but it depends somewhat on what you are used to. I got a 5/8 U, which (it turned out) did not fit my turning needs at all. Doug very graciously traded me a V for the virtually unused U.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#4

Great person to deal with

Bill Howatt

>He's so good to deal that I think he might be even a notch up on Lee Valley and that's saying something. I had a shipping problem with my order and I am more than pleased on how he dealt with it!

Bill

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#5

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>I prefer the V shape with a fingernail grind for general turning -- both of the inside and outside of the bowl. But I use a U, sharpened almost straight across (no fingernail) with a secondary bevel so the working bevel is only about 1/8 inch deep for finishing the insides of bowls. Main bevel on this one is about 45 degrees.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#6

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>I can go just a hair faster with my V gouge over the U gouge, and I prefer the V for most of my cuts. I don't think a person could go wrong with either one.

Disclaimer: Doug has named a gouge with my name, so I do have something of a financial interest in this - for one gouge anyway. ;-)

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Steve Kubien

>Initially I prefered the U-shape. I found it easier to control and get a nice cut, inside and outside of a bowl. In fact, the V-shape sat lonely for a couple of months. Lately I have been using the V more and find it easier for push and pull cuts. When I have to shear scrape, the U-shape is still more to my liking. In both cases, I am talking about the 1/2" size. I also have a 3/8" U which is sweet in tight spaces.

Steve

-One more thing, the V-shape seems stiffer though that could be that I've got it mounted in a Peebles handle and the U-shape is a homemade wooden one. Love the Peebles handle BTW!

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#8

Steven Antonucci

You would benefit from both

steve antonucci

>The V is a "go to" tool, but the U steers better inside a bowl (at least the way I have ground mine.

If I had to pick one, it would be the V, but luckily, I don't have to be that decisive.

Steve

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#9

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Texian

>Never thought about naming my Thompson gouges; maybe for my cats, Missie Muffin (5/8V) and Christine (1/2V.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#10

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Texian

>Good point about the 1/2" and 3/8" U. Would like one of the latter, but no more tools for a while. Maybe next year.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#11

Thanks Steve

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>It is terrific to get the feedback.

I also like the V shape, but that has been my favorite for many years. I first used it on the Glasers, but I find Doug's a little less severe... by that I mean not quite as V as Jerry's. Doug's V has a little rounder bottom. It seems just right for my style of turning and the grind I use on it.

Dave

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#12

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

robo hippy

>I prefer the V gouge. I have one of the Glaser V gouges, and don't like it too much, too steep of a V. Dougs U gouge is more of a C gouge to me. I like it, but to get the best finish cut, I do lay it on its side more than I do the V. As to which will remove the most wood in one pass, for me, it is the one that is ground back the most on the wings, but I prefer scrapers for roughing work.

robo hippy

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#13

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

john lucas

>Maybe it's just my style of working but I don't notice a nickels worth of difference in the V vs U gouge. I like the shape of the cutting edge on the wings of the V for general overall cutting. The wings tend to have a thicker cutting angle which holds an edge better.

my way of grinding my U gouge leaves the wings with a much thinner cutting angle. I find this very handy for pull cuts on wood that is being difficult and also for shear cutting. It's sort of like using a skew vs a scraper. The cutting edge is thinner but loses the edge quicker.

For general push cuts I don't see any real difference in the two other than the actual shape of the tip. That is assuming the tip angle is the same. The V shaped gouge has a smaller rounded tip which can be tricky to sharpen if you don't pay attention. The nose can get pointy real quick.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#14

Re: I learned to turn with the Sorby .....

Jamie Donaldson

>....U flute, and stick with it now. The rounded flute exposes more cutting surface to the wood, and more efficiently evacuates shavings without clogging. It is also easier to sharpen, especially for beginners.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#15

Re: I learned to turn with the Sorby .....

Rick Bane

>I have both the u and v in 1/2 inch size as well as a 5/8 u shape. I use the 5/8 for most of my larger cuts and fine tune with the 1/2 v. I can't say enough positive things about the Thompson tools. I have had mine for a while and the edge holds longer than any other tool I have used. Let alone the fact that Doug is such a nice guy!!

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#16

Aage Rendalen

Sharpening my Thompson is a problem....

Aage Rendalen

>I have a 5/8 V-shaped Thompson gouge and find it difficult to sharpen compared to my workhorse, the Crown Ellsworth gouge. Any tips?

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#17

Re: Sharpening my Thompson is a problem....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Could you explain what the problem is when sharpening, the Ellsworth is oval and mine is a radius with straight wings.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#18

Roger in MO

Re: Thanks V vs U Thompson Bowl Gouges

Roger in MO

>Many thanks to all who responded. It sounds like I should get both!

Well, Christmas is coming so I'll have to get my letter written.

Roger

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#19

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

Russ Fairfield

>Don't forget there is a compromise, the Superflute which is a parabolic cross between the V and U and offers the best of both. I don't think Doug makes this flute profile.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#20

Re: I don't know if he still makes....

Jamie Donaldson

>...the parabolic flute gouges, but I have one of his early prototypes that is a gem for spindle turning, especially finials and similar items.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#21

Re: Sharpening my Thompson is a problem....

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>The steel, itself, should sharpen as easily as the steel in the Ellsworth gouge. Is it the angle? As Doug mentioned, the shape is a bit different,. I have found that a bit of experimenting and I can reproduce practically any grind out there on my Thompson tools. I now have close to 20 of Doug's tools and have replaced Crowns, Sorbys Hamlets, and practically every other make out there without difficulty.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#22

Aage Rendalen

It just doesn't get as sharp

Aage Rendalen

>Sorry I'm late in responding. I have your V-gouge and I sharpen it according to the instruction sheet. My problem is that the edge does not get as sharp as the Crown gouge off the grinding wheel. It seems to need additional honing.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#23

Re: It just doesn't get as sharp

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Without seeing the tool this is what I found from the past. A grinding wheel will leave the same scratches no matter what steel is it used on. The jig leg angle shown in the sharpening guide works best around the 60 degree nose angle. If you could take the time to take a picture and post it here or in a email I work to get this figured out.

Re: Thompson Bowl Gouges

#24

Aage Rendalen

Will try some more

Aage Rendalen

>It may be that I'm just more conversant with the Crown gouge. Tonight I paid more attention to the sharpening and it came out fine and cut well. It may be that it's my technique that has been inconsistent since I early on put it aside because of the sharpening issue and that I haven't used it that much. If the problem recurs, I'll email you a picture of how I grind it.