Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Posts

Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#1

Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Rick Davenport

>I did a three day Arts Festival last weekend.

One of the larger festivals in the state of Washington.

The local AAW chapter did demos throughout the show at a location nearby.

They had a number of items for sale at absolutely rock bottom prices.

This undercut me and the other turners who paid to be in the show and looked forward to some actual income from the endeavor.

In addition, dozens of the local turners came to my booth and felt obligated to critique my work and trade info on methods, tools and equipment.

They usually parked smack dab in the middle of the booth, blocking out potential paying customers.

My wife was very good at herding them, but a few were still oblivious to the fact that I was trying to conduct business and ignored her efforts.

At that point I had to bluntly tell them to get out of the way.

I know all of these folks meant well, but I hope they read this and understand the impact their friendly visits can have on woodturners who chose to spend the time and effort to participate in Art Shows.

The festival had lots of quality artists in all mediums and was very well attended by people who wanted to spend money.

And I did fairly well in sales, but less than I had hoped for.

I plan to participate next year but may not if the AAW demo coincides with the festival.

Has anyone else experienced something like this?

R

On the positive side, two of the locals came back later and gave me some local turning wood (yew and madrone) just because they were nice folks and had extra wood on hand.

Thank you very much!

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#2

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Rick Davenport

>And I don't mean turners shouldn't stop by and visit, they just need to be aware of what's going on around them.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#3

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

bob davis

>you probably willnot see many woodturners in the future

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#4

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Rick, I have some observations and some similar experiences to relate. On the one hand, I am a firm believer in the free market. People should be able to sell their work for whatever they want to sell it for. Caveat emptor, let the buyer beware, holds true. Not all turners are turning out work of similar quality. Not all customers have wallets or priorities of the same size. Some people will be happy to get $10.00 for a bowl, and some people do not mind owning a $10.00 bowl with tool marks, poor form, or scratches. Some people will sometimes find a very well done bowl by someone who doesn't realize the worth of his or her work too.

Regarding people who take up valuable time and space, unfortunately, there is no shortage of them, and to the best of my knowledge, no way to (politely) get rid of them. Everywhere you go you are going to find people who have the need to impress you with their knowledge of the craft, or their knowledge of someone else who has knowledge of the craft. You know the saying, "If I had a dime for every person who told me I should see so and so's work..." We have counteracted this in the past by having my wife interrupt to tell me a customer needed help. The real persistent ones though, would wait until I was done so they could continue their story where they left off. The good news is, these extreme ones are rare.

My view on the whole thing is this: I do my work to the best of my ability. The people who are going to appreciate it at the prices I set will recognize it for what it is worth. The people who are buying the rock bottom stuff aren't going to buy my stuff anyway. I do get the occasional person who tells me that my work is not worth what I am asking (in so many words). My reply is that most people agree with them. That always comes as a shock to that person, but it is true. If it weren't, I would be churning out bowls by the thousands to keep up with the demand.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#5

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

john lucas

>Rick It's not just turners. I visit a lot of friends who are at art shows because I photograph for them. I have seen this happen in all mediums. When I'm talking to my friends I try to be aware of others who come into the booth and step aside so my friend can wait on them.

As the artist you also have to learn to politely excuse yourself and visit the new people who might actually purchase something. It's a hard game to play.

Being undercut on price is something that is always a problem in woodturning and I don't know the solution. Anyone has the right to sell at any price they like but it does suck when someone who is retired and simply trying to make some money to pay for their hobby is underselling those who are still working and trying to make a living. I've been on both sides so I can say that I'm guilty. I was doing demos once where I was paid very little and allowed to sell. I sold several items pretty low because I wanted some gas money. I hated to do that but necessity is a mother. I've also been at a show where I was selling at fair prices and had a gentleman selling below my cost. If someone has a good answer please come forward.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#6

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Rick, I understand your frustration. If the club in question paid the same fee as you then there is really nothing that anyone could do. If they did not pay the same fee you have a very legitimate complaint to lodge with the organizers.

It is always a shame when artists undervalue their work.

At our local juried show, local artists can set up a demo or just a display in the provided tent. They do not pay to be there but they are not allowed to sell. Anyone who wants to sell has to have their work accepted and pay the fee.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Brad Vietje

>Hey Rick,

Some people are simply oblivious to the world around them, and some small percentage just don't get it. You are absolutely right that some people completely fail to understand that you are there to *sell stuff* in addition to visiting, and they can really block potential customers from seeing your work or meeting with you personally.

A few thoughts do occur to me:

Could you join the AAW affiliate, or are they not the closest one for you? By knowing these folks better, you can probably prevent some future friction.

Could you plan to visit briefly with them at their booth, and then make it clear that talking turning and selling turnings are two different things "OOPS -- gotta go talk to my customers..." or a loud-ish whisper about making room for the customers who want to see your work.

Now, don't take this the wrong way -- Is there any merit to any of their concerns about your work? If you conduct a pretty rigorous self-examination of your work, and you are pleased, you can be sure others will be, too. Usually we are our own worst critics. If your designs or workmanship are in any way not completely up to snuff, you can make some refinements for the next show. Otherwise, you'll just have to be a little more direct in shooing the bone-heads away!

In this economy, coming away with pretty good sales is a good thing; I hope the next sales event works out even better.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#8

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Barry Irby

>I've been on both sides of this.

Maybe we need a phrase like "I am enjoying your visit, but I really have to wait on this customer."

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#9

One answer is specialization

Curly Smith

>The best way to control your price is by producing a product that is unique. You can't compete selling a "walnut bowl" or a "set of candlesticks" or a "peppermill" unless your product is distinctly different from those produced by the average turner. You'll never compete with a "commodity" because the lowest cost producer always wins. You have to have something special.

Granted, that "something special" will likely take longer to make and will have a much more targeted audience because of the higher price. A good compromise might be an assortment of commodity items to pay the booth fee and your more specialized items that will actually generate a profit. However, there's a distinct possibility that placing low cost commodity items next to your higher cost unique items will devalue the unique items. Again, the lowest cost producer always sets the commodity prices so your $50 walnut bowl will be devalued to $10 by the retired weekend turner and your $250 bowl with exemplary pyrography will correspondingly be devalued by the same factor of 5 to $50.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#10

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Rick Davenport

>Don't get me wrong!

I like woodturners.

As a matter of fact, I've never met such a bunch of friendly, helpful folks.

I just wanted to raise awareness of the "agenda" of those who participate in Art Shows and the like.

My wife and I just about flipped out when a potential customer, back for the second time, was looking at a $200 natural edge Vietnamese rosewood bowl when a helpful lady called out: "My brother's a woodturner and he gave me one just like that for Christmas!"

No sale.

Gaaaahhhhhh!

R

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#11

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Bill Crommett

>On the other hand !! I was at an art show once as a visitor to a booth that had some great ear rings. I was about to purchase a set for my daughter when the artist spyed a fellow with a tee shirt from his old university. He completely ignored me and another potential customer to talk about the "Old School Stuff" So we both walked away.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#12

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Rick Davenport

>You're right Bill, it works both ways.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#13

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Dick Coers

>Hey Rick, nothing against professional woodturners, but maybe your sales techniques and people handling skills need a little tune up. If you approached all your interested prospects at the art show, like you start your rants on here, you may want to do some reading on salesmanship.

When I ran my own custom woodworking business, and showed at art shows, I quickly discovered that being a good woodworker was probably less than half the equation to success.

I've never been one to think that others affect my sales. It's the artisan and his product. If both are "right", it will sell.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#14

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Rick Davenport

>You missed my point entirely Dick.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#15

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Dick Coers

>I don't think I missed your point at all. I was just trying to suggest that sales skills are just not about the actual selling an item, it's about moving people, knowing how to handle difficult shoppers/gawkers, and the tactfulness used in the process.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#16

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>If it is any consolation similar happenings occur in the UK!

I'm afraid that because we are such friendly people and exchange our ideas freely plus many are purely hobbyists, many tend to forget that others are trying to earn a living!

Regards, Peter.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#17

Well said Peter

Rick Davenport

>

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#18

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Stuart Johnson

>It's not just at craft shows where aisles are blocked. This is a pet peeve of mine at instant galleries and at times in front of vendor booths. I wish fellow turners would stop blocking the aisles when they run into old or new friends and want to catch up on what has been going on for the last year. Please step off to the side out of the traffic flow. You can then talk with out all the rude people interrupting you asking to get past.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#19

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Rick Davenport

>Yikes!

It appears that I have stirred up a hornet�s nest!

I posted my thoughts to open a dialog about an issue that, to my knowledge, hasn�t been addressed here.

I am sure that the local AAW chapter at the show is quite upset with me.

I�ve even gotten concerned phone calls from members of the AAW chapter to which I do belong.

Thank you Bill, John, Barbara, Brad, Barry, Stuart, etc. for understanding what I was trying to say.

When you take the time, money and effort to build a quality inventory and spend money on fees, commissions, displays, lodging and travel to show your personal vision of wood art, it can be annoying when well meaning people make things just a bit harder for you to reach your goals.

I repeat: the fraternity of wood turners is unique in my experience. I have never met a nicer bunch of people - willing to help each other and exchange knowledge and ideas.

People like Jack Wayne, Hal Johnson, Molly Winton and Jack McDaniel have gone out of their way to help me develop into the wood turner (dare I say artist?) I am today.

I made some wonderful woodturning friends at the show last week. I got some new ideas. Maybe some even got ideas from me.

But at this juried art show, in a larger proportion than usual, I encountered a number of people who said and/or did things that were frankly frustrating.

Call me a whiner, a hack, an amateur, a jerk�.. whatever.

I can only hope that those who know me think otherwise.

And I hope we can all be a little more empathetic and aware in the future.

R

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#20

Steven Antonucci

Make them work for you

steve antonucci

>I am in sales for a living. There is no shortage of people who will consume your time if you let them. If you have qualified them as turners (who will never buy something from you), why not put them to work for you?

"Hey Joe, you turn to right? How much do you think that Vietnamese burl cost?"

"How long would it take you to get this finish, Joe?"

Etc.

If they validate your skill and your work, you may be able to have them hang around AND sell your work. Or they may not be comfortable with "selling for you" and just leave.

Either way, you get what you wanted without looking like the bad guy.

Steve

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#21

Re: Make them work for you

Hugh

>we have a woodshow here in Hamilton our guild is invited to demonstrate turning and solicite members but we are not allowed to sell any of our turnings, we can display them. As we are not charged a fee, this is fair, and I believe the main point Rick was getting at, if you are not paying a fee you should not be allowed to sell, whatever the price you sell for. Critiques and questions are part of the craft shows you can deal with, or another turner who has paid there entry fee and sells for less so be it....maybe seeing what they can get for the turnings will increase their price for the next show.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#22

Some people are ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>"positionally challenged". In another life I competed in sheepherding competitions with a couple of very bright border collies. One thing a herder must learn is how to position themselves so that the sheep can move where they need to go and that the herder mustn't block them from going there. This experience has made me overly sensitive to blocking aisles and being in the way.

I know a lady who will invite people into her home and then stand in the doorway and wonder why they don't come in. They can't because she is blocking them.

My point is simple: There are many people who are clueless about blocking aisles and there are other people whose self-importance allows them not to care.

If you have potential customers who can't approach your sales items because of "blockers" who are clueless, just ask those trying to move forward if they are unable to come forward and then say "Excuse me!" to the blockers with a big smile and say "These folks would like to see this bowl unless you are going to buy it." Chances are the blockers will move quickly. It's your booth, so you are in charge of traffic.

Ed

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#23

Marketplace determines price

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Sounds like you may been a victim of a sort of, Art/Craft "Dumping" That's life, It happens! If several people are selling very similar work, the lowest prices gets the business, period. I see price undercutting at most every art show I do. Competition is always the most intense at lower price levels. Someone, somewhere will ALWAYS undercut your price, and some will always have a production or material cost advantage. That's reality. . . That's supply and demand at work.

The best method to combat price undercutting is to find your own niche of original or unique offerings. Art Work that is truly unique has no real competition and therefore can fetch a wide range of prices, depending on the customers desires and finances. If no one can duplicate your work then no one can compete with you, much less undercut your price. If you are not doing original or unique works of art then you are probably more of a craftsman than an artist, and most craft prices are highly competitive.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#24

Re: Some people are ...

Brian George

>A GREAT topic, Rick!

It needs to be discussed often, IMHO.

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

#25

Re: Minor Rant at my fellow woodturners

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I keep coming back to this post so I have to respond. I would rather see a booth with people in and around than a booth that is DOA. People don't care where they stand so when your booth is crowded just say let's move out here and they will follow. Let your wife watch the booth until she needs help then excuse yourself and help... it's that simple.

Look at the reason why the show was only fair and not good, people in or around the booth wasn't nor was a comment from a passerby, if the product is unique no one could undercut the price. How did the other vendors do, is this a good show for wood art.