>I'v never tried DNA soaking,but I HATE WALNUT,sorry.I have had walnut crack while turnin it,crack after I rough turned it and sealed the end with anchor seal,wraped in chips in a bag an a few other times I can't think of,BUT I still turn the stuff.Don't ask me why,guess I just like pain.I guess that when I do win one it makes the sffort worth while.I guess what I am trying to is walnut can crack anytime any place.
>leave the inside of the bowl exposed to the air while wrapping the outside in the bag? You have to do that in order for the wood to dry properly.
I commonly leave roughed bowls in the DNA for more than 24 hours or longer. Length of time doesn't matter. What's important is that it's in there at least 2 full hours (I think...it's been so long that I've been leaving it in for 24 hours that I forget the exact time).
>I'm not too sure what condition the walnut was in prior to turning but, I typically leave my pieces in DNA for two to three days. I will rough turn one piece daily until I have three pieces in the alcohol, then as one comes out another goes in.
Pieces that have a major section close to the pith will have a tendency to crack more than other pieces.
I also double bag my pieces. Please note that I am in an area that has very low Rh. typically around 10%.
>What size is the bowl, what shape, how thick or thin, is the thickness even. All of these things affect it somewhat. One of the most common things among new turners is turning wood that already has cracks. You don't see them but if the wood is stored wrong or harvested incorrectly you risk losing it no matter what else you do.
I find Walnut to be one of the most forgiving woods I turn green. I have better luck storing it in log form and better luck with drying the green bowls. Cherry on the other hand apparently hates me but we are learning to accept each other. Maybe Obama will bring me and my cherry log over for Beer.
>John, I was thinking the same thing....often students bring their own wood to class; it's already worthless before they turn it. Many times when you see a crack on the end grain, it's caused damage far deeper than you may expect, and cracked bowls are the result. DNA or anything else for that matter won't help. Walnut is one of my favorites..go figure.
>I have found generally Black Walnut is one of the most stable woods I work with. Just off hand I cannot remember a bowl cracking, denatured alcohol or just paper bag. Now, I have sawn fast growing small logs that have violently cracked halfway up the log as I removed some of the outside. I think all of the walnut I have turned has come from very large logs.
>How come everybody has good luck with walnut cept me???Don't mean to hijack the the post,but probably 80% of mine get cracks in em,not necessarily so bad I can't use em.I mean wood thats been dried for 3 or 4 yrs,no splits till I'm bout done turnin em,then I notice those dog gone little hairline cracks.
>I think most of us are presuming you are roughing out the bowl in a short period of time, say <1 hour and then treating it from there. However, if you do part of it, walk off and have lunch, cut the grass, etc. without covering it with a plastic bag then you might be encouraging the damage you are finding. Roughing out is typically short and sweet and should ideally be done from start to finish in one go.
>There are a lot of variables. You don't give location information; that could be part of the problem (location, growing conditions, age of trees, humidity, etc., etc.).
I have left rough turnings soaking in DNA for six weeks or more with no bad effects. It is important to follow the process described in Dave's article, including wrapping the outside, leaving the inside exposed and upside down.
>I have soaked my walnut and other fruit bowls for about 5 days. I haven't had a problem with cracking. Crab apple and apple are the worst for cracking for me.
>I forgot to add one thing that I did have some walnut that had ring shake and it cracked all over the place no matter what I did. I chucked it all. I couldn't see any cracks when I started but they sure showed up after turning. I took it to a tree surgeon and he told me ring shake. I had never seen that before then until yesterday on some Russian Olive which he said got ring shake a lot.
>I would suggest you skip the alcohol to start with. Walnut is a very stable, easy to dry wood. If you have clear, clean wood without cracks to start, no pith or knots, it will dry without cracking if you prevent the outside from drying quicker than the inside(the inside of the thickness, not the inside of the bowl). It really is that simple.
Mike Mahoney, Dave Lancaster, Dan Bailey, Al Stirt turn tens of thousands of rough turned bowls a year. No alcohol soaking needed.
There's an article on my website that goes into some of the basics of turning with green wood.
I don't understand the need to spend good money for a very toxic product to soak your wood, in order to fix a problem that people who make a living turning don't seem to have.
>It sounds like the only thing you are doing different from me is the Alcohol. I never use the stuff. Well OK a little wine every now and then but not on my bowls.
Most people have problems with them cracking around the tenon but you said you made that thin which is good. You can get away with a thin base because you won't have much movement there. Your cracks seem to be on the side. I'll be interested in what others have to say.
The green honey locus I started with I had the cracks at the tenon but was told I probably had the bottoms too thick over the tenon. So I started turning these walnut bowls with thinner bottoms. Then I get crack like above in short order.
I guess I used the DNA since told it shortens the drying time and since I don't have much wood I want to keep turning what I got.
Enjoy just doing the turning but would like to end up with a final piece once in a while!
>I know if I post here it is how I learn. No problem with ANY comments.
With limited wood I have turned some green wood to finish shape and made 1/8" to 3/16" thin and let it find it's final shape. No cracks.
Watch Mike Mahoney turn a green calabash bowl in Albuquerque and looked at predicted shape the next day. Took the shape like your paper indicates and no cracks. Thin enough it could move.
If I had more wood probably would not be trying the DNA to speed up the time.
Seems I need to learn how thin to turn a given piece of green wood to allow movement without cracks and still be able to turn to final shape when dry.
>You said you have limited wood...is most of your walnut from the same tree? Is it trunk wood or limb wood? I don't think I have ever had a piece of walnut crack after I started turning it. One time I did spend a bunch of time cutting and hauling trunk wood from a huge walnut that went down at our church....nearly every piece had ring shake (unusual in walnut) that didn't show itself until a couple of weeks later.
>I used to have problems with the tenons checking on rough outs. I started turning the bottom+ tenon to the same thickness as the sides. For example the sides might be 3/4 and as it gets down toward the bottom the actual sides get a little thinner with the very bottom including the tenon is close to 3/4.
Since I do have problems with checking I coat the end grain portions with anchorseal and if it's a bowl I really don't want to lose I coat most of the outside with anchorseal. Since I brush it on it goes on pretty thin and doesn't seem to slow down the drying all that much. I put my fresh bowls on the garage floor. I've had severe checking if I put them up on the shelf 6 feet off the floor. I do move them up there after they've been on the floor for a month or so.
I've tried putting them in boxes and packed with shavings but then I get lots of mold which I discolors the bowl and I don't want to breath it.
You are obviously having some sort of drying problems with the checks as large and numerous as they are. The outside appears to be drying faster than the inside so you need to figure out how to slow that down. I've tried putting some paper on the outside of the bowls and leaving the inside open. Then place them upside down on a surface that allows them to breath. I usually only do this for bowls turned to completion, not rough turned, but it's something that might work for you.
As far as wanting to dry the bowls faster to get to them sooner, I can't offer a suggestion. It appears to me, since your doing things very similar me that the problem is the alcohol. My suggestion is to simply try and turn more rough bowls. Grab anything you can and turn it. In 6 months time you will have plenty of dry bowls to work with.
While I'm waiting or if I get excited about the new wood I just got I finish turn several. Usually these are natural edge bowls because I convinced myself I didn't like the warped bowls. However, I have been turning bowls lately with the bark down and the warp really hasn't been bad. In fact once I sand the bottom flat after they are dry most people won't notice that the bowl is slightly out of round. In this orientation the wood lifts at the pith. You can either plan for this by putting detail near the rim so you can accentuate the lift,(see Bill Luce's bowls) or you can cut the bowl shorter so the lip is further away from the heart. In this last case the lift of the rim won't be very noticeable to anyone other than a turner.
I hope this helps. I used to have lots of problems and now I don't. I think it's a combination of all the little things, but mostly it's turning the wood while it's really fresh, making sure I cut enough off the ends to avoid any checks and then sealing the endgrain areas with Anchorseal.