Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT- Digital Cameras

Posts

OT- Digital Cameras

#1

OT- Digital Cameras

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Have a question for the photographers here.

1. Going to get a dSLR; most likely a Canon EOS Rebel T1i. Comments?

2. Option is to go "body only" and stick a 18-270 [either Canon or Tamron] superzoom on it or go with the "stock" 14-55 and then add a 55-250 zoom at half the price. From my younger days with an OM-1 and a bag full of lenses, my tendency is to go with the 2-lens solution for better image quality and color.

Personal experience with these is appreciated. No, don't have the bucks for big Nikons with in-body IS, etc.

mm

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#2

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

john lucas

>Mark We have 2 of the "super zooms" a Tamron 18 to 200 and Nikon 18-200 with image stabilization. Both are good lenses. They flare a little when bright light shines in at an angle but most zooms do that nowdays. Both are acceptably sharp. I use the Nikkor 18-200 daily for professional photography and it's fine. My older 80-200 and 35-70 are both sharpen but marginally and much heavier and more expensive.

We have the Nikon 18 to 55 and they are sharper than the 18-200 but only when you blow an image up really big. The less expensive zooms are OK. It depends on what your final quality needs to be. For the most part there's very little difference in the quality of the image. There are differences in the ability to take abuse. I think the zooms with less range have fewer complicated internal movements and seem to last longer. You do have to take into account that our lenses are handled by students who didn't pay for them and consequently don't take care of them like you and I might.

Another consideration is changing lenses. When you change lenses you risk getting dirt on the sensor. This happens a lot. You can clean the sensor but you better be really careful. I've damaged a camera to the tune of $250 dollars when I caught the shutter with the cleaning tool. I've been doing camera repair off and on for a long time and it was fluke thing but it can happen. If you have a super zoom you simply don't change lenses. Takes care of that problem.

I'm very happy with my Nikkor 18-200 and have purchased one for my personal camera as well.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#3

Re: I haven't researched the prices, but....

Jamie Donaldson

>... have always been cautious about hanging brand X lenses on bodies and expecting them to be as good as the good stuff. The superzooms are getting better all the time, but often are slower(in max. aperture), often have limited close focus ranges, and give a dimmer image in the VF. I would stick with the kit lenses, then upgrade when you find it necessary for your purposes.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#4

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

Rick Allen

>I have the same lens that Jon is talking about. It's a great lens which is almost always found on my camera. If that was the only lens I had I would be satisfied.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#5

Traveling Light

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The camera is being purchased for my son's honeymoon with including travel in some fairly dusty areas. I'm therefore wonder if the superzoom might be better since it will stay on the camera and eliminate lens changing and dirt infusion opportunities.

Seems to come down to a choice between the Canon 18-200 and the Tamron 18-270. The Canon is a little brighter at 3.5 - 5.6 as opposed to 3.2 to 6.3, and they're both about the same price.

Further suggestions??

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#6

Ditto

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Mark,

I also have the Nikon D80 with the 18 - 200 and I love it, sometimes i wish it had a macro function, but for most situations is a great lens.

You can save some dinero going the D40 route, a smaller sister of the D80 with virtually identical capabilities.

I have no personal experience with Canons, but my 3 daughters have them and all three have to send them in for repair within the first year. I have been a Nikon person since 1949 and the only time I had to send a Nikon for repair was with the 5500, digital, it was repaired at no cost, not even for shipping, so something to think about.

Jorge

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#7

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

Jim Pugh

>Mark, I sent a fairly comprehensive answer that applied to the questions you asked but your email bounced. Give me a shout with a good address and I'll send it on.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#8

Re: Traveling Light

john lucas

>Mark The Nikon zoom has a pretty good close focus feature and the Tamron doesn't. I don't know about the CAnon.

I had the Canon Digital Rebel. It was a decent camera but when you work with professional grade Nikon's all day it was just hard to step down to the Canon at night. That's primarily why I switched to the Nikon D80. The new Canon versions of the Rebel appear to be really nice.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#9

Re: Mark- a traveling light camera for an .....

Jamie Donaldson

>...amateur shooter is a whole 'nother ball game! Go with the superzoom of choice for ease of handling and no need to change lenses. There will be little obvious difference in optical quality with small prints and web posting.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#10

Re: Traveling Light *LINK*

mark wollschlager

>For a superzoom, take a look at the Panasonic Lumix FZ series.

The FZ28 or the new FZ35 if your timeframe isn't too short ( they were just announced ).

They are pretty compact, have good zoom ( 18x optical ), image stabilization, f2.8-4.4.

I don't have the FZ28, but I have two others in that line and have been very happy with them.

I currently have a Panasonic G1 u4/3 DSLR and am happy with it.

If you have an investment in older good quality SLR lenses, they will work on the G1 with adapters ( manual focus ).

It's one of the big draws of that camera.

Other than its small size and weight.

There is a link to other reviews below.


Superzoom reviews

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#11

Old Glass

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My old lenses are 30+ years old with OM-1 mounts. Loved that camera and made a lot of pictures. The light meter's funky even when I can find batteries that fit it, and Great Yellow Poppa done took my Kodachrome away. Still takes nice b&w pitchers though. |;-}}

Have a 5mp Sony P&S, but I'm getting to the point that a new camera may well be in order.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#12

Sent

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Remember to drop the "2"

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#13

Re: I have used the Canon SX 10 IS ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... and can recommend it as an excellent travel camera, and the price was in the $350~375 range. That's a lot of camera for the money, and very user friendly.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#14

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

JohnKyler

>I want to know more about the 14-55 lens you refer?

I have the 18-55 and have had fair but far from good results.

I want to step up to a better lens. Even when I stop the 18-55 down I find there is poor sharpness.

John

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#15

Sorry, TYPO

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>it is the same "kit" 18-55 lens of which you speak.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#16

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

Colin

>John

Have a look at the Sigma 17-70 very good lens for the money and a slightly better range than the kit lens.

Mark

My son has the 55-250 IS Canon kit lens and I have been very impressed with the results. My advice like Jamie's would be to go with the standard kit lenses, the dust problem is not too much of an issue as you do have the sensor shake built in to that body and just change lenses in an area shaded from wind and dust / sand.

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#17

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

DavidWalser

>Are you married to the Canon or would you be willing to consider another brand of DSLR? If so, take a look at the new Pentax K-7. It may be more money than you plan on spending, but it has been getting very good reviews and packs a lot of features for its price. Some of the advantages of the K-7 (and the cheaper K20D and K10D models that the K-7 replaces) include in-body image stabilization and extensive weather sealing. The advantage of in-body image stabilization is that virtually every lens that you can mount on the body has the benefit of image stabilization. The advantage of the extra weather sealing is you can use the camera in the rain or in dusty conditions without fear you'll damage the body. (Pentax is now making weather sealed lens, too. Otherwise, rain and dust are still the enemies of your lenses.) Another advantage of the Pentax system is that the DSLR bodies are compatible with virtually every lens Pentax has ever made (or others have made for the Pentax mount). There's a lot of high quality Pentax lens that are available on the used market.

As to your question about which lens to get. I have the Tamron 18-250 mounted on my K10D and love it. The lens has some vignetting at the extreme short end of its range when wide open, but it is decently sharp and is very versatile. Sometimes I wish I had a wider or longer lens mounted on my camera, but not often. If you haven't done so already, check out the reviews at slrgear.com Tamron's newer lens, the 18-270, is supposed to be even better. It's supposedly sharper than the Nikon 18-200 through most of the focal range. The Canon is slightly sharper than the Tamron at 200mm.

Good luck!

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#18

Bill Blasic

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

Bill Blasic

>Mark,

I use the Sigma 70-300 with macro on my Canon Rebel XT, a nice lens at a fair price. As I've said before I'm approaching 17,000 photos with this camera without a problem. I would seriously consider leaving the one lens on for the trip.

Bill

Re: OT- Digital Cameras

#19

Thanks for the Responses!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>