>Thought I'd stir it up again :) In my opinion, the manufacturer of tools knows there is an inherent danger with the use of the hollowing tools, but I have no knowledge of any efforts of adding a safety device. There is a lot of talk about experience increasing the safety of this tool. Wouldn't it be nice if we could give the amateur an injection of experience?
My thought would be the addition into the shaft of the tool of a simple shear pin which would break on overload. How about it, manufacturers, and maybe a retrofit kit? Do a Google search for Shear Pin.
>I dunno, thoughts of the broken shaft flying out of the bowl, or of loss of balance as a result of the fracture of a tool shaft strike me (pun intended) as potential hazards. I'd feel uncomfortable using a tool that might suddenly disassemble.
Where do these *bleeping* Webkit names come from???
>There is an potential danger in almost everything we do as turners. It seems to me most of them are rather obvious. Why should manufactures be responsible for our lack of thinking through our actions (AKA stupidity)?
>It is a problem between the way some browsers, usually on Mac OS, parse the scripts that run our board. With a whole lot of work I could probably upgrade our existing scripts, but, instead, I'm working on a major upgrade to our messageboard system that will cure this for good as well as give us a lot more features without losing the look and feel of our current boards. Stay tuned. It's going to take a while because we need to write code that will convert all our archived messages to database entries that can be read by the new scripts.
>It's really impossible to make tools that will work well and at the same time fix every possible contengency of misuse. That being said, I am not sure exactly what your complaint is? I have not heard of any particular problem with hollowing tools as far as safety, are you talking about hand held and or hollowing capture bars?
If hand held, the answer for you may be a hollowing bar.
You even state that it is the inexperienced user that is the problem, so is it that or the tool? Perhaps we should make it mandatory that you have to have a test and be issue some form of license before you can purchase a lathe and begin to use it! Like driving cars and gun ownership!
Everytime there is a preceived problem someone whats laws and regulations to cure it but consider the cost involved, not only in money but it loss of freedom.
You stated it was your opinion, so I'll state mine. The most serious safety issue with turning in my opinion are lathes (especially for newbies) that are pulley only speed controlled lathes. Even the slowest pulley is too fast for roughing unless very small. So should all of them be banded and only those with electronic variable speed control be allow on the market? How about light weight lathes improperly secured, maybe we should allow only Oneway 2436's and Robust to be sold. I'm NOT being serious here with that point, just trying to point out and ask, where should the line be drawn and if there is a line WHO gets to pick where it is drawn.
Do you know of a particular tool that has a manufacturing defect in it that makes it a problem? If so, lets talk about it, not all hollowing tools in general.
>I thing the problem with all things like this is education. You can't regulate stupidity or inexperience or make a tool that is beyond abuse. That's why I'm such a big supporter of the AAW. Education is what they strive for.
The other problem is pushing yourself. When your tired or have been working at hollowing too long it's too easy to make silly mistakes. That's how I got hurt. I was not experienced at hollowing so it took many times longer to hollow the vessel than it normally would have. I kept pushing trying to get it done and then did something dumb. If I had quit for the night, put a plastic bag over it and come back the next morning I would have been fresh and probably had better control of the tool.
Rolly Monroe's tool is more or less catch free. It's cost and the clogging tip were why I didn't buy it. Money always becomes an issue with highly engineered tools and those of us on a budget simply can't do it.
>Sharp tools cut better than dull ones and are far safer to use. Should we require proof of ownership of a Tormek before the sale of every gouge or skew? Should the required Tormeks be fitted with a "smart usage" meter that will report electronically to the Bureau of Tool Sharpening? Should the gouges and skews be fitted with sharpness monitoring devices to ensure that they're at their optimum sharpness? After all, it's not enough to have the safety devices - they must be utilized.
Which brings us to the shear pins. Would the manufacturer include a software program to calculate the maximum stress based on the size of each particular piece and then recommend a shear pin for that task? Should the hollowing tool communicate with the software to ensure that the correct pin was utilized and lock-out the lathe if an inappropriate pin was inserted? You wouldn't want the equivalent of a 30A fuse in a 5A circuit would you? Or, would each prospective turner be required to take a physical exam to determine the maximum stress that their shoulder can withstand and would they then be issued a "prescription" that must be produced before the sale of any shear pins?
The problem you're attempting to address is very rare and infrequent. And, while it is extremely serious to the few involved, your proposed solution is a serious infringement on personal responsibility and individual liberty. If you want to build and sell a hollowing system equipped with shear pins then go for it. That's what this country used to be about. You see a niche that needs to be filled, you build a product to fill that niche, and people flock to buy your critically needed product. This country, however, wasn't built on the notion of legislating a marketing niche that you'd hold the monopoly rights to fill based on your patent. Are you next going to force me to upgrade to a SawStop?
>...thinks like the need to put "Caution, contents hot!" on cups of coffee in order to avoid lawsuits? My favourite is the warning against using toaster under water. Even if you survived, who would want water-logged toast? Ah, the Age of Litigation!
And further to the original post, the idea of things breaking off while I am turning does not appeal to me. I try to avoid those situations. Perhaps I am missing something. BTW, I have seen hand-held hollowing tools which feature an arm the attaches to the shaft of the tool, bends toward the headstock and rests on the toolrest. I belive the idea of to help counteract the twisting motion brought on by the lathe. Perhaps that is the answer for those who like to hollow by hand?
>Bob, the very thought of a shear pin in the shaft of a hollowing tool brings the image of a bar of metal flying around at God knows what velocity. This absolutely scares the h**l out of me. It would be like a bullet ricocheting around...it has to land somewhere or in something.
I believe good instruction and experience are the best methods to prevent hollowing mishaps.
>Much like the tablesaw device, I think it should be mandated that all lathes are outfitted with a LatheStop. Much like the SawStop, it would jam a chunck of metal instantly stopping the wood. On the back of the ways, there would need to be a bungee mechanism to jerk the turner to the far end of the shop, which would be padded with an airbag set to trigger when LatheStop is engaged.
While all of this safety equipment is firing, the tool rest would also fire a rapidly expanding foam to encase whatever bits and tools might be flying about. No chance of injury exists, and obviously if we can save one life, it's all worth it...
Steve
Didn't Darwin cover all of this in Natural Selection?
In my opinion the purchaser of a tool knows or should know the inherent dangers of using the tool. If he doesn't he has no d**n business buying the tool. All these government mandated "stupid stoppers" are an insult to people with half an ounce of common sense.
The first thing that needs overhauling in this country is the tort system that now follows the dictate "the manufacturer knew or should have known that my poor uninformed client would use this item in this stupid manner." therefore we are wanting damages.
When I was in the bowling business OHSA was instituted. A newbie inspector came in, looked at the pinsetting machines and promptly informed us because of the moving parts the machine had to be totally enclosed in a cage. We asked, "How will our customers be able to bowl with a cage in front of the pins? If you can believe it, it actually took a call to a supervisor at the federal level to get this inspector to understand it couldn't be the way he wanted it. That was forty years ago and the government mandates of "stupidty stoppers" has increased at what seems to be an exponential rate.
Amen, John! And we have enough blasted regulations, ridiculous required warnings and insane safety devices now. And the costs for all that crap just keeps going up. Who's paying for it? We are.
Excuse me....I have to run wash my hands because I just handled the cord on my circular saw and according to the State of California, that cord will may me cancer.... sheesh!
>Are the idiots the folks injured and going to the lawyers, the lawyers for not kicking such folks out of their offices or the judges who don't both of them out of their court?
>Last night I turned my first hollow form at the tutalage of a friend that has turned many,many hollow forms. The deep caprured tool system he has is a modified Jamison rig with a variety of manufacturers cutting bits. I used primarily the Kelton cutting tools but tried a number of other types. My friend started me out a a low and controlable speed and I proceeded at a pace where I built confidence and minimized the chance of digging in the cutter. My first deep cutting experience was a joy and the evening was punctuated with grins and satisfaction.
I have a varied work experience but all my carriers had inherient risks. I worked at bucking hay, spent years in both an aircraft plant and an oil refinery and finished my working carrier inspecting pressure vessels and boilers. I have a few scars to attest that I didn't always pay attention when I should. My success in my work carrier and my hobbies is a result of my actions and responsibility for my own safety. Working in a risk filled arena isn't the total responsibility of the provider of the equipment I use but primarily mine.
Remember what Norm says... Read and understand how to safely operate your power tools and always start with safety glasses.
>If you have a break-away feature on a hollowing tool, this broken away piece is now tumbling around inside of your turning, throwing it way out of balance, thus a catalyst for a centrifical explosion, now with the added benefit of a heavy piece of metal in the schrapnel path.
Wood turning is inheriently dangerous. What other power tool is designed to have your fingers so close to quickly turning components on a regular basis? For some reason, this is part of the alure of the hobby. Living life on the edge.
Most commercial wood turning shops do not have lathes like ours anymore because of the safety concerns with the process.
There are jigs & fixtures out there to make the hollowing process safer, but the risk of a centrifical explosion will still be there, only to a lesser degree.
Hundreds of thousands of people use tablesaws every day, but they, with the proper jigs & fixtures, are relatively safe to use because of the nature of the process, and create good products (square boards). Only "thousands" of people turn, because it requires a high degree of skill to do it right, and jigs & fixtures will not allow a poor turner create a great turning.
>"...Wood turning is inherently dangerous. What other power tool is designed to have your fingers so close to quickly turning components on a regular basis? For some reason, this is part of the alure of the hobby. Living life on the edge...."