Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries
David Walser
>
...Captured systems just never appealed to me all that much. ... I would much rather hollow a vessel free-hand, than with a captured system with or without laser. To me, it's almost like using a lathe with a duplicating attachment....
I understand where you're coming from. To some, using a captured system just doesn't feel as "free" as hollowing free-hand. However, you asked about safety and this freedom v. constraint reminds me of a discussion I had with a rock climbing friend years ago. He loved climbing rock faces and disdained the use of ropes and other safety equipment. To him, climbing with a safety rope just wasn't as aesthetically pleasing as climbing free of any restraints. He'd climbed for years (and as far as I know, still does) without using ropes. So, he was safe, right? His wife wasn't as lucky; she fell about 25 feet. Fortunately, she was only injured, and not killed, in the fall.
What has this to do with using an arm brace hollowing tool? Many turners use such tools daily for years without injury. That fact does not mean the practice is safe. My mother used to drive all without using her seatbelt. She's never been injured in a crash. Does that prove driving without a seatbelt is safe?
People can and do get injured using an arm brace. When they do, it's usually because they did something wrong. My rock climbing friend's wife was perfectly safe climbing without a rope -- until she did something wrong and slipped and fell. I once threatened to fire an employee if I caught him again ripping a thin board without using a push stick. He'd been doing it for years and assured me he was quite safe. The next day his right thumb suddenly became about 1/4" shorter than nature had intended. (I didn't fire him. He learned his lesson.) As long as you do x, y, and z, you won't have any problems. Of course, too many of us do not do x, y, and z every time. If, despite of your intent to always do x, y, and z, you still get a severe catch, do you really want your arm and shoulder to absorb the energy?
Note: I'm NOT saying using an arm brace is wrong or stupid. You asked about safety. Only you can judge whether, like my rock climbing friend, the extra enjoyment you get is worth the additional risk. I just think it's fair to say there is some additional risk. I believe the number of injuries we've seen reported over the years proves that.



