Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Posts

Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#1

Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Barry Turner

>I am in the market for a set of hollowing tools. In pondering whether or not to consider arm brace-type handles, it struck me that these types of handles could possibly be dangerous in the event of a catch. I can't help wondering what would happen to one's arm if there were a catch and the handle couldn't be released quick enough. What if the tool were being used to hollow a vessel, shavings were allowed to build up inside, causing the tool to seize up and rotate with the vessel. I can envision some very serious elbow and shoulder injuries. I hope my description makes sense. Am I over-thinking this potential safety issue, or is this a real concern? Anyone have any first-hand experiences?

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#2

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Ken ward

>I made one with the arm brace and have gotten some nasty catches,but had complete control with no problems and I'm turning on a Nova 1624 1.5 hp

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#3

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries *LINK*

charlie belden

>"I made one with the arm brace and have gotten some nasty catches,but had complete control with no problems and I'm turning on a Nova 1624 1.5 hp"

It's not the horsepower spinning the wood that's the killer - it's the mass of the wood and the square of the rpms - a version of E=mc^2 where E is the energy in the moving chunk of wood with a mass "m", spinning at "c" rpms.

Our turning club president had to have his shoulder reconstructed after an "incident" with an arm braced hollowing tool. He turns on a Stubby, and usually at around 3K rpms.

With all the Captured Hollowing Systems out there at affordable prices, including a laser to know where the cutting tip you can't see is at, I don't understand why, with the exception of little boxes and christmas ornament, anyone hollows "free hand" - if they're not a production turner where hogging out wood fast means Mo' Money!

Go through the attached compendium, check out reviews of the ones that you might be interested in and THEN decide if free handing - with an arm brace seems like a better idea.

(I've got a JET Mini/Midi and went with the MiniMonster. Got me hollowing things I wouldn't even have considered doing without it)


Compendium of Captured Hollowing System

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#4

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Barry Turner

>Thanks for the response. I also turn on a Stubby, like your friend, but usually at a much lower speed. Captured systems just never appealed to me all that much. I don't do all that many vessels and would find it difficult to justify the cost of a captured system. I would much rather hollow a vessel free-hand, than with a captured system with or without laser. To me, it's almost like using a lathe with a duplicating attachment. (I know I'm gonna catch Hell over that comment!)

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#5

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

jon gaynor

>I have tried the elbow system - works like a champ.

Saw the Monster system at AAW looks every bit as good, but no personal experience.

Jon

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#6

3000 RPM?

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Charley that is insane. I am not surprised to hear of his injury. This is the President of your club? Wow!!!

Handheld for 12 years :) Ellsworth style hollowers.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#7

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I've been turning with a Stewart armbrace system since 1987. Many many hundreds of HF's. I've never come close to an injury.

Hollowing at 3000 rpm is an accident waiting to happen.

The key to using any hand held hollowing tool safely is maintaining control with any catch, large or small. That is done by keeping the tool tucked against your side and using your body for tool movement. I'm convinced that nearly all large catches are the result of losing control of the tool with a small catch.

Wally

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#8

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I hollow at very fast speed -- but only for quite small boxes and such. For larger pieces such speed is nuts! And not necessary. At reasonable speeds you can safely use an arm brace system, like the John Jordan, if you keep your arm close to your side and make sure that the straight part of a swan neck tool is behind the tool rest -- i.e. the shaft must be supported toward the tail sock side. Even if there is no swan neck to minimize rotational torque, as long as your cutting edge is close to the axis of the lathe spindle, a catch should merely rotate the cutting edge away from the wood more or less harmlessly. There is always some risk, of course, but I've been doing it this way for a long time with no serious problems. That said, I also use constrained rigs, where the risk of injury is even smaller. And I don't agree that there is anything less satisfying about using rigs. The satisfaction comes from turning good forms with nice grain, etc. Only my opinion.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#9

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Russ Fairfield

>The arm brace is safe IF you always keep your elbow tucked tightly against your body. and move the tool with body movement.

You can get into trouble with the Arm Brace when your arm is extended out over the lathe and away from your body. You have little control of the tool in this situation.

The same is true for any turning tool.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#10

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

cliff

>i have been using the don pencil scropion armbrace for a while now with no probs, is a great tool easy to use and control. 3k rpm is dangerous on anything but small spindles or pens, nevr hollow anywhere near that.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#11

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

john lucas

>Barry I almost got hurt. I was turning a large hollow hollow form and was making one of the famous last cuts trying to thin out an area. Bam, it blew up and my wrist hurt like hell. Thought I had brocken it but it stopped hurting and didn't swell up so I survived. This was using a homemade arm brace. It wasn't the fault of the brace, It's just like the commercial ones. It was something I did. It was a really nasty catch and I think the damage came from the twisting action that occured with that nasty of a catch.

That's when I built the captured rig. You are so much more relaxed when turning with a captured rig. The downside is set up, but in reality it only takes a few minutes. You also may have to adjust the rear tool rest for some cuts because it limits travel. Still, you can hollow with one hand, completely relaxed.

I keep practicing hollowing by hand and I think I'm pretty good at it,but certainly not as relaxed or secure as John Jordan. I turn smaller work by hand but when the piece gets deep or very large I switch back to the captured rig. Come on over some weekend and I'll put you on mine and you can see for yourself.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#12

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Carole Valentine

>I don't use an arm brace for two reasons. One is the one you mentioned, and the other is that none of the braces seem to be designed for a woman's arm. I did try using one for a bit early in my turning career and had a really bad catch at normal speed (probably 1200) Nothing broken but gave my shoulder quite a jolt. To be fair, I did not have my headstock swiveled, and unless I do that, it is almost impossible for me to always keep my arm against my side when hollowing and leaning over the bed. I would like to have a captured rig to do some larger pieces, but money is really tight right now so I guess I will just continue to turn small stuff that doesn't put undue stress on my joints.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Lyle Jamieson

>Barry, there are very good issues already posted. The bottom line is use it before you buy it, OR MAKE IT. You can make a supported system easily if you are into that sort of thing. You can buy the best supported hollowing system, with the laser for the same price that you can get a hand held system going. By the time you buy the straight bar and cutters, the hook tool and cutters, and the arm brace you have spent the same money as the supproted system costs. Now you are turning blind without a laser, you would not have the capacity to use the new Hunter carbide cutters, and you are still beating your body up even when you go through the learning curve to handle it without a catch. Again the important thing is to use one before you buy it. I would bet you there is one of mine being used by one of your club members. If you are not in a club you should be. They are a great resource. Seeing is believing.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#14

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

John Jordan

>Barry, You got some good responses. Hold the tool close to your body-that way your entire body weight controls the leverage. DON'T EVER let go of any tool. An armbrace style tool is really made for a short lathe/pivoting head etc. Stand up straight and don't try to look inside the piece. The loop on the armbrace handles is just a "locater" it doesn't tie you to the tool in any way.

If the tool is held close to your side,it can't hurt your shoulder, elbow, or anything else.

Nothing wrong with the captured rests. Lyle's is about as simple as can be.

start with SMALL, SIMPLE pieces. :)

John

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#15

Steven Antonucci

Waht does a "set of hollowing tools" mean to you?

steve antonucci

>Are you focused on a system that will do "everything"? On the cutter end? On the bars? Do you already have some things in your possession that you are looking to reuse?

I made a "supported"(not captured)system from ordinary shop scraps (MDF, screws) that works very well in keeping the cutter on centerline. It took about an hour to put together, and is still handheld (sort of). It might be a solution to your problem.

Steve


img

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#16

Re: 3000 RPM?

Barry Turner

>Amen! I'm not sure my Stubby has ever been to 3000 rpm. Just joking, of course, but not with a hollow vessel mounted on it.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#17

Dick Hines

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

Dick Hines

>At 3000 RPMs he is lucky busting up his shoulder is all that happened.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#18

Re: Waht does a "set of hollowing tools" mean to y

Barry Turner

>I'm not really considering a "system", either manufactured or homemade. I have an intermediate size set of Kelton hollowers and need something with a little more reach. So, I'm looking at the large John Jordan tools. I already have the small set of JJ's, a Sorby multi-tip (straight & bent). I'm probably going to spring for the JJ's, I just had some concerns about the arm brace style handles.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#19

Re: JJ's large hollowers work well...

Jamie Donaldson

>... in both captured and armbrace configuration, or I wouldn't have spent the money to upgrade my old tools.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#20

Re: JJ's large hollowers work well...

Barry Turner

>Do you have JJ's armbrance handle or some other?

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#21

Rob Wallace

Re: Waht does a "set of hollowing tools" mean to y

Rob Wallace

>I have been using the John Jordan 'standard' hollowing tools for several years, and I like them a lot. However, I do use them with the Sorby armbrace handle instead of John's handle. I liked the pistol grip better than the 'angled' grip John's handle has. (I also thought the broad support 'plate' of the Sorby [and Stewart] armbrace felt more comfortable to me opposed to John's 'bent wire' support; personal preference). After attending a demo by Mike Jacofsky and his discussing the ergonomics and hand position that he uses while hollowing, I am even more comfortable and happy with the Sorby armbrace handle (although I must admit the tightening screw/knob on it is pretty lame).

I do have a set of John Jordan's mini-hollowers, but don't use them nearly as much as the standard set.

My next 'toolmaking' project is to finish my captive arm secondary rest for the Jamieson set-up so I can try some deeper forms. Talked with Lyle at the AAW Sympiosium, got some good advice, and I think I'm ready to start playing a different hollowing game after a few more weeks....

Rob Wallace

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#22

Re: I use an old Stewart handle, same as ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...the current Sorby armbrace handle, which in less expensive as well.

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#23

charles , you are SO RIGHT

bob davis

>

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#24

listen to lyle!

bob davis

>

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

#25

Re: Hollowing Tools/Safety/Injuries

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I own a Scorpion/Stinger armbrace system and love it. When using the Scorpion, I do my hollowing while standing at the end of either my Jet mini or, now, my new Delta Midi, both of which are short beds. I have never had an issue using the armbrace, but, as others have said, I always keep my elbow close to my body and never have the lathe speed above 1200rpm. BTW, I use my Kelton hollowers in the armbrace.

I also have a Kelton Hollowing rig and am soon to be the owner of a new Monster hollowing system I purchased out in ABQ.

keithz