Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

What tool would you use to turn this?

Posts

What tool would you use to turn this?

#1

What tool would you use to turn this?

david

>My friend in Connecticut uses his lathe primarily for turning block rims for banjoes that he makes. Below is a shot of a segmented octagon from vertical grain Purple Heart wood. The desired result is a 3/4" thick ring the full depth of the glue-up. Getting the outside surface round is not a problem: band saw, disc sander, etc. can be utilized because access is not a problem. The inside diameter, however, has been a battle for him to turn. The wood is hard, as many can attest to, and cutting vertical grain adds to the difficulty. My friend primarily uses skews, but I suggested that a bowl gouge may be a better choice. The initial cuts with the tool and the impact from the eight sides on the tool will be hairy. Angle of approach with the gouge will be critical. Then I thought about the newer carbide tipped tools. Has anyone used a Ci1 roughing gouge on this kind of wood in a similar situation with what would be a plunge cut?


img

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#2

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

Carl Barton

>David,

While I do not own a Ci tool it seems to me it would be a much better choice than a skew. Just my 2c's.

Carl

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#3

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

john lucas

>David I would think the C1 would work but you might get a lot of tearout. Purple heart is bad about that. What I would do is to take a bowl gouge and point the flute to the left, maybe 11 oclock. Make a series of cuts from right to left to get rid of all the uneven area and get it close to final thickness. Then you could use the lower wing of the bowl gouge to fine tune the shape using a scraping motion.

A skew held flat on the tool rest will also do a good job of the final clean up.

Personally after I got it close I would use a spindle gouge to get the final shape but that can be a little tricky for some.

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#4

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

john lucas

>I meant to tell you that parting tool will also do a pretty good job of cleaning up the unround areas. That's why I think the C1 will get you pretty close.

If your going to buy a tool from scratch the Hunter #4 will do the job using the same motions I described above but of course you don't have to sharpen it.

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#5

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

Rick Allen

>This is primarily a box. You can turn the inside of a box with a variety of tools. Some use a scraper, some use a spindle gouge as a scraper, some use a ring tool like the Oneway termite, Some use a hook tool.

I turn this sort of shape often to make stave ring canisters. For the inside I use a big stiff bowl gouge. I use the lower cutting edge with the flute facing the inside wall of the stave ring. This is a scraping action not a cutting action. The flute on this tool is fairly short to preserve the stiffness of the tool. The flute ejects the scraping as the tip of the tool along the sharpened flute does the scraping action presenting the tool at a 45 degree angle to the cut surface.

Because this is a scraping action the surface off the tool is slightly less than perfect. Sanding improves the surface.

I turn out a little over half the depth and then reverse the ring to turn the rest. The ring is made about an inch longer than needed as the regluing and mounting will consume some of the height of the ring.

The outside is primarily cut with a rouging gouge. A big one that is 1 1/2" across. The stave ring is a big spindle so the roughing gouge is an effective tool for this operation.

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#6

Mike Stafford

Any Hunter tool will eat the end grain up!

Mike Stafford

>

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#7

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

Bob Lemon - Sacramento, CA

>David, I think you should think outside of the box (lathe). There are multiple ways to accomplish the desired results by using a router with good hard carbide tools. Template routing can give you a very smooth cut on both the inside and outside. If need be, you can also true up the length of the side with the right setup. Try posting this on the flat woodworking forum for more ideas.

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#8

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

Cyril Griesbach

>How about a scroll saw?

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#9

A Bedan or a Scraper

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>It is just like making a box, any end grain tool, or alternately, a router, if you are willing to a time investment with the set up.

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#10

Re: The #5 Hunter tool would be .....

Jamie Donaldson

>..,.much stronger than the smaller shaft on the #4, and end grain purpleheart is really nasty to turn. I would start the Hunter at the front edge and make a series of draw cuts to first get it round, and then smooth with the same #5 Hunter or a big scraper. What I'm more curious about is how he mounts these rings on the lathe?

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#11

Re: The #5 Hunter tool would be .....

david

>Jamie:

I forgot what they call it, but it is a type of Longworth expanding chuck where the banjo pot is held in place with those rubber buttons.

Re: What tool would you use to turn this?

#12

Thanks for your responses!

david

>