>In the recent threads on sanding, I've seen no mention of using steel wool. Why is this?
My theory is that the wood-removing action of sandpaper and steel wool is different: sandpaper scratches the wood away; steel wool actually cuts it away. So, theoretically, you should get a smoother surface from steel wool.
My observations in the shop seem to bear this out.
Of course I'm thinking in terms of the final finishing applications, in the realm of 400 - 600 grit and 0000 steel wool.
>I have my doubts about steel wool actually doing much to cut wood fibers like sandpaper does. I use steel wool for two things...the first is rubbing out an oil based finish and the second is to bring a high sheen to certain oily woods that will have no finish - an African Blackwood finial for instance. For both of those purposes I use 6/0 steel wool cloth.
I don't use steel wool because the steel dust gets trapped in the pores of the wood. Sometimes this can result in staining the wood, especially light-colored wood.
>I use steel wool after my first and 2nd coat of poly or lacquer finish. This is just to remove any dust particles and raised fibers. It does not take much, but a light rub. wipe it off before the next application of finish. I wipe on my finish with a paper towel. It makes a big difference in final finish being smooth as glass.
>Like Ric I don't use steel wool on bare wood. The tannin's in the wood can make any steel wool fibers left over, rust. I do use it to refine the finish. I'll put down one or two coats and then touch it up with 600 grit. Then apply some more finish. if it's level I will switch to 4/0 steel wool and then either buff with the beal or hand rub white automotive abrasive.
>Doc, I would like to hear you expand on your theory about steel wool cutting wood fiber. I've never used steel wool on raw wood. Personally, I don't even like using steel wool on finish any more. I have always thought that I get a flatter and better finish by using abrasive paper, especially when backed with cork, felt, or rubber. I've always thought that steel wool will ride over the dust bumps a lot more than paper. I now use Abralon to adjust the sheen of the finish. I'm not saying my methods are the best, just my preferences.
>Dick, my theory is simple and not backed up with any real experimental evidence. Steel wool consists of slivers of metal with sharp edges. It cuts when the edges are brought into contact with the wood.
On the other hand, sandpaper "cuts" by scratching, that is, making progressively finer scratches as you go to higher grits.
So, steel wool is like a skew. Sandpaper is like a pointed hollowing tool applied straight to the wood.
To keep the cutting action going with steel wool, you have to constantly rearrange the pad to expose new edges. It "dulls" quickly, and beyond that point, as Carole said, not much happens.
When steel wool is dull, the slivers of metal simply slide over the surface rather than dig in and cut. About the only thing that happens then is burnishing of the wood. Or so it seems. ~Doc
>This not a contest. Sandpaper and steel wool are two different abrasives that will bring a different quality to the surface of a piece of wood or a finish.
If I dare make such a comparison, 0000-steel wool is about equivalent to 400-grit sandpaper. They both remove the wood by cutting into the surface, but their cutting patterns on the surface are very different. Aluminum Oxide sandpaper leaves a pattern of "V" shaped grooves in the surface, Silicon Carbide (black wet or dry) sandpaper leaves a "U" shaped pattern with rounded bottoms and sharp peaks in the scratch pattern, and the steel wool leaves a flatter rolling wave shape on the surface. We say the "V", the "U", and the "sine wave" patterns are "equivqlent" when they are the same frequency, when they are really quite different in shape and reflective qualities.
The "V" pattern from the Aliminum Oxide sandpaper scatters the light from the surface. The "U" pattern from the wet/dry has a more reflective surface because of the rounded bottoms in the pattern, while the steel wool has even more reflective surface because both the bottoms and the peaks of the pattern are rounded. That gives the wet/dry the appearance of having a higher gloss than the dry sandpaper, and the steel wool as having more gloss than either sanding medium, while all of them have left somewhat similar patterns in the wood surface.
There is nothing wrong with smoothing out the bare wood by changing the sharp "V's" from the 400 grit Aluminum Oxide to a flatter pattern with a 0000-steel wool, or rounding off the tops of the "U" pattern from the wet/dry. Our final finish will be the better for doing it. The surface will be brighter and more reflective, and that will accent the differences in the grain pattern without having to resort to the color changes from an oil finish or dyes.
Obviously, the sharper scratches and the durability of the Aluminum Oxide sandpaper makes it more agressive for removing wood from the suyrface. But there is merit in switching to a different abrasive with a smoother pattern as we approach the end of our surface preparation with the finer grits, and then finishing it off with steel wool.
We could use sandpaper for smoothing out the surface of a finish, but it will usually clog up faster than we can change the abrasive sheets, while all we need to do with steel wool is to shake it and open it up to a fresh supply of cutting edges, and keep working with the same piece. The shape of the pattern in the surface will also give a higher gloss with steel wool than it will for any equivalent sanding abrasive, and we are far less likely to cut through the finish because the wool is less abrasive.
I have always heard about the rust problems with steel wool in light woods with waterborne finishes, but I have never experienced it that I know of. I am starting to use the waterborne lacquers more frequently, but still haven't experienced the problem.