Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Sanding Discs

Posts

Sanding Discs

#1

Sanding Discs

Jeff Rich

>Hello everyone!

I would like to know where people buy their sanding discs, what abrasive is typically used, and how they perform.

I have been power sanding for a while but would like to experiment.

My cuts are getting pretty good so I dont have much sanding.

Thanks!

Re: Sanding Discs

#2

Re: Sanding Discs *LINK*

Ed Moore of SW VA

>I have used other discs, but I prefer the discs from Vince. His mandrels and interface pads work extremely well.

Check out his link.

Ed


http://www.vinceswoodnwonders.com/

Re: Sanding Discs

#3

Bill Blasic

Re: Sanding Discs

Bill Blasic

>I've tried a lot of disks myself and my preference are those sold by Steve Worcester. They last longer than any I have used and the power sanding mandrels he sells are superb.

http://www.turningwood.com/

Re: Sanding Discs

#5

Re: Sanding Discs

Jeff Rich

>Thanks!

I have used Steve's discs as well and found them pretty good.

I am doing some exploring to find what works best for my woodturning girlfriend and her birdhouses.

Re: Sanding Discs

#6

Re: Sanding Discs *LINK*

Cyril Griesbach

>Ditto on the discs from Vince. I've been very pleased with them. The 3M Ceramic discs are really great too but only come as PSA and in limited grits


VincesWoodNWonders.com

Re: Sanding Discs

#7

Re: Sanding Discs

Donna Banfield

>Here's another plug for Vince's discs.

I've used plenty, the discs sold in packaging at Woodcraft, the 1 meter by 1 yard sheets from Industrial Abrasives (Ryhno Grip), and a few other hook & loop sandpaper; none have compared to the quality of discs sold by Vince.

Vince's don't separate under use, don't load up, unless you're sanding wet, or with a lubricant (and then any paper will load), and they continue to cut longer than the others I've used. Dollar for dollar, you can't beat the price, and Vince is prompt and a really great guy to deal with.

Re: Sanding Discs

#8

slight Hijack, does anyone make good....

Barry Irby

>Mandrels with hex shafts with the groove around them so I could use a quick couple? I'd like to have about six so I could have one for each grit and then use a snap connector to change them quickly. I think the sand paper would last longer and so would the mandrels. The hooks wouldn't get as hot and have time to cool off between uses.

Re: Sanding Discs

#9

Re: slight Hijack, does anyone make good.... *LINK*

Don Evans

>One and only time I ordered any hex shaft, which is all I want, don't care for the round shafts, I got them from Packard Woodworks here in NC.

Don


Packard

Re: Sanding Discs

#10

Re: Sanding Discs-The Sanding Glove

Greg Haugen

>Jeff,

I go through Bruce at The Sanding Glove. I use the purple 3M PSA discs up to 220 and then the Norton discs beyond. The 3M discs are PSA but with the starter pack, you get conversion discs that make them H&L. All of the other suppliers that carries the disc only give you a mandrel and disc, no conversion discs. I don't care for the PSA mandrels. Each disc will usually last 5-7 bowls. So you'd have to have a mandrel for each or you ruin the disc when you remove it. That's why I like the conversion discs so I can just treat them as H&L. A 10 pack is around $7 and lasts as long as a 50 pack of standard discs which is usually $12- $16. Bruce has great customer service and fast shipping.

I started to use the 3M discs after talking to Mike Mahoney about them and hearing a review from David Lancaster.

Re: Sanding Discs

#12

Re: Sanding Discs

mike Nelson

>Woodchuckers has Astrodot, best I have found. I cut squares for home made hook and loop with Ridgid angle drill just nip the corners off and you have a basic disk sander that last a long time. Comes in rolls or disk, rolls are cheaper 10 bucks or so. Also very nice guy to deal with.

Re: Sanding Discs

#13

Re: Sanding Discs *LINK*

RJ

>We have oversized Blueflex Micron Film sanding discs with the radius and tapered edge interface pads as well as White Rhyno, Abranet, and Abralon at 2Sand.com.

RJ Stroman


img

2Sand.com

Re: Sanding Discs

#14

Re: Sanding Discs

Jeff Rich

>THANKS!!! to everyone!

Re: Sanding Discs

#15

Don Pencil

Re: Sanding Discs

Don Pencil

>I have had the best results from SANDING GLOVE, service, selection, and quality. Personally, got to go with Bruce the stuff is killer.

Be Well,

Don

Re: Sanding Discs

#16

Re: Sanding Discs------WebKitFormBoundaryra4+I5BQn

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>First, let me say there is no "bad" sandpaper out there. Each has been carefully designed to meet a need. The problem is that none have been specifically designed for wood turners -- we have to adapt papers designed for other uses.

After a number of years of testing (and several thousand dollars) I have come up with three that work best for me. These are:

Astra Dot from WoodChuckers (only North American source -- call John at 1-800 551-0192)

3M 900DZ Ceramic with a psa backing from The Sanding Glove and Packard Woodworks. The psa backing is a problem as once you take it off the mandrel, dust sticks to the glue and it becomes useless except for hand sanding.. There are conversion pads -- put them on the psa sandpaper disk -- and keep track of them. I keep throwing mine out as I have gotten used to firing used disks in the garbage. Another option is separate pads for each grit, which is rather expensive.

Norton 975 (Dry Ice) -- another ceramic. It is available from Jamestown Distributors (www.jamestowndistributors.com). This is a boating supplies company. Any Norton retailer can order it, but it fairly new and generally available only at the wholesale level (except for Jamestown). It comes in 6 inch disks and you can cut iit with a hole saw in a drill press -- remove the teeth first on a grinder along with the centering bit. That way, you get 2- 3 inch disks for 32 cents and 2- 2 inch disks for 16 cents from each six inch disk.

For inexpensive, good paper, try Rhyno Grit from Industrial Abrasives (www.industrialabasives.com/zencart/. If you get it in sheets (36" x 39" and cut the disks yourself, you can get three inch disks for 10 cents apiece. A number of companies sell it cut into disks -- but you have to pay for the work.

In between, there are a number of very good papers, including Mirka Royal, (Steve Worcester) ASAP Blueflex (Jerry Horne) 255L Hookit Disks (The Sanding Glove) and Premium Green, a ceramic coated paper from Craft Supplies USA. {Packard and others. These are only a few. The list is much longer.

Do you always need the best? No. If I have a good clean piece of wood, I will use one of the best., and it almost makes sanding a pleasure. But, If I am working with CA glue, sanding sealer, shellac or other wood hardners, I will reach for the Rhyno. If I wreck a disk, I don't stop to cry.

------WebKitFormBoundaryra4+I5BQnefYAZbc

Re: Sanding Discs

#17

Thanks and Info

Jeff Rich

>Thanks to everyone that replied!

I currently use a variety of discs and paper.

I buy a lot of the bargain boxes from Klingspor and I have used Steves discs which I like a lot.

I tend to use 120 the most to start, although I have had to use 80 on some tricky tearout, even when finishing cuts were not as good as I would like them.

The girlfriend likes to use CA and fillers for her projects and she turns a lot of glued up projects.

Where I turn mostly bowls, goblets, boxes and mushrooms, she turns birdhouses and genie bottles.

Thanks again!

Re: Sanding Discs

#18

Re: Sanding Discs

robo hippy

>Another vote for Vince's discs. I have tried them all except for the ceramic discs from 3M, and they outlast all by about 2 to 1. His firm interface pad with the quarter round profile on the edge is great. I can easily get two 14 inch bowls from one set of discs. The meduim density interface pad is super as well. Didn't like the Astra Dot, Mirka was good for the outside of one bowl, and not beyond that. The Green Ceramic from Craft Supplies was okay, maybe close to Vinces discs, but not really as good as. The Abranet mesh pads are nice, but the coarser discs don't stay on the hooks very well. The 3M ceramic can get the not for 'Best Abrasive' and Vince's discs bet 'Best Buy'.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding Discs

#19

Re: Sanding Discs

Russ Fairfield

>Most of my sanding problems went away when I learned to sand at slower speeds of both sanding disc and lathe. Slower sanding cuts faster and there is no heat to destroy the mandrels.

My sanding discs and mandrels started lasting longer when I started using a dedicated mandrel for each disc.

I have also learned that the rubber in the mandrels deteriorates with age. Old rubber is old rubber, even if it hasn't been used.

I prefer the 2" discs because there is less torque while sanding and that makes it easier to control. I use the Rynho-Grip from Industrial Abrasives, because it lasts as long and sands as well for me as the others.

Re: Sanding Discs

#20

Dick Hines

Re: Sanding Discs

Dick Hines

>Good advice Ed. Vince is a good guy to work with and his sanding disk are the only disk I use.

Re: Sanding Discs

#21

Re: Sanding Discs

Vince Welch

>Hi Rich,

Feel free to contact me for free samples. I will be happy to send some your way or anyone else. Also note I have my new Gold line discs available from 60-800 grit!!! Just let me know if you prefer 2 or 3" please.

Vince

Re: Sanding Discs

#22

Re: Sanding Discs - Have to agree witih Don. *LINK*

Jeff Willaford

>Bruce at The Sanding Glove seems (to me) to carry a good selection at reasonable prices. He has the same blue discs Vince carries and also has the Norton discs at a price I like. I am not affiliated with The Sanding Glove...simply satisfied with the quality of products and service.


http://www.thesandingglove.com/

Re: Sanding Discs

#23

Re: Sanding Discs - Have to agree witih Don.

wilbur

>Which are the blue discs that the Sanding Glove has? I looked at their catalog and didn't see anything that matches Vince's blue discs.

Re: Sanding Discs

#24

Re: Sanding Discs - Have to agree witih Don.

Bruce Hoover

>Wilbur,

The blue discs are not listed in our catalog, because we carry them only as our Economy Line as a convieneince for those looking for something inexpensive. They are an import from Korea with a stated primary use for automotive applications with woodworking being secondary according to the manufacturer. 3 3/8" 50 packs are $10.00, an the 2 3/8" 50 packs are $9.00

Our line of NORTON A275 discs a well as others we carry will far out perform the blue economy discs. We have several full time pros using the NORTON with good results. Used to be we carried the Indasa white Rhyno discs also(for about 7 years), but dropped them as soon as we got the NORTON line because they offer superior performance and quality at the same price range.

Also, someone earlier in the thread mentioned the NORTON 3X discs. We have tested them extensively (as we do all our products) and we currently have stock on order. They will be available in both 2" and 3" by sometime in August. These are the "big brother" to the A275 and their performance is superior even to the 275s.

Just give us a call (number is on the website - www.TheSandingGlove.com ) and we can supply you with a product that suits your needs and your budget.

Bruce

Re: Sanding Discs

#25

I think I've tried them all... *LINK*

Carole Valentine

>Wave, Fincat, Rhino, the Blue Discs and about every other thing I could find, but once I tried the Norton discs (I get mine from The Sanding Glove) my search was over. Flexiblity is extremely important to me and the Nortons are incredibly flexible, but tough as nails. They also seem to have a more consistent grit - no oversized "boulders" to gouge the wood. You will never find the abrasive flaking off and they have a latex saturated fiber backing that simply will not separate and the discs can be used wet or dry. Love 'em!


The Sanding Glove