Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

hand cut rasps *LINK*

Posts

hand cut rasps *LINK*

#1

hand cut rasps *LINK*

Pascal Oudet

>Hello,

some days ago, there was a discussion about power carving wheels, and about hand cut rotating rasps for the arbortech. in case you have never seen this, a maker of rasps posted on utube how the rasps are hand stiched. I find it fascinating

Pascal


hand stitching rasps

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#2

Very interesting

Cyril Griesbach

>

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#3

Thanks Pascal.

Don Orr

>

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#4

Re: Thanks Pascal. Gives new meaning...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. the fact that some high quality tools are still hand made. I didn't see any hearing protection, and wonder what materials and heat treating are involved?

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

Couple questions

Ellis Walentine

>What is that big drum rasp all about? Is it used to refine the surface of wood like a drum sander?

Do they have to temper these tools before they can be used?

What about the rasp/grinder wheels? Will they be available?

Ellis Walentine

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#6

Re: Couple questions *LINK*

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>found this page, it is a google translation. As I don't speak French, I can not tell you for sure about the accuracy of the translation. If you know someone who speaks French maybe they can inquire about the process.


http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&u=http://sculpture.forumactif.com/outillage-f52/piquage-a-la-main-des-rapes-et-rifloirs-t3736.htm&ei=vLguSrL-IJ2qtgeDy7CLDA&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=3&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522RAPE%2BPIQUER%2

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#7

Re: Couple questions

Pascal Oudet

>Hello,

this big rasp is used for polyurethane shaping (1400mm long=55" * 120mm diameter=5", more than 100.000 hammer strokes).

after the rasp is stitched, yes it is heat treated (carbon steel XC48, I believe quenched in salted water, under controlled conditions of course).

regarding the rotating rasps (2" diameter), I'll have some new prototypes with me in Albuquerque, that I'll probably use in my "spiky creature" demo.

I must say I have no business affiliation with this maker, but he is a very nice guy, interested in how we use the tools and very open to inputs from users; we have been discussing needs and use of hand stitched rasps for some time, and he is developping new shapes based on this.

he's been doing this for 11 years, and the other guy we see in the video for 19 years. I was told 2 years are needed to get the skills, and only 12 people in France today still have the know-how. I'm happy if I can help them coming up with new products and continue this tradition.

Pascal

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#8

Roger in MO

Re: hand cut rasps

Roger in MO

>Fascinating. Think about repetitive motion and carpal tunnel syndrome. Ouch!

Roger in MO

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#9

Re: Couple questions

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Pascal,

Very interesting, if you have a chance drop by the booth one day in the afternoon.

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#10

Re: hand cut rasps question

Stuart Johnson

>I can't imagine doing that for more than a few minutes but I do have a question.

Why are the hand cut rasps so in demand? It seems like they could be produced by machine much faster and more accurately. I don't mean to take anything away from the craftsmen I'm just curious.

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#11

Randomness of pattern

Alex Yeilding

>My understanding is that it is the slight randomness of pattern in the hand-stitched rasps that lets them cut with a combination of aggressiveness and smoothness not attainable with machine-cut rasps. I don't doubt that a machine tool maker could create a machine to give the appropriate pattern of randomness, but I suspect the market is not large enough to support such an effort.

P.S. Watched Michael Auriou stitching hand rasps at Berea. Could have been a display at Colonial Williamsburg; definitely old, time-tested methods. He was at a sitting bench, with the blank held down by lether thongs, tensioned by his foot on a pedal. I presumed that he used a different punch for different grains, but was told that it was the weight of the hammer that determined that.

Re: hand cut rasps *LINK*

#12

Re: hand cut rasps question

Pascal Oudet

>only man's hand can produce even teeth all around the raps whatever the shape, in pointy ends (such as rat tail shape), in concave and convex shapes. the slight irregularities are an advantage over machine made rasps, because the teeth don't create "channels" as they are not aligned (maybe a cnc machine could add some randomness, I don't know). Also, teeth are slightly angled differently for left handed or right handed people, and I was told (though I don't understand why) a machine can't do that.

many users who have tried hand cut rasps say the comfort in use and result can't be compared with a machine made tool.

I agree it seems a bit strange in this modern era, but if an industry or a surgeon prefers to use these tools, there must be a reason.

Pascal