Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Mini lathe with slow speeds

Posts

Mini lathe with slow speeds

#1

Mini lathe with slow speeds

Jonathan

>I am new to these forums, and I have tried to research this issue in other messages, but I am confused, so I figured I would start a new thread.

I recently learned how to turn boxes and peppermills by taking one-on-one instruction. I have turned many pens and some other spindle work up to now. The lathe I have at home is a Rikon mini lathe. For the work I have done so far this lathe has been great.

The lathe that I used while learning the boxes was a Powermatic full-size lathe with a full range of speeds (variable). I found that much of the work I was doing (especially drilling and end grain work) was being done at 150-350 RPM. My Rikon has a low speed of 430 RPM, and drilling at that speed does not seem practical.

I am looking for a variable speed mini lathe, as the boxes and pepper mills I am looking to work on are medium sized. All of the variable speed mini lathes I have seen have a range that starts at about 500 RPM - some are even higher. The only VS mini that I have come across that had a lower speed was the Nova (formerly Teknatool) Mercury, and that is no longer being made.

If a lathe has variable speed, how come the STARTING speed is so high? Why can't it start at 0 and turn at any speed between 0 and the top speed of the range? I understand the concept of speed ranges, but I do not understand why a VS lathe cannot start at 0 in its lowest range.

The consideration of getting a mini over a full lathe is cost. I am okay with spending ~$500 to get speeds that I need in a smaller lathe, but the $2K+ that I would spend on a full lathe is outside of my budget.

Is there something I am missing? Can the Jet or Delta mini lathe actually turn at the lower speeds? Is there another lathe out there that would fit the needs that I have stated?

Any feedback very much appreciated.

Thanks,

Jonathan

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#2

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Jerry Hall

>Jonathan, You are not confused. You have summed up the dilemma in the current market place well. You can't do much better than what you have. A true electronic variable speed (EVS) as with the PM3520 in a smaller lathe is just too pricey apparently for the market place. Vicmarc I believe makes a wonderful EVS but not marketed here any more, no doubt due to price. You can buy an EVS motor and control but they run maybe $500. Some clever turners have repurposed used motors. My advice is to tough it out and save your shavings for a Jet1642, still the best buy on the market for a quality EVS lathe. You can drill a smaller hole, and build your hollowing skills with a gouge in the mean time. That will not be a wasted endeavor by any means and will work fine. Jerry

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#3

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Jonathan

>I very much appreciate the response! I think that maybe I could work on boxes using the gouges, as long as I feel comfortable hollowing them out at 430 RPM. The pepper mills, though, will have to wait. I don't think that I could hollow out the length of a pepper mill instead of using the Forstner bits to drill the holes through the blank, and I would need to slow down the lathe too far to do that. My drill press also is too fast for that work, I think. The slowest speed on that is 620 RPM.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#4

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Mike Brazeau

>Johnathan - the new Delta 46-460 starts at 250 rpm. I have no need of one right now, but if was shopping would definitely give it a good look. Delta have addressed many of the short comings in midis with this one.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#5

Re:A slight speed increase would ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...not be a problem for the turning, but a lack of torque and slower speeds will make drilling on the Rikon nearly impossible. That's why we are spoiled by turning small objects on a big lathe(a real lathe!)and discovering the handicaps of attempting same on a toy lathe.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#6

250 RPM slow enough to drill?

Jonathan

>Thanks! It does look like the Delta 46-460 could be the answer to my dilemma, as at 250 RPM I could probably do the drilling that I need to do (any opinions out there on that?)...now the problem is that I cannot find any place that sells it near me. From reading online, Lowe's might have it. I will try to call them soon to see if they can order it for me.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#7

Re:Well now, I have just been accused...

Jamie Donaldson

>... as an egotist by a WC viewer because I called a Rikon mini lathe a toy by comparison to a Powermatic! There was no malicious intent, and any fool can see the contrasting relationships when making such comparisons in reference to torque and slow speed capabilities. That in no way denigrates anyone who turns on a small lathe because most of us started there, including me, and I still do! I guess someone was having a bad morning?

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#8

Re:Well now, I have just been accused...

Jonathan

>I just assumed your 'toy' comment was meant with a bit of humour, and did not think twice about it.

Unless you do turning for a living, all lathes are toys by definition :)

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#9

Re:Thanks for your understanding....

Jamie Donaldson

>....Jonathan- all of my toys are my toys!

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#10

Peter Lamb, in SC

Re:Thanks for your understanding....

Peter Lamb, in SC

>Call Don Russell AAW member 770-784-1993 . He tested the Delta 46-460 once manufactured. He speeks very highly about it. The lathe is just becomming available. Lots of much highly desired features.

Peter

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#11

Brad Vietje

Used ? Jack Shaft? (Long) *LINK*

Brad Vietje

>Jonathan,

Mini lathes usually don't have enough torque to turn slowly -- you need a beefier motor for that.

For boxes and small items, these speeds are not a problem. For learning tool control, and getting used to all the new equipment, start off between centers with a dead cup center in the headstock, instead of a spur drive. That way, if you get a bad catch, the piece stops spinning (while the motor keeps going) -- a built-in safety clutch. If you get a decent chuck, you can learn to hollow boxes with a 3/8 drill bit and a spindle gouge, followed up with scrapers. Drilling a 2" hole into end grain with a Forsner bit is not my idea of fun!

The larger problem results in turning heavier, often green pieces, like rough-turning bowl blanks. That's where a slower speed will really help a lot. One option is a jack shaft mounted behind or below the lathe... These days, we like everything automated, but people were making small to medium bowls long before anyone on this forum was born. A lathe with step pulleys can be stepped down much further with the addition of a small pulley on a parallel shaft. For example, a 1" pulley that drives a 4" pulley will slow the lathe by a factor of 4.

I would say get started with a high-quality lathe*** in any size range (harder to do in small sized lathes), learn the basics, and as your skills and confidence grow, continue to challenge your abilities. Join a club if at all possible. Once you are ready to start roughing out bowls, either set up a jack shaft speed reducer, or consider befriending a club member with a heavy-duty lathe, and rough-turning bowls on their equipment. When they're dry enough to finish turn, your skills will be 4-6 months ahead, and the 500 RPM speed won't be so difficult. Air-dried rough-outs will also be much lighter, so that speed won't be too intimidating.

*** Another point to consider: Modern mini lathes are not only too fast, they're usually much too light. Roughing out bowls from wet, heavy green wood really is a lot more comfortable on a heavier lathe. Don't overlook an OLD used lathe -- usually a much better value than a new-ish used lathe. A 50 year-old Delta is a lot more cast iron than a new mini, and even if the bearings are worn, on many models they can be easily replaced without hiring a machine shop. Again, by joining a club and meeting all the nice people who can serve as mentors, some of them have older lathes they no longer, or only rarely use. A club might also have an experienced person who can help you find a good deal on used equipment. Some may even loan you a lathe for 6 months to help you get started.

For small lathes, I like the Vicmarc and the General better than the Jet or Delta. The General Maxi-lathe is about 40 pounds heavier than the Jet and Delta, and all things being equal, heavier is better -- much better. My own mini is a Nova Comet, which I bought used, a model later replaced by the Nova Mercury. I have no experience with the Rikon models.

Best of luck getting a good deal on some good equipment.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


Jack Shaft Photo

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#12

Re: Used ? Jack Shaft? (Long)

Jonathan

>Thank you for the response regarding the mini lathes. It would seem that the new Delta 46-460 should have enough to turn what I want to turn, no? I do not, at present, have enough interest in bowls to make issues related to bowl turning a consideration.

As for drilling...I plan to hollow out my boxes using the gouges and scrapers, not the Forstner bits...but the pepper mills I plan to drill out.

I plan to call the person named in the other post about the Delta lathe to see if it will fit my needs. I don't think that I need much...but the variable speed and low speed would be great additions.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#13

Re: 250 RPM slow enough to drill?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Not a problem Jonathan. I have a Delta 46-460 and drilled many pen blanks last week with no problems. I did all the drilling at 250rpm. prior to getting my Delta, I did my drilling on a Jet Mini VS at 500rpm and still did not have any problems.

The Delta is also a wonderful machine. I am really looking forward to learning all it's capabilities.

keithz

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#14

Re: Used ? Jack Shaft? (Long)

john lucas

>Johnathan I have only made a few pepper mills but I drilled them on a drill press and then used a mandrel on a faceplate to turn them.

They have one of the new Delta mini's at the Woodcraft store in Chattanooga, Tn. I didn't get to run it because they were having another class in there. It should do all you need to do. Low rpm around 250, high around 4000. 1hp motor with forward and reverse and variable speed. I beleive it's a variable frequency drive so it should have plenty of power at the slow speeds.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#15

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Gordon Seto

>The Jet 1220 VS has minimum speed of 200 rpm. The non variable speed model and the smaller 1014 has min. speed of 500.

The variable speed still has 5 pulley positions (instead of 2 positions on the larger lathes); it has plenty of torque.


img

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#16

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Gordon Seto

>Correction.

The Jet 1220 VS has 6 pulley positions, not 5.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#17

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Jonathan

>That's strange. Specs that I have just looked up have said

"Continuous variable speed from 270 - 4200 RPM"

(http://www.tools-plus.com/jet-708376vs.html?utm_medium=feed&utm_source=froogle&utm_term=JET708376VS and others), which does not seem to agree with the picture OR with the specs that I thought I found earlier for the Jet 1220 VS (minimum 500 RPM).

So, now the comparison seems to be between the Jet 1220VS and the Delta 46-460. Maybe. This discussion seems to be ever-evolving

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#18

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Glad that Jet keeps the incompetent people writing the specs instead of running the production.

The specs were wrong on speed (270 to 4200) and net weight (125 lb).

In page 5 of the manual:

The speed:200 to 4300

Net weight: 106 lb

I have pointed out the discrepancy to Jet long time ago, it was never corrected. That was why I posted the picture. I believe Jet specs overstated the net weight on the 1220VS. The shipping on the VS was about $10 higher than the non VS model at one time.


Jet 1220 VS Manual

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#19

Re: PSI motor kit *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I put this kit on a Fische mini lathe similar to Jet and Delta. I was able to use original 3-step pulley (� 14 mm shaft). This gave me slow speed of around 100 rpm. It has enough torque to drill a 2" forstner bit in dry red maple. Turned a 8" x 2" bowl in red maple with 1/2" bowl gouge without stalling. Rpm is listed at 650 rpm, but original pulley slows it down considerably. Installation took about 1.5 hours, drilled two holes, transferred pulley, and cut into original wire to motor. At $109.95 plus $10 shipping this is an excellent change-out. If you decide to try this, read the instructions about turning a centering pin/jig before taking lathe apart! Five minutes spent helps considerably.


VS motor kit

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#20

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Jim B

>I use a Jet 1014 with a low speed of 500 rpm and make 2-3 10" to 12" Peppermills a week. No problem at all...Lidded boxes, no problem. Oil lamps, no problem. Salt boxes, no problem. There isn't a valid reason, other than personal comfort level, to not consider boring a mill at 500 rpm.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#21

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I have a Vicmarc VL-100 evs, which is a great little machine, unfortunately they aren't being sold in the United States at this point because the US Dollar is down enough to make them non-competitive on the market. Christian said he could get one, but it would have to sell for about $1900.00, the price of a much larger lathe.

I contacted Christian Brisepierre, President, Woodworker's Emporium, 5461 Arville St., Las Vegas, NV 89118 to see if he might have any left in stock. He said that he does have a few VL-100's without motors and might be able to make up a unit with power from his inventory of replacement parts. His e-mail address is: chbwwe@mpowercom.net


Woodworkers's Emporium

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#22

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Jonathan

>You drill with Forstner bits at 500 RPM? That is the part that I find an issue, really.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#23

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Don wilcut

>Fred, I've tried that link for the last two years and it's still under construction. Must be using nonunion labor.

Don

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#24

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

KEW

>One key difference between the Delta and Jet VS midi's is that the Delta has an 8 Amp motor while the Jet has an 4.5 Amp motor. That is a 77% increase in power between the two.

I have heard both good and bad reports from people I know and respect on the torque of the Jet, so I went with the Delta just in case.

The Woodcraft in Atlanta is where I got mine. Packard should have them by now.

PS-You can probably expect to pay a bit more for the Delta right now, YMMV.

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

#25

Re: Mini lathe with slow speeds

Gordon Seto

>Kurt,

I don't know which Amp number is correct. I just looked at my Jet 1220 VS; the plate on the motor says 3/4 HP, 3.5 Amp. On the Jet 1014 VS; the plate says 1/2 HP, 3 Amp.

It kind of make me think that the numbers on their specs were randomly generated. May be Energy Star is in trend now.