Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

Posts

A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#1

A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

Russ Fairfield

>The words of that distinguished linguist, Spiro Agnew, were the first thing that came to my mind as I read through all of the messages this morning. I may not have the quotation exact, but I think you will get the message of what I thought of the whole affair that flooded noth this and the AAW forum for several days..

I took the time to discover that several of you are not even menbers of the AAW, or I should say that your names are not in the latest 2009 Directory. That says a lot about you.

To those who are members, I challenge them to run for the job of Director. There is no pay, no compensation, but you will have an opportunity to change the AAW into the organization that does meet your approval. However, be prepared to get a lot of flack from the complainers, who just like youeselves, offer nothing constructive.

If you can't offer yourself as a potential Director, did you VOTE in the last election? If you didn't vote, you have nothing to complain about.

To those who don't like the Journal content, when was the last time you wrote an article?? Always remember that the Editor cannot publish articles that she doesn't receive, or pictures that have never been taken. All that is re1uired is that you get up off your butt, quit complaining, and do something about it. You will find that this editor is very willing to work with you on making the content suitable for publication.

If you cannot do any of these things, when was the last time you volunteered to help with any of the many AAW committees and functions?? Did you offer to help when the Symposium was in your town or close by?? The committees are only as good as their members. If you have something to offer, then volunteer your services. If you cannot do that, then at least offer some constructive suggestions to those who did volunteer.

If you can't do anything else, when was the last time you sent an e-mail message to anybody at the AAW?? I would guess that for most of you, the answer is NEVER. It really is easier to complain on an Internet forum. If you did, and didn't get a reply, what was the tenor of your message?? If it was anything like the rants that some of you wrote on this forum, you probably wouldn't have replied to it either. I know that I wouldn't.

As a final suggestion, if you are a member, and you hate the AAW so much, and neither it nor the Journal does anything for you, then don't send in your renewal next year. Both you and the AAW will be the better off for your not being a member.

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#2

Very well said

mfoster

>I tend to just overlook such posts and blow off those who post them as people with nothing better to do. I don't respond on them (add fuel to the fire) and waste little time wending through them.

An excellent response from a respected member of the turning community.

Mike

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#3

AMEN....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#4

Listen to Russ...

david

>BTW, I am a member of the AAW too.

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#5

Peter Lamb, in SC

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativi

Peter Lamb, in SC

>Amen again

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#6

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativi

Jeff Brockett

>Wow it looks like everyone was painted as a negative voice with a broad stroke. Last I checked if you paid your dues and are a member you are afforded the opportunity to voice your concerns. I am a paid member of the AAW and have voted for the directors. I have submitted an article for the journal and sent board members suggestions. It would be nice to receive a response back from the AAW, but it would appear that the communication line is only open one way. I have kept copies of the emails and communications that I have sent, but my best guess based on my experience is that they either don't want the feedback or only respond to feedback that is within their criteria.

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#7

Whoa! Hold on there, feller!

mjonesrdg

>You been too huffin' your terps too long, friend. This here is a Public forum and guys get to air thier laundry whether you agree with them or not.

That I don't send my Check to AAW anymore says absolutely nothing about me....and who gives you license to judge? I don't send my money anymore...to those people that seem, at times, to live on another planet. I preview the Journal at Barnes and Noble...buy if there is anything worth taking home.

You think your rant about the ranters is a superior rant in some way? I hear the neighbors dogs barking and the other neighbors dogs barking back. Yip-yip..yap yap..woof woof...it's all just so much noise, although I am sure that these over here think that those over there are are bigger or something.

Your post is but the pot callin' the kettle black and with a smidgin of arrogance too!

I'd like all of us to go back to talkin' about sandpaper...go curl up somewhere and quit barkin at each other.

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#8

Merry Christmas Everyone!

David Belser

>

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#9

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativi

Ken

>I am not a member of AAW,been thinking about it though,BUT I am on several differnt forums,I do not complain about any of them,if I have a suggestion ,I PM one of the mod's and make it in privite.I have the utmost respect for all the folks who work there tails off keping these places up an running and to all of you,I say THANK YOU.

Ken

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#10

right on, Russ

GaryG in MD

>I wasn't going to get involved in this ridiculous waste of electrons, but you said what I was thinking. ...Gary

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#11

Steven Antonucci

I think I saw it flinch?

steve antonucci

>Someone want to beat the dead horse again?

Fundamentally agree with every word you said, but AARRRRGGHH!

It seems that the only posts that generate interest these days involve some squabble about the AAW or us vs. them? Whatever happened to people actually turning on a turning board?

And I get a bad rap...?

Steve

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#12

A Bit Simplistic

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>As was the VP in his alliterative attempts to stifle valid criticism of his crooked boss.

The issue of Mr. & Mrs. Lacer is a very serious one because the AAW is a not-for-profit charitable organization subject to very strict rules under the tax laws. A charge of conflict of interest, or placing Mr. or Mrs. in a position where they would be continuously be impaired (recusal notwithstanding) in their functioning, would actually impair the organization and might well invite a problem with the IRS. It is not a function of the two individuals' intent or dedication to the entity, but rather compliance with the ethics rules that have been established over the years to prevent such conflicts and abuse of the charitable form that allows the AAW to function at all. Once exceptions to the rules begin, in no time at all the rules become worthless, they having been "swallowed by the exceptions." It is most likely that when Mary Lacer decided to take the paid management position, she froze her husband out of the opportunity to become a Board member during her employment. The opposite would also be true. That's a decision that they both should have discussed beforehand. Mr. & Mrs. Lacer's dedication to the AAW or their motives are not the question; adherence to the special rules that have allowed the AAW to grow and flourish is, and must be, the controlling principal. Alan Lacer is not impaired in his opportunities to carry on his generous support of the organization.

Those who raise the issue in good faith have a right and obligation to do so for the good of the AAW. Denigrating them for doing so is unwarranted and improper.

However, those who see phallic symbols in wood shavings need therapy.

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#13

Way To Go Russ

Ron in Drums PA

>Everything settles down and you try to start it back up again.

While I may agree with what you say, I do question your poor timing.

Get A Grip!

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#14

Re: A Bit Simplistic

Barry Elder

>Thanks, Mark!

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#15

Hey Ron

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I question any obligation on Russ to comment within a certain time period. He can clearly wait to get a better sense of opposing views aired before putting out his own considered opinions. In fact, too many Internet chatroom posters run off at the keyboard without any real knowledge of facts to back up their comments, apparently just to see their opinions in print. The AAW situation certainly deserved more careful thought and consideration than that.

Remember the crap-storm over Monster Tools and the guys from Kobra? Remember Doug Thompson putting himself in position to receive a "world of hurt" because a whole bunch of people on this board jumped in where they didn't belong on a topic they knew absolutely nothing about? You don't want to know how much effort it took to get that mess unwound.

Perhaps we'd all do well to be a bit slower in posting our position statements on "topics of the day."

Of course, that's just my take, YMMV |;-}}}

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#16

Re: A Bit Simplistic

David Walser

>Mark,

I don't think you and I are in disagreement, so please don't take what I am about to say as anything more than an attempt on my part to clarify and important issue. It was right and proper for the AAW to check with a professional well versed in the ethical rules that apply to charities before allowing Alan Lacer to run for a seat on the board. As you said, the AAW's tax status as a charity is important and that status should be protected.

This is an area I've advised several charities on in the past. (I'm a tax CPA who works in the area.) Nothing in my experience causes me to believe Alan's service board would pose a risk to AAW's status as a charity for federal income tax purposes. Procedures would need to be adopted (or may already exist) to prevent any appearance of impropriety or any technical violation of IRS rules. For example, Alan might be required to abstain from any evaluation of his wife's salary and her performance. Mary might be required to have someone else review and approve any expense reimbursement request Alan might make. Etc. Otherwise, Alan could still serve on the board and have a full voice in setting the strategic direction of AAW. Such arrangements are quite common in the not-for-profit sector (as they are in the for-profit sector). So, while the AAW was right to make sure Alan could serve (and if so, under what conditions), I would be very surprised if a reasonable arrangement could not be worked out.

Note: I'm not offering anything here as my professional opinion. Instead, I'm just offering a general observation. Before reaching a conclusion, I would need to examine the facts (AAW's charter, employment practices, and other factors). That's something I have not done and have no intention of doing.

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#17

Not So Simple

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Agreed in principal, especially without more to go on. But my experience has been that the arrangements required to "play by the rules" tend to become cumbersome, at best, because of issues that have be examined (a/o counsel consulted) before a decision on abstention can be made. Slows down the whole process of getting stuff done, and leaves the governing body open to some malcontent's rants. In the situations that I've consulted on, it's been my recommendation to keep the board "clean" by avoiding even the appearance of an opportunity for improper influence. There are always ways for the "excluded one" to still play a vital part in helping the organization.

|;-}

Re: A messgae to the "Nattering Nabobs of Negativism"

#18

Re: Not So Simple

David Walser

>Agreed. My advice, like yours, is to avoid conflicts of interest whenever possible. That's a good general rule. Still, it's a general rule with a lot of exceptions. In Alan Lacer's case, his desire to serve might be better expressed OFF the board. Or, his passion and talent might make worthwhile the extra effort required to allow his service on the board. Once the AAW learns what steps would need to be taken to allow Alan to serve, Alan and, eventually, the AAW membership can make that call.

What I've found both surprising and disappointing is that so many seem so willing to assume the worst in motives of those leading the AAW. Yes, it would have been nice, in a perfect world, to get a prompt explanation of what was going on with Alan and the logo. This isn't that world. In this world, it takes a couple days (or more) to get a response to even simple questions vetted. In today's world of instant electronic communications, we seem to have forgotten that a question sometimes simply cannot be answered in internet time.